Currently not accepting online orders

Four Brothers Drive In 4957 New York 22
4957 New York 22, Amenia, NY
Featured Items
Single Burger
$7.00Sm 16oz Shake
$7.50French Fries
Side Cars$6.95
Grand Shack
Eat
CT Lobster Roll
$35.00Maine Lobster Roll
$35.00Spicy Truffle Lobster Roll
$35.00Single Burger
$7.00Double Burger
$9.00JT Burger
$14.00Grilled Foot Long
OUT OF STOCK$3.00Corn Dog
$5.00Super Sonic Grilled Cheese
$9.00Reg. Grilled Cheese
$7.00BEC
$5.00French Fries
Side Cars$6.95Truffle Parm French Fries
Side Cars$13.00Chicken Wings 7 pcs
$10.95Chicken Wings 12 pcs
$17.45Chicken Fingers
Side Cars$11.95Mozzarella Sticks 7 pcs
Side Cars$10.95Mozzarella Sticks 12 pcs
$15.95Onion Rings
Side CarsOUT OF STOCK$10.95Mac & Cheese
$15.95Side Ranch
$0.75Side Blue Cheese
$0.75Side BBQ
$0.75Side Buffalo Sauce
$0.75Side Honey Mustard
$2.50Side Mayo
$0.75Side JT Sauce
$2.50Side Garlic Aioli
OUT OF STOCK$2.50Side JT Jam
$2.50Side Spicy Mayo (dynamite)
$2.50
Drink
Sm 16oz Shake
$7.50Lg 24oz Shake
$9.00Sm Nutella Shake
Vanilla custard blended with Nutella, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$11.50Lg Nutella Shake
Vanilla custard blended with Nutella, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$13.00Sm Rocket Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup and espresso$11.00Lg Rocket Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup and espresso$12.50Sm Brownie Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup, fudge brownie mix, and whole milk$10.50Lg Brownie Shake
Chocolate custard blended with chocolate syrup, fudge brownie mix, and whole milk$12.00Sm Date Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, date sugar, and whole milk$11.50Lg Date Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, date sugar, and whole milk$13.00Sm Dubai Shake
Chocolate custard blended with pistachio spread, kataifi, and whole milk$11.50Lg Dubai Shake
Chocolate custard blended with pistachio spread, kataifi, and whole milk$13.00Sm Birthday Cake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, funfetti cake mix, and whole milk$10.50Lg Birthday Cake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with vanilla syrup, funfetti cake mix, and whole milk$12.00Sm Strawberry Shortcake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with fresh strawberry topping, funfetti cake mix, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$10.50Lg Strawberry Shortcake Shake
Vanilla custard blended with fresh strawberry topping, funfetti cake mix, vanilla syrup, and whole milk$12.00Sm S'mores Shake
Chocolate custard blended with marshmallow topping, graham crackers, chocolate syrup, and whole milk$11.50Lg S'mores Shake
Chocolate custard blended with marshmallow topping, graham crackers, chocolate syrup, and whole milk$13.00Pumpkin Spice Shake
Vanilla ice cream, pumpkin spice mix, dash of caramel$10.50+Pumpkin Spice Espresso Shake
Vanilla ice cream, pumpkin spice mix, shot of espresso$12.00+Maple Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream blended with a dash of maple syrup$8.50+Salty Caramel Cinn. Sugar Shake
$10.00+Classic Lemonade
$6.00Strawberry Lemonade
$7.50Arnold Palmer
$7.50Cherry Lemonade
$6.00Frozen Lemonade
$8.50Sparkling Lemonade
$7.50Sparkling Strawberry Lemonade
$7.50Sparkling Cherry Lemonade
$6.00Iced Latte
$5.50Hot Latte
