Skip to Main content
Benny's Pick-up & Delivery Guidelines
  • Benny's Big Time Pizzeria

Banner image

Benny's Big Time Pizzeria Wilmington

206 Greenfield St., Wilmington, NC
Pickup Only
‌
‌
BENNYS MENU
BEER | WINE | COCKTAILS | BEV
CATERING
APP

Featured Items

  • MARGHERITA

    red sauce, parm, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
    $17.00
  • TONY PEPPERONI

    red sauce, mozzarella, parm, fresh oregano pepperoni. Order a 3 Pack of Tony's for $63!
    $22.00
  • HOUSE SALAD

    mixed lettuces, red onion, pickled peppers, house-made croutons, pecorino, oregano vinaigrette
    $11.00+

BENNYS MENU

BENNY'S BIG TIMERS

  • PIZZA PACKS - TONY PEPPERONI'S 3 OR 5

    Why not have another slice? Or, keep a little Tony Pepp in the fridge in case of emergency. Either way, we got you covered.
    $63.00+
  • PIZZA PACKS - KEVIN McCALLISTER'S 3 OR 5

    Our wildly popular cheese pizza for adults - not adults only. The combination of the funky taleggio cheese and Benny's Hot Honey is now a little cheaper to hoard. Go for it.
    $57.00+
  • BENNY'S HOT HONEY BEARS

    Feeling like the little cup of Benny's Hot Honey is just never enough? Stock up with the Honey Bear!
    $11.00

SALADS, ANTIPASTI & FRIED STUFF

  • HOUSE SALAD

    mixed lettuces, red onion, pickled peppers, house-made croutons, pecorino, oregano vinaigrette
    $11.00+
  • BENNY'S CAESAR SALAD

    fried & raw brussels sprouts, mixed lettuces, pecorino, lemon, Caesar dressing, house-made crouton
    $13.00+
  • CHOPPED SALAD + RED WEAPON RANCH

    baby kale mix, cured meats,, chickpeas, Castelvetrano olives, pecorino, pickled tomatoes (Red Weapons), house-made crouton, Red Weapon ranch
    $13.00+
  • BENNY'S CHICKEN PARM

    parmesan, stracciatella, hot honey, pickled peppers, sage
    $15.00
  • CHARRED BRUSSEL SPROUTS

    charred radicchio, dried cranberry, golden balsamic vinaigrette, pecorino
    $14.00
  • CRISPY FREE RANGE WINGS

    free range wings, Red Weapon ranch
    $14.00
  • FRIED MOZZ

    Breaded & fried mozz balls, marinara
    $14.00

PASTA & THINGS

  • SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS

    marinara, beef & pork meatballs, parmesan, oregano
    $20.00
  • RIGATONI ALLA VODKA

    House-made rigatoni, vodka sauce, burrata cheese, parm, basil
    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.00

HOUSE - MADE GLUTEN FREE DETROIT STYLE PIZZA (SERVES 1)

  • GLUTEN FREE DETROIT STYLE PIZZA

    Our gluten free DETROIT style pizza crust is amazing! Our standard comes with cheese and sauce but you can build your own pizza, just as you like it. Sorry - no half pie builds on the Gluten Free.
    $21.00

GRANDMA STYLE PAN PIZZA (SERVES 3+)

Our Grandma dough is 48 hour cold proofed with an additional 12 hours to rise in the pan before baking. What comes out of the oven is rectangular, crusty, classic sheet pan goodness. And, sure to be your new favorite.
  • GRANDMA STYLE PIZZA

    Rectangular, crusty, classic sheet pan pizza goodness. Comes with red sauce, oregano, basil, mozzarella & parm (grandma pies will have a longer cook time)
    $23.00

NEAPOLITAN PIZZA (SERVES 2+)

Our Neapolitan style pizza is made with 100% Caputo Italian wheat flour and cooked in our authentic Acunto Mario ovens. Neapolitan pizzas are special in their elastic, lightly crips charred crust and known for fresh top quality ingredients. Out pizzas are hand-made from start to finish and will showcase those qualities in each 12-14 inch pie.
  • CONSTRUCTION ZONE

