You are ordering from our Carrollwood location!

Best NY Pizza Inc 14741 N Dale Mabry Hwy
Cheese Pizza (Build Your Own)
Build Your Own Pizza
Family Size Pizza.
(for up to 4 or more people) NY Style thin crust pizza.
$20.94Large Size Pizza
(for up to 3 or more people) NY Style thin crust pizza.
$19.94Medium Size Pizza
(for up to 2 or more people) NY Style thin crust pizza.
$16.94Personal Size Pizza
(for up to 1 person) NY Style thin crust pizza. Also available in Gluten Free or Cauliflower Crusts.
$12.94Sicilian Pizza
(for up to 4 or more people) Sicilian Cheese Pizza: Square Thick Pizza with double dough, double Marinara sauce & double Mozzarella Cheese.
$27.94
Specialty Pizzas & Sicilian Specialty Pizzas
Specialty Pizzas & Specialty Sicilian Pizzas
Meat Pizza
Included Toppings: Bacon, Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatballs and Ham with Melted Mozzarella & Marinara Sauce.
Veggie Pizza
Included Toppings: Fresh Veggies! Tomato, Green Pepper, Onion, Mushroom, Black Olives on Melted Mozzarella & Marinara Sauce
Margherita Pizza
NO MARINARA SAUCE. Included Toppings: Sliced Tomato, Fresh Basil, Melted Mozzarella Cheese & Tuscan Seasonings
White Pizza
NO MARINARA SAUCE. Included Toppings: Melted Mozzarella, Ricotta Cheese, Romano Parmesan Cheese & Tuscan Seasoning.
Four Cheese Pizza
Included Toppings: Cheddar Cheese, Provolone Cheese, Romano Cheese & Mozzarella Cheese on Marinara Sauce
Hawaiian Pizza
Included Toppings: Ham, Pineapple, Mozzarella Cheese & Marinara Sauce
Best Pizza
TEN Included Toppings: Bacon, Pepperoni, Ham, Meatball, Sausage, Tomato, Onion, Mushroom, Green Pepper & Black Olives on Melted Mozzarella & Marinara Sauce
BBQ Chicken Pizza
NO MARINARA SAUCE. Included Toppings: Breaded Chicken on Sweet BBQ Sauce and topped with Melted Mozzarella Cheese
Chicken Parm Pizza
Included Toppings: Breaded Chicken, Romano Parmesan Cheese on Marinara Sauce and topped with Mozzarella Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
NO MARINARA SAUCE. Included Toppings: Breaded Chicken & Mozzarella Cheese on either Mild, Medium or Hot Buffalo Sauce.
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
NO MARINARA SAUCE. Included Toppings: Breaded Chicken, Bacon, Onion, Pineapple on Melted Mozzarella & Sweet BBQ Sauce.
Philly CheeseSteak Pizza
Included Toppings: Sliced Philly Steak, Onions, Green Peppers & Mushrooms on Marinara Sauce and topped with Provolone & Mozzarella Cheese.
Grandma Sicilian
Sicilian Pizza topped with Garlic Pesto, light Marinara Sauce, light Mozzarella Cheese and Fresh Basil
$34.94
Half & Half Pizza -Cheese or Specialties Toppings
Half & Half Pizza
Family Size Pizza
Family Size Pizza with the option to customize each half of your pizza.
Large Size Pizza
Large Size Pizza with the option to customize each half of your pizza.
Medium Size Pizza
Medium Size Pizza with the option to customize each half of your pizza.
Personal Size Pizza
Personal Size Pizza with the option to customize each half of your pizza.
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Size Pizza with the option to customize each half of your pizza.
Calzones
Family Size Calzone
(for 2 or more people) Calzones include a rich blend of Grande Ricotta Cheese & Mozzarella, wrapped in a delicious "dough" and baked to perfection. Additional varieties are available with different toppings.
Medium Size Calzone
(for 1 to 2 people) Calzones include a rich blend of Grande Ricotta Cheese & Mozzarella, wrapped in a delicious "dough" and baked to perfection. Additional varieties are available with different toppings.
Personal Size Calzone
(for 1 person) Calzones include a rich blend of Grande Ricotta Cheese & Mozzarella, wrapped in a delicious "dough" and baked to perfection. Additional varieties are available with different toppings.
Flatbread
Bacon Chicken Ranch Flatbread.
Flavorful Crisp Flatbread with Smoked Bacon, Savory Grilled Chicken and Grande Mozzarella Cheese on a delightful Ranch sauce and Tuscan seasoning, fired on an ultra thin crispy crust.
$16.49Bruchette Chicken Flatbread.
Rustic Crisp Flatbread with Grilled Chicken, Vine Ripened Tomatoes, Red Onions, Julienned Basil and Mozzarella Cheese all Marinated in Balsamic Vinaigrette, fired on an ultra thin crispy crust.