$5.50Iced Cappuccino
$5.50Hot Cappucino
$5.50Affogato
$9.00Espresso
Sm Banana Smoothie
$7.50Lg Banana Smoothie
$9.00Sm Pina Colada Smoothie
$7.50Lg Pina Colada Smoothie
$9.00Sm Strawberry Smoothie
$7.50Lg Strawberry Smoothie
$9.00Sm Strawberry/Banana Smoothie
$7.50Lg Strawberry/Banana Smoothie
$9.00Bottled Soda
$2.50Bottled Speciality
$3.95Bottled Water
$2.50Coke
$3.25+Diet Coke
OUT OF STOCK$3.25+Sprite
$3.25+Fanta
$3.25+Rootbeer
$3.25+Iced Tea
$3.25+Seltzer
$3.25+Fountain Water
$0.50
Sin
Soft Serve
Hard Ice Cream
Small Sundae
Sundaes$6.50Large Sundae
Sundaes$8.00Johnny Sundae
Signature Sundaes$9.00Cookie Sundae
Signature Sundaes$11.00Banana Split
Signature Sundaes$12.00Ice Cream Nachos
Signature Sundaes$12.00Dubai Sundae
Chocolate custard topped with pistachio spread, sprinkled with kataifi$11.00Cereal Sundae
Vanilla soft serve ice cream, marshmallow topping, corn flake cereal, whipped cream.$8.50Popcorn
Old School GoodiesFried Dough Balls
Old School Goodies$10.00Fried Oreos
Old School Goodies$12.00Soft Pretzel
Old School Goodies$6.00Cotton Candy
Old School Goodies$6.25Assorted Candy
Old School Goodies$3.50Chips
Old School Goodies$2.50Chocolate Chip Cookie
$3.25S'mores Kit
$6.00The Fiona
Paw Treats$7.00Drumstick
$4.50Toll House
$4.50Spider Man
$2.95Haagen Daz
$4.50Dibs
$3.50Snickers
$2.95Spongebob
$2.95Push Pops
$2.95Italian Ice
$3.50Sandwich Bars
$2.953-pack i/c sandwiches
$9.001-pack i/c sandwich
$5.00
Merch
FAHLO Bracelet
$16.95T-Shirt
$30.00Bug Spray
$9.00Bug Bracelets
$2.50Blanket
$52.00Frisbee
$6.00Key Chain
$3.50Tote Bag
$30.00DVD
$20.00Hats (baseball cap style)
$25.00Bucket Hat
$45.00Metal Caravana Cup
$20.00
Four Brothers Pizza
Salads
Dinner Greek Salad
$6.95Sm Greek Salad
$12.95Lg Greek Salad
$15.95Dinner Tossed Salad
$5.95Sm Tossed Salad
$10.95Lg Tossed Salad
$13.95Sm Antipasto Salad
$14.95Lg Antipasto Salad
$16.95Caesar Salad
$13.95Atlantic Salmon Salad
$20.95Fried Goat Cheese Salad
$16.95Bottle Dressing
$5.95
To Share
Spinach + Artichoke Dip
$13.95Hummus Dip
$10.95Vegetable Spring Rolls
$15.95*Chicken Wings
$10.95Chicken Fingers
$11.95R- Mozzarella Sticks
OUT OF STOCKMeatball + Ricotta
$13.95Caprese Salad
$15.95Garlic Bread
$6.95Calamari
$13.95Coconut Shrimp
$12.95R - French Fries
Soup & SidesOUT OF STOCK$6.95Onion Rings
Side CarsOUT OF STOCK$10.95
Pasta
Pasta with Sauce
$13.45Pasta with Meat
$15.95Garlic Butter Pasta
$15.95Carbonara
$20.95Cheese Ravioli
$15.95Mac & Cheese
$15.95Chicken Scampi Supreme
$20.95Shrimp Scampi Supreme
$22.95Basil Pesto
$21.95Baked Ziti
$16.95Alla Vodka
$20.95Chicken Parmesan
$20.95Chicken & Broccoli Alfredo
$21.95
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger Deluxe
House Favorites$15.95Caprese Sandwich
House Favorites$15.95Beef Gyro
$14.95Chicken Gyro
$14.95Four Brothers Wrap
$14.95Crispy Chicken Wrap
Wraps$14.95Caesar Wrap
Wraps$14.95
Hot Oven Grinders
Chicken Parmesan Grinder
$12.95Meatball Parmesan Grinder
$11.95Eggplant Parmesan Grinder
$11.95Sausage and Pepper Grinder
$11.95Classic Ham Grinder
$11.95Combination Ham & Salami Grinder
$11.95Cheeseburger Grinder
$12.95Philly Cheesesteak Grinder
$13.95
Entrees
Eleni's Lasagna
House Favorites$16.95Spanakopita
House Favorites$16.95Chicken & Eggplant Parm Casserole
Served with a side of spaghetti$20.95Eggplant Casserole
Casseroles$16.95Chicken Casserole
Contains mushrooms, peppers, mozzarella cheese, and housemade marinara sauce.$16.95Sausage Casserole
Contains mushrooms, peppers, mozzarella cheese, and housemade marinara sauce.$16.95Meatball Casserole
Contains mushrooms, peppers, mozzarella cheese, and housemade marinara sauce.$16.95Oven Baked Herbed Chicken
Chicken$19.95Salmon Dinner
Seafood$24.95Fish & Chips
Seafood$20.95Sunday Fried Chicken
Chicken$19.95
Pizza
Small Pizza
6 slices, 10"$12.45Medium PIzza
8 slices, 14"$15.75Large Pizza
12 slices, 18"$18.9510" GF Pizza
Cauliflower Crust$12.95Calzone
$12.45
Beverages
Regular Coffee
$2.50Iced Coffee
$2.75Hot Chocolate
$3.95Black Tea (Lipton)
$2.50Decaf Black Tea (Lipton)
$2.50Tropical Green
$2.50Egyptian Chamomile
$2.50Red Raspberry
$2.50Hot Cinnamon Spice
$2.50Regular Milk
$2.95Chocolate Milk
$3.95
Soups & Sides
French Onion
Soup & Sides$7.50Soup of the Day
Soup & Sides$4.95Side Vegetables
Soup & Sides$5.95Side Coleslaw
Soup & Sides$4.95Side of Meatballs (2)
Soup & Sides$4.95Side of Sausages (2)
Soup & Sides$4.95Salmon Piece (8oz portion)
$13.95Spanakopita Only (no greek salad)
$10.95Small Side Grilled Chicken
$4.50Small Side Crispy Chicken
$4.50Small Side Grilled Shrimp
$6.50Large Side Grilled Chicken
$4.50Large Side Crispy Chicken
$5.50Large Side Grilled Shrimp
$7.50Finger & FF Combo
$13.95
GF Specialties
GF Brothers Pizza
$19.95GF Vegetable Pizza
$19.95GF MVP Pizza
$19.95GF Hawaiian Pizza
$19.95GF White Special
$19.95GF Chicken Bacon Ranch
$19.95GF Goat Cheese Pizza
$19.95GF Margherita
$19.95GF BBQ Chicken
$19.95GF Meat Lovers
$20.45GF Mac n Cheese Pizza
$20.45
Small Specialties
SM Brothers Pizza
$17.45SM Vegetable Pizza
$17.45SM MVP Pizza
$17.45SM Hawaiian Pizza
$17.45SM White Special
$17.45SM Chicken Bacon Ranch
$17.45SM Goat Cheese Pizza
$17.45SM Margherita
$17.45SM BBQ Chicken
$17.45SM Meat Lovers
$18.45SM Mac n Cheese Pizza
$18.45
Medium Specialties
MD Brothers Pizza
$21.75MD Vegetable Pizza
$21.75MD MVP Pizza
$21.75MD Hawaiian Pizza
$21.75MD White Special
$21.75MD Chicken Bacon Ranch
$21.75MD Goat Cheese Pizza
$21.75MD Margherita
$21.75MD BBQ Chicken
$21.75MD Meat Lovers
$22.75MD Mac n Cheese Pizza
$22.75
Large Specialties
LG Brothers Pizza
$26.95LG Vegetable Pizza
$26.95LG MVP Pizza
$26.95LG Hawaiian Pizza
$26.95LG White Special
$26.95LG Chicken Bacon Ranch
$26.95LG Goat Cheese Pizza
$26.95LG Margherita
$26.95LG BBQ Chicken
$26.95LG Meat Lovers
$27.95LG Mac n Cheese Pizza
$27.95
Calzone Specialties
Brothers Calzone
$17.45Vegetable Calzone
$17.45MVP Calzone
$17.45Hawaiian Calzone
$17.45White Special Calzone
$17.45Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Calzone
$17.45Goat Cheese Calzone
$17.45Margherita Calzone
$17.45BBQ Chicken Calzone
$17.45Meat Lovers Calzone
$18.45Mac n Cheese Calzone
$18.45
On-Screen Message
On-Screen Message (one night)
On-Screen Message (for one night)
A video or image of your own creation that will play on our screen for a maximum of 30 seconds before the first movie starts. You must email content to info@playeatdrink.com at least 24 hours in advance!$96.00
Mozzarella Sticks 7 pcs
$10.95
Side Cars
Customize your item
Mozz Stick Prep
Select up to 2
Allergies
Optional
Request advisory
Please include the make, model, color, license plate and the row that your vehicle is in for car hop orders (car hop done during movie only)
1