Online Ordering Available!
Sweet Sister's Fault - Seaford
Rewards & Savings
Sweets & Desserts
Sweets & Desserts
- 10 Slices (BUILD YOUR OWN CAKE)
10 randomly choose slices of cake for you! (this is a non diet item) and it looks like a whole cake! PERFECT FOR CELEBRATIONS AND SHARING. You may list flavors of your preference if available we will added for you, if not available we will replace it. NOT AVAILABLE TO PICK UP FRIDAY OR SATURDAY
$49.99 - Ben & Jenn Chocolate Lovers Cake$5.00
- Brownie M&M$4.75
- Brownie Tres Leches$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Cannoli Cake
Cake made with Limoncello Liquor and homemade compote
$5.00 - Carrot & Cream Cheese Cake$5.00
- Cheesecake Plain - GF
Puerto Rican Style - Crustless Cheesecake. Gluten Free Contains Sugar. Special Price Online Only
$4.00 - Cheesecake with Berries - GF
Our Crustless Puerto Rican Style Cheesecake. Fluffy and delicious.
$4.75 - Cheesecake with Nutella$4.75
- Chocolate Mousse Cake$4.75
- Flan Cream Cheese - GF
Puerto Rican Style Cream Cheese Custard
$4.75 - Flan de Vanilla Slice -GF
Puerto Rican Style Vanilla Custard.
$4.75 - Guava Puff Pastry/ Pastelillo
Puffpastry filled with guava jelly
$2.00OUT OF STOCK - Hot Cocoa Cake$5.00
- Limoncello Blueberry Cake
Cake made with swiss butter cream (alcohol free)
$5.00OUT OF STOCK - Napoleon with Pastry Cream$5.00
- Oreo Chocolate Cake$5.00
- Quesito - Puff Pastry
Puff Pastry filled with Cream Cheese a classic Puerto Rican delicatesse perfect to pair with a MSF Coffee
$3.25OUT OF STOCK - Reese's Chocolate Cake
Chocolate Cake with peanut butter icing
$5.00 - Strawberry Tres Leches$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Tiramisú Cake$5.00OUT OF STOCK
- Tres Leches 5oz
Vanilla Cake soaked in three milks topped with a homemade whipped cream.
$3.00 - UBE CAKE
Ube Cake (Philippine Yam) with a Ube mascarpone icing.
$5.00 - Rum Cake
Inspired in our trip to the Bahamas (contain nut & rum)
$4.75
Sugar Free & Gluten Friendly Desserts
- GF SF Double Chocolate Cake$4.50
- GF SF PretzelLess Salad
Made with Crushed Pecans instead of pretzels is our #1 most popular GF & SF dessert!
$4.50 - GF SF Pumpkin Cheesecake CUP$4.00OUT OF STOCK
- GF SF Tres Leches Vanilla$5.00
- GF SF Churro Cheesecake Donut$4.50
- GF SF Lemon Blueberry Donut$3.50
- GF SF Cookies & Cream Donut
Please eat at room temperature (may contain coconut or almond flour)
$3.50
Gluten Friendly Desserts (contains sugar)
- Flan Cream Cheese - GF
Puerto Rican Style Cream Cheese Custard
$4.75 - Flan de Vanilla Slice -GF
Puerto Rican Style Vanilla Custard.
$4.75 - Cheesecake Plain - GF
Puerto Rican Style - Crustless Cheesecake. Gluten Free Contains Sugar. Special Price Online Only
$4.00 - Cheesecake with Berries - GF
Our Crustless Puerto Rican Style Cheesecake. Fluffy and delicious.
$4.75
Desserts Special Orders (4 days required)
Whole Cakes & Other Desserts (4 days required)
- Whole Cake 9'' Top Sellers
Cakes are non-customizable. We do not write on cakes. We do offer a free Happy Birthday Sign if requested.
$50.00 - Dessert Party Tray 24 Count
A variety of bite size desserts. Perfect for gatherings. 24 count(variety is randomly choose) this is the simple version. For a more elegant version is an extra charge of $25
$55.00 - Build Your Own Cake (10) SLICES (24 hour)
10 randomly choose slices of cake for you! (this is a non diet item) and it looks like a whole cake! PERFECT FOR CELEBRATIONS AND SHARING. You may list flavors of your preference if available we will added for you, if not available we will replace it.
$49.99 - 24 count Mini Quesitos & Mini Pastelillos (12 of each)
Quesitos - Cream Cheese Puff Pastry. Pastelillos - Guava Puff Pastry. Both in bite sizes.
$35.00 - Virgin Coquito {DRINK}
Classic Puerto Rican drink made with coconut cream, coconut milk, cinnamon and cloves.
$20.00 - Tres Leches 9'' Whole
Our Tres Leches is SUPER MOIST! and is not sliceable. We recommend customers to taste our tres leches (by the cup) before ordering a whole one, It is delicious but different!!!!
$17.00 - Vanilla Flan 9'' Whole
9'' aluminum pan. Flip it over and let the caramel shine!
$20.00 - DOZEN MINI QUESITOS
Our cream cheese filled puff pastry but mini versions of it!
$24.00 - DOZEN MINI Guava Puff Pastry
Our guava filled puff pastry but the mini version.
$12.00 - Cheesecake Tray Bite Size 20 count
Variety of flavor cheesecakes in a bite size! 20 count
$50.00 - 7'' Rum Cake (Large)
Simple, Yet Delicious! Bundt Cake Style with Walnuts and lots of RUM!!!!
$15.00 - 9” PRETZELESS SALAD Gluten Friendly & Sugar Free
Made with Crushed pecans instead of pretzels this Gluten friendly and sugar free dessert is our most popular dessert!
$30.00 - 9” Passion Fruit Cheesecake Topped with Berries Gluten Friendly & Sugar Friendly
Made with a GF crust and tangy passion fruit filling topped with berries.
$30.00 - 9” Tembleque / Coconut Custard (VEGAN)
Our only Vegan, Dairy Free & Gluten Free dessert. Puerto Rican style coconut custard. Get it while is available this holiday season! Contains (cloves & cinnamon)
$20.00
Drinks, Coffees & Teas
- Aquafina Bottle Water$2.00
- ICED- My Sisters Fault Coffee
Made with Whole Milk We ADD Condensed Milk and a hint of cinnamon.
$3.50 - HOT TEA (variety)
We have a variety of hot teas earl gray with Milk is the top requested. Just leave a comment and we will serve to you if available.
$3.50 - Passion Fruit Goya Juice 33oz$4.00OUT OF STOCK
- Tropi Cola (can)$2.00
- Malta Goya$3.00
- Coke (can)$2.00
- Diet Coke (can)$2.00
- Canada Dry$2.00
- Sprite (can)$2.00
- NesQuick Hot Chocolate$3.50
- NesQuick ICED Chocolate$3.50
- Pepsi (can)$2.00OUT OF STOCK
- Mtn Dew can$2.00
- Guayaba (Guava)Goya Juice 33oz$4.00
Raw Empanadas (24 hour required)
Raw Empanadas Menu
- RAW Beef Empanada
Made with 100% ground beef and diced potatoes. Seasoned with Sazon Complete, Sazon Goya, Sazon de color (coriander & annatto), Sofrito, Recaito, Garlic and other spices.
$2.75 - RAW Chicken & Cheese Empanada
Made with Shredded chicken breast, cream cheese, mozarella cheese and diced potato. Seasoned with Sazon Complete, Sazon Adobo Goya, Sazon de color (coriander & annatto), Sofrito, Recaito, Garlic and other spices.
$2.75 - RAW Veggie & Cheese Empanada
Made with Spinach,, Onions, Mushroom, Mozarella, Parmesan, Heavy Cream, Garlic, Salt & Pepper.
$3.00 - RAW Cheesedog Empanada
Made with 100% beef hotdog and american cheese.
$2.75 - RAW Pionono Empanada
Made with Beef, Sweet Plantains and Cream Cheese. Sazon Complete, Sazon Adobo Goya, Sazon de color (coriander & annatto), Sofrito, Recaito, Garlic and other spices.
$4.00
Limoncello Blueberry Cake
Cake made with swiss butter cream (alcohol free)