
Elm Street Bakery - Elm Street Bakery
72 Elm Street, East Aurora, NY
Pickup Only
Featured Items
ESB Breakfast Sandwich
farm egg, bacon, cheddar cheese, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, sriracha aioli, on our sourdough$9.50Egg Sammy
2 Ordinary Farms fried eggs, cheddar cheese, spicy aioli, on a brioche bun$10.00
Sesame Batard (Available at 9:30AM)
$7.00
THANKSGIVING PRE-ORDERS (PICK UP WED 11/25)
Pastries (Thanksgiving preorder 11/25)

Pumpkin Pie
$36.00
Apple Pie
$36.00
Chocolate Caramel Tart
$44.00
Banana Bread Loaf
$22.00
Gluten-Free Pumpkin Bread
$26.00
Coffee Cake
$36.00
Bake at Home Cinnamon Buns
$36.00
Apple Cake
$42.00
Bread (Thanksgiving preorder 11/25)

Cranberry Walnut Bread (Thanksgiving preorder)
OUT OF STOCK$12.00
Dinner Rolls (12) (Thanksgiving preorder)
$15.00
Dinner Rolls (6) (Thanksgiving preorder)
$7.50
Baguette (Thanksgiving preorder)
$5.00
Caraway Rye (Thanksgiving preorder)
$8.50
EA Sourdough (Thanksgiving preorder)
$8.00
ALL-DAY MENU
Avocado Toast
marinated avocado, feta, pickled red onion, micro greens, lemon vinaigrette, everything bagel seasoning on our sourdough$13.00Bialy
italian style bagel-baked not boiled, plain, as is.$3.25Bialy with Cream Cheese
italian style bagel-baked not boiled choice of: rosemary sea salt, everything, or sesame seed$4.00Pumpkin Pie French Toast
brioche, pumpkin puree, streusel, whipped cream$15.00Egg Sammy
2 Ordinary Farms fried eggs, cheddar cheese, spicy aioli, on a brioche bun$10.00ESB Breakfast Sandwich
farm egg, bacon, cheddar cheese, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, sriracha aioli, on our sourdough$9.50ESB Veggie Breakfast Sandwich
farm egg, cheddar cheese, sauteed red pepper + onion, arugula with lemon vinaigrette, sriracha aioli, on sourdough$9.00Everything Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, dillOUT OF STOCK$14.00Rosemary + Sea Salt Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, dill$14.00Sesame Smoked Salmon Bialy
smoked salmon, caper cream cheese, thinly sliced red onion, green goddess dressing, dill$14.00Yogurt Parfait
whole milk yogurt, seasonal compote, ESB granola (contains gluten)$7.00Toast & Jam
2 slices of our baked fresh daily sourdough (choice of plain or seeded), buttered with a side of seasonal house-made compote$4.00Mushroom & Caramelized Onion Omelette
2 eggs, mushrooms, gruyere, caramelized onions, side of sourdough toast$14.00Skillet Pancake
fluffy buttermilk pancake, candied pecans, whipped cream, maple syrup$14.00English Muffin Sammy
1 fried egg, cheddar cheese, on a sourdough english muffin$10.00Hash
Butternut squash, Yukon potato, kale, red onion, sunny side egg, sourdough toast$16.00Chicken, Spinach & Artichoke CUP
onion, garlic, herbs, chicken stock, chicken, spinach, artichoke, creamOUT OF STOCK$5.50Chicken, Spinach & Artichoke BOWL
onion, garlic, herbs, chicken stock, chicken, spinach, artichoke, creamOUT OF STOCK$9.00Tomato Bisque CUP
tomato, garlic, basil, cream (vegetarian/gf)$5.50Tomato Bisque BOWL
tomato, garlic, basil, cream (vegetarian/gf)$9.00Butternut Squash Bisque CUP
Roasted Butternut squash, onion, garlic, vegetable stock, sage (GF)(V)$5.50Butternut Squash Bisque BOWL
Roasted Butternut squash, onion, garlic, vegetable stock, sage (GF)(V)$9.00Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce, grana padano, sourdough croutons, lemon, caesar dressing$13.00House Salad
baby green leaf lettuce, confit tomatoes, pickled red onions, sourdough croutons, carrots, shaved grana padano, lemon vinaigrette$12.00Squash & Radicchio Salad
Delicata squash, Fresno peppers, manchego cheese, chiogga radicchio, spiced pepitas, honey & olive oil dressing$16.00Grilled Cheese & Tomato Bisque Combo
garlic aioli toasted sourdough, cheddar, cup of tomato bisque (vegetarian)$15.00The Classic Smash Burger
two 3 oz patties, cheddar cheese, house burger sauce, red onion, lettuce, brioche bun, side of pickles + kettle chips add bacon +4$14.00Mediterranean Mezze Plate
Wood-fired pita, house made hummus, greek olives, marinated feta, pickled and raw seasonal vegetables$18.00Thanksgiving Sandwich
Stuffing bread, thick sliced turkey, gruyere, cranberry sauce, gravy, side of kettle chips + pickles$16.00Italian Sandwich
grilled capicola, salami, & prosciutto, provolone cheese, arugula, confit tomatoes, red onion, red wine vinegar, olive oil, on ciabatta roll, side of kettle chips & pickles$16.00Jambon Beurre
ham and butter on baguetteOUT OF STOCKCaprese
house made fresh mozzarella, pesto, red onion, confit tomato, saba, arugula, on baguetteOUT OF STOCK
BREAD & PASTRY (SATURDAY)
Bread
3 Seed Sourdough
$8.50
Baguette (Available at 9:30AM)
$5.00
Caraway Rye
our lightest sourdough rye that improves with age- a classic deli rye with caraway seeds studded throughout. (contains gluten)OUT OF STOCK$8.50
EA Sourdough
our signature traditional sourdough bread. crusty on the outside, tender on the inside with that mild bite of sourdough tang. (contains gluten)$8.00
French Batard (Available at 9:30AM)
OUT OF STOCK$7.00Honey Wheat
OUT OF STOCK$7.75
Sesame Batard (Available at 9:30AM)
$7.00Cranberry Walnut
OUT OF STOCK$12.00
Pastry
Almond Croissant
frangipane filled croissant twice baked with sliced almonds and powdered sugarOUT OF STOCK$5.25
Bakery Box
6 of our classic, beloved staples. includes an assortment of scones, muffins, quick breads and other specialties. substitutions may be made based on availability of product.$27.50Banana Bread Loaf
crusty sugar top, moist banana cake-ours has no nuts. (serves 8-10)$22.00
Banana Bread Slice
crusty sugar top, moist banana cake-ours has no nuts.$4.75Blueberry Muffin
$4.75Brookie Cookie
fudgy, chocolate brownie-like cookie with chocolate chips$3.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie
soft center, crispy edges, with belgian chocolate chips$3.25
Cinnamon Bun
soft whole wheat buns, topped with a brown butter vanilla icing$5.50
Coconut Macaroon (GF)
chewy + toasty coconut cookie, dipped in belgian chocolate (gf)OUT OF STOCK$4.00
Coffee Cake
vanilla + almond fluffy cake, with cinnamon/cocoa swirled throughout, topped with a cinnamon pecan streusel (contains gluten, dairy, eggs, nuts)OUT OF STOCK$4.75
Cowgirl Cookie
chewy oatmeal cookie with coconut, pecans, craisins, + chocolate chips (contains nuts)$3.25
Cranberry Orange Scone
our beloved classic, orange + vanilla scone with cranberries throughout, topped with coarse sugar$5.00Croissant
$5.00Lemon Yogurt Bread Slice
moist yogurt lemon pound cake topped with icing + lemon zest$4.75
Molasses Ginger Cookie
$3.25Pumpkin Cranberry Muffin (GF)
apple, carrot, coconut, golden raisin, walnut (gf/*contains nuts)OUT OF STOCK$4.75Pain Au Chocolate
$5.50
Peanut Butter Cookie (GF)
chewy with the perfect amount of crispy. (gf/contains nuts)$3.25Peanut Butter Granola Bar
peanut butter, chocolate chips, pumpkin/sesame/sunflower seeds, craisins + oats make this a nutrient packed treat (contains nuts, dairy, gluten)$4.50Sticky Bun
soft, pillowy yeasted bun topped with caramel and chopped pecans (contains nuts)$5.50Ham & Gruyere Croissant
$5.75
MARKET
Market Cooler