$16.49BBQ Luau Flatbread.
Savory & Sweet Flatbread with Smoked Bacon, flavorful Ham, sweet diced Pineapple & Mozzarella Cheese, all on a delicious BBQ Sauce, Fried on a ultra thin crispy crust.
$16.49Red White and Balsamic Flatbread.
Fresh Crisp Flatbread with a delicate topping of Vine Ripened Tomatoes, dollops of flavorful Ricotta Cheese, Julienned Basil and Fresh Spinach drenched in a delicious Balsamic Vinaigrette, fired on an ultra thin crispy crust.
$16.49Formaggio 4 Flatbread.
Delicious Crisp Flatbread with a perfect blend of 4 cheese. Cheddar, Provolone, Romano & Mozzarella melted on Marinara Sauce and sprinkled with Tuscan Seasoning, fired on an ultra thin crust.
$16.49Bleu Tomato Flatbread.
Crisp Rustic Flatbread with Fresh Vine Ripened Tomatoes, Julienned Basil and Grande Mozzarella Cheese on a flavorful Blue Cheese Sauce and Tuscan Seasoning, fired on an ultra thin crisp crust.
$16.49Italian Meats Flatbread.
Savory Flatbread with delicate toppings of diced Italian Sausage, Meatballs, Salami, Pepperoni and Mozzarella Cheese with Marinara Sauce and Tuscan Seasoning, fired on an ultra thin crust.
$16.49
Appetizers
Buffalo Wings
Large Wings, Bone-In, comes with your choice of Hot, Mild, Medium, Garlic Parmesan, BBQ or Naked!
$11.49Boneless Wings
Boneless Wing Nuggets, comes with your choice of Hot, Mild, Medium, Garlic Parmesan, BBQ or Naked!
$11.49French Fries
Choice Long Cut Fries, cooked perfectly till golden, slightly crisp outside with a warm soft center. Seasoned with Salt.
$7.49Mozzarella Sticks
Gourmet Mozzarella Sticks crafted with the best Mozzarella Cheese and a delightful crispy breaded outside.
$11.94Onions Rings
Gourmet Onion Rings crafted with large Onions and seasoned breading for a delightful crisp outside and amazing taste.
$11.49Calamari
Tender premium Calamari with traditional light batter, fried just right for the perfect taste!
$16.49Meatball App
Tasty Italian Meatballs with Marinara Sauce.
$7.94Sausage App
Tasty Mild Italian Sausage with Marinara Sauce.
$9.94Garlic Knots
Delicious Garlic Knots covered with Garlic Pesto Sauce. Served with a side of Marinara Sauce.
$1.49Cheesy Bread
$9.94Meatball Garlic Knot Sliders (3)
3 Meatball Sliders to an Order. Meatball Sliders are stuffed with an Italian Meatball covered in marinara sauce and melted cheese, all on a delicious Garlic Knot Roll (3 Sliders to an order)
$11.94
Salads
Tossed Salad-Personal
Personal Size Salad Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olives, Pepperocini Pepper & Cheddar Cheese.
$7.94Tossed Salad- Large
Large Size Salad Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olives, Pepperocini Pepper & Cheddar Cheese.
$11.94Caesar Salad- Personal
Personal Size Salad Romaine Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese & Croutons.
$7.94Caesar Salad- Large
Large Size Salad Romaine Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese & Croutons
$11.94Greek Salad- Personal
Personal Size Salad Iceberg Lettuce, Feta Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olives, Pepperocini Pepper & Kalamata Olives.
$10.49Greek Salad- Large
Personal Size Salad Iceberg Lettuce, Feta Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olives, Pepperocini Pepper & Kalamata Olives.
$15.49Antipasto Salad-Personal
Personal Size Salad Iceberg Lettuce, Pepperoni, Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olives, Pepperocini Pepper & Kalamata Olives.
$11.49Antipasto Salad- Large
Large Size Salad Iceberg Lettuce, Pepperoni, Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion, Black Olives, Pepperocini Pepper & Kalamata Olives.
$16.49
Subs
Meatball Parm Sub
Traditionally Seasoned Italian Meatballs covered in Marinara Sauce, smothered in melted Mozzarella Cheese. Baked to Perfection.
$13.94Sausage Parm Sub
Mild Italian Sausage covered in Marinara Sauce, smothered in melted Mozzarella Cheese. Baked to Perfection.
$13.94Chicken Parm Sub
Traditionally Breaded & Seasoned Chicken covered in Marinara Sauce, smothered in melted Mozzarella Cheese. Baked to Perfection.
$13.94Eggplant Parm Sub
Deliciously Breaded & Seasoned sliced Eggplant covered in Marinara Sauce, smothered in melted Mozzarella Cheese. Baked to Perfection.
$13.94Philly CheeseSteak Sub
Famous Philly CheeseSteak- Thin Sliced Steak, Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Provolone & Mozzarella Cheese with a perfect blend of seasonings. Baked to Perfection!
$13.94
Dinners
Pasta with Marinara Sauce Dinner
$10.94Pasta & Meatball Dinner
Your Choice of Spaghetti, Penne or Fettuccini Pasta smothered in our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce". Includes Italian Style Meatballs and 2 Homemade Garlic Knots.
$16.94Pasta & Sausage Dinner
Your Choice of Spaghetti, Penne or Fettuccini Pasta smothered in our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce". Includes Mild Italian Sausage and 2 Homemade Garlic Knots.
$16.94Fettuccini Alfredo Dinner
Fettuccini Pasta drenched in a delicious creamy Alfredo Sauce. Served with 2 homemade Garlic Knots. Add Grilled Chicken or Grilled Shrimp to enhance your meal.
$16.94Pasta Bolognese Dinner
Your Choice of Spaghetti, Penne or Fettuccini Pasta smothered in our Family's "Signature Meat Sauce". Includes 2 Homemade Garlic Knots.
$16.94Ravioli Dinner
Pasta Filled "Pillows" filled with Premium Ricotta Cheese and generously smothered in our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce". Includes 2 Homemade Garlic Knots.
$18.94Lasagna Dinner
Delicate Pasta Sheets layered with Ricotta Cheese, Sliced Mild Italian Sausage and Sliced Italian Meatballs, covered in our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce" & Melted Mozzarella Cheese. Includes and 2 Homemade Garlic Knots.
$19.94Eggplant Parmesan Dinner
Tender slices of Eggplant in traditional Italian breading, covered in melted Mozzarella Cheese and our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce". Your Choice of Pasta: Spaghetti, Penne or Fettuccini. Includes 2 homemade Garlic Knots.
$19.94Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Savory Chicken Covered in Traditional Breading, smothered in melted Mozzarella Cheese and our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce". Includes 2 homemade Garlic Knots.
$20.943 Cheese Penne Dinner
Penne Pasta in a blend of Ricotta, Romano & Parmesan Cheese. Covered in our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce" and melted Mozzarella Cheese. Includes 2 homemade Garlic Knots.
$18.94Stuffed Shells Dinner
Delicious Pasta "Shells" filled with Ricotta Cheese and covered in melted Mozzarella Cheese. Smothered in our Family's "Signature Marinara Sauce". Includes 2 homemade Garlic Knots.
$19.94
Desserts
Cannoli
Made Fresh to order with a Creamy Sweet filling & Chocolate Chips. Wrapped in a Crunchy pastry and sprinkled with powdered sugar and a chocolate syrup drizzle. Served as a single cannoli.
$7.49Zeppoli Stix
Light and delicious sticks of fried pastry dough generously sprinkled with powdered sugar.
$7.49
Items on the Side
Sauce on the Side
Marinara Sauce Small Side
$0.75Marinara Sauce Large Side
$1.79Garlic Pesto Small Side
$1.79Garlic Pesto Large Side
$2.98Mild Sauce Small Side
$0.59Mild Sauce Large Side
$0.89Medium Sauce Small Side
$0.59Medium Sauce Large Side
$0.89Hot Sauce Small Side
$0.59Hot Sauce Large Side
$0.89BBQ Sauce Small Side
$0.59BBQ Sauce Large Side
$0.89Butter Small Side
$0.59Garlic Butter Small Side
$0.59Alfredo Sauce Small Side
$1.79Alfredo Sauce Large Side
$2.98Alfredo Sauce Extra Large Side
$5.96
Dressing on the Side .
Toppings on the Side
Mozzarella Cheese Side
$3.16Cheddar Cheese Side
$3.16Parmesan Cheese Side
$2.56Parmesan Cheese Side
$3.16Ricotta Cheese Side
$4.56Feta Cheese Side (Small)
$2.56Feta Cheese Side (Large)
$4.56Basil Side
$3.16Banana Pepper Side
$3.16Black Olives Side
$3.16Broccoli Side
$3.16Eggplant Side
$4.56Garlic Side
$2.56Green Peppers Side
$3.16Jalapeno Side
$3.16Mushrooms Side
$3.16Onion Side
$3.16Pineapple Side
$3.16Provolone Side
$3.16Spinach Side
$3.16Diced Tomato Side
$3.16Kalamata Olives Side
$4.56Red Onions Side
$4.56Bacon Side
$4.56Ground Beef Side
$3.16Ham Side
$4.56Meatball (Sliced) Side
$3.16Mild Pepperocini
$4.56Pepperoni Side
$3.16Salami Side
$3.16Sausage Side
$3.16Anchovy (10pcs)
$4.56cold Grilled Chicken (diced) Side
$4.56cold Breaded Chicken (diced) Side
$4.56