Currently not accepting online orders

Four Brothers Drive In - 4957 New York 22
4957 New York 22, Amenia, NY
Featured Items
Single Burger
$7.00Sm 16oz Shake
$7.50French Fries
Side Cars$6.95
Grand Shack
Eat
CT Lobster Roll
$35.00Maine Lobster Roll
$35.00Spicy Truffle Lobster Roll
$35.00Single Burger
$7.00Double Burger
$9.00JT Burger
$14.00Grilled Foot Long
OUT OF STOCK$3.00Corn Dog
$5.00Super Sonic Grilled Cheese
$9.00Reg. Grilled Cheese
$7.00BEC
$5.00French Fries
Side Cars$6.95Truffle Parm French Fries
Side Cars$13.00Chicken Wings 7 pcs
$10.95Chicken Wings 12 pcs
$17.45Chicken Fingers
Side Cars$11.95Mozzarella Sticks 7 pcs
Side Cars$10.95Mozzarella Sticks 12 pcs
$15.95Onion Rings
Side CarsOUT OF STOCK$10.95Mac & Cheese
$15.95Side Ranch
$0.75Side Blue Cheese
$0.75Side BBQ
$0.75Side Buffalo Sauce
$0.75Side Honey Mustard
$2.50Side Mayo
$0.75Side JT Sauce
$2.50Side Garlic Aioli
OUT OF STOCK$2.50Side JT Jam
$2.50Side Spicy Mayo (dynamite)
$2.50
Drink
Sm 16oz Shake
$7.50Lg 24oz Shake
$9.00Sm Nutella Shake
Vanilla custard blended with Nutella, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$11.50Lg Nutella Shake
Vanilla custard blended with Nutella, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$13.00Sm Rocket Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup and espresso$11.00Lg Rocket Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup and espresso$12.50Sm Brownie Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup, fudge brownie mix, and whole milk$10.50Lg Brownie Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup, fudge brownie mix, and whole milk$12.00Sm Date Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, date sugar, and whole milk$11.50Lg Date Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, date sugar, and whole milk$13.00Sm Dubai Shake
Chocolate custard blended with pistachio spread, kataifi, and whole milk$11.50Lg Dubai Shake
Chocolate custard blended with pistachio spread, kataifi, and whole milk$13.00Sm Birthday Cake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, funfetti cake mix, and whole milk$10.50Lg Birthday Cake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, funfetti cake mix, and whole milk$12.00Sm Strawberry Shortcake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with fresh strawberry topping, funfetti cake mix, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$10.50Lg Strawberry Shortcake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with fresh strawberry topping, funfetti cake mix, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$12.00Sm S'mores Shake
Chocolate custard blended with marshmallow topping, graham crackers, chocolate syrup, and whole milk$11.50Lg S'mores Shake
Chocolate custard blended with marshmallow topping, graham crackers, chocolate syrup, and whole milk$13.00Pumpkin Spice Shake
Vanilla ice cream, pumpkin spice mix, dash of caramel$10.50+Pumpkin Spice Espresso Shake
Vanilla ice cream, pumpkin spice mix, shot of espresso$12.00+Maple Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream blended with a dash of maple syrup$8.50+Salty Caramel Cinn. Sugar Shake
$10.00+Classic Lemonade
$6.00Strawberry Lemonade
$7.50Arnold Palmer
$7.50Cherry Lemonade
$6.00Frozen Lemonade
$8.50Sparkling Lemonade
$7.50Sparkling Strawberry Lemonade
$7.50Sparkling Cherry Lemonade
$6.00Iced Latte
$5.50Hot Latte
