Skip to Main content
Limited menu of same-day items. Full menu @ www.billysbakerynyc.com (48 hrs advance notice required).
  • Billy's Bakery

    Billy's Bakery

Billy's Bakery Upper West Side

410 Columbus Avenue, Unit D, New York, NY
Cakes & Slices
Cupcakes, Bars & Cookies
Puddings, Pies & Cheesecakes
Merchandise

Featured Items

  • Confetti Cupcake w/Vanilla Buttercream

    Classic yellow butter cake flavored with confetti sprinkles baked-in. Frosted with Vanilla Buttercream.

    $4.50
  • Lemon Cupcake w/Cream Cheese

    Deliciously light lemon cupcakes iced with cream cheese frosting.

    $4.50
  • Chocolate Cupcake w/Vanilla Buttercream

    For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with Vanilla Buttercream. Frosting colors vary in pastel shades.

    $4.50

Cakes & Slices

8" Cake (serves 8-12)

  • 8" Banana Cake

    Classically delicious! Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with cream cheese frosting. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 8" Carrot Cake

    Cinnamon batter with carrots, coconut, pineapple and pecans; topped with cream cheese frosting and chopped pecans. Contains NUTS. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 8" Chocolate Cake w/Choco BC

    For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with chocolate buttercream icing. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 8" Chocolate Cake w/Van BC

    For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with vanilla buttercream icing. Frosting colors vary in pastel shades. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 8" Confetti Cake w/Van BC

    Classic yellow butter cake with confetti sprinkles baked-in. Frosted with vanilla buttercream. Garnished with multi-colored, sugar confetti. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
  • 8" Cookies & Buttercream Cake

    Our version of a cookies & cream cake made with layers of chocolate cake, frosted with chocolate cookie vanilla buttercream and garnished with cookie crumbles. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 8" Crowd Pleaser w/Choco BC

    Alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla cake filled with alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla frosting. Frosted with chocolate buttercream frosting. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 8" Crowd Pleaser w/Van BC

    Alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla cake filled with alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla frosting. Frosted with vanilla buttercream frosting. Inscription available; just make a note of text and color below! ** Last-minute cakes are sold FROZEN and require 2-4 hours at room-temperature to thaw **

    $80.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Cake Slice

  • Banana Slice

    Classic Delicious! Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with cream cheese frosting.

    $7.50
  • Carrot Slice

    Cinnamon batter with carrots, coconut, pineapple and pecans; topped with cream cheese frosting and chopped pecans. Contains NUTS.

    $7.50
  • Chocolate Slice

    For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with either vanilla or chocolate buttercream icing.

    $7.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Cookies & Buttercream Slice

    Slice of our version of a cookies & cream cake made with layers of chocolate cake, frosted with chocolate cookie vanilla buttercream and garnished with cookie crumbles.

    $7.50
  • Crowd Pleaser Slice

    Alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla cake filled with alternating layers of chocolate and vanilla frosting. Frosted with either vanilla or chocolate buttercream frosting.

    $7.50
    OUT OF STOCK

Cupcakes, Bars & Cookies

Cupcakes

  • Banana Cupcake w/Cream Cheese

    Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with cream cheese frosting.

    $4.50
  • Banana Cupcake w/Nutella Cream Cheese

    Reminiscent of banana bread but richer and sweeter; made with fresh bananas and buttermilk and iced with Nutella cream cheese frosting. Contains NUTS.

    $4.50
  • Carrot Cupcake w/Cream Cheese

    Cinnamon batter with carrots, coconut, pineapple, and pecans; topped with cream cheese frosting. Contains NUTS.

    $4.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Chocolate Cupcake w/Chocolate Buttercream

    For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with Chocolate Buttercream.

    $4.50
  • Chocolate Cupcake w/Vanilla Buttercream

    For the chocolate lover: a deep, moist chocolate cake made with rich, dark cocoa. Frosted with Vanilla Buttercream. Frosting colors vary in pastel shades.

    $4.50
  • Confetti Cupcake w/Vanilla Buttercream

    Classic yellow butter cake flavored with confetti sprinkles baked-in. Frosted with Vanilla Buttercream.

    $4.50
  • Cookies & Buttercream Cupcake

    Our version of a cookies & cream cake - chocolate cupcake, frosted with chocolate cookie vanilla buttercream and garnished with cookie crumbles.

    $4.50
  • Crowd Pleaser Cupcake

    Classic chocolate and vanilla batters folded into one cupcake. Frosted in vanilla and chocolate buttercream frosting. Garnished with assorted chocolate pearls.

    $4.50
  • Cupcake of the Month

    May Cupcake of the Month: Bourbon Salted Caramel Cupcake A rich classic chocolate cupcake topped with semi-sweet chocolate frosting drizzled with bourbon caramel and sprinkled with sea salt. Don't worry, you won't get tipsy.

