Skip to Main content

Garguilo's Bakery 503 lake Ave

Cart icon0

Garguilo's Bakery 503 lake Ave

We are not accepting online orders right now.

Online Menu

Uber Eats

Online Menu

CAKES

7" Layer Cakes

7" Layer Cakes

Choice of cake

Raspberry Cookie Tort

Raspberry Cookie Tort

$28.00

CHEESECAKE

Plain Cheesecake

Plain Cheesecake

BREAD

Challah

Challah

Braided Challah; choice of size

Cinnamon Raisin

$4.73
French Bread

French Bread

$4.20
Irish Soda Bread

Irish Soda Bread

$4.20
Italian Bread

Italian Bread

Option of style and size

Sourdough

Sourdough

$4.20
Pumpernickle

Pumpernickle

$4.20
Pumpernickle Rye

Pumpernickle Rye

$4.20
Raisin Pumpernickle

Raisin Pumpernickle

$5.25
Rye

Rye

Six Grain

Six Grain

Wheat Bread

$4.20
White Bread

White Bread

$4.20

FOCACCIA

Broccoli & Cheddar Focaccia

Broccoli & Cheddar Focaccia

$10.00
Spinach & Swiss Focaccia

Spinach & Swiss Focaccia

$10.00
Spinach & Cheddar Focaccia

Spinach & Cheddar Focaccia

$10.00
Tomato, Onion & Garlic Focaccia

Tomato, Onion & Garlic Focaccia

$10.00
Artichoke, Roasted Pepper & Black Olive Focaccia

Artichoke, Roasted Pepper & Black Olive Focaccia

$10.00

ROLLS & MORE

Hard Roll

Hard Roll

$0.68

add butter, cream cheese or jelly

Hamburger Roll

Hamburger Roll

$4.10

add butter, cream cheese or jelly

Dinner Roll

Dinner Roll

$6.30

add butter, cream cheese or jelly

PIES

Apple

Apple

$16.50+
Blueberry Apple

Blueberry Apple

Cherry

Cherry

Chicken Pot Pie

Chicken Pot Pie

Shredded chicken, peas, green bean, carrot, corn

Raspberry Peach

Raspberry Peach

QUICHE

Lorraine Quiche

Lorraine Quiche

With bacon and egg

Broccoli Cheese Quiche

Spinach & Cheese Quiche

Spinach & Cheese Quiche

Ham & Cheese Quiche

Ham & Cheese Quiche

Crab Quiche

DONUTS

Plain Cronuts

Plain Cronuts

$2.10

Choice of flavor

Filled Cronuts

Filled Cronuts

$3.15

Choice of filling

SINGLE BAKED GOODS

Black & White Cookie

$2.63
Brownies

Brownies

$2.63

With or without nuts

Carrot Cake

Carrot Cake

$2.63
Danish

Danish

$2.36

Choice of flavor

Mini Italian Pastries

Mini Italian Pastries

$1.31

Choice of flavor

Mini Sfegetelli

Mini Sfegetelli

$1.58
Metropolitan

Metropolitan

$2.89

vanilla cupcake with raspberry and buttercream

Raspberry Crumb Square

Raspberry Crumb Square

$3.15
Sugar-Free Turnover

Sugar-Free Turnover

$2.36

Choice of flavor

MUFFINS

Banana Chip

Banana Chip

$2.89
Blueberry

Blueberry

$2.89
Bran Muffin

Bran Muffin

$2.89
Chocolate Chip

Chocolate Chip

$2.89
Corn

Corn

$2.89
Cranberry Nut

Cranberry Nut

$2.89
Lemon Poppy

Lemon Poppy

$2.89
Morning Glory

Morning Glory

$2.89

CUPCAKES

Vanilla

Vanilla

Chocolate

Chocolate

Chocolate Ring Ding

Chocolate Ring Ding

$2.89
Red Velvet

Red Velvet

$4.20

Large size

GLUTEN FREE

Almond Horn

Almond Horn

$3.15
Biscotti

Biscotti

$6.30

6 pc.; made with walnuts

Brownies

Brownies

$3.15

*does not contain nuts

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$5.51

6 pc.

Chocolate Covered Marshmellows

$2.10
Shortbread Cookie topped with Chocolate Chips

Shortbread Cookie topped with Chocolate Chips

$6.30

4 pc.; topped with chocolate tips

Shortbread Cookie topped with Sprinkles

Shortbread Cookie topped with Sprinkles

$6.30

4 pc.; topped with sprinkles

Linzer Tart

Linzer Tart

$3.15

Pignoli Cookies

$23.10

Per pound

Pizza Dough

Pizza Dough

$4.20

Plain Cake

Choice of size and flavor

Raspberry Wafers

GF Rolls

GF Rolls

White Bread

White Bread

FRIDGE & FREEZER

Gluten Free Pizza Dough

Gluten Free Pizza Dough

$4.20
Pizza Dough

Pizza Dough

$3.68

Garlic Bread

$4.73

DOGGY TREATS

Doggy Treats

Doggy Treats

DRINKS

Coffee

Tea

Water

Nesquik

$2.36

Orange Juice

$2.36

Starbucks Iced Coffee

$2.63

Brisk Iced Tea

$1.58

Uber Eats

COOKIES

Large Sprinkle Cookie

Large Sprinkle Cookie

$2.75
Large Chocolate Chip Cookie

Large Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.75
Large Linzer Tart

Large Linzer Tart

$4.75

Butter Cookies assorted

$22.00+

Rainbow Cookies

$16.50+
Pignoli Cookies

Pignoli Cookies

$20.00+

MUFFINS

Corn Muffin

$4.00

Chocolate Chip Muffin

$4.00

Blueberry Muffin

$4.00

Lemon Poppy

$4.00

Bran

$4.00

Cranberry Nut

$4.00

Morning Glory

$4.00

Pumpkin Walnut

$4.00
Garguilo's Bakery 503 lake Ave Location and Ordering Hours
(631) 804-7399
503 lake Ave, St. James, NY 11780
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 5AM
This site is powered byToast logo
Terms of Service | Privacy Statement