Welcome to our new online ordering page!

Chicago Style Pizza Shack 534 Upper Sherman Ave
534 Upper Sherman Ave, Hamilton, ON
Tuesday Menu
Appetizers

Small Garden Salad
Simple and refreshing--fresh iceberg lettuce and tomatoes with your choice of our homemade italian or french dressing.$6.75Large Garden Salad
$9.50
Small Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, croutons, Romano, and bacon with creamy caesar dressing.$10.00
Large Caesar Salad
$14.75
Mediterranean Salad
Iceberg + romaine lettuce, tomato, green pepper, onion, black olives, red cabbage, croutons and feta cheese with our homemade italian dressing.$17.50
Antipasto Salad
Iceberg lettuce with salami, capicollo, mozzarella, pepperoncini, croutons, onions, tomatoes, red cabbage and black olives. Served with our homemade italian dressing.$17.50
Chicken Caesar
Large portion of caesar salad, topped with our signature breaded chicken breast.$24.75
Straciatella Soup
Italy's famous chicken egg drop soup enhanced with endive, pastina and Romano cheese.$6.75
Fried Ravioli
Breaded cheese ravioli, served with your choice of tomato or piccante sauce for dipping.$7.75
Battered Mushrooms
Juicy battered mushrooms, deep fried until golden brown and served with a delightful dip.$11.50
Appy Platter
Fried ravioli and battered mushrooms, served with dip. Great starter to share!$19.25
Bruschetta
Blend of diced tomatoes, garlic, herbs and spices, baked on our famous garlic bread.$11.25
Garlic Bread
$6.25
Garlic Bread with Cheese
$12.00
Combo Bread
For those who can't decide: Half bruschetta, half garlic cheese bread.$12.00
Goat Cheese Bruschetta
$18.75
Feta Bruschetta
With black olives.$17.25
Goat Combo
Half goat cheese bruschetta, half garlic cheese bread.$18.75Feta Combo
Half feta bruschetta, half garlic cheese bread.$17.25
Dinners

Small Lasagna
Relentless sheets of pasta, mozzarella, and a rich meat sauce.$17.75Large Lasagna
Relentless sheets of pasta, mozzarella, and a rich meat sauce.$29.00
Small Cannelloni
Seasoned ground beef and pork inside a large pasta tube, smothered in meat sauce and baked mozzarella.$13.75Large Cannelloni
Seasoned ground beef and pork inside a large pasta tube, smothered in meat sauce and baked mozzarella.$21.25
Small Baked Rigatoni
Rigatoni pasta in an enticing mushroom meat sauce, paired with a meatball and baked under a blanket of mozzarella.$16.50Large Baked Rigatoni
Rigatoni pasta in an enticing mushroom meat sauce, paired with 2 meatballs and baked under a blanket of mozzarella.$22.50
Small Veal Parmigiana
Breaded veal cutlet and spaghetti with mushroom + green pepper meat sauce, all under melted mozzarella.$29.95Large Veal Parmigiana
2 breaded veal cutlets and spaghetti with mushroom + green pepper meat sauce, all under melted mozzarella.$38.25
Veal Piccante
Breaded veal cutlet and linguine in a spicy green + hot pepper tomato sauce.$28.00
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded slices of eggplant with rigatoni in your choice of tomato, meat, or piccante sauce and baked with mozzarella cheese.$24.25
Match Made in Heaven
One meat-filled cannelloni, snuggled beside one cheesey spinach manicotti, baked with mozzarella and your choice of tomato, meat, or piccante sauce.$32.00
Chicken Al Diavolo
Breaded chicken breast and spaghetti with spicy green + hot pepper tomato sauce.$28.00
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded chicken breast and rigatoni under meat sauce and melted mozzarella.$29.95
Chicken Red & White
Breaded chicken breast under tomato sauce next to penne alfredo, all baked under mozzarella.$29.95
Chicken Alfredo
Breaded chicken breast and fettuccine under our famous alfredo sauce.$29.95
Small Baked Penne
Penne pasta with your choice of our homemade tomato or spicy piccante sauce, baked with mozzarella on top.$16.00
Large Baked Penne
Penne pasta with your choice of our homemade tomato or spicy piccante sauce, baked with mozzarella on top.$21.50
Pasta Pleasures

Small Spaghetti
$12.50Large Spaghetti
$16.00Small Rigatoni
$12.50Large Rigatoni
$16.00
Small Gnocchi
Traditional Italian potato and flour dumplings.$17.00Large Gnocchi
Traditional Italian potato and flour dumplings.$21.50Small Tortellini
$17.00Large Tortellini
$21.50Small Meat Ravioli
Filled with seasoned beef$17.00Large Meat Ravioli
Filled with seasoned beef$21.50
Small Cheese Ravioli
Filled with ricotta$17.00Large Cheese Ravioli
Filled with ricotta$21.50
Small Mixed Ravioli
Can't decide between cheese or meat? why not both?$17.00Large Mixed Ravioli
Can't decide between cheese or meat? why not both?$21.50
Small Linguine
$12.50Large Linguine
$16.00
Small Fettuccine
$12.50Large Fettuccine
$16.00
Small Penne
$12.50Large Penne
$16.00
Small Fettuccine Alfredo
$18.25Large Fettucine Alfredo
$23.75
Small Tortellini Alfredo
Filled with seasoned beef$18.25Large Tortellini Alfredo
Filled with seasoned beef$23.75
Small Linguine with Red Clam Sauce
Linguine pasta with baby clams simmered in tomato sauce.$19.25Large Linguine with Red Clam Sauce
Linguine pasta with baby clams simmered in tomato sauce.$24.75
Small Spinach Manicotti
Seasoned ricotta cheese and spinach in a large pasta tube.$16.50Large Spinach Manicotti
Seasoned ricotta cheese and spinach in a large pasta tube.$25.25
Pizza

Medium Regular Crust Pizza
A classic. Not too thick, not too thin. topped generously with pizza sauce, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings, cooked until golden and crisp. (8 slices, serves 2-3)$23.75
Large Regular Crust Pizza (Tues Special)
$32.00
Medium Thick Crust Pizza
This crust is thick all the way through the entire base of the pizza, not just the edge. It's like fresh-baked bread under delicious pizza sauce and mozzarella. (8 slices, serves 3-4)$26.00Large Thick Crust Pizza
This crust is thick all the way through the entire base of the pizza, not just the edge. It's like fresh-baked bread under delicious pizza sauce and mozzarella. (12 slices, serves 4-5)$32.75
Personal Stuffed Pizza
6" stuffed pizza with your choice of 3 toppings (excludes roast beef--It'sa no fit).$19.00
Small Stuffed Pizza
The one we're famous for. This decadent pie is loaded with sauce, toppings, and a boat-load of our signature cheese blend. