Skip to Main content
  • Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket

Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket

23 Broad Street, Nantucket, MA
Pickup Only
‌
‌
Soups + Appetizers
Burgers
Sandwiches
Entrées
Salads
Kids Menu
Desserts
Sides
Appetizers
Essential Rolls
Nigiri
Sashimi
Specialty Rolls
Bowls
Platters

Featured Items

  • Spicy Rigatoni

    Panko-breaded chicken in a Calabrian chili vodka cream sauce, topped with Pecorino Romano
    $28.00
  • Curly Fries

    Classic or Parmesan-truffle
    $9.00
  • Thai Chicken Lettuce Wraps

    Poached chicken, carrots, cabbage, cilantro, peanuts, and sesame-ginger vinaigrette
    $18.00

Food Menu

Soups + Appetizers

  • CUP Chowder

    New England style
    $11.00
  • BOWL Chowder

    New England style
    $13.00
  • French Onion Soup

    Beef broth, with melted gruyere and house croutons
    $12.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Curly Fries

    Classic or Parmesan-truffle
    $9.00
  • Boom Boom Shrimp

    Crispy fried, sweet sriracha sauce, sesame seeds
    $22.00
  • Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice

    Diced raw tuna, sweet soy sauce, wasabi tobiko, crispy rice
    $24.00
  • Crab & Avocado

    Colossal lump crab, crispy wontons, watermelon radish, yuzu vinaigrette
    $24.00
  • Buffalo Chicken Tenders

    Mango-buffalo sauce, pineapple salsa, and blue cheese dressing
    $18.00
  • Thai Chicken Lettuce Wraps

    Poached chicken, carrots, cabbage, cilantro, peanuts, and sesame-ginger vinaigrette
    $18.00
  • Chicken Dumplings

    Pan-fried, lemongrass, ginger soy dipping sauce
    $18.00
  • Cheesesteak Egg Rolls

    American and provolone cheeses, caramelized onions, and Chinese mustard
    $20.00
  • Heirloom Burrata

    Local burrata, heirloom tomatoes, basil, balsamic pearls, grilled focaccia
    $20.00

Burgers

  • Brotherhood Burger

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, and choice of cheese on griddled sesame brioche bun
    $22.00
  • Reverend Foster Burger

    American cheese, caramelized onions, lettuce, and special sauce on a griddled sesame brioche bun
    $22.00
  • BBQ Burger

    Cheddar, bacon, BBQ sauce, and onion strings on a griddled sesame brioche bun
    $24.00
  • Cisco Burger

    Blue cheese, caramelized onions, bacon, lettuce, and balsamic on a griddled sesame brioche bun
    $24.00
  • Veggie Burger

    House made with quinoa, sweet potato, and black beans, topped with pickled onion, avocado, cilantro crema
    $20.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Sandwiches

  • Caprese

    Fresh mozzarella, arugula, pesto aioli, and tomato jam, on toasted ciabatta
    $22.00
  • Fried Chicken

    Buttermilk or Nashville hot, sour pickles, lemon aioli, and seeded brioche
    $22.00
  • Blackened Swordfish

    Pickled veggies, arugula, cilantro, piri-piri sauce, sriracha aioli, and seeded brioche
    $26.00
  • Scallop Roll

    Lightly fried, shredded lettuce, coleslaw, tartar, griddled brioche bun
    $36.00
  • Cold Lobster Roll

    Celery, chive, lemon, and mayo. With fries and coleslaw, on griddled brioche
    $39.00
  • Warm Lobster Roll

    Warmed in brown butter. With fries and coleslaw, on griddled brioche
    $39.00

Entrées

  • Spicy Rigatoni

    Panko-breaded chicken in a Calabrian chili vodka cream sauce, topped with Pecorino Romano
    $28.00
  • Chicken Souvlaki

    Lemon-herb marinated grilled chicken skewers, cous cous, tzatziki, pickled onions, cucumber-tomato salad
    $28.00
  • Latin Salmon

    Grilled, avocado, salsa verde, glazed sweet potatoes, grilled corn
    $38.00
  • Sole Piccata

    Pan seared, crispy fingerlings, green beans, capers, lemon-wine butter sauce
    $36.00
  • Pan-Seared Scallops

    Giants, roasted corn and white bean succotash, confit tomato, sautéed spinach
    $48.00
  • Lobster Fettuccine

    Lobster meat, spinach, cherry tomatoes, lobster cream sauce, toasted focaccia
    $44.00
  • Fish and Chips

    Beer battered or lightly fried cod, with curly fries and coleslaw
    $32.00
  • Steak Frites