    $5.00
  • Gluten-Free VEGAN Choco Chip Cupcake

    Our popular Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip cupcake is made with NO eggs, NO milk, and NO butter. To top that, we use gluten-free flour, so it's Vegan & Gluten-free! Contains refined sugar. ALLERGENS: almond milk, and soy lecithin. Frosted with choice of Vanilla or Chocolate (Vegan) Buttercream.

    $5.75
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Holiday Cupcake

    Traditional vanilla or chocolate cupcake and frosting, garnished with sprinkles and a themed sugar decoration. Garnish style and colors may vary. Holiday varies, by season; plz call for details.

    $5.50
  • Lemon Cupcake w/Cream Cheese

    Deliciously light lemon cupcakes iced with cream cheese frosting.

    $4.50
  • Pumpkin Cupcake w/Cinnamon Cream Cheese

    Fall Seasonal Cupcake: PUMPKIN Cinnamon spiced cake filled with chopped pecans and topped with cream cheese icing.

    $5.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Red Velvet Cupcake w/Cream Cheese

    A southern classic…a mild cocoa flavor with a bright red color. Frosted with cream cheese frosting.

    $4.50
  • Vanilla Cupcake w/Chocolate Buttercream

    Classic yellow butter cake flavored with pure vanilla extract. Frosted with Chocolate Buttercream.

    $4.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Vanilla Cupcake w/Vanilla Buttercream

    Classic yellow butter cake flavored with pure vanilla extract. Frosted with Vanilla Buttercream. Frosting colors vary in pastel shades.

    $4.50
  • Mini Cupcakes: Traditional

    Our famous cupcakes, in bite-size form. Perfect for all occasions, from birthdays to holidays to a well-deserved afternoon snack. Assorted Traditionals - 6 Yellow Daisy mini cupcakes + 6 Chocolate mini cupcakes frosted with Vanilla & Chocolate buttercream. Tree nut-free. Frosting colors and garnish may vary.

    $27.00

Cupcake Cups

  • Cupcake Cup, Nuts OK

    Our famous cupcake flavors put into a convenient cup. Selected from assortment of daily flavors which may include Banana Nutella, Carrot, Chocolate Peanut Butter & German Chocolate.

    $4.75
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Cupcake Cup, NO Nuts

    Our famous cupcake flavors put into a convenient cup. Selected from assortment of daily flavors which do NOT contain nuts. Varieties include Banana, Chocolate, Confetti, Cookies & Buttercream, Crowd Pleaser, Lemon, Red Velvet & Vanilla.

    $4.75

Bars

  • Fudge Brownie

    Rich and fudgy deep chocolate brownies.

    $4.50
  • Hello Dolly Bar

    Made with graham crackers, chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, coconut, and chopped pecans. Contains NUTS.

    $4.50
  • PB Choco Bar

    Chocolate cookie crust with creamy peanut butter filling, topped with rich chocolate ganache. Contains NUTS.

    $5.00
  • Seasonal Bar

    Spring Seasonal Lemon Bar Zesty lemon filling on a shortbread crust.

    $5.25

Cookies

  • Chocolate Chip Sandwich w/Vanilla Buttercream

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich filled w/ Vanilla Buttercream

    $4.50
  • Chocolate Chip Sandwich w/Chocolate Buttercream

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich filled w/ Chocolate Buttercream

    $4.50
  • Chocolate Chip Sandwich w/ Sprinkles

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich filled w/ Vanilla Buttercream, then rolled in rainbow sprinkles.

    $4.50
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie w/Black & White (Van & Choco Buttercream)

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich w/Black & White (Van & Choco Buttercream) Filling

    $4.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Confetti Sandwich w/Vanilla Buttercream

    Our chewy confetti cookie stuffed with vanilla buttercream, then rolled in confetti quins.

    $4.50
  • Snickerdoodle Sandwich w/Cream Cheese Frosting

    Snickerdoodle Cookie Sandwich w//Cream Cheese Frosting

    $4.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Peanut Butter Sandwich w/Chocolate Buttercream

    Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich w/Chocolate Buttercream

    $4.50
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    Classic brown sugar cookie dough filled with semisweet chocolate chips.

    $1.50
  • Confetti Cookie

    Our classic chewy sugar cookie with confetti quins baked-in.

    $1.50
  • Peanut Butter Cookie

    Sweet and salty peanut butter dough filled with creamy peanut butter chips.

    $1.50
  • Snickerdoodle Cookie

    A family tradition…chewy sugar cookie dusted with cinnamon sugar.

    $1.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Decorated Sugar Cookie, Wrapped

    Our scrumptious sugar cookies are the perfect treat for any special occasion. Cut into festive shapes, and frosted with royal icing.

    $5.95

Extras!

  • Birthday Candle (Box of 24)

    Add a box of (24) candles to your order. Colors and designs may vary. Cupcakes not included.

    $3.75
  • Number Candle

    Individual number candles 0-9. Colors and styles vary. Please specify number below.

    $3.75
  • Birthday Pick

    "Happy Birthday" cupcake pick. Plastic. Color and styles may vary.

    $0.25
  • Birthday Card

    Various NYC Scenes on a greeting card. Hand-crafted by our baker, Alvaro Melo. Envelope included.

    $6.00
  • Cello Bag + Billy's Bakery Sticker (DIY)

    Individual DIY packaging option. Product NOT included in pricing.

    $0.50
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Vintage Note Card

    Add a mini vintage note card to your order. Colors and designs vary.

    $1.00
  • Individual Cupcake Box

    Individual cupcake boxes are perfectly-sized to fit our full-size cupcakes (all flavors fit just fine).

    $1.50
  • Wares: 12 utensils OR plates

    12 enviro-friendly disposable plates OR utensils. Perfect for eating on go! Please note which item you are looking for!

    $3.00

Puddings, Pies & Cheesecakes

9" Pie

  • Banana Cream Pie

    Fresh banana slices layered with vanilla pudding and topped with whipped cream. 9" / Approx 6 servings

    $39.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Coconut Cream Pie

    Light, creamy vanilla pudding filled with sweetened coconut flakes and topped with toasted coconut. 9" / Approx 6 servings

    $41.00
  • PB Chocolate Pie

    Fluffy peanut butter filling in a graham cracker crust, topped with chocolate syrup and peanut butter cups. Contains NUTS. 9" / Approx 6 servings

    $39.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Pie Slice

  • Banana Cream Pie Slice

    Slice of our Banana Cream Pie - fresh banana slices layered with vanilla pudding and topped with whipped cream.

    $7.25
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Coconut Cream Pie Slice

    Slice of our light, creamy vanilla pudding filled with sweetened coconut flakes and topped with toasted coconut.

    $7.25
  • PB Chocolate Pie Slice

    Slice of our Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - creamy peanut butter filling in a graham cracker crust topped with chocolate syrup and peanut butter cups.

    $7.25
    OUT OF STOCK

7" Cheesecake

  • 7" Blueberry

    Our classic cheesecake topped with plump, juicy blueberries.

    $41.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 7" Cherry

    Our classic cheesecake topped with sweet, juicy cherries.

    $41.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 7" Coconut

    The perfect spring treat! Shredded coconut cheesecake batter in a graham cracker crust, topped with toasted coconut / fresh whipped cream. Sorry, we cannot inscribe on this item; consider a Happy Birthday pick. 7" / 6-8 servings

    $41.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • 7" Plain

    Smooth and creamy, flavored with pure vanilla extract and baked with a graham cracker crust.

    $41.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Cheesecake Slice

  • Blueberry Cheesecake Slice

    A slice of our classic cheesecake topped with plump, juicy blueberries.

    $7.95
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Cherry Cheesecake Slice

    A slice of our classic cheesecake topped with sweet, juicy cherries.

    $7.95
  • Coconut Cheesecake Slice

    Slice of our Coconut Cheesecake -sShredded coconut cheesecake batter in a graham cracker crust, topped with toasted coconut / fresh whipped cream.

    $7.95
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Plain Cheesecake Slice

    A slice of our smooth and creamy cheesecake, flavored with pure vanilla extract and baked with a graham cracker crust.

    $7.95

Pudding

  • Banana Pudding Cup

    Delicious vanilla pudding layered between fresh bananas and vanilla wafers. Single-serving 8oz cup.

    $7.75

Merchandise

Retail

  • FreshCut Paper®

    FreshCut Paper's Forever Flowers - always in bloom. Send some colorful and whimsical pop up flower bouquet greeting cards that bring joy to everyone! Selection varies by season.

    $12.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Logo Enamel Pin

    Billy's Bakery 1.25" Logo pin in hard enamel (jadeite green enamel with gold metal). Great for gifting and/or swapping.

    $10.00
  • Logo Mug

    Ceramic diner-style mug complete with the Billy’s logo. Great for coffee, hot chocolate and more, our mugs are perfect for Billy’s fans of all ages!

    $17.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Logo T-Shirt

    100% combed and ring-spun cotton tee, made in the USA by Bella + Canvas. Printed locally by Works in Progress. Design and colors may vary. 2020 Design: black tee w/green logo imprint

    $27.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Retro Tote Bag

    Celebrate Homemade with our cotton canvas, retro-inspired tote!

    $29.00

Billy's Bakery Locations and Ordering Hours

Show Locations

Chelsea

(212) 647-9406
184 9th Ave, New York City, NY 10011
Open now • Closes at 9PM

Tribeca

(212) 647-9958
75 Franklin St, New York City, NY 10013
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 11AM

Upper West Side

(347) 894-2024
410 Columbus Avenue, Unit D, New York, NY 10024
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 11AM
This site is powered byToast logo
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement
  • |