Skip to Main content
📲YOU WILL RECEIVE A TEXT MESSAGE WHEN YOUR ORDER IS READY FOR PICK-UP.

  • Betty's Seafood Shack

    Betty's Seafood Shack

Betty's Seafood Shack 9315 Amherst Avenue

9315 Amherst Avenue, Margate City, NJ
Specials
Appetizers
Chowdahs/Soups
Salads
Poke Bowls
Gluten Free-Breaded Boxes
Boxes/Hand Breaded
Boxes/Blackened or Grilled
Lettuce Wraps (2) GF
Hand Helds
One If By Land
Seafood Towers
Oyster Platter
Kids Meal
Sides
Desserts
Extra Protein
Sauces (Additional Charge)
Agua Fresca
Drinks

Featured Items

  • Lobster Roll (ME)

    Maine-style chilled lobster meat, mixed w/ very light seasoned mayo, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun

    $31.00

  • Yellow Fin Tuna Poke

    Avocado, seaweed salad, cucumber, edamame, scallion, ginger, Korean daikon, sesame seeds & rice with ponzu sauce on the side topped with fresh raw yellowfin tuna

    $24.00

  • New England Clam Chowdah

    Creamy Classic New England Chowdah with chopped clams, potato & topped w/ scallion

    $8.00

‌

Specials

  • Tomato & Burrata Salad

    Burrata Tomato Salad w/ Roasted Corn, balsamic reduction & basil olive oil

    $12.00

  • White Grouper

    White Grouper {Grilled/Blackened} served with Jasmine Rice, Green Beans, choice of sauce

    $29.00

Appetizers

  • Shrimp Cocktail GF

    3 colossal 6/8's served w/ cocktail sauce & lemon

    $17.00

  • Crab Meat Cocktail GF

    Jumbo lump & colossal crab served w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $21.00

  • Seared Sesame Encrusted Tuna Sashimi GF

    served w/ wasabi, ginger & a side of ponzu APPROX 5-6 PIECES

    $17.00

  • Steamers GF

    local middle neck clams - bigger than little necks & smaller than top necks - perfectly sweet size, served w/ warm butter 1doz $14 2doz $26 3doz $37

  • Betty's Stuffed Clam

    (one) x-large clam shell baked w/ lotsa tender chopped clam, sautéed veggies, bacon herbs & spices

    $8.50

  • Clams Casino

    6 local top necks broiled w/ chopped clam, onion, pepper, bacon & breadcrumbs

    $14.00

  • Mahi Fingers

    hand-breaded mahi served w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $14.00

  • Betty's Mac DADDY 'n Cheese

    Luis' creamy, dreamy mac 'n cheese

    $10.00

  • Betty's Lobster Mac DADDY 'n Cheese

    chunks of lobster atop Chef Luis's creamy, dreamy mac 'n cheese

    $18.00

  • Betty's Crab Mac DADDY 'n Cheese

    jumbo lump crab atop Chef Luis's creamy, dreamy mac 'n cheese

    $18.00

  • Calamari

    served w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $14.00

  • Onion Rings

    served w/ a spicy aioli

    $9.00

  • Fried Pickles

    served w/ a spicy aioli

    $8.00

  • U-Peel Shrimp

    served with Betty's cocktail sauce & lemon wedges

  • For Pete's Sake Fries

    Fries smothered in house-made cheese sauce & topped with jumbo lump crab & a sprinkling of Old Bay

    $18.00

Chowdahs/Soups

  • New England Clam Chowdah

    Creamy Classic New England Chowdah with chopped clams, potato & topped w/ scallion

    $8.00

  • Manhattan Clam Chowdah

    Tender sea clams, vine-ripened tomatoes and tender potatoes in a handcrafted fish stock with chopped scallions and a dash of pepper sauce

    $8.00

  • Long Island Clam Chowdah

    Perfect blend of our New England & Manhattan Clam Chowdah..It’s like someone who likes the Yankees AND the Red Sox

    $8.50

  • QUART NE Clam Chowdah

    Enjoy a QUART of our Creamy Classic New England Chowdah with chopped clams, potato & topped w/ scallion

    $17.00

  • QUART Soup Du Jour

    $17.00

Salads

  • Outta the Parc Salad

    Betty's take on the classic warm shrimp salad. 3 massive 6/8 grilled shrimp served warm w/ our beurre blanc sauce, w/ fresh greens, roasted seasoned Italian tomatoes, shaved parmesan & avocado dressed w/ our house-made champagne vinaigrette

    $24.00

  • Classic Caesar Salad

    fresh romaine w/ shaved parmesan & croutons, dressed in Renee Naame's iconic house-made Maloney's of Margate Caesar dressing IYKYK!

    $10.00

Poke Bowls

  • Yellow Fin Tuna Poke

    Avocado, seaweed salad, cucumber, edamame, scallion, ginger, Korean daikon, sesame seeds & rice with ponzu sauce on the side topped with fresh raw yellowfin tuna

    $24.00

  • Grilled Scallops Poke

    Avocado, seaweed salad, cucumber, edamame, scallion, ginger, Korean daikon sesame seeds & rice with ponzu sauce on the side topped with grilled scallops

    $25.00

  • Grilled Shrimp Poke

    Avocado, seaweed salad, cucumber, edamame, scallion, ginger, Korean daikon, sesame seeds & rice with ponzu sauce on the side topped with grilled shrimp

    $26.00

  • Poached Lobster Poke

    Avocado, seaweed salad, cucumber, edamame, scallion, ginger, Korean daikon, sesame seeds & rice with ponzu sauce on the side topped with poached lobster

    $31.00

  • Chilled Lobster Poke

    Avocado, seaweed salad, cucumber, edamame, scallion, ginger, Korean daikon, sesame seeds & rice with ponzu sauce on the side topped with chilled lobster salad

    $31.00

  • Jumbo Lump Crab Poke

    Avocado, seaweed salad, cucumber, edamame, scallion, ginger, Korean daikon, sesame seeds & rice with ponzu sauce on the side topped with jumbo lump crab

    $27.00

Gluten Free-Breaded Boxes

  • GF Breaded Shrimp Box

    served w/ gluten free Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $27.00

  • GF Breaded Scallops Box

    served w/ gluten free Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $26.00

  • GF Crab Cake (1)

    served w/ gluten free Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $26.00

  • GF Crab Cakes (2)

    served w/ gluten free Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $46.00

  • GF Combo- 2 Shrimp, 3 Scallops, & Crab Cake

    Hand-breaded GF 2 colossal 6-8 shrimp, 3 large 10-20 scallops, & crab cake served w/ gluten free Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $37.00

Boxes/Hand Breaded

served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce

  • Scallop Box (FRIED)

    served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $25.00

  • Clam Strips Box (FRIED)

    served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $18.00

  • Whole Belly Clams Box (FRIED)

    New England whole belly clams served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $28.00
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Shrimp Box (FRIED)

    served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $26.00

  • Crab Cake (1) Box (FRIED)

    served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $25.00

  • Crab Cake (2) Box (FRIED)

    served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $45.00

  • Fish 'n Chips - Beer Battered Cod (FRIED)

    served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $20.00

  • Combo - 2 Shrimp, 3 Scallops, Crab Cake (FRIED)

    2 colossal 6/8 shrimp, 3 large 10/20 scallops & 1 crab cake served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $35.00

Boxes/Blackened or Grilled

served w/ Lamb Weston fries & Betty slaw w/ choice of house-made sauce

  • Yellowfin Tuna Box (BLACKENED)

    Yellowfin Tuna with blackened seasoning served rare unless otherwise requested, w/ Betty slaw & fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $24.00

  • Yellowfin Tuna Box (GRILLED)

    Yellowfin Tuna grilled served rare unless otherwise requested, w/ Betty slaw & fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $24.00

  • Shrimp Box (BLACKENED)

    Colossal shrimp with blackened seasoning served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $26.00

  • Shrimp Box (GRILLED)

    Colossal grilled shrimp served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $26.00

  • Scallop Box (BLACKENED)

    Large scallops with blackened seasoning served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $25.00

  • Scallop Box (GRILLED)

    Large grilled scallops served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $25.00

  • Crab Cake (1) Box (BLACKENED)

    served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $25.00

  • Crab Cake (1) Box (GRILLED)

    served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $25.00

  • Crab Cake (2) Box (BLACKENED)

    served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $45.00

  • Crab Cake (2) Box (GRILLED)

    served w/ Betty Slaw & Lamb Weston fries w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $45.00

  • Combo - 2 Shrimp, 3 Scallops, Crab Cake (BLACKENED)

    2 colossal 6/8 shrimp, 3 large 10/20 scallops & a crab cake with blackened seasoning, served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $35.00

  • Combo - 2 Shrimp, 3 Scallops, Crab Cake (GRILLED)

    2 colossal 6/8 shrimp, 3 large 10/20 scallops & a crab cake grilled served w/ Betty slaw & Lamb Weston fries, choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $35.00

Lettuce Wraps (2) GF

Lettuce Wraps (2) served with house-pickled veggies

  • Shrimp - Lettuce Wrap (BLACKENED)

    served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli 4 EACH SHRIMP

    $26.00

  • Shrimp - Lettuce Wrap (GRILLED)

    served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli 4 EACH SHRIMP

    $26.00

  • Scallops - Lettuce Wrap (BLACKENED)

    served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli 5 EACH SCALLOPS

    $25.00

  • Scallops - Lettuce Wrap (GRILLED)

    served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli 5 EACH SCALLOPS

    $25.00

  • Yellowfin Tuna - Lettuce Wrap (BLACKENED)

    Yellowfin tuna, quickly seared, blackened seasoning served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli

    $25.00

  • Yellowfin Tuna - Lettuce Wrap (GRILLED)

    Yellowfin tuna, quickly seared served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli

    $25.00

  • Butter Poached Lobster - Lettuce Wrap

    butter-poached chunks of cold water lobster meat served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli

    $28.00

  • Jumbo Lump Crab - Lettuce Wrap

    served w/ house-pickled veggies & lemon zest aioli

    $27.00

Hand Helds

served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun, served with choice of house-made sauce (Add Fries $4.50)

  • Lobster Roll (ME)

    Maine-style chilled lobster meat, mixed w/ very light seasoned mayo, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun

    $31.00

  • Lobster Roll (CT)

    Connecticut-style warm butter poached lobster meat, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun

    $31.00

  • Sasquatch Lobster Roll (ME)

    double the lobster meat, Maine-style chilled lobster meat mixed w/ very light seasoned mayo, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun

    $58.00

  • Sasquatch Lobster Roll (CT)

    double the lobster meat, Connecticut-style warm butter poached lobster meat served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun

    $58.00

  • Whole Belly Roll

    hand-breaded whole belly clams from New England, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5

    $21.00
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Clam Strip Roll

    hand-breaded clam strips, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $16.00

  • Shrimp Roll

    hand-breaded, grilled or blackened colossal 6/8 shrimp served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5 3 EACH SHRIMP

    $19.00

  • Scallop Roll

    hand-breaded, grilled or blackened large 10/20 scallops, served in a buttered, grilled, top-cut New England style bun w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli) add fries +4.5 4 EACH SCALLOPS

    $18.00

  • Crab Cake Sandwich (FRIED)

    served on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $22.00

  • Crab Cake Sandwich (BLACKENED)

    served on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $22.00

  • Crab Cake Sandwich (GRILLED)

    served on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $22.00

  • Beer Battered Cod Sandwich

    served w/ lettuce & pickles on a grilled round potato roll w/ choice of house-made sauce (Betty's Cocktail, Tartar, Lemon Zest Aioli)

    $16.00

One If By Land

add fries $4.50

  • Double Angus Smash Burger

    Pair of grilled Smashed Angus Patties, w/ cheese, w/ pickle & onion on a potato roll

    $13.00

  • Chicken Fingers

    served w/ honey mustard

    $11.00

Seafood Towers

  • The Tower

    6 oysters, jumbo lump crab meat, 3 colossal shrimp, tuna poke, 8 oz lobster meat & served with Betty's cocktail sauce, lemon zest aioli, mignonette sauce, lemon wedges add caviar

    $86.00

  • The Tower of Power

    12 oysters, 6 colossal shrimp, jumbo lump crab meat, 1 lb of lobster meat, tuna tartare served with Betty's cocktail sauce, lemon lest aioli, mignonette sauce, lemon wedges add caviar

    $165.00

Oyster Platter

Selection of Oysters served with House Mignonette, Betty Cocktail and lemon $2.25 per 6 min

  • Oyster platter

Kids Meal

  • Kid Cheeseburger

    includes juice box & fries

    $10.00

  • Kid Chicken Fingers

    includes juice box & fries

    $10.00

  • Kid Mac 'n Cheese

    includes juice box & fries

    $10.00

  • Kid Mahi Fingers

    includes juice box & fries

    $10.00

  • Kid Shrimp

    includes juice box & fries

    $10.00

Sides

  • Lamb Weston Fries GF

    Lamb Weston Fries

    $5.00

  • Betty Slaw GF

    shredded carrots and cabbage, mayonnaise seasonings

    $5.00

  • Corn on Cob GF

    Fresh Corn-Shucked here at Betty's none fresher, w/ side of butter

    $5.00

  • House Pickled Veggies GF

    House-pickled carrots, cucumber & onion

    $7.00

  • Sautéed Garlic Broccoli GF

    Sautéed with garlic & seasoned

    $6.00

  • Crispy Brussels Sprouts

    served in a light Thai chili glaze

    $7.00

Desserts

  • Frozen Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie

    Sweet Melissa's Key Lime Pie, dipped in a hard chocolate shell, served frozen on a stick

    $7.00

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

    Sweet Melissa's Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie w/ delicious chocolate ganache topping

    $6.00

Extra Protein

  • Extra Scallops

    4 each U10/20 Scallops

    $19.00

  • Extra Jumbo Lump Crab

    5 oz Jumbo Lump Crab Meat

    $23.00

  • Extra Lobster

    5 oz chilled Lobster Meat

    $29.00

  • Extra Shrimp

    3 Colossal Shrimp

    $19.00

  • Extra Tuna

    available grilled or blackened 6-8oz filet cooked rare

    $18.00

  • Extra Avocado

    $3.50

Sauces (Additional Charge)

  • Ponzu

    $0.75

  • Tartar

    $0.75

  • Betty's Cocktail

    $0.75

  • Lemon Aioli

    $0.75

  • Spicy Mayo

    $0.75

  • Honey Mustard

    $0.75

  • Caesar Dressing

    $1.00

  • Champagne Vinny

    $1.00

Agua Fresca

house-made blends of juice & herbs

  • Strawberry Lemonade

    Cane Sugar Lemonade (no Fructose Corn Syrup) blended with Strawberries

    $6.00

  • Watermelon Basil

    Fresh Watermelon Juice blended with Freshly Cut Basil

    $6.00

Drinks

  • Water

    $2.25

  • Coke

    $2.25

  • Diet Coke

    $2.25

  • Ginger Ale

    $2.25

  • Pellegrino

    $2.25

  • Dr. Brown's Black Cherry

    $2.25

  • Dr. Brown's Diet Black Cherry

    $2.25

  • Dr. Brown's Rootbeer

    $2.25

  • Seltzer - Nixie

    $2.25

  • Apple Juice Box

    $2.25

  • Diet Arizona Arnold Palmer

    $2.25

  • Sweetened Pure Leaf Tea

    $3.00

  • Unsweetened Pure Leaf Tea

    $3.00

  • Cold Brew Coffee

    $4.50
    OUT OF STOCK

Betty's Seafood Shack Location and Ordering Hours

(609) 246-7411
9315 Amherst Avenue, Margate City, NJ 08402
Open now • Closes at 3:59AM
This site is powered byToast logo
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement
  • |