    Grilled Brandt farms NY strip, chimichurri, garlic aioli, and truffle fries.
    $44.00

Salads

  • Lobster Avocado

    Chilled lobster, grilled corn, arugula, avocado, pickled red onion, tomato, tortilla strips, chipotle lime dressing
    $40.00
  • Salmon Noodle Bowl

    Mango, avocado, cucumber, cabbage, tomato, cilantro, chilled noodles, mint & basil Thai vinaigrette
    $34.00
  • Poke Bowl

    Diced bluefin or salmon, rice, mango, cucumber, cabbage, cilantro, avocado, carrots, and pineapple-ginger dressing.
    $34.00
  • Chicken Caesar

    Regular or buffalo crispy chicken tenders, romaine, Pecorino, and house croutons
    $24.00
  • Greek Salad

    Lemon-marinated grilled chicken skewer, feta, cukes, tomatoes, red onions, Kalamata olives, romaine, red wine vinaigrette
    $26.00
  • Chicken Cobb

    Grilled chicken, romaine, arugula, avocado, corn, tomatoes, egg, bacon, blue cheese, and champagne vinaigrette
    $28.00
  • Caesar

    Classic
    $14.00
  • Fancy Simple House

    Mixed greens with grape tomato, cucumber, pickled onion, creamy sherry vinaigrette
    $14.00

Kids Menu

  • Kids Cheeseburger

    4 oz ground beef patty with American cheese on griddled sesame brioche bun
    $12.00
  • Kids Grilled Cheese

    Classic grilled cheese on white bread with American
    $12.00
  • Kids Tenders

    Breaded chicken tenders
    $12.00
  • Kids Chicken Sand

    Grilled Chicken on a griddled sesame brioche bun
    $12.00
  • Kids Pasta

    Butter or Red sauce
    $12.00

Desserts

  • Brohood Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

    In a cast iron skillet, with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, and chocolate sauce
    $15.00
  • Carrot Cake

    Cream cheese frosting, pecans, and caramel sauce
    $12.00
  • Strawberry Shortcake

    House-made biscuit, vanilla ice cream, strawberries, whipped cream
    $14.00
  • Ice Cream Scoop

    Scoop of vanilla ice cream
    $3.00

Sides

  • Side roasted potato

    $8.00
  • Side sweet potato

    $8.00
  • Side sushi rice

    $8.00
  • Side green beans

    $8.00
  • Side spinach

    $8.00
  • Side slaw

    $7.00
  • Side bread

    $2.00
  • Side avocado

    $2.00
  • Side pickles

    $2.00
  • Side of bacon

    $2.00
  • Side Grill Chicken

    $10.00
  • Side Breaded Chicken

    $12.00
  • Side Skewer(1)

    $8.00
  • Side Cold Lobster

    $24.00
  • Side Warm Lobster

    $24.00
  • Side Salmon

    $16.00
  • Side Shrimp

    $14.00
  • Side Burger

    $12.00
  • Side NY Strip

    $20.00
  • Side Veg Burger

    $10.00

Sushi Menu

Appetizers

  • Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice

    Diced raw tuna, sweet soy sauce, wasabi tobiko, crispy rice
    $24.00
  • Tuna Tartare

    Diced bluefin, avocado, micro cilantro, ginger soy, tortilla chips
    $20.00
  • Hamachi Carpaccio

    Thinly slice yellowtail, micro cilantro, and mustard soy sauce
    $18.00
  • Seaweed Salad

    Traditional wakame style
    $10.00

Essential Rolls

  • Maki Roll

    Tuna, yellowtail or salmon with avocado
    $15.00
  • Spicy Maki Roll

    Tuna, salmon or yellowtail with cucumber
    $15.00
  • Shrimp Tempura Roll

    Avocado, cucumber, and sweet soy
    $15.00
  • California Roll

    Crab, cucumber, and avocado
    $15.00
  • Tuna Crunch Roll

    Tuna, avocado, tempura crunch, and sweet chili sauce
    $15.00
  • BBQ Eel Roll

    Eel, cucumber, avocado, sweet soy
    $15.00

Nigiri

  • Tuna Nigiri

    $12.00
  • Yellowtail Nigiri

    $12.00
  • Salmon Nigiri

    $12.00
  • Salmon Roe Nigiri

    $12.00
  • Eel Nigiri

    $12.00
  • Seabass Nigiri

    $12.00
  • Toro Nigiri

    $17.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Sea Urchin Nigiri

    $17.00
  • Kobe Beef Nigiri

    $17.00

Sashimi

  • Tuna Sashimi

    $15.00
  • Yellowtail Sashimi

    $15.00
  • Salmon Sashimi

    $15.00
  • Salmon Roe Sashimi

    $15.00
  • Eel Sashimi

    $15.00
  • Seabass Sashimi

    $15.00
  • Toro Sashimi

    $20.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Sea Urchin Sashmi

    $20.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Kobe Beef Sashimi

    $20.00

Specialty Rolls

  • Endless Summer Roll

    Tuna, cucumber, avocado, crab stick, topped with tuna, avocado, spicy mayo, and sweet soy
    $24.00
  • Toro Jalapeño Roll

    Spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with torched Toro, jalapeño, tobiko, and mustard soy sauce
    $26.00
  • Everything Roll

    Tuna, salmon, yellowtail, cucumber, avocado, crab stick, tempura crunch, spicy mayo, and tobiko
    $25.00
  • Triple Salmon Roll

    Spicy salmon, crab, cucumber, avocado, topped with seared salmon, salmon roe, and chef's secret sauce
    $25.00
  • Dynamite Roll

    Spicy yellowtail, crab, cucumber and avocado, topped with spicy tuna, sriracha, spicy mayo, sweet soy, and tempura crunch
    $25.00
  • Nantucket Roll

    Spicy scallops, cucumber and tempura crunch, topped with tobiko
    $26.00
  • Rainbow Roll

    Crab, cucumber, avocado, topped with tuna, salmon, and yellowtail
    $24.00
  • Brohood Roll

    Spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with torched yellowtail, salmon, jalapeño, and sriracha
    $24.00
  • Cisco Beach Roll

    Spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with seared yellowtail, spicy mayo, sweet soy, scallions, lime, and tobiko
    $25.00
  • Angry Dragon Roll

    Shrimp tempura, spicy tuna and avocado, wrapped in soy paper, topped with crab stick, sweet soy, and mango sauce
    $25.00
  • Tornado

    Shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado and crab meat, wrapped in soy paper and potato, deep-fried and topped with sweet soy, spicy mayo, and sweet chili
    $25.00
  • Shaggy Dog

    Shrimp tempura and avocado, topped with crab stick, sweet soy, spicy mayo, and mango sauce
    $25.00
  • Volcano

    Crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with baked spicy scallop, crab stick, unagi sauce, scallion, and tobiko
    $26.00
  • Pipeline

    Shrimp, crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with lobster, spicy mayo, sweet soy, and tobiko
    $30.00
  • Dragon

    Crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with BBQ eel, avocado, and sweet soy
    $24.00
  • Caterpillar

    Crab and cucumber, topped with avocado, sweet soy, and tempura crunch
    $24.00
  • Veggie Futo

    Soy and yuzu vinegar marinated veggies, with cucumber, carrot, and avocado
    $20.00
  • Spicy Lobster

    Lobster, spicy mayo, avocado, cucumber, and tobiko
    $28.00
  • Surf and Turf

    Shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado, topped with torched A5 kobe beef, sweet soy, sweet chili, and spicy mayo
    $28.00
  • Kobi-Wan

    Grilled A5 kobe beef, marinated Japanese veggies, soy, topped with cucumber, avocado, and sesame oil
    $28.00
  • Samurai

    Crab, shrimp tempura, avocado, cucumber, topped with lobster, spicy mayo, sweet soy, and tobiko
    $28.00

Bowls

  • Poke Bowl

    Bluefin tuna, rice, onions, radish, cucumber, avocado, carrots, seaweed salad, tobiko, sesame seed, tempura crunch, garlic soy dressing, and spicy aioli
    $34.00
  • Salmon Sashimi Bowl

    Sliced salmon, spicy seaweed salad, rice, fresh wasabi, ginger, cucumber, avocado, salmon roe, and sesame dressing
    $26.00
  • Chirashi

    A sushi salad of tuna, salmon, yellowtail, tobiko, fresh wasabi, greens, and rice
    $28.00

Platters

  • Nigiri Sampler

    1 piece each, bluefin tuna, salmon, yellowtail, black seabass, a5 kobe beef, toro, and choice of 1 large roll
    $45.00
  • Toro Sampler

    4 pieces nigiri, 4 pieces sashimi, and 1 Toro jalapeño roll
    $60.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Ferry Boat

    Choice of 8 pieces nigiri, 8 pieces sashimi, one essential roll, and one large roll
    $100.00

Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket Location and Ordering Hours

(774) 325-5812
23 Broad Street, Nantucket, MA 02554
Open now • Closes at 9:30PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement