Skip to Main content
  • Poppy Seed Bagels

Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering - 2220 Forest Avenue

2220 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • BYO Egg Sandwich

    $4.00
  • Big Jack.

    Sausage, Bacon, Eggs & Hot honey
    $12.10
  • Bumble Bee

    Bacon, Egg, & Scallion Cream Cheese & Hot Honey
    $11.10

Create-A-Breakfast

Top Picks

  • BYO Egg Sandwich

    $4.00
  • BYO Egg Platter

    $7.70
  • BYO Omelette

    1 Meat + 1 Cheese + 2 Veggie of your choice
    $10.50+

Breakfast

Breakfast Specials

  • Big Jack.

    Sausage, Bacon, Eggs & Hot honey
    $12.10
  • The Jersey

    Fried Eggs, Taylor Ham, & American cheese & Ketchup Aioli
    $10.70
  • The Mexican

    Jalapeño Bagel, Peppers, onions, Chorizo, Eggs & Cheddar & jack
    $13.00
  • Hold 'em

    Steak, Eggs, Pepperjack & Caramelized onion
    $12.90
  • Bumble Bee

    Bacon, Egg, & Scallion Cream Cheese & Hot Honey
    $11.10
  • Cali

    Scrambled Egg, avocado & American cheese
    $9.90
  • Spicy Pig

    Eggwhites, Turkey Bacon, Swiss & Hot Sauce
    $11.90
  • The Sriracha

    Sausage, Egg & Honey Bacon Sriracha Cream Cheese
    $11.30
  • Angry Avocado

    Avocado, Bacon, Eggs & Chipotle Cream Cheese
    $11.90
  • BELT

    Double bacon, fried egg, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo
    $11.30
  • Sweet Life

    Bacon, Egg, American cheese, On a french toast bagel, Syrup
    $11.50
  • Gobbler

    Turkey, Fried eggs, cheddar, avocado, chipotle aioli
    $11.80
  • Breeze

    $10.50

House Omelettes

  • Green Sandwich

    Jalapeño, Avocado, Scallion, Pepperjack
    $9.40
  • Cheesy Sandwich

    3 Cheeses of your choice.
    $7.70
  • Western Sandwich

    Ham, Peppers, Onion & American
    $8.20
  • Veggie Sandwich

    Spinach, Mushroom & feta
    $8.30
  • Muscle Sandwich

    Ham, Bacon, Sausage & American
    $10.60
  • Southwest Sandwich

    Chorizo, pepper jack, jalapeño, tomato & avocado
    $10.60
  • Chicken Fajita Sandwich

    Grilled chicken, caramelized onion, bell pepper, cheddar jack
    $10.60
  • Green Omelette Platter

    Jalapeño, Avocado, Scallion, Pepperjack
    $12.70
  • Cheesy Omelette Platter

    3 Cheeses of your choice.
    $10.60
  • Western Omelette platter

    Ham, Peppers, Onion & American
    $12.60
  • Veggie Omelette platter

    Spinach, Mushroom & feta
    $12.00
  • Muscle Omelette platter

    Ham, Bacon, Sausage & American
    $13.80
  • Southwest Omelette platter

    Chorizo, pepper jack, jalapeño, tomato & avocado
    $13.80
  • Chicken Fajita platter

    Grilled chicken, caramelized onion, bell pepper, cheddar jack
    $13.80

Side Orders

  • French Fries

    $4.00
  • Tater Tots

    $4.00
  • Jalapeño Poppers

    5 jalapeño poppers
    $7.00
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    $7.00
  • Onion Rings

    $7.00
  • Side Bacon

    $5.00
  • Side Sausage

    $5.00
  • Side Chorizo

    $5.00
  • Side Turkey Bacon

    $5.00
  • Side Turkey Sausage

    $5.00
  • Side Ham

    Boar's Head Branded Deluxe Ham, sliced fresh.
    $5.00
  • French Fries lg

    $7.00
  • Tater Tots lg

    $7.00

Butter Me Up

  • Silver Dollar Pancake (6)

    $6.00
  • Short Stack (2P)

    $6.00
  • Pancakes (3)

    $8.00
  • Short Cut (2FT)

    $6.00
  • French Toast Platter

    $8.00
  • Belgian Waffle

    $8.00

Brunch

Brunch Specials

  • Florence

    Ham, salami, pepperoni, Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Seasoned Italian Dressing
    $12.80
  • Old School

    Roast Beef, Fresh Mozz & beef onion gravy
    $12.80
  • Forest Club

    Turkey, Tomato, Lettuce, Avocado, Bacon & Honey Aioli
    $12.80
  • Maple Pkway

    Honey Turkey, fresh mozz, bacon & Honey aioli
    $12.80
  • Prime

    Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers, mozzarella, Spinach, Pesto Aioli
    $12.80
  • South Ave

    Crispy Chicken, Cheddar, Jalapeño spread, caramelized onion, Chipotle Aioli
    $12.80
  • Buff Chick

    Buffalo Chicken, cheddar, Scallions, Ranch
    $12.80
  • Regis Dr

    Cheesesteak, Caramelized Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, & Swiss
    $12.80
  • The Harbor

    Sliced Lox, Scallion Cream Cheese, Capers, Tomato, Red Onion
    $14.80
  • Red Hook

    Red roasted peppers, fried chicken cutlets, fresh mozz, balsamic glaze & pesto aioli
    $12.80
  • Black and Yellow

    Hot pastrami, caramelized onions, american cheese, Pickles, Spicy mustard, Onion Bagel
    $12.80
  • Melty Way

    $12.80

BYO Sandwich

  • Ham

    Boar's Head Branded Deluxe Ham. Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Turkey

    Boar's Head Ovengold Turkey. Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Pastrami

    Boar's Head 1st Cut Pastrami. Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Honey Turkey

    Boar's Head Honey Coat Turkey. Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Nova Lox

    Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Salami

    Boar's Head Genoa Salami. Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Roast Beef

    Boar's Head Top Round Roast Beef. Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Steak

    Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Chorizo

    Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Vegan Chorizo

    Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Grilled Chicken

    Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Chicken Cutlet

    Begins with Meat Only; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • BLT

    Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato; add your choice of cheese, toppings and spreads/condiments
    $8.95
  • Grilled Cheese

    $5.95
  • Chopped Cheese

    Ground Beef, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Peppers, Caramelized Onions, Ketchup and Mayo
    $10.00
  • Chicken Caesar

    $9.95

Sliced Meat Per LB

  • Ham per Lb

    Boar's Head Branded Deluxe Ham. All Meat is available in 1/4LB , 1/2LB, or 1LB
    $3.99+
  • Turkey per Lb

    Boar's Head Ovengold Turkey. All Meat is available in 1/4LB , 1/2LB, or 1LB
    $3.99+
  • Pastrami per Lb

    Boar's Head 1st Cut Pastrami. All Meat is available in 1/4LB , 1/2LB, or 1LB
    $5.50+
  • Honey Turkey per Lb

    Boar's Head Honey Coat Turkey. All Meat is available in 1/4LB , 1/2LB, or 1LB
    $3.99+
  • Roast Beef per Lb

    Boar's Head Top Round Roast Beef. All Meat is available in 1/4LB , 1/2LB, or 1LB
    $5.50+
  • Salami per Lb

    Boar's Head Genoa Salami. All Meat is available in 1/4LB , 1/2LB, or 1LB
    $3.99+
  • Pepperoni per Lb

    Boar's Head Sandwich Pepperoni, sliced fresh.
    $3.99+
  • American Cheese per Lb

    Boar's Head Yellow American, sliced fresh.
    $3.25+
  • Swiss Cheese per Lb

    Boar's Head Gold Label Swiss, sliced fresh.
    $3.25+
  • Pepperjack Cheese per Lb