Caper Cream Cheese
$6.50
Cornichon
$5.50
ESB Hummus
featured on our beloved mezze plate, now available for you to enjoy at home. ingredients: chick peas, tahini, cumin, lemon, garlic$6.50
ESB Olives
perfect paired with our hand curated selection of cheeses. ingredients: mixed olives, thyme, rosemary, oregano, garlic, lemon zest, crushed red pepper, olive oil$6.00
Pizza Dough
$3.25
Pizza Kit (cheese)
includes dough ball, pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese$12.75
Pizza Kit (pepperoni)
includes dough ball, pizza sauce, mozzarella and pepperoni$15.75
Pizza Sauce
tomato, garlic onions, salt$4.50
Veggie Cream Cheese
$6.50Chicken Wing Dip 16oz
$12.50Stuffed Banana Pepper Dip 16oz
$12.50
Market Pantry

Bagged Coffee (12 oz)
$17.00
Crostini
$6.50
ESB granola
$12.00
Biscotti
$9.00
EA advertiser
$2.25
Raw honey
$9.95Croutons
$6.75
Coffee & Beverages

LRG Coffee
$4.00
SM Coffee
$3.50
Hot Tea
$3.25
Cold Brew
$4.25
Iced Tea
$3.25
Saratoga Water
$3.25
Natalies Orange Juice
$4.25
Soda
$3.50
Spindrift
$3.00
Red Jacket Juice
$3.75Coke
$3.00
PIZZA
6 inch Cheese Pizza
tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmesan$10.0012 inch Cheese Pizza
tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmesan$20.006 inch Margherita Pizza
tomato sauce, house made fresh mozzarella, basil$12.0012in Margherita Pizza
tomato sauce, house made fresh mozzarella, basil$22.006 inch Mushroom Pizza
roasted mushrooms, truffle oil, fontina, caramelized onions, thyme, oregano$14.0012 inch Mushroom Pizza
roasted mushrooms, truffle oil, fontina, caramelized onions, thyme, oregano$26.006 inch Spicy White Pizza
roasted banana peppers, confit tomatoes, red onion, ricotta cream, oregano$13.0012 inch Spicy White Pizza
roasted banana peppers, confit tomatoes, red onion, ricotta cream, oregano$25.006 inch Breakfast Pizza
garlic cream, scrambled eggs, bacon, cheddar, crispy potatoes, chives$13.0012 inch Breakfast Pizza
garlic cream, scrambled eggs, bacon, cheddar, crispy potatoes, chives$25.006 inch Squash
Delicata squash, Calabrian chile, provolone, brussel sprout leaves, sage$14.0012 inch Squash
Delicata squash, Calabrian chile, provolone, brussel sprout leaves, sage$26.0010 inch Gluten Free Crust
$18.00
Mushroom & Caramelized Onion Omelette
$14.00
2 eggs, mushrooms, gruyere, caramelized onions, side of sourdough toast
1