Browned butter chocolate chip with a hint of maple for subtle caramel notes. Note: This cookie is nut-free - for a more complex chocolate chip cookie, refer to our classic cookie, Gourmet Chocolate Chip! Allergens: milk, eggs, wheat, soy

Inspired by the PSL - it's got warm spices, brown sugar and browned butter, with a cheesecake filling. (Allergens: milk, eggs, wheat)

Cereal milk cookie packed with creaminess and a mix of fruity flavor (like fruity pebbles). has a burst of fruity sweetness with crunchy cereal texture (made for kids but adults can enjoy too)

Frankenpudge is a Halloween special made of 2 flavors: Matcha and Coal. It's essentially a matcha + oreo sandwich flavor, with candy googly eyes. Each Frankenpudge may have a slightly different appearance as they are all hand-shaped :) Allergens: milk, eggs, wheat (trace amount of soy)

Ube (like a nutty vanilla) meets the toasty butterscotch notes of caramelized white chocolate and toffee. Customer favorite. - Ube is purple yam. It is naturally purple with a subtle nutty, vanilla flavor. - Caramelized white chocolate is made by cooking white chocolate until it takes a unique golden hue. It has toasty caramel notes with the creaminess of white chocolate. Allergens: milk, eggs, wheat, soy, almonds

1 Pudge or a pack of 4 classic cookies that need a home in your belly! Random flavor - take your chances :) Individually wrapped. Pudges come with reheating instructions :) **Day-olds are meant to be sold the next day only. Advance orders will be cancelled!** (Possible allergens: milk, eggs, wheat, soy, walnuts, pecans, almonds)

Browned butter and miso bring depth to this medley of dark chocolate, toasted pecans, and toffee for an ultra addicting, deep flavor profile. Topped with flaky salt for a balanced bite. Customer favorite. Allergens: milk, eggs, wheat, soy, pecans, almonds

Like a sophisticated blondie; browned butter, toffee, caramelized white chocolate create an ultra-addictive, caramelized flavor. Toasted pecans amp up the depth of flavor while tempering sweetness. Topped with flaky salt for balance. Note: Caramelized white chocolate is white chocolate that has been cooked until it reaches caramelization. It has toasty butterscotch notes with the creaminess of white chocolate. Unlike white chocolate, this is more complex and not cloyingly sweet. "Dulcey" is chocolate maker Valrhona's brand name of caramelized white chocolate. Allergens: milk, eggs, wheat, soy, pecans, almonds

Updated 5/28/25 - Now made with browned butter, our earl grey milk chocolate is a phenomenal milk-tea-like cookie. It's got a present earl grey flavor backed by browned butter and creamy milk chocolate. Crisp edges with a chewy center. Customer favorite. Allergens: milk, eggs, wheat

Ordering for a small party? A dozen pudges could feed up to 48 people!

Try all of our classic cookies!! They're perfectly snack sized and addicting.

6 assorted day-old Pudges (or 4 classic cookies) that need a new home in your belly! Can be reheated :) (Possible allergens: milk, eggs, wheat, walnuts, pecans, almonds)

Lactose-free whole milk in a cute jar :)

It's our logo, a potato chef!! Can withstand water/rain.

Detective Potato, out to find out who stole the last bite of the Pudge. Sticker can withstand water/rain. Just shy of 2" in size.

Just shy of 2". Weather-resistant!

The size of a trader joe's mini tote! Measures 12 1/2" W x 11 1/8" H with 6" gusset. Straps are just long enough to hold on your elbow or shoulder (for most people). Canvas is thicker than our first run of mini totes.

Includes: Pudge Monster - Cookies n cream with extra Halloween flare Dark Chocolate Orange - With festive Halloween sprinkles Ube Dulcey - Ube cookie with caramelized white chocolate and toffee Franken - Matcha face with blackout brownie for the hair