Catering Orders: 24-48 Hours Notice Required!

Joe's Next Door - - Carmel
111 West Main Street, Suite 115, Carmel, IN
Cold Sandwiches

Turkey Pesto
Brined roasted turkey breast, tomato conserva, basil pesto, fresh mozzarella, shredded romaine, parm crisp, served on a Stirato Roll$12.99
The French Orchard
Tulip Tree Trillium brie, local butter, bourbon fig jam, Granny Smith apple, served on a French Batard$13.99
The Italian Next Door
Spicy capicola, genoa salami, cotto ham, provolone, heirloom tomato, shredded romaine, and oregano vinaigrette, served on a Stirato Roll$13.99
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad(contains pecans), avocado, local cucumber, butter lettuce, served on a Challah Bun$11.99
Roast Beef and Cheddar
House made roast beef, scallion/horseradish cream, aged white cheddar, romaine, served on a Stirato Roll$13.99
House BLT
House cured candied bacon, sweet butter lettuce, heirloom local tomatoes, sliced avocado, garlic aioli, served on toasted Sourdough$11.99
The #9
We've created a special sandwich with our favorite pro basketball player! Blackened Turkey breast, house made honey dijon dressing, herbed goat cheese topped with fried shallots, served on Amelia's Dinner roll$11.99
Hot Sandwiches

Hot Capicola
Capicola, havarti cheese, caramelized onion, sliced jalapeno, pressed and served on Sourdough bread$11.99
Evan's IPA Braised Beef
12 hour IPA braised beef, havarti fondue, sweet caramelized onion, spicy arugula, red winegastrique, served on a Stirato Roll *Evan's favorite, $1 is contributed to the Merciful H.E.L.P. Center$14.99
Debris Po' Boy
Blackened IPA braised beef, pickled red onion, garlic aioli, house remoulade, romaine lettuce, fresh tomato, served on a French Batard$12.99
Chef's Banh Mi
Citrus braised caramelized pork belly, house pickled vegetables, handpicked cilantro, fresh jalapeno, house made chili aioli, served on a French Batard$14.99
Mission Chicken Torta
House pulled chicken, roasted salsa verde, avocado, aged cotija, shredded iceberg, served on a warm Challah Roll$11.99
El Cubanito
10-hour house braised mojo pork, cotto ham, creamy swiss, house dill pickles, garlic mustard butter, served pressed on French Batard$12.99
Aji Amarillo Flank Steak
House marinated flank steak, cilantro aioli, pickled red onion, cotija cheese, shredded romaine, served on a warm Challah Roll$15.99
Hot Italian Beef
Thin sliced roasted beef in our house au-jus, giardiniera, melty provolone cheese, served on a Soft Roll$12.99
Sicilian Meatball
Family recipe meatballs, house made sunday “gravy”, melted provolone, served on a toasted Soft Roll$12.99
Turkey Tarantino
Brined turkey, sundried tomato pesto, lemon artichoke ricotta, bacon, arugula, served on a Stirato Roll$12.99
Grown-Up Grilled Cheese
Melty havarti, provolone, and white cheddar, candied bacon, and tomato served on Sourdough$9.99
Main St. Meatloaf Sandwich
Delicious homemade meatloaf, red onion, natural swiss cheese, and homemade tomato jam. Mom is jealous!$10.99
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Sustainably raised Duroc pork, braised and shredded soaked in our sweet Indiana bbq sauce, topped with our house brined pickles and served on a challah bun.$11.99
Shrimp Po Boy
Cajun seasoned and sauteed shrimp, shredded lettuce, pickled red onions, and diced tomatoes. Scratch-made remoulade sauce and roasted garlic aioli. Served on toasted French Batard$14.99
Kids Menu

Classic PB&J
Nothing fancy, white bread, peanut butter, and choice of strawberry or grape jelly, just as kids like it!$4.99
Turkey and Cheese Please
Brined roasted turkey, your choice of white cheddar or provolone cheese served on Sourdough....tell us if you want mayo, mustard, lettuce or tomato$7.49
Salads

Basque Steak Salad
Freshly shredded romaine lettuce, sliced marinated flank steak, roasted red pepper, pickled red onion, marcona almonds, shaved parmesan cheese, house made poblano cream dressing$14.99
Side House Salad
Spring mixed lettuce, tomatoes, fresh cucumber, shredded carrots, herbed croutons, with balsamic dressing$7.99
Chips

Broad Ripple Chips ORIGINAL
A local classic. Hand crafted in small batches.$1.99
Broad Ripple Chips SWEET/SPICY
Hand crafted locally, a touch of sugar and bit of spicy heat!$1.99
Great Lakes Buffalo Wing
$1.59
Great Lakes Plain
$1.59
Great Lakes Salt & Vinegar
$1.59
Great Lakes Parmesan Ranch
$1.59
Great Lakes Michigan Cherry BBQ
$1.59
Great Lakes Jalapeño Ranch
$1.59
Sides each

Broccoli Salad- 6oz
6oz, Broccoli, bacon, cran raisins, red onion, carrot, and orange dressing$4.50
Potato Salad- 6oz
6oz, Home made with red potatoes, mayo, mustard, and sweet pickle relish, the classic$3.00
Pasta Salad- 6oz
6oz, Tri-color fussili with italian herb dressing, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, olives and more$3.50
Shaved Brussels Sprouts Salad- 6oz
6oz, Fine shaved brussels sprouts with bacon and brown sugar$4.25
Lemon Pepper Coleslaw- 6oz
6oz, Fresh shaved cabbage and carrots with our homemade lemon pepper dressing$3.25
Macaroni Salad- 6oz
6oz, Fresh made Elbow Macaroni with Green Pepper, Red Pepper, Mayonaise, Celery, Onion, Dijon Mustard, and Sour Cream. Just like Mom used to make!$3.00
Street Corn- 6oz
6oz, Corn, Red and Green Peppers, Jalapeno, Red Onion, Mayo, Lime, Cilantro, Paprika and Cotija Cheese!$4.25
Desserts

Salted "Carmel" Brownie
Home baked dark chocolate brownie cut generously then coated in our house made salted caramel cream$4.99
Chocolate Chip Chip Cookie
Two scratch-made chocolate chip cookies with ruffles potato chips to add a nice salty texture to the sweetness.$4.99
Drinks

Bottled Water
16.9oz, 500ml, bottled water$1.25
Coca-Cola
Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love 12oz can$1.69
Diet Coke
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink 12oz can$1.69
Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free 12oz can$1.69
San Pelligrino Pom Orange 11.15oz
11.15oz can, pomegranate orange flavor$2.49
A' Siciliana Limonata - Lemon Italian Soda - 11.15oz
$2.49
A' Siciliana Aranciata - Italian Blood Orange Soda - 11.15oz
$2.49
Gatorade Orange - 11.6 oz. can
$1.99
Gatorade Lemon Lime - 11.6 oz. can
$1.99
Joe's Butcher Shop & Fish Market Locations and Ordering Hours
- Carmel
Closed • Opens Sunday at 11AM
- ONLINE NOT IN SERVICE - CALL STORE TO ORDER
Closed • Opens Sunday at 11AM