Please remember to order in advance for holidays and big events!

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville, TX
4712 Colleyville Blvd, 160, Colleyville, TX
Featured Items

9" Key Lime
Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.$35.00
Stack of 4 Mini-Pies
Mix 'n' match your mini-pies for seasonal variety! The perfect way to sample our pie flavors. Great gift for clients, friends or yourself and way better than a slice!$25.00
9" Granny's Apple
Crisp Granny Smith apples covered in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.$35.00
THANKSGIVING MENU (November 23rd - November 25th)
From Monday, 11/23 through Wednesday, 11/25, we're offering a limited holiday menu so we can focus on your Thanksgiving favorites.
We will only have 9" pies - Minis will return after the holiday on 11/27.
Orders for any other flavor can't be picked up during Thanksgiving week. Please choose a pickup date before 11/23 or after the holiday.
We can't wait to be part of your Thanksgiving table!

9" Spiced Pumpkin
A rich, velvety pumpkin filling blended with warm fall spices and baked to creamy perfection. Topped with a dollop of our spiced cream cheese whip for the perfect finishing touch to your holiday table!$35.00
9" Nanny's Pecan
The perfect blend of toasted pecans & gooey filling spread into a buttery crust. A Southern favorite!$35.00
9" I-40
A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a shortbread crust.$35.00
9" Granny's Apple
Crisp Granny Smith apples covered in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.$35.00
9" Key Lime (LIMITED QUANTITY)
Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.$35.00
9" Chocolate Cream (LIMITED QUANTITY)
This pie starts with our house-made Oreo crust. We add our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, top it with our creamy & sweet cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it with delicate chocolate curls.$35.00
9" Gluten-Friendly Pecan (LIMITED QUANTITY)
This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.$40.00
9" Gluten-Friendly I-40 (LIMITED QUANTITY)
A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.$40.00
9" Pies

9" Granny's Apple
Crisp Granny Smith apples covered in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.$35.00
9" I-40
A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a shortbread crust. A gluten-friendly version is available with 24-hour's notice.$35.00
9" Nanny's Pecan
This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery shortbread crust. A gluten-friendly version is available with 24-hour's notice.$35.00
9" Chewy Chocolate Chip
Brown sugar, butter, chocolate chips and vanilla combine to create an irresistible pie that will inspire you to share with a friend.$35.00
9" Southern Custard
A mild and buttery custard-based pie that lands somewhere between chess pie, cheesecake, and sugar cookie. The not-too-sweet buttermilk filling is baked into our delicious shortbread crust and is taken out of the oven before it gets too brown.$35.00
9" Key Lime
Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.$35.00
9" Chocolate Cream
This pie starts with our house-made Oreo crust. We add our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, top it with our creamy & sweet cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it with delicate chocolate curls.$35.00
9" Coconut Cream
Our filling is cooked over the stovetop giving it a sweet, rich flavor that is complemented by our buttery crust and the beauty of a coconut sprinkled Italian meringue that is lightly toasted in the oven.$35.00
9" Peanut Butter Cream
Peanut butter and cream cheese are sweetened and whipped into a rich filling that is set into an Oreo cookie crust, topped with our house made ganache, cream cheese whipped cream topping and a sprinkle of Reese's crumble.$35.00
9" Spiced Apple Custard
A delicious twist on apple pie - Apple butter and seasonal spices are baked into a custard and topped with spiced cream cheese whip.$35.00
9" Spiced Pumpkin
A rich, velvety pumpkin filling blended with warm fall spices and baked to creamy perfection. Topped with a dollop of our spiced cream cheese whip!$35.00
9" Gluten-Friendly Pecan
*Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.$40.00
9" Gluten-Friendly I-40
*Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.$40.00
9" Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Cream
*Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie** Our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, is topped with our cream cheese whipped cream topping, placed in our Gluten-Free shortbread crust and finished with delicate chocolate curls.$40.00
4” Pies

Stack of 4 Mini-Pies
Mix 'n' match your mini-pies for seasonal variety! The perfect way to sample our pie flavors. Great gift for clients, friends or yourself and way better than a slice!$25.00
Dozen 4” Mini-Pies
It's not a party until the pie arrives! 12 individually packaged mini-pies, conveniently bundled in our handy pie tote, flavors of your choosing. Our Seasonal Flavors is Spiced Pumpkin!$72.00
4" Apple
Crisp Granny Smith apples coated in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.$7.00
4" I -40
A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a shortbread crust.$7.00
4" Chewy Chocolate Chip
Brown sugar, butter, chocolate chips and vanilla combine to create an irresistible pie that will inspire you to share with a friend.$7.00
4" Pecan
This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery shortbread crust.$7.00
4" Southern Custard
A mild and buttery custard-based pie that lands somewhere between chess pie, cheesecake, and sugar cookie. The not-too-sweet buttermilk filling is baked into our delicious shortbread crust and is taken out of the oven before it gets too brown.$7.00
4" Coconut Cream
Our filling is cooked over the stove top giving it a sweet, rich flavor that is complemented by our buttery crust and the beauty of a coconut sprinkled Italian meringue that is lightly toasted in the oven.$7.00
4" Key Lime
Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.$7.00
4" Peanut Butter Cream
Peanut butter and cream cheese are sweetened and whipped into a rich filling that is set into an Oreo cookie crust, topped with our house made ganache, cream cheese whipped cream topping and a sprinkle of Reese's crumble.$7.00
4" Chocolate Cream
This pie starts with our house-made Oreo crust. We add our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, top it with our creamy & sweet cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it with delicate chocolate curls. *Not available 11/23-11/25.$7.00
4" Spiced Pumpkin
A rich, velvety pumpkin filling blended with warm fall spices and baked to creamy perfection. Topped with a dollop of our spiced cream cheese whip!$7.00
4" Spiced Apple Custard
A delicious twist on apple pie - Apple butter and seasonal spices are baked into a custard and topped with spiced cream cheese whip.$7.00
4" Gluten-Friendly I-40
*Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.$9.00
4" Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Cream
*Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. Our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, is topped with our cream cheese whipped cream topping, placed in our Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust and finished with delicate chocolate curls.$9.00
4" Gluten-Friendly Pecan
*Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.$9.00
Thumbprint Cookies
Our thumbprint cookies will take you back in time to your favorite old school bakery counter. Simple, sweet, and made from scratch.

Vanilla Cookies (12)
Buttery, scratch-made shortbread with just a hint of Madagascar vanilla.$12.00
Pumpkin Spice Cookies (12)
Our buttery, house-made shortbread cookies filled with a sweet and creamy pumpkin spice filling. The perfect little taste of fall!$12.00
Chocolate Cookies (12) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE
** Requires 48hr Notice** Our soft, melt in your mouth chocolate shortbread filled with sweet vanilla icing$15.00
Chocolate Cookies w/ Chocolate Ganache (12) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE
** Requires 48hr Notice** Our chocolate shortbread cookies filled with smooth chocolate ganache$15.00
Vanilla Cookies w/ Chocolate Ganache (12) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE
** Requires 48hr Notice** Our signature shortbread cookies filled smooth chocolate ganache$15.00
Custom Color Cookies (36) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE
**Requires 24hr Notice** Make your celebration extra special with our signature Thumbprint Cookies - now available with customizable colors! Whether you’re planning a baby shower, birthday party, or themed event, we can match your cookies to your color scheme for a sweet (and picture-perfect) treat. Soft, buttery, and filled with flavor, these cookies aren’t just delicious - they’re a beautiful way to tie your dessert table together.$45.00
Cloud Cookies
Handmade pecan shortbread cookies finished with a generous dusting of powdered sugar.
Gifts

9" Pie with Twine & Gift Tag
Say it with pie for any occasion! Choose the 9" pie flavor, baker's twine color and gift tag; make someone's day extra special!$38.00
Pie Stack 4" (2)
Say it with a pie stack! Choose the 2 mini-pie flavors, baker's twine color and gift tag; make someone's day extra special!$17.00
Pie Stack 4" (3)
Say it with a pie stack! Choose the 3 mini-pie flavors, baker's twine color and gift tag; make someone's day extra special!$24.00
4" Pie for a Year Card
This will allow the recipient to come in and pick out any 4” pie each month for an entire year! A sweet & unique gift for the pie lovers in your life! Perfect for birthdays, thank you gifts, baby showers, and Christmas gifts!$75.00
9" Pie for a Year Card
This will allow the recipient to come in and pick out a 9” pie each month for an entire year! A sweet & unique gift for the pie lovers in your life! Perfect for birthdays, thank you gifts, baby showers, and Christmas gifts!$360.00