    Build your own pie. Keep it simple, if you get greedy your pizza will suffer.
    $16.00
  • MARGHERITA

    red sauce, parm, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
    $17.00
  • TONY PEPPERONI

    red sauce, mozzarella, parm, fresh oregano pepperoni. Order a 3 Pack of Tony's for $63!
    $22.00
  • MEATING OF THE MINDS

    red sauce, parm, mozz, pepperoni, sausage, soppressata, pancetta, red onion, basil
    $23.00
  • THE CORLEONE

    red sauce, garlic, parm, taleggio, mozz, pancetta, dried oregano
    $21.00
  • THE LITTLE GREENIE

    red sauce, garlic, pickled red onion, brussels sprouts, spinach, guindilla peppers, nutritional yeast, Calabrian chili oil
    $19.00
  • PINEAPPLE EXPRESS

    parm, mozzarella, speck, mint, Calabrian & serrano chilis, pineapple jam
    $20.00
  • SPACE JAM

    red sauce, mozz, parm, taleggio, meatball crumble
    $21.00
  • HI BARBIE!

    hot honey BBQ sauce, mozz, parm, chicken, pancetta, Serrano chili, pickled onion
    $21.00
  • JIMMY PESTO JR.

    vodka sauce, parm, mozz, chicken, speck, pesto
    $24.00
  • KEVIN MCCALISTER

    ricotta base, parm, taleggio cheese, mozzarella, hot honey
    $20.00
  • TALK'IN SHITAKE

    ricotta base, house-made sausage, shitake & cremini mushroom, fennel, mozz, parm, garlic, olive
    $20.00
  • DOOGIE HOWSER

    mozz, parm, basil, sausage, soppressata
    $21.00
  • THE FLO

    ricotta base, mozzarella, basil, house-made sausage, red onion
    $20.00
  • PIZZA ALLA CARBONARA

    olive oil base, mozz, parm, garlic, red onion, chicken, pancetta, parsley, egg yolk
    $22.00

BEER | WINE | COCKTAILS | BEV

SODA & BEVERAGES

  • DR PEPPER

    $2.50
  • PEPSI

    $2.50
  • DIET PEPSI

    $2.50
  • GINGER ALE

    $2.50
  • STARRY

    $2.50
  • MUG ROOT BEER

    $2.50
  • 2 LITER DIET PEPSI

    $6.00
  • 2 LITER STARRY

    $6.00

CATERING

ANTIPASTI + FRIED STUFF

$150 Catering min. Please order 24 hours in advance. A 10% service charge per order. Prices & menu subject to change. * A $25 delivery fee will be added to all catering deliveries * Please ask about gluten free & vegan options. Serves 10-12
  • CRUDITE

    assorted seasonal vegetables, cheeses, house made pickles & wood fired bread
    $40.00+
  • CHARRED BRUSSELS

    charred radicchio, dried cranberry, golden balsamic vinaigrette, pecorino
    $45.00+
  • WING PLATTER

    served with Red Weapon ranch
    $75.00+
  • MEATBALL PLATTER

    fresh ground & tender beef & pork meatballs, marinara
    $70.00
  • FRIED MOZZ PLATTER

    Breaded & fried mozz balls, marinara
    $60.00

SALADS

$150 Catering min. Please order 24 hours in advance. A 10% service charge per order. Prices & menu subject to change. * A $25 delivery fee will be added to all catering deliveries * Please ask about gluten free & vegan options. Serves 10-12
  • CATERING HOUSE SALAD

    baby lettuces, red onion, pickled peppers, pecorino, house-made croutons, oregano vinaigrette - serves 10-12
    $40.00
  • CATERING CAESAR

    fried & raw brussels sprouts, mixed lettuces, pecorino, lemon, LGD, house-made croutons, Caesar dressing - serves 10-12
    $46.00
  • CATERING CHOPPED

    baby kale mix, Red Weapons, soppressata, chick peas, castelvetrano olives, provolone, pecorino, house-made croutons -serves 10-12
    $46.00

PASTA PLATTERS

$150 Catering min. Please order 24 hours in advance. A 10% service charge per order. Prices & menu subject to change. * A $25 delivery fee will be added to all catering deliveries * Please ask about gluten free & vegan options. Serves 10-12
  • BUILD YOUR PASTA

    Benny's takes pride in making our pasta everyday in house. We love fresh pasta & hope your guests do too! Choose your sauce and any additions or let us create something for you.
    $65.00+

NEAPOLITAN PIZZA (SERVES 2+)

Our Neapolitan style pizza is made with 100% Caputo Italian wheat flour and cooked in our authentic Acunto Mario ovens. Our 12-14 inch Neapolitan pizzas are special in their elastic, lightly crips charred crust and known for fresh top quality ingredients. Take 10% off your pizzas when ordering 10 or more!
  • CONSTRUCTION ZONE

