Super-Premium Ice Cream Made in Warren, OH 🍦
Currently not accepting online orders

Cockeye Creamery - Canfield
18 N. Broad Street, Canfield, OH
Featured Items

Peanut-Butter Pie
A Cockeye signature: Creamy Reese’s peanut butter, marshmallow, graham cracker, and dark chocolate chunks$4.80+
Cookie Monster
Cookie dough (molasses, brown sugar) ice cream with chocolate creme cookies and chocolate chip cookie dough$4.80+
Deep Chocolate
Award-winning traditional chocolate ice cream. Milk, cream, sugar, cocoa. Look no further.$4.80+
2026 ICE CREAM ADVENT CALENDARS
Ice Cream Advent Calendar (PRE-ORDER ONLY!)

2026 Ice Cream Advent Calendar (CANFIELD PICK UP)
24 flavors of super-premium ice cream in 24 sealed mini cups (3.25 oz each), featuring Cockeye Signature classics and “From the Vault” holiday picks; a scoop for every day in December. We’re also throwing in some pretty sweet extras again this year, including a chance at a Cockeye Golden Ticket, winners’ access to our ice cream production facility, and a chance at some sweet prizes like free ice cream for a year. Pick-up orders starting Black Friday, 11/27 at selected location. https://www.cockeyecreamery.com/-cockeye-creamery-holiday-advent-calendar-2026$44.99
ICE CREAM
ICE CREAM SANDWICHES

SUGAR COOKIE
Your choice of any flavor between two house-baked sugar cookies$5.50
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
Your choice of any flavor between two house-baked chocolate chip cookiesOUT OF STOCK$5.50
FRANKY'S ITALIAN ICE
Dairy-Free, No Artificial Dyes or Flavorings

Strawberry-LĂmonata Italian Ice - 16oz. Pint
Real lemon, strawberries, and cane sugar swirled into an ice!$4.99
LĂmonata Italian Ice - 16oz. Pint
Classic Italian ice flavor. Real lemon and cane sugar processed into an almost creamy frozen treat! Deliziosa!$4.99
Current Flavors
Updated in real-time!

(Vegan/Dairy-free) Chocolate
Nondairy chocolate ice cream made with real cocoa and sugar.$4.80+
(Vegan/Dairy-free) Cookies & Cream
Nondairy ice cream made with molasses and brown sugar with chocolate creme cookies$4.80+
(Vegan/Dairy-free) Pistachio
Nondairy pistachio ice cream with salted pistachios$4.80+
(Vegan/Dairy-free) PumQueen
the PumQueen that you know and love, just vegan/dairy-free!$4.80+
Andromeda
Chocolate ice cream, brownies, candy-coated mini chocolate chips$4.80+
Blackberry Chocolate Chunk
Blackberry-vanilla ice cream with real blackberries and chocolate chunks.$4.80+
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry cheesecake ice cream with real blueberry swirl and hunks of cheesecake$4.80+
Butter Pecan
Local (Cleveland, OH) Hillson buttered pecans in smooth nutty base$4.80+
Buttermilk Pie
A Cockeye signature chef-inspired flavor: made with fresh-baked buttermilk pies from Cockeye BBQ’s kitchen$4.80+
Cherry The Hatchet
Black cherry and rich chocolate super-premium ice cream w/ chocolate chunks, brownies, and hunks of real black cherries$4.80+
Chocolate Pecan
Increasingly famous chocolate ice cream with local (Cleveland, OH) salted pecans$4.80+
Cookie Monster
Cookie dough (molasses, brown sugar) ice cream with chocolate creme cookies and chocolate chip cookie dough$4.80+
Darkest Hour
Our Deep Chocolate super-premium ice cream filled with brownies, chocolate sandwich cookies, and chocolate chunks$4.80+
Deep Chocolate
Award-winning traditional chocolate ice cream. Milk, cream, sugar, cocoa. Look no further.$4.80+
French Vanilla Bean
Award-winning traditional French vanilla ice cream, made with milk, cream, sugar, egg, premium Madagascar vanilla beans$4.80+
Fresh Strawberry
Award-winning strawberry ice cream made with strawberry fruit puree, vanilla, and real strawberries$4.80+
Girlypop!
Cotton candy super-premium ice cream, made with real cotton candy flossugar and loaded with colorful nonpareils & fizzy, crackling cotton candy piecesOUT OF STOCK$4.80+
Honey Lavender
Real Ohio wildflower honey, vanilla, and lavender$4.80+
Kong
Banana ice cream with graham crackers and mini buckeyes$4.80+
Mint to Be
Mint chocolate ice cream: creme de menthe, dark chocolate chunks$4.80+
Monster Mash
IT'S A GRAVEYARD SMASH! All of your favorites from the trick or treat bag. Snickers, Heath, and Butterfinger candies!$4.80+
Peanut-Butter Pie
A Cockeye signature: Creamy Reese’s peanut butter, marshmallow, graham cracker, and dark chocolate chunks$4.80+
Pistachio
Traditional green pistachio super-premium ice cream with halved salted pistachios$4.80+
Praline Pecan
Loaded with crunchy, caramelized, candied pecans$4.80+
Pretty In Pink
PINK cake batter super-premium ice cream, house-made icing swirl, white chocolate chips. 100% of the pint proceeds supports Pink Lights the Way!$4.80+
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Pumpkin cheesecake super-premium ice cream with creamy cheesecake pieces$4.80+
PumQueen
Pumpkin super-premium ice cream with cinnamon and graham cracker swirls$4.80+
Salted Caramel Brownie
Salted caramel super-premium base filled with chewy brownie pieces$4.80+
Spumoni
Chocolate, pistachio, and black cherry super-premium ice cream$4.80+
Technicolor
Fruity Pebbles super-premium ice cream$4.80+
White House
Our French vanilla bean ice cream with maraschino cherries$4.80+
Wired!
Coffee-flavored super-premium ice cream made with fresh ground Youngstown Coffee Co. espresso beans, chocolate chunks, and brownies$4.80+
RETAIL
BBQ RETAIL

Cockeye BBQ Original BBQ Sauce - 16 oz. Jar
Cockeye BBQ's Original BBQ sauce, now available in retail jars for bringing Cockeye flavor home!$5.99
Cockeye BBQ Hot BBQ Sauce - 16 oz. Jar
Cockeye BBQ's Hot BBQ sauce. Add a little kick to your smoked, grilled, or otherwise prepared proteins!$5.99
Cockeye BBQ Blackberry Smoke BBQ Sauce - 16 oz. Jar
Cockeye BBQ's Hot BBQ sauce. Add a little kick to your smoked, grilled, or otherwise prepared proteins!$5.99
CREAMERY SWAG

T-SHIRTS
Just tell us what size and color at the register!$25.00
KOOZIES
A cute little koozie that fits Cockeye Creamery pints. You'll wish you had this when you're eating a pint on your couch!$7.99
COOLER FANNY PACK
A cute cooler bag sized to fit up to two pints or four bowls! Perfect for getting our super-premium ice cream back home after a long drive...OUT OF STOCK$9.50
Creamery Bumper Sticker
$3.00
Cockeye Creamery Pink Hat
OUT OF STOCK$19.99
Cockeye Creamery OTTO Green Hat
$19.99
DRINKS

KAST IRON ROOTBEER
Bottled in Salem, OH!$2.99BOTTLE OF WATER
$1.99
ICE CREAM PIES

Cookie Monster Ice Cream Pie
Our Cookie Monster ice cream inside of a cookies and cream pie crust!OUT OF STOCK$22.99
Peanut Butter Ice Cream Pie
Our Peanut-Butter Pie ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!OUT OF STOCK$22.99
Buttermilk Pie Ice Cream Pie
Our Buttermilk Pie ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!OUT OF STOCK$22.99

Mint to Be
$0.00
Mint chocolate ice cream: creme de menthe, dark chocolate chunks
Customize your item
Size
Required
Select 1
Request advisory
Feel free to add special requests here. We think our menu is pretty straightforward, but if you have any questions please just give the shop a call!
1
Cockeye Creamery Locations and Ordering Hours
Cockeye Creamery - Canfield
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 12PM
Cockeye Creamery - Warren
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 11AM