$5.50Iced Cappuccino
$5.50Hot Cappucino
$5.50Affogato
$9.00Espresso
Sm Banana Smoothie
$7.50Lg Banana Smoothie
$9.00Sm Pina Colada Smoothie
$7.50Lg Pina Colada Smoothie
$9.00Sm Strawberry Smoothie
$7.50Lg Strawberry Smoothie
$9.00Sm Strawberry/Banana Smoothie
$7.50Lg Strawberry/Banana Smoothie
$9.00Bottled Soda
$2.50Bottled Speciality
$3.95Bottled Water
$2.50Coke
$3.25+Diet Coke
OUT OF STOCK$3.25+Sprite
$3.25+Fanta
$3.25+Rootbeer
$3.25+Iced Tea
$3.25+Seltzer
$3.25+Fountain Water
$0.50
Sin
Soft Serve
Hard Ice Cream
Small Sundae
Sundaes$6.50Large Sundae
Sundaes$8.00Johnny Sundae
Signature Sundaes$9.00Cookie Sundae
Signature Sundaes$11.00Banana Split
Signature Sundaes$12.00Ice Cream Nachos
Signature Sundaes$12.00Dubai Sundae
Chocolate custard topped with pistachio spread, sprinkled with kataifi$11.00Cereal Sundae
Vanilla soft serve ice cream, marshmallow topping, corn flake cereal, whipped cream.$8.50Popcorn
Old School GoodiesFried Dough Balls
Old School Goodies$10.00Fried Oreos
Old School Goodies$12.00Soft Pretzel
Old School Goodies$6.00Cotton Candy
Old School Goodies$6.25Assorted Candy
Old School Goodies$3.50Chips
Old School Goodies$2.50Chocolate Chip Cookie
$3.25S'mores Kit
$6.00The Fiona
Paw Treats$7.00Drumstick
$4.50Toll House
$4.50Spider Man
$2.95Haagen Daz
$4.50Dibs
$3.50Snickers
$2.95Spongebob
$2.95Push Pops
$2.95Italian Ice
$3.50Sandwich Bars
$2.953-pack i/c sandwiches
$9.001-pack i/c sandwich
$5.00
Merch
FAHLO Bracelet
$16.95T-Shirt
$30.00Bug Spray
$9.00Bug Bracelets
$2.50Blanket
$52.00Frisbee
$6.00Key Chain
$3.50Tote Bag
$30.00DVD
$20.00Hats (baseball cap style)
$25.00Bucket Hat
$45.00Metal Caravana Cup
$20.00
Four Brothers Pizza
Salads
Dinner Greek Salad
$6.95Sm Greek Salad
$12.95Lg Greek Salad
$15.95Dinner Tossed Salad
$5.95Sm Tossed Salad
$10.95Lg Tossed Salad
$13.95Sm Antipasto Salad
$14.95Lg Antipasto Salad
$16.95Caesar Salad
$13.95Atlantic Salmon Salad
$20.95Fried Goat Cheese Salad
$16.95Bottle Dressing
$5.95
To Share
Spinach + Artichoke Dip
$13.95Hummus Dip
$10.95Vegetable Spring Rolls
$15.95*Chicken Wings
$10.95Chicken Fingers
$11.95R- Mozzarella Sticks
OUT OF STOCKMeatball + Ricotta
$13.95Caprese Salad
$15.95Garlic Bread
$6.95Calamari
$13.95Coconut Shrimp
$12.95R - French Fries
Soup & SidesOUT OF STOCK$6.95Onion Rings
Side CarsOUT OF STOCK$10.95
Pasta
Pasta with Sauce
$13.45Pasta with Meat
$15.95Garlic Butter Pasta
$15.95Carbonara
$20.95Cheese Ravioli
$15.95Mac & Cheese
$15.95Chicken Scampi Supreme
$20.95Shrimp Scampi Supreme
$22.95Basil Pesto
$21.95Baked Ziti
$16.95Alla Vodka
$20.95Chicken Parmesan
$20.95Chicken & Broccoli Alfredo
$21.95
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger Deluxe
House Favorites$15.95Caprese Sandwich
House Favorites$15.95Beef Gyro
$14.95Chicken Gyro
$14.95Four Brothers Wrap
$14.95Crispy Chicken Wrap
Wraps$14.95Caesar Wrap
Wraps$14.95
Hot Oven Grinders
Chicken Parmesan Grinder
$12.95Meatball Parmesan Grinder
$11.95Eggplant Parmesan Grinder
$11.95Sausage and Pepper Grinder
$11.95Classic Ham Grinder
$11.95Combination Ham & Salami Grinder
$11.95Cheeseburger Grinder
$12.95Philly Cheesesteak Grinder
$13.95
Entrees
Eleni's Lasagna
House Favorites$16.95Spanakopita
House Favorites$16.95Chicken & Eggplant Parm Casserole
Served with a side of spaghetti$20.95Eggplant Casserole
Casseroles$16.95Chicken Casserole
Contains mushrooms, peppers, mozzarella cheese, and housemade marinara sauce.$16.95Sausage Casserole
Contains mushrooms, peppers, mozzarella cheese, and housemade marinara sauce.$16.95Meatball Casserole
Contains mushrooms, peppers, mozzarella cheese, and housemade marinara sauce.$16.95Oven Baked Herbed Chicken
Chicken$19.95Salmon Dinner
Seafood$24.95Fish & Chips
Seafood$20.95Sunday Fried Chicken
Chicken$19.95
Pizza
Small Pizza
6 slices, 10"$12.45Medium PIzza
8 slices, 14"$15.75Large Pizza
12 slices, 18"$18.9510" GF Pizza
Cauliflower Crust$12.95Calzone
$12.45
Beverages
Regular Coffee
$2.50Iced Coffee
$2.75Hot Chocolate
$3.95Black Tea (Lipton)
$2.50Decaf Black Tea (Lipton)
$2.50Tropical Green
$2.50Egyptian Chamomile
$2.50Red Raspberry
$2.50Hot Cinnamon Spice
$2.50Regular Milk
$2.95Chocolate Milk
$3.95
Soups & Sides
French Onion
Soup & Sides$7.50Soup of the Day
Soup & Sides$4.95Side Vegetables
Soup & Sides$5.95Side Coleslaw
Soup & Sides$4.95Side of Meatballs (2)
Soup & Sides$4.95Side of Sausages (2)
Soup & Sides$4.95Salmon Piece (8oz portion)
$13.95Spanakopita Only (no greek salad)
$10.95Small Side Grilled Chicken
$4.50Small Side Crispy Chicken
$4.50Small Side Grilled Shrimp
$6.50Large Side Grilled Chicken
$4.50Large Side Crispy Chicken
$5.50Large Side Grilled Shrimp
$7.50Finger & FF Combo
$13.95
GF Specialties
GF Brothers Pizza
$19.95GF Vegetable Pizza
$19.95GF MVP Pizza
$19.95GF Hawaiian Pizza
$19.95GF White Special
$19.95GF Chicken Bacon Ranch
$19.95GF Goat Cheese Pizza
$19.95GF Margherita
$19.95GF BBQ Chicken
$19.95GF Meat Lovers
$20.45GF Mac n Cheese Pizza
$20.45
Small Specialties
SM Brothers Pizza
$17.45SM Vegetable Pizza
$17.45SM MVP Pizza
$17.45SM Hawaiian Pizza
$17.45SM White Special
$17.45SM Chicken Bacon Ranch
$17.45SM Goat Cheese Pizza
$17.45SM Margherita
$17.45SM BBQ Chicken
$17.45SM Meat Lovers
$18.45SM Mac n Cheese Pizza
$18.45
Medium Specialties
MD Brothers Pizza
$21.75MD Vegetable Pizza
$21.75MD MVP Pizza
$21.75MD Hawaiian Pizza
$21.75MD White Special
$21.75MD Chicken Bacon Ranch
$21.75MD Goat Cheese Pizza
$21.75MD Margherita
$21.75MD BBQ Chicken
$21.75MD Meat Lovers
$22.75MD Mac n Cheese Pizza
$22.75
Large Specialties
LG Brothers Pizza
$26.95LG Vegetable Pizza
$26.95LG MVP Pizza
$26.95LG Hawaiian Pizza
$26.95LG White Special
$26.95LG Chicken Bacon Ranch
$26.95LG Goat Cheese Pizza
$26.95LG Margherita
$26.95LG BBQ Chicken
$26.95LG Meat Lovers
$27.95LG Mac n Cheese Pizza
$27.95
Calzone Specialties
Brothers Calzone
$17.45Vegetable Calzone
$17.45MVP Calzone
$17.45Hawaiian Calzone
$17.45White Special Calzone
$17.45Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Calzone
$17.45Goat Cheese Calzone
$17.45Margherita Calzone
$17.45BBQ Chicken Calzone
$17.45Meat Lovers Calzone
$18.45Mac n Cheese Calzone
$18.45
On-Screen Message
On-Screen Message (one night)
On-Screen Message (for one night)
A video or image of your own creation that will play on our screen for a maximum of 30 seconds before the first movie starts. You must email content to info@playeatdrink.com at least 24 hours in advance!$96.00
Dinner Greek Salad
$6.95
Customize your item
Dinner Salad Additions
Optional
Greek Salad Mods
Optional
Dressing Mods
Optional
Allergies
Optional
Request advisory
Please include the make, model, color, license plate and the row that your vehicle is in for car hop orders (car hop done during movie only)
1