    Build your own pie. Keep it simple, if you get greedy your pizza will suffer.
    $16.00
  • MARGHERITA

    red sauce, parm, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
    $17.00
  • TONY PEPPERONI

    red sauce, parm, pepperoni, mozzarella, oregano. Order a 3 Pack of Tony's for $54!
    $22.00
  • MEATING OF THE MINDS

    red sauce, parm, mozz, pepperoni, sausage, soppressata, pancetta, red onion, basil
    $23.00
  • THE CORLEONE

    red sauce, garlic, parm, taleggio, mozz, pancetta, dried oregano
    $21.00
  • THE LITTLE GREENIE

    red sauce, garlic, pickled red onion, brussels sprouts, spinach, guindilla peppers, nutritional yeast, Calabrian chili oil
    $19.00
  • PINEAPPLE EXPRESS

    parm, mozzarella, speck, mint, Calabrian & serrano chilis, pineapple jam
    $20.00
  • SPACE JAM

    red sauce, mozz, parm, taleggio, meatball crumble
    $21.00
  • HI BARBIE!

    hot honey BBQ sauce, mozz, parm, chicken, pancetta, Serrano chili, pickled onion
    $21.00
  • JIMMY PESTO

    vodka sauce, parm, mozz, chicken, speck, pesto
    $24.00
  • KEVIN MCCALISTER

    ricotta base, parm, taleggio cheese, mozzarella, hot honey
    $20.00
  • TALK'IN SHITAKE

    ricotta base, house-made sausage, shitake & cremini mushroom, fennel, mozz, parm, garlic, olive
    $20.00
  • DOOGIE HOWSER

    mozz, parm, basil, sausage, soppressata
    $21.00
  • THE FLO

    ricotta base, mozzarella, basil, house-made sausage, red onion
    $20.00
  • ALWAYS SUNNY

    parm, provolone, Wagyu salami, caramelized onion, red bell pepper
    $22.00
  • PIZZA ALLA CARBONARA

    olive oil base, mozz, parm, garlic, red onion, chicken, pancetta, parsley, egg yolk
    $22.00

GRANDMA STYLE PAN PIZZA (SERVES 3+)

Take 5% off any order of 5 or more Grandma's. Please order 24 hours in advance. A 10% service charge per order. Prices & menu subject to change. * A $25 delivery fee will be added to all catering deliveries * Please ask about gluten free & vegan options.
  • GRANDMA STYLE PIZZA

    Rectangular, crusty, classic sheet pan pizza goodness. Comes with red sauce, oregano, basil, mozzarella & parm (grandma pies will have a longer cook time)
    $23.00

NY STYLE PIZZA 18 INCH (SERVES 3+)

$150 Catering min. Please order 24 hours in advance. A 10% service charge per order. Prices & menu subject to change. * A $25 delivery fee will be added to all catering deliveries * Please ask about gluten free & vegan options.
  • NY STYLE PIZZA 18"

    Classic NY Style thin crust.
    $22.00

HOUSE - MADE GLUTEN FREE DETROIT STYLE PIZZA (SERVES 1)

  • GLUTEN FREE DETROIT STYLE PIZZA

    Our gluten free DETROIT style pizza crust is amazing! Our standard comes with cheese and sauce but you can build your own pizza, just as you like it. Sorry - no half pie builds on the Gluten Free.
    $21.00

SWEETS

$150 Catering min. Please order 24 hours in advance. A 10% service charge per order. Prices & menu subject to change. * A $25 delivery fee will be added to all catering deliveries * Please ask about gluten free & vegan options.
  • SEASONAL COOKIE PLATTER

    $35.00
  • FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE TORTE BITES (GF)

    Serves 10-12
    $50.00

ADD ON...

  • UTENSIL + PLATE PACK

    For 10-12pp Includes: plates, utensil packs, extra napkins
    $5.00
  • FRESH GRATED PARM

    A full pint of freshly grated parmesan cheese.
    $10.00
  • PARM & RED PEPPER PACKS

    Serves 10-12 1oz parm & red pepper packs to go.
  • RANCH BOTTLE

    $12.00
  • OREGANO VINAIGRETTE

    $12.00

APP

Appfront Items

  • App Comments

SPACE JAM

$21.00

red sauce, mozz, parm, taleggio, meatball crumble

Customize your item

Whole Pizza - Add Meat

Optional

Whole Pizza - Add Veggies

Optional

Whole Pizza Extra (Add a little more)

Optional

Whole Pizza Other

Optional

1st Half - Add Meat

Optional

1st Half - Add Veggies

Optional

2nd Half - Add Meat

Optional

2nd Half - Add Veggies

Optional
Request advisory
No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
1

Benny's Big Time Pizzeria Location and Ordering Hours

(910) 550-2525
206 Greenfield St., Wilmington, NC 28401
Closed • Opens Sunday at 12PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement