Skip to Main content
Please remember to order in advance for holidays and big events!
  • Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville, TX

Banner image

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville, TX

4712 Colleyville Blvd, 160, Colleyville, TX
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • 9" Key Lime

    Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.
    $35.00
  • Stack of 4 Mini-Pies

    Mix 'n' match your mini-pies for seasonal variety! The perfect way to sample our pie flavors. Great gift for clients, friends or yourself and way better than a slice!
    $25.00
  • 9" Granny's Apple

    Crisp Granny Smith apples covered in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.
    $35.00

THANKSGIVING MENU (November 23rd - November 25th)

From Monday, 11/23 through Wednesday, 11/25, we're offering a limited holiday menu so we can focus on your Thanksgiving favorites. We will only have 9" pies - Minis will return after the holiday on 11/27. Orders for any other flavor can't be picked up during Thanksgiving week. Please choose a pickup date before 11/23 or after the holiday. We can't wait to be part of your Thanksgiving table!
  • 9" Spiced Pumpkin

    A rich, velvety pumpkin filling blended with warm fall spices and baked to creamy perfection. Topped with a dollop of our spiced cream cheese whip for the perfect finishing touch to your holiday table!
    $35.00
  • 9" Nanny's Pecan

    The perfect blend of toasted pecans & gooey filling spread into a buttery crust. A Southern favorite!
    $35.00
  • 9" I-40

    A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a shortbread crust.
    $35.00
  • 9" Granny's Apple

    Crisp Granny Smith apples covered in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.
    $35.00
  • 9" Key Lime (LIMITED QUANTITY)

    Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.
    $35.00
  • 9" Chocolate Cream (LIMITED QUANTITY)

    This pie starts with our house-made Oreo crust. We add our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, top it with our creamy & sweet cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it with delicate chocolate curls.
    $35.00
  • 9" Gluten-Friendly Pecan (LIMITED QUANTITY)

    This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.
    $40.00
  • 9" Gluten-Friendly I-40 (LIMITED QUANTITY)

    A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.
    $40.00

9" Pies

  • 9" Granny's Apple

    Crisp Granny Smith apples covered in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.
    $35.00
  • 9" I-40

    A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a shortbread crust. A gluten-friendly version is available with 24-hour's notice.
    $35.00
  • 9" Nanny's Pecan

    This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery shortbread crust. A gluten-friendly version is available with 24-hour's notice.
    $35.00
  • 9" Chewy Chocolate Chip

    Brown sugar, butter, chocolate chips and vanilla combine to create an irresistible pie that will inspire you to share with a friend.
    $35.00
  • 9" Southern Custard

    A mild and buttery custard-based pie that lands somewhere between chess pie, cheesecake, and sugar cookie. The not-too-sweet buttermilk filling is baked into our delicious shortbread crust and is taken out of the oven before it gets too brown.
    $35.00
  • 9" Key Lime

    Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.
    $35.00
  • 9" Chocolate Cream

    This pie starts with our house-made Oreo crust. We add our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, top it with our creamy & sweet cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it with delicate chocolate curls.
    $35.00
  • 9" Coconut Cream

    Our filling is cooked over the stovetop giving it a sweet, rich flavor that is complemented by our buttery crust and the beauty of a coconut sprinkled Italian meringue that is lightly toasted in the oven.
    $35.00
  • 9" Peanut Butter Cream

    Peanut butter and cream cheese are sweetened and whipped into a rich filling that is set into an Oreo cookie crust, topped with our house made ganache, cream cheese whipped cream topping and a sprinkle of Reese's crumble.
    $35.00
  • 9" Spiced Apple Custard

    A delicious twist on apple pie - Apple butter and seasonal spices are baked into a custard and topped with spiced cream cheese whip.
    $35.00
  • 9" Spiced Pumpkin

    A rich, velvety pumpkin filling blended with warm fall spices and baked to creamy perfection. Topped with a dollop of our spiced cream cheese whip!
    $35.00
  • 9" Gluten-Friendly Pecan

    *Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.
    $40.00
  • 9" Gluten-Friendly I-40

    *Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.
    $40.00
  • 9" Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Cream

    *Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie** Our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, is topped with our cream cheese whipped cream topping, placed in our Gluten-Free shortbread crust and finished with delicate chocolate curls.
    $40.00

4” Pies

  • Stack of 4 Mini-Pies

    Mix 'n' match your mini-pies for seasonal variety! The perfect way to sample our pie flavors. Great gift for clients, friends or yourself and way better than a slice!
    $25.00
  • Dozen 4” Mini-Pies

    It's not a party until the pie arrives! 12 individually packaged mini-pies, conveniently bundled in our handy pie tote, flavors of your choosing. Our Seasonal Flavors is Spiced Pumpkin!
    $72.00
  • 4" Apple

    Crisp Granny Smith apples coated in sugar and spice, packed to peak into our buttery crust and topped with our house-made apple crumble.
    $7.00
  • 4" I -40

    A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a shortbread crust.
    $7.00
  • 4" Chewy Chocolate Chip

    Brown sugar, butter, chocolate chips and vanilla combine to create an irresistible pie that will inspire you to share with a friend.
    $7.00
  • 4" Pecan

    This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery shortbread crust.
    $7.00
  • 4" Southern Custard

    A mild and buttery custard-based pie that lands somewhere between chess pie, cheesecake, and sugar cookie. The not-too-sweet buttermilk filling is baked into our delicious shortbread crust and is taken out of the oven before it gets too brown.
    $7.00
  • 4" Coconut Cream

    Our filling is cooked over the stove top giving it a sweet, rich flavor that is complemented by our buttery crust and the beauty of a coconut sprinkled Italian meringue that is lightly toasted in the oven.
    $7.00
  • 4" Key Lime

    Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling, then we pipe on a generous border of cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it off with a sweet key lime glaze and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs.
    $7.00
  • 4" Peanut Butter Cream

    Peanut butter and cream cheese are sweetened and whipped into a rich filling that is set into an Oreo cookie crust, topped with our house made ganache, cream cheese whipped cream topping and a sprinkle of Reese's crumble.
    $7.00
  • 4" Chocolate Cream

    This pie starts with our house-made Oreo crust. We add our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, top it with our creamy & sweet cream cheese whipped cream topping and finish it with delicate chocolate curls. *Not available 11/23-11/25.
    $7.00
  • 4" Spiced Pumpkin

    A rich, velvety pumpkin filling blended with warm fall spices and baked to creamy perfection. Topped with a dollop of our spiced cream cheese whip!
    $7.00
  • 4" Spiced Apple Custard

    A delicious twist on apple pie - Apple butter and seasonal spices are baked into a custard and topped with spiced cream cheese whip.
    $7.00
  • 4" Gluten-Friendly I-40

    *Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. A pecan pie with the added goodness of coconut and chocolate chips baked into a Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.
    $9.00
  • 4" Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Cream

    *Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. Our slow-cooked, rich chocolate filling, is topped with our cream cheese whipped cream topping, placed in our Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust and finished with delicate chocolate curls.
    $9.00
  • 4" Gluten-Friendly Pecan

    *Kindly give us 24-hours' notice for this pie. This southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery Gluten-Friendly shortbread crust.
    $9.00

Thumbprint Cookies

Our thumbprint cookies will take you back in time to your favorite old school bakery counter. Simple, sweet, and made from scratch.
  • Vanilla Cookies (12)

    Buttery, scratch-made shortbread with just a hint of Madagascar vanilla.
    $12.00
  • Pumpkin Spice Cookies (12)

    Our buttery, house-made shortbread cookies filled with a sweet and creamy pumpkin spice filling. The perfect little taste of fall!
    $12.00
  • Chocolate Cookies (12) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE

    ** Requires 48hr Notice** Our soft, melt in your mouth chocolate shortbread filled with sweet vanilla icing
    $15.00
  • Chocolate Cookies w/ Chocolate Ganache (12) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE

    ** Requires 48hr Notice** Our chocolate shortbread cookies filled with smooth chocolate ganache
    $15.00
  • Vanilla Cookies w/ Chocolate Ganache (12) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE

    ** Requires 48hr Notice** Our signature shortbread cookies filled smooth chocolate ganache
    $15.00
  • Custom Color Cookies (36) - REQUIRES 48 HR NOTICE

    **Requires 24hr Notice** Make your celebration extra special with our signature Thumbprint Cookies - now available with customizable colors! Whether you’re planning a baby shower, birthday party, or themed event, we can match your cookies to your color scheme for a sweet (and picture-perfect) treat. Soft, buttery, and filled with flavor, these cookies aren’t just delicious - they’re a beautiful way to tie your dessert table together.
    $45.00

Cloud Cookies

Handmade pecan shortbread cookies finished with a generous dusting of powdered sugar.
  • Cloud Cookies (16)

    These delicious cookies are made with our shortbread, crushed pecans, and then dusted in powdered sugar.
    $12.00
  • Cloud Cookies (24)

    These delicious cookies are made with our shortbread, pecans and are dusted in powdered sugar. They are sold in boxes of 24 cookies.
    $18.00

Gifts

  • 9" Pie with Twine & Gift Tag

    Say it with pie for any occasion! Choose the 9" pie flavor, baker's twine color and gift tag; make someone's day extra special!
    $38.00
  • Pie Stack 4" (2)

    Say it with a pie stack! Choose the 2 mini-pie flavors, baker's twine color and gift tag; make someone's day extra special!
    $17.00
  • Pie Stack 4" (3)

    Say it with a pie stack! Choose the 3 mini-pie flavors, baker's twine color and gift tag; make someone's day extra special!
    $24.00
  • 4" Pie for a Year Card

    This will allow the recipient to come in and pick out any 4” pie each month for an entire year! A sweet & unique gift for the pie lovers in your life! Perfect for birthdays, thank you gifts, baby showers, and Christmas gifts!
    $75.00
  • 9" Pie for a Year Card

    This will allow the recipient to come in and pick out a 9” pie each month for an entire year! A sweet & unique gift for the pie lovers in your life! Perfect for birthdays, thank you gifts, baby showers, and Christmas gifts!
    $360.00

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville, TX Location and Ordering Hours

(817) 581-7437
4712 Colleyville Blvd, 160, Colleyville, TX 76034
Open now • Closes at 6:45PM
Facebook logoX (formerly Twitter) logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement