Thank you for a great 2024 season! We are currently closed and preparing for 2025!

Pier i Cafe
FOOD - PiC
Starters
White Bean Hummus
house-made white bean hummus topped with Calabrian chili oil, celery, carrots, house made pita chips
$12.50Classic Chicken Tenders
5 pieces of crispy & tender chicken, choice of dipping sauces
$14.50OUT OF STOCKTomato Soup
House made tomato soup served with parmesan toast crisps
$7.00Calamari
crispy calamari, parsley, lemon wedge, house made spicy marinara
$16.00Chicken Wings
$17.00
Burgers & Handhelds
Veggie Burger
house made black bean and mushroom patty, crispy shallots, arugula, black-garlic aioli
$14.50BYO Burger
7oz custom steak blend, green leaf lettuce, tomato, pickle, toasted Eli's brioche bun
$15.00OUT OF STOCKBlack Bean Tacos
3 crispy black bean tacos served with pico de gallo and salsa verde
$16.00OUT OF STOCK
Salads
Seafood Specialties
Something Sweet
Kids Menu
To Go
DRINKS - PiC
PiC Cocktails
Blue Lemon
Tito's Vodka blended with our house made Blueberry Lemonade.
$13.00Spicy Margarita
$13.00Rocks Margarita
Anza Silver tequila mixed with pier-made margarita mix, lime garnish.
$13.00Spicy Wtrmln Rita
Jalapeno tequila, fresh pressed watermelon and lime juice, a hint of agave and a salt rim
$15.00Sangria
Pinot Grigio wine blended with peach liquor, a splash of sparkling citrus, topped with mangos and blueberries.
$13.00Pier i Tea Party
Jack Daniels Honey Whiskey, peach puree, fresh brewed iced black tea
$14.00Mango Mezcalita
Mezcal, mango puree, lime, tajin rim
$15.00Strawberry Mint Spritz
Muddled strawberries & mint, lillet rose, prosecco.
$15.00Hudson Mojito
$14.00Apperol Spritz
Aperol, apple cider, Prosecco
$14.00Blackberry Mojito
Rum, blackberry liqueur, muddled blackberries & mint, lime
$15.00Vanilla Espresso Martini
Vanilla vodka, Mr. Black coffee liqueur, espresso
$16.00Mimosa
$13.00Bloody Mary
$13.00Cucu cooler
Gin & Cucumber Tonic
$14.00Negroni
$15.0012oz Long Island Iced Tea
$18.00
Beer
Pier i Light Lager (Draft)
Our special house lager, ABV 4.2% -crisp, light refreshing, crushable beer.
$7.00Montauk wave chaser IPA(Draft)
$9.00Five Boroughs Pumpkin (Draft)
$9.00OUT OF STOCKommegang Witte (Draft)
$8.00Five Boroughs Feist Beer (Draft)
$9.00Coney Island Mermaid Pilsner (Draft)
$8.00Corona (Can)
$7.00TALEA Pilsner (Can)
$12.00Athletic Brewing Non Alcoholic Beer
$8.00DownEast Cider (Can)
{All ToGo Alcohol orders must be accompanied by food; dine-in customers must also have food on their first order at the table} original blend, unfiltered, 5.1% abv, 12oz can
$8.00Lunar Hard Seltzer Passion Fruit
Delicious and refreshing craft hard seltzer, made with real fruit juice, no artificial flavors! 4.5% abv
$11.00Tales Pink Lemonade Lager (Can)
$12.00Brooklyn Lager (Cans)
$8.00OUT OF STOCKwatermelon ale (Can)
$8.00
Wine
Chardonnay
Hess Select Chardonnay. Monterey County, California. A classic central coast Chardonnay, offering tropical aromas of grilled pineapple with a hint of star fruit and vanilla.
$13.00Whitehaven Sauv Blanc
$15.00Sancerre
$16.00Prosecco
Villa Jollanda, I love you Prosecco, Italy - a perfectly delicate fizz with hints of pink grapefruit and white peach.
$14.00Prosecco Rose
$15.00OUT OF STOCKclarendelle Rose
From Coteaux d'Aix-en-Provence region. Dry, medium-bodied and zesty with raspberry, red berry, wild herb and briny mineral flavors creamy on the palate matched with crisp acidity. Best paired with our grilled salmon entree.
$15.00Rose
The Little Sheep, French. Nicely balanced with floral and fruity notes.
$14.00Malbec
Aquabiray, Argentina. Dominated by fresh fruits with touches of morello cherry, plum and cassis.
$12.00Pinot Noir
Lodi, California. Medium bodied with delicate cherry and raspberry flavors and a light touch of oak.
$14.00Cabernet Sauvignon
Radley & Finch. Western Cape, South Africa. A classic cabernet, with notes of dark berries, country herbs and a hint of red cherries.
$13.00
Spirits
Sea Ice Vodka
$10.00Tito's
$12.00Ketel One
$13.00New Amsterdam Citron
$11.00House Gin
$10.00Hendrick's
$15.00Bombay Sapphie
$14.00House Rum
$10.00Bacardi
$13.00Gosling's Dark
$13.00Don Q Silver Rum
$12.00House Silver Tequila
$10.00Tanteo Jalapeño
$12.00Herradura Ultra Anejo
$16.00Sauza Silver
$12.001800 Coconut Tequila
$13.001800 Silver Tequila
$13.00Espolon Silver
$12.00Jaja Anejo
$16.00Jaja Blanco
$15.00Jaja Reposado
$16.00De Nada Blanco
$15.00Herradura Silver
$14.00Vida Mezcal
$13.00House Whiskey
$10.00Jack Daniels
$13.00Dewars
$14.00Bulleit Bourbon
$12.00Crown Royal
$13.00Johnnie Walker Black
$15.00Maker's Mark
$13.00Jack Daniels Honey
$12.00Great Jones Bourbon
$13.00Jim Beam
$12.00Jameson
$14.00Woodford
$15.00Aperol
$11.00Campari
$11.00Mr. Black Coffee
$10.00Amaretto
$7.00Peach Schnapps
$7.00Hennessy
$12.00
Frozen
Soft Drinks
Water Bottle
$3.00Blueberry Lemonade
Our pier made blueberry lemonade, garnished with fresh blueberries.
$4.00Frozen Blueberry Lemonade
$6.00Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
$3.75Moroccan Mint (Green) Iced Tea
$4.00Soda
Boylan Soda, authentic handcrafted soda since 1891.
$2.50Small Sparkling Water
Hal's Seltzer
$3.50Juice Cup
12oz with ice
$3.50Kids Juice Box
$2.50Watermelon Aqua Fresca
Cold pressed watermelon and lime juice topped with seltzer
$7.00Limeade
$6.00Pier i Palmer
$4.00Mango Gogo
Frozen Mango
$8.00Hibiscus Iced Tea
$4.00Mela
$5.00Mango Mule (virgin)
$7.00Strawberry Fields
$7.00Coco Coolada
Virgin Pina Colada
$8.00Mangonada
Frozen Mango, Chamoy, Tajin Rim
$11.00OUT OF STOCKCold Apple Cider 12oz
$5.00Hot Apple Cider 8oz
$5.00Frozen Apple Cider 16oz
$8.00
Coffee Drinks
Hot Coffee
$3.25Iced Coffee
$4.00Espresso
$3.50Latte
$4.75Iced Latte
$4.75Cappuccino
$4.75Hot Americano
$3.50Iced Americano
$4.50Chai Latte
$5.50Iced Chai Latte
$5.75Iced Mocha Late
$5.00Matcha Latte
$5.00Iced Matcha
$5.00Hot Tea
$2.75Iced Tea
$3.75Moroccan Mint (Green) Iced Tea
$4.00Light Roast Coffee
$2.25OUT OF STOCKFresh Orange Juice
$4.00Milk
$2.00Macchiato
$4.00Cortado
$4.00Hot Chocolate
$4.00Salted Caramel Mocha
$5.00Pumpkin Spice Latte
$5.00Caramel Brûlée Latte
$5.00Toffee Nut Latte
$5.00Peppermint Hot Chocolate
$4.00