    Boar's Head Pepper Jack, sliced fresh.
    $3.25+
  • Provolone Cheese per Lb

    Boar's Head Provolone, sliced fresh.
    $3.25+
  • Cheddar Per Lb

    Boar's Head Vermont Cheddar, sliced fresh.
    $3.25+
  • Fresh Mozz per Lb

    $3.25+

Spreads by Lb

Spread by Lb

  • Spreads By LB


Catering

Breakfast Packages

Big order? You've got the right bagel shop. Orders over $1,000: please call us first at (718) 233-8656. Online orders over $1,000 are held until we call you to confirm, so we're not in the middle of another big catering order or a rush and your order comes out right on time.
  • #1 Bagel & Schmear Box

    $7 per person · Groups of 10+. Assorted Bagels with 5 Flavored Cream Cheeses, Butter & Jelly. How to order: 1) pick how many people (60+ people can add juice or water by the case), 2) pick bagel flavors, then tap "Assorted for the rest", 3) pick up to 5 spreads. Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10.
  • #2 Buns & Yolk

    $8 per person · Groups of 10+. Hot egg sandwiches: Egg, Egg & Cheese, Protein & Egg, or Protein, Egg & Cheese (bacon, sausage, Taylor ham, pastrami or ham; turkey bacon or turkey sausage +$1). On bagels, rolls or wraps (+$1). How to order: 1) pick how many people, 2) pick exactly that many sandwiches (5-packs for 30+; 60+ people can add juice or water by the case) and (optional) how many on wraps or rolls (skip = all bagels), then tap Confirm, 3) pick bagel flavors (optional; skip if all on wraps or rolls). Includes ketchup, salt & pepper. Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10. Hot food stays hot 1½–2 hours.
  • #3 Sunny Side Feast

    $15 per person · Groups of 10+. Scrambled Eggs, Sausage Patties, Bacon, Pancakes & Hash Brown Tots. Includes Ketchup, Salt, Pepper, Syrup & Butter, Plus Assorted Bagels. How to order: 1) pick how many people (60+ people can add juice or water by the case), 2) everything is already included, just pick Regular or Crispy bacon, 3) pick bagel flavors, then "Assorted for the rest", 4) pick up to 5 spreads. Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10. Hot food stays hot 1½–2 hours.
  • #4 Stacks on Stacks

    $7 per person · Groups of 10+. Choice of 3 Pancakes or 4 French Toast Triangles Per Person with Syrup & Butter. How to order: 1) pick how many people (60+ people can add juice or water by the case), 2) pick Pancakes, French Toast or half and half. Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10. Hot food stays hot 1½–2 hours.
  • #5 Brew & Chew

    $6 per person · Groups of 10+. Assorted Pastries & Muffins with Box O' Joe coffee: 1 Box O' Joe (96 oz, about 12 cups) per 10 people. How to order: 1) pick how many people (the next screen shows how many Box O' Joe you get; 60+ people can add juice or water by the case) and tap Confirm (tap the coffee line if you want some boxes decaf), 2) tap Add to Cart (everything else is already included). Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10.
  • #6 Breakfast Bestie Box

    $10 per person · Groups of 10+. Muffins & Pastries with Assorted Bagels & Specialty Cream Cheeses. How to order: 1) pick how many people (60+ people can add juice or water by the case), 2) pick bagel flavors, then "Assorted for the rest", 3) pick up to 5 spreads. Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10.
  • #7 Nova Nation

    $15 per person · Groups of 10+. Smoked Nova Lox, Specialty Cream Cheeses, Assorted Bagels, Tomato, Red Onion & Capers. How to order: 1) pick how many people (60+ people can add juice or water by the case), 2) pick bagel flavors, then "Assorted for the rest", 3) pick up to 5 spreads. Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10.
  • #8 Feast Mode

    $18 per person · Groups of 10+. Assorted Bagels with up to 5 choices of Flavored Cream Cheese, Butter, Jelly, Assorted Pastries & Muffins, Seasonal Fruit and Box O' Joe: 1 Box O' Joe (96 oz, about 12 cups) per 10 people and 1 fruit platter per 12 people (rounded up). How to order: 1) pick how many people (the next screen shows your coffee and fruit; 60+ people can add juice or water by the case) and tap Confirm (tap the coffee line if you want some boxes decaf), 2) pick bagel flavors, then "Assorted for the rest", 3) pick up to 5 spreads. Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10.
  • #9 The Crowd Pleaser

    $11 per person · Groups of 10+. Sandwich platter from our Brunch Specials. How to order: 1) pick how many people, 2) pick exactly that many sandwiches (5-packs for 30+; 60+ people can add juice or water by the case) and (optional) how many on wraps (+$1 each; skip = all bagels), then tap Confirm, 3) pick bagel flavors (optional; skip if all on wraps or rolls). Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10. Hot food stays hot 1½–2 hours.
  • #10 Flip it & Dip it

    $75 a tray. 1 tray = 6 quesadillas (Cheese, Chicken and/or Chorizo (pork), cut into 4) and feeds about 10. Order 2 trays for 15-20 people, 3 for 25-30. Served with Sour Cream & Salsa. How to order: 1) pick how many trays (Quantity at the bottom), 2) 1 of each kind is already picked: tap + to add 3 more (6 total). Plates & napkins included. Delivery from about $10. Hot food stays hot 1½–2 hours.
    $75.00

Extras

  • Farm Fresh Scrambled Eggs

    Half tray feeds 5-6, full tray feeds 10-12.
    $30.00+
  • Hash Brown Tots

    With Peppers & Onions. Half tray feeds 5-6, full tray feeds 10-12.
    $30.00+
  • Seasonal Fruit Platter (feeds 10-12)

    Feeds 10-12.
    $60.00
  • Yogurt Parfaits (1 per person)

    Pick how many people you're feeding (10 person minimum). $45 for 10 people, $4 for each extra person.
    $45.00+
  • Muffin & Pastries Platter (feeds 10-12)

    Feeds 10-12.
    $50.00
  • Bacon, Sausage, or Grilled ham

    Choose bacon, sausage or grilled ham. Pick how many people you're feeding (10 person minimum). Priced per person.
    $40.00+
  • Box O' Joe (96 oz, about 12 cups)

    Serves about 12.
    $28.00

Bagels & Spreads

Bagel with Spreads

  • Bagel with Spreads

    $1.30

Dry Bagels

Half Dozen

  • Half Dozen

    Pick 7 bagels (6 + 1 free). Extra bagels +$1.30 each. Want us to pick? Order Half Dozen ASSORTED. Want them cut in half and boxed? Add 'Cut in half / Put in Box' (+$5).
    $7.50
  • Half Dozen ASSORTED

    We pick 7 assorted bagels for you. Want more? Add extra bagels below (+$1.30 each).
    $7.50
  • Cut in half / Put in Box

    Add this with your Half Dozen or Dozen and we'll cut them in half and box them.
    $5.00

Dozen Bagels

  • Dozen Bagels

    Pick 14 bagels (12 + 2 free). Extra bagels +$1.30 each. Want us to pick? Order Dozen ASSORTED. Want them cut in half and boxed? Add 'Cut in half / Put in Box' (+$5).
    $15.00
  • Dozen ASSORTED

    We pick 14 assorted bagels for you. Want more? Add extra bagels below (+$1.30 each).
    $15.00
  • Cut in half / Put in Box

    Add this with your Half Dozen or Dozen and we'll cut them in half and box them.
    $5.00

Single Dry Bagels

  • Plain Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Egg Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Cinnamon Raisin Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Everything Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Blueberry Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Egg Everything Bagel!

    $1.30
  • French Toast Bagel!

    $2.26
  • Garlic Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Multi-Grain Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Onion Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Poppyseed Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Pumpernickel Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Rainbow Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Sesame Bagel!

    $1.30
  • WW Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Whole wheat Everything bagel!

    $1.30
  • Salt Bagel!

    $1.30
  • Gf Everything!

    $3.95
  • Gf Plain!

    $3.95
  • Jalapeño Bagel!

    $1.30

Muffins/Pastries/Fruit

  • Muffin

    $3.50
  • 2 Muffins for $6

    $6.00
  • Crumb Cake

    $4.50
  • Creme Brulee Tart

    $2.00
  • Fruit Cup

    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.95
  • Croissant

    $3.25
  • Almond Croissant

    $3.95
  • Chocolate Croissant

    $3.95
  • Chocolate Cigars

    $3.95
  • Cinnabun

    $3.95
  • Cheese Pocket (danish)

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.95
  • Lemon loaf

    $3.95
  • Apple Danish

    $3.95
  • Brownie

    $3.95
  • Blueberry Scones

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.95
  • Apple fritter

    $3.95
  • Apple pie stick

    $2.00
  • Seasonal Pastry

    $3.95
  • Gum

    $2.50
  • Parfait (1)

    $3.95
  • Mentos

    $2.50
  • Mascarpone French Toast

    $7.00
  • Chips

    $2.89
  • LARGE chip

    $4.29
  • Tic tac

    $2.50
  • Halls Throat

    $2.50

Drinks

Coffee & Tea

  • Hot Coffee

    $2.67
  • Cold Brew Coffee

    $3.75
  • Hot Coffee Decaf

    $2.67
  • Hot Cocoa

    $3.75
  • Hot Tea

    $2.75

Drinks

  • Tropicana

    $2.69
  • Snapple

    $2.50
  • Minute Maid

    $2.69
  • Poland Spring

    $1.50+
  • Calypso

    $2.50
  • 16oz Soda Can

    $2.25
  • 2 Liter

    $3.75
  • 20oz Bottle

    $2.69
  • Aloevine Coco 1.5L

    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.00
  • Arizona

    $2.50
  • Bai

    $2.69
  • Bang

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.29
  • Bloom

    $3.00
  • Body Armor

    $2.89
  • C4

    $3.29
  • Can soda

    $1.75
  • Celsius

    $3.00
  • Coffee Mate

    $7.49
  • Core Power

    $5.95
  • Dunkin Iced Coffee

    $3.65
  • Electrolit

    $3.95
  • Essentia

    $2.25+
  • Fairlife Milk

    $2.89
  • Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice

    $7.99
  • Gatorade

    $2.69
  • Good2Grow

    $4.50
  • Halls

    $2.69
  • Joe's Tea

    $3.50
  • Lean Body

    $5.95
  • Manhattan Special

    $3.00
  • Martinelli Apple Juice

    $3.00
  • Milk

  • Monster

    $3.29
  • Muscle Milk

    $5.95
  • Nesquik

    $2.89
  • Ocean Spray

    $2.99
  • Poppi

    $2.50
  • Pure Leaf

    $3.00
  • Red Bull

    $2.99+
  • San Pellegrino

    $2.50
  • Smart Water

    $2.25+
  • Smart Water alkaline

  • Starbucks Double shot

    $4.50
  • Starbucks Espresso

    $3.65
  • Starbucks Frappe

    $4.65
  • Stewarts

    $3.00
  • Tropicana 32oz

    $4.50
  • Tropicana Lg

    $6.50
  • Vita Coco

    $3.50+
  • Vitamin Water

    $2.79
  • Yoohoo

    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.79
  • Nantucket Nectar

    $2.69
  • Snapple LARGE

    $3.95
  • Fiji Water

    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.25
  • Buckle Up Energy

    $3.29
  • Refresher

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.95
  • Naked

    $4.95
  • Naked protein

    $5.50
  • David protein

    $4.95

Cali

$9.90

Scrambled Egg, avocado & American cheese

Customize your item

Bread Choice

Required
Select 1

Toast Options

Required
Select 1

Condiments

Optional

Extra Toppings

Optional

Spreads

Optional

Egg Choice

Select up to 1

Protein

Select up to 1

Side

Select up to 1

Cheese

Select up to 1

Custom

Optional

Instructions

Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Poppy Seed Bagels Location and Hours

(718) 233-8656
2220 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10303
Closed • Opens Sunday at 6AM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement