Currently not accepting online orders
Caseys Dugout
2900 Lincoln Avenue, Evansville, IN
App/Desserts/Sides
Appetizers
Cheese Bread
Fresh local bread topped with garlic butter and bubbly mozzarella. Served with pizza sauce.$8.00Jalapeno Cheese Bread
Fresh local bread topped with garlic butter, mozzarella, and jalapenos. Served with your choice of cheese sauce, marinara, or garlic butter.$8.25Breadsticks
Order of 5 breadsticks with choice of cheese sauce, marinara, or garlic butter$7.50Fireballs
Baked doughballs topped with Mike's Hot Honey & Bacon. Add jalapenos to kick up the heat!$9.50Hot Honey Sticks
Garlic Butter breadsticks, topped with hot honey and a dusting of parmesan. Served with marinara$8.25Bruschetta
$9.85Sausage Cheese Bread
$9.00pepperoni rolls
$10.50Cheesy Breadsticks
$8.25pepperoni breadsticks
$9.00
Sides
Desserts
Tiger Balls
Warm and gooey cinnamon sugar dough balls with vanilla icing drizzle. A perfect sweet bite to end your meal.$10.00Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.2510" Dogfather's Dessert Pizza
Our pizza crust with a buttery cinnamon sugar topping and a vanilla icing swirl.$10.0010" Smores Pizza
OUT OF STOCK$12.0016" dogfather
$15.00Vanilla Soft Serve
OUT OF STOCK$3.00Chocolate Soft Serve
OUT OF STOCK$3.00Twists Soft Serve
OUT OF STOCK$3.00Plain Cheesecake
OUT OF STOCK$4.25Key Lime Pie
OUT OF STOCK$4.25
Sandwiches
Hot Ham and Cheese
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$14.50Stromboli
Stromboli meat, pepperoni, diced onion, green peppers, red sauce, mozzarella cheese$14.501/2 Strom
$9.35Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$13.00Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$14.75Meatball Sub
House made sliced meatballs, topped green peppers, onions, marinara, and melty mozzarella. Served with a side of giardiniera.$15.00CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$14.50BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$13.00Caprese
Our stromboli bread toasted and topped with fresh mozzarella slices, tomato, fresh basil & a balsamic glaze drizzle.$14.001/2 Hot Ham
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$9.351/2 Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$9.501/2 Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$8.501/2 CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$9.351/2 BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$8.501/2 Caprese
Our stromboli bread toasted and topped with fresh mozzarella slices, tomato, fresh basil & a balsamic glaze drizzle.$9.001/2 Meatball Sub
House made sliced meatballs, topped green peppers, onions, marinara, and melty mozzarella. Served with a side of giardiniera.$10.00whole Parthenon
$16.001/2 Parthenon
$11.50Whole Chicken Parmesan
OUT OF STOCK$15.001/2 Chicken Parmesan
OUT OF STOCK$10.00BBQ Chicken
$14.751\2 BBQ Chicken
$9.50
Pizza
10" Pizza
10" Cheese Louise
Order it as is or add toppings to build your own pie!$12.0010" The Hitman
Sausage, mushroom, and extra cheese... just how Donnie Baseball likes it!$16.0010" The "Graham" Slam
Loaded! Sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham,bacon, onion, green pepper, black olives, mushroom, and pepperoncinis$21.0010" Harper's Hot Honey Hawaiian
Ham, pineapple, brown sugar, red sauce, and a drizzle of hot honey!$20.0010" The Tater
Potato, bacon, red onion, garlic butter sauce, cheddar cheese, and a side sour cream or tzatziki.$18.0010" The Utopian
Chicken, fresh sliced mushrooms, truffle, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.$20.0010" Mary's Little Lamb
Gyro meat, feta, mozzarella, red onion, tomato, with a side of tzatziki sauce$20.0010" BBQ Chicken
BBQ Chicken, green pepper & onion$20.0010" Field of Greens
All the veggies. Green peppers, red onion, mushroom, black olives, & banana peppers.$18.0010" The Meat Head
Pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, bacon,$21.0010" Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken,bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese$19.0010" Angry Bird
Buffalo chicken, red onion, blue cheese crumble, and ranch drizzle$19.0010" Rancher Pizza
Ranch base, cheese, & tomato.$16.0010" The Popeye
Garlic olive oil base, mozzarella cheese, red onion, feta, & a mound of spinach.$20.0010" The MARGO-rita
Red sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sprinkled with parmesan & finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle.$18.0010" Thai Chicken
Grilled Chicken, thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheese, red onion, zucchinni, & topped with peanuts and toasted sesame seeds$19.0010" Donnie MEATball
Sliced housemade meatballs, herb-infused ricotta, green peppers, onions, red sauce, and mozzarella.$21.0010" Tuscan
$18.0010" Hot Pig
Pepperoni, jalapeno, and hot honey.$18.0010" Stomboli Pie
Sausage crumbles, green pepper, onions, pepperoni, extra red sauce, and mozzarella.$19.0010" Flame Thrower
$21.0010" Jamaican Jerk
$21.0010" Dugout Double Play
Double pepperoni pie with extra cheese$18.0010' The Niner
$19.0010" Big Mac-K
OUT OF STOCK$17.0010" Chicken Caeser Pizza
OUT OF STOCK$16.0010" Chicken Fajita
OUT OF STOCK$17.0010" Garlic Breath
OUT OF STOCK$19.0010" Birria Pizza
$20.0010" The Green Standard
OUT OF STOCK$20.0010" Tasty Taco
Taco seasoned ground beef, taco sauce, cheese, jalepenos, topped with lettuce, tomato, and a side of sour cream. Only available on Taco Tuesday!$19.0010" Chicken Broccoli Cheese
$19.00
16" Pizza
16" Cheese
Order it as is or add toppings to build your own pie!$18.0016" The Hitman
Sausage, mushroom, and extra cheese... just how Donnie Baseball likes it!$23.0016" The "Graham" Slam
Loaded! Sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham,bacon, onion, green pepper, black olives, mushroom, and pepperoncinis$32.0016" Harper's Hot Honey Hawaiian
Ham, pineapple, brown sugar, red sauce, and a drizzle of hot honey!$28.0016" The Tater
Potato, bacon, red onion, garlic butter sauce, cheddar cheese, and a side sour cream or tzatziki.$27.0016" Mary's Little Lamb
Gyro meat, feta, mozzarella, red onion, tomato, with a side of tzatziki sauce$28.0016" Utopian
Chicken, fresh sliced mushroom, truffle and mushroom base, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.$28.0016" Field of Greens
All the veggies. Green peppers, red onion, mushroom, black olives, & banana peppers.$24.0016" BBQ Chicken
BBQ Chicken, green pepper, & onion.$28.0016" The Meat Head
Pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, bacon,$31.0016" Chicken Bacon Ranch
Grilled chicken,bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese$26.0016" Angry Bird
Buffalo Chicen, red onion, blue chees crumble, & ranch dressing drizzle.$27.0016" Rancher
Ranch base, mozzarella cheese, red onion & tomato.$24.0016" the Popeye
Garlic olive oil base, melted mozzarella cheese, red onion, spinach, tomato, and feta.$26.0016" The MARGO-rita
Red sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sprinkled with parmesan & finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle.OUT OF STOCK$25.0016" Thai Chicken
Grilled Chicken, thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheese, red onion, zucchini, & topped with peanuts and toasted sesame seeds..$27.0016" Donnie Meatball Pizza
Sliced house made meatballs, herb infused ricotta, red onion, green pepper, red sauce, & mozzarella$30.0016" Tuscan
$27.0016" Flame Thrower
$28.0016" Stromboli Pizza
$27.0016" Dugout Double Play
Double pepperoni and extra cheese$26.0016" Hot Pig
$25.0016" Jamaican Jerk
$29.0016" Chicken Fajita
OUT OF STOCK$27.0016" Big Mac-K
OUT OF STOCK$23.0016" Chicken Caeser Pizza
OUT OF STOCK$24.0016" Birria
$30.0016" Garlic Breath
OUT OF STOCK$28.0016" The Green Standard
OUT OF STOCK$30.0016 The Niner
Sausage, Grippo crumbles, & hot honey drizzle.$26.0016" Chicken Broccoli Cheese
Chicken, broccoli, bacon, sauted onions, cheese sauce base, cheddar cheese, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.$27.00
Salads/Sandwiches
Salads
Sandwiches
1/2 Hot Ham
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$9.35Hot Ham and Cheese
Local shaved ham, green peppers, onions & mozzarella$14.501/2 Strom
$9.35Stromboli
Stromboli meat, pepperoni, diced onion, green peppers, red sauce, mozzarella cheese$14.501/2 Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$9.50Evansville BBQ Strom
Cumbled stromboli sausage, bbq sauce, onion, cheese, with a BBQ Grippos Dusting.$14.751/2 CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$9.35CBR
Chicken. Bacon. Ranch.$14.501/2 Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$8.50Veggie Strom
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, marinara, and mozzarella cheese$13.001/2 BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$8.50BBQ Veggie Strom
Mushroom, green pepper, onion, black olive, banana peppers, mozzarella, bbq sauce, & topped with Grippo dust.$13.001/2 Parthenon
$11.50whole Parthenon
$16.001/2 caprese
$9.00Caprese
Our stromboli bread toasted and topped with fresh mozzarella slices, tomato, fresh basil & a balsamic glaze drizzle.$14.00BBQ Chicken
$14.751/2 BBQ Chicken
$9.50
Tuesday Special
$2 off Large PIZZA
16" The Hitman (Copy)
Sausage, mushroom, and extra cheese... just how Donnie Baseball likes it!$21.0016" The "Graham" Slam (Copy)
Loaded! Sausage, pepperoni, beef, ham,bacon, onion, green pepper, black olives, mushroom, and pepperoncinis$29.0016" Harper's Hot Honey Hawaiian (Copy)
Ham, pineapple, brown sugar, red sauce, and a drizzle of hot honey!$26.0016" Mary's Little Lamb (Copy)
Gyro meat, feta, mozzarella, red onion, tomato, with a side of tzatziki sauce$26.0016" BBQ Chicken (Copy)
BBQ Chicken, green pepper, & onion.$26.0016" The Tater (Copy)
Potato, bacon, red onion, garlic butter sauce, cheddar cheese, and a side sour cream or tzatziki.$25.0016" Field of Greens (Copy)
All the veggies. Green peppers, red onion, mushroom, black olives, & banana peppers.$22.0016" The Meat Head (Copy)
Pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, bacon,$29.0016" Chicken Bacon Ranch (Copy)
Grilled chicken,bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese$24.0016" The Herbavor (Copy)
Green peppers, onion, tomato, black olive, mushroom$21.0016" Cheese (Copy)
Order it as is or add toppings to build your own pie!$16.0016" Utopian (Copy)
Chicken, fresh sliced mushroom, truffle and mushroom base, bacon, and mozzarella cheese.$26.0016" Angry Bird (Copy)
Buffalo Chicen, red onion, blue chees crumble, & ranch dressing drizzle.$26.0016" Rancher (Copy)
Ranch base, mozzarella cheese, red onion & tomato.$22.0016" the Popeye (Copy)
Garlic olive oil base, melted mozzarella cheese, red onion, spinach, tomato, and feta.$23.0016" Margherita (Copy)
Red sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sprinkled with parmesan & finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle.$23.0016" Thai Chicken (Copy)
Grilled Chicken, thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheese, red onion, zucchini, & topped with peanuts and toasted sesame seeds..$26.0016" Donnie Meatball Pizza (Copy)
Sliced house made meatballs, herb infused ricotta, red onion, green pepper, red sauce, & mozzarella$28.0016" Flame Thrower
$26.0016" Chicken Fajita
OUT OF STOCK$25.0016" Stromboli Pie
$25.0016" Hot Pig
$23.0016" Tuscan
$25.00Baked Ziti
$12.0016 double play
$24.0016 NINER
$24.0016 jerk pizza
$27.00
$6 Buckets
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.
Fireballs
$9.50
Baked doughballs topped with Mike's Hot Honey & Bacon. Add jalapenos to kick up the heat!
Customize your item
10" Toppings
Optional
Extra Dipping Sauces
Optional
10" NO Toppings
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1