Skip to Main content
Hello! Please first select your pick up date, then browse the menu. Thanks!
  • Fairport Harbor Creamery

Fairport Harbor Creamery

202 High St, Fairport Harbor, OH
Pickup Only
‌
‌

THANKSGIVING '26 - only avail for pick up, 11/25 11A-6P

THANKSGIVING '26 - only avail for pick up, 11/25 11A-6P **if you need an alternate pick up day - please email hello@fairportharborcreamery.com with your pick up day / time and we can see what we can make work for you!
  • Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake ICE CREAM PIE

    graham crust + pumpkin caramel cheesecake ice cream, house caramel, our graham crumbles, buttercream decor
    $36.00
  • Chocolate Turtle ICE CREAM PIE

    chocolate crust + chocolate ice cream layered with house caramel, salty pecans and fudge. buttercream decor
    $36.00
  • 10" Pumpkin Cake

    10", 1 layer spiced pumpkin cake, cream cheese frosting, fall buttercream decor. $36, serves 12+
    $36.00
  • 9" Winterberry Cheesecake

    house graham crust, vanilla cheesecake, house winterberry jam, vanilla buttercream. $32, serves 8+
    $32.00
  • 9" Peanut Butter Mousse Pie

    chocolate crust, peanut butter mousse (whipped cream folded into cream cheese & peanut butter blend), chocolate ganache & chocolate decor. $32, serves 8+
    $32.00
  • 9" Pumpkin Coffee Cake

    pumpkin spice sour cream coffee cake, streusel crunch layer & a pumpkin vanilla bean glaze. $17, serves 8+
    $17.00
  • 4" Bourbon Pecan Tart

    graham crust filled with our house bourbon pecan pie filling, pecan pieces and 1/2s, decorated with buttercream
    $6.00
  • 4" Chocolate Caramel Tart

    4" graham crust, house caramel & chocolate ganache, buttercream & chocolate straws/pearls
    $6.00
  • 4" Lemon Curd Tart

    our sugar cookie crust, house lemon curd and decorated with buttercream, lemon zest and while chocolate decor
    $6.00
  • 4" Biscoff Cheesecake Tart

    our ginger molasses crust, house cheesecake mousse, decorated with biscoff cookie butter and biscoff cookie crumbles
    $6.00
  • Box of 4 Tarts

    Choose a mix of any 4 tarts!
    $21.00
  • Cinnamon Rolls, (take&bake, 4)

    tin of 4 of our brioche cinnamon rolls, ready for an overnight pause out of the fridge, and then ready to bake. side of our tangy cream cheese frosting
    $21.00
  • Cinnamon Rolls (take&bake, 6)

    tin of 6 of our brioche cinnamon rolls, ready for an overnight pause out of the fridge, and then ready to bake. side of our tangy cream cheese frosting
    $30.00

Ice Cream Pies & Cakes

Ice Cream Pies

  • Customized Ice Cream Pie **NEED 48HRS NOTICE**

    Don't like our options? We get it. You're the creative genius here! Build your own ice cream pie, add toppings as you please. **NEED 48 HRS NOTICE** If your pick up date isn't 48 hrs from when we receive your order, we will be calling you. Don't make us do that please :)
    $35.00
  • Reese's Lovers Ice Cream Pie

    oreo crust + layer of whole reeses + peanut butter + reese's chunks ice cream, decorated with peanut butter, chocolate buttercream, cookies crumbles & sprinkles
    OUT OF STOCK
    $21.00

Ice Cream Cakes

  • Butterscotch Biscoff IC Cake WHOLE

    vanilla cake / biscoff & biscoff crumb layer / vanilla ice cream swirled with biscoff & butterscotch. Covered in fresh whip, decorated with our swiss meringue buttercream
    $60.00
  • Chocolate PB Caramel IC Cake WHOLE

    chocolate cake / PB & caramel swirls with oreo dirt layer / chocolate ice cream swirled with PB & caramel sauce. Decorated in fresh whipped cream & our swiss meringue buttercream
    $60.00

Ice Cream

Ice Cream

  • Sampler

    Choose 4 flavors for your sampler. Comes in a compartmentalized container to keep your flavors from touching!
    $8.25
  • Pup Cup

    $1.00
  • Apple Cider Float (12OZ)

  • 3oz cup Waffle Cone Chips

    $0.50

To-Go Treats

  • House Drumstick With Peanuts

    classic drumstick with vanilla ice cream, chocolate dipped + peanuts, made in house
    $7.00
  • BYO Ice Cream Sammy

    Build Your Own Ice Cream Sammy!- choose a cookie option- choose a ice cream flavor (single scoop amount)- add toppings for us to roll them in!
    $7.50
  • Seasonal To-Go Sundaes

    $9.00
  • Ice Cream Sammy

    $7.00
  • Spongebob Bar

    $3.60
  • Lemon Italian Ice

    $3.60
  • Strawberry Italian Ice

    $3.60
  • Caramel Apple Pecan IC Cake Slice

    white cake / house caramel & salty pecans / apple ice cream / house whip, more house caramel & salty pecans
    OUT OF STOCK
    $12.25
  • Pumpkin Pecan Biscoff 24OZer

    Layers of vanilla bean ice cream, house pumpkin cake, our candied pecans & biscoff cookie butter drizzles
    $16.50
  • Chocolate Elvis IC Cake Slice

    • chocolate cake / fudge, PB drizzles & Oreo dirt layer / banana jam swirled vanilla ice cream / house whip, Oreo dirt, fudge & PB drizzles
    $12.00
  • Caramel Crunch IC Cake Slice

    Vanilla cake // caramel & crunch coat layer // salted caramel ice cream // topped with fresh whip, crunch coat & more house caramel drizzles
    $12.00

Pints (2026)

  • *BOOZY* Chocolate Pint

    Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey infused chocolate ice cream
    $11.75
  • *BOOZY* Mint Pint

    whiskey and creme de menthe infused mint ice cream
    $11.50
  • *BOOZY* PB Cinnamon Whiskey

    cinnamon Jack Daniels whiskey infused peanut butter & cinnamon ice cream
    OUT OF STOCK
    $11.95
  • *BOOZY* Pumpkin Whiskey Pint

    pumpkin and pumpkin spiced ice cream + Jack Daniels whiskey
    $11.50
  • *BOOZY* Vanilla Pint

    kahlua and seven brothers expresso vodka infused vanilla ice cream (approx. 4% - 4.5% ABV per pint)
    $11.50
  • Apple Crumble Pint

    apple compote infused ice cream + our house brown butter oat streusel
    $9.85
  • Banana Cream Pie Pint

    fresh banana ice cream with house brown butter, oat & vanilla wafer crumble
    $9.75
  • Biscoff Cheesecake Pint

    biscoff cookie butter and cheesecake ice cream, all blended in!
    $9.75
  • Black Cherry Oreo Pint

    Black cherry flavored ice cream + Oreo chunks mixed throughout
    $9.75
  • Butter Pecan Pint

    butter pecan ice cream + buttery toasted pecans mixed in
    $9.75
  • Chocolate Orange Pint

    orange zested ice cream + house chocolate orange ganache
    $9.85
  • Chocolate Pint

    chocolate ice cream made with Extra Brute cocoa powder, making a sinfully delicious chocolate ice cream
    $9.75
  • Cookie Dough Pint

    vanilla bean ice cream + house edible cookie dough crumbles
    $9.75
  • Cookies & Cream Pint

    vanilla ice cream + Oreo cookie chunks
    $9.75
  • Dark Chocolate Caramel Mallow Pint

    our darkest chocolate ice cream + house caramel streaks & mini jet puff mallows
    $10.00
  • Figs & Orange Pint

    Orange zested ice cream + a fig jam swirl
    $9.85
  • Friendsgiving Pint

    white chocolate & spiced pumpkin ice cream + our coffee cake crumbles with a pecan & almond streusel
    $9.85
  • Maple Coffee Pecan Pint

    maple and coffee ice cream with a roasted, buttered & salted pecans folded in
    $9.85
  • Mint Chip Pint

    green mint ice cream + soft chocolate flakes
    $9.65
  • Mocha Pint

    coffee ice cream made with Rising Star Coffee + house chocolate ganache streaks
    $9.65
  • Orange Dole Whip Pint

    gluten free/ dairy free / vegan Orange Dole Whip
    $9.50
  • PB Oreo Pint

    real peanut butter ice cream + oreo chunks
    $9.75
  • Pineapple Dole Whip Pint

    gluten free / soy free / dairy free / vegan Pineapple Dole Whip
    $9.50
  • Pumpkin Caramel Cheesecake Pint

    pumpkin and cheesecake ice cream + house caramel streaks & our house graham crumbles
    $9.95
  • Pumpkin Pecan Praline Pint

    butterscotch pumpkin ice cream + house pecan praline chunks
    $9.95
  • Salted Caramel Pint

    caramel ice cream + salted caramel streaks
    $9.75
  • Strawberry Pint

    strawberry ice cream + house roasted strawberries
    $9.75
  • Vanilla Bean Pint

    classic vanilla ice cream made with pure Mexican vanilla and vanilla bean
    $9.65
  • VEGAN Biscoff Pint

    Our vegan coconut cream base with Biscoff cookie butter *Contains gluten,
    $10.00
  • VEGAN Strawberries & Cream Pint

    vegan coconut cream ice cream with house strawberry jam streaks
    $9.95
  • Winterberry Crumble Pint

    Sweet cream ice cream + house winterberry jam (strawberries, cranberries, & orange) + our brown butter oat streusel
    $9.95

Toppings To Go (8oz)

  • Caramel Topping To Go Container

    8oz of caramel sauce
    $5.00
  • Cherries To Go Container

    8oz of maraschino cherries
    $4.00
  • House Crunch Coat

    house candied peanuts & rainbow sprinkles
    $5.50
  • Homemade Jam

    8oz of our homemade jam
    $7.00
  • Hot fudge To Go Container

    8oz of hot fudge
    $5.00
  • PB Sauce To Go Container

    8oz of peanut butter sauce
    $5.50
  • Sprinkles To Go Container

    8oz of sprinkles
    $3.00
  • Strawberry Sauce (not jam!) To Go Container

    8oz of strawberry sauce
    $4.00
  • Waffle Cones (2)

    2 waffle cones, for ice cream cone making at home!
    $2.00
  • Whipped Cream Can

    Did you forget the whip? We've got you!
    $4.25
  • House Caramel

    $7.00

Bakery

COOKIE

  • 1/2 Dozen Cookies (6)

    $15.00
  • Bakers Dozen Cookies (13)

    $29.50
  • Brown Butter Cookie

    $3.00
  • Salty Choc. Chip Cookie

    $3.10
  • Peanut Butter Cookie

    $3.00
  • Chocolate Orange Cookie

    $3.05
  • Maple Toffee Cookie

    $3.05

BROWNIE / BAR

  • Triple Chocolate Brownie

    our fudgey chocolate brownie with milk and semi-sweet chocolate chunks
    $3.50

EXTRAS

  • Oatmeal Cream Pie

    $6.50
  • Italian Stallion Scone

    $4.25
  • Chocolate Ginger Scone

    $4.25
  • Orange Curd Filled Cookie

    $5.25
  • Frosted Sugar Cookie, any

    $4.00
  • Chocolate Butterscotch Pecan Bar

    $4.50
  • Chocolate & Toasted Mallow Cream Pie

    $6.75
  • Caramel Apple Cakelet

    $4.50
  • Pumpkin Cake Slice

    $5.25
  • Pumpkin Coffee Cake Slice

    $6.00

Take & Bake Menu

  • Take&Bake Brown Butter Cookies (6)

    6 of our brown butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake! comes with parchment and directions
    $15.00
  • Take&Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies (6)

    6 of our chocolate chip cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper, instructions, and enough Maldon salt for all 6
    $15.00
  • Take&Bake Peanut Butter Cookies (6)

    6 of our peanut butter cookies, frozen and ready to bake. Includes 1 sheet parchment paper & instructions
    $15.00
  • 4 Take&Bake Scones, savory only

    Call for current flavor option! It will always be cheesey, but if you need to know specifics -- 440-898-0030
    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.50

BYO Ice Cream Sammy

$7.50

Build Your Own Ice Cream Sammy!- choose a cookie option- choose a ice cream flavor (single scoop amount)- add toppings for us to roll them in!

Customize your item

Cookie Flavor (6)

Required
Select 1 to 6

Ice Cream Flavor (SCOOP$)

Required
Select 1 to 2

Boozy flavor (+$2)

Select up to 4
1

Fairport Harbor Creamery Location and Ordering Hours

(440) 898-0030
202 High St, Fairport Harbor, OH 44077
Open now • Closes at 8:45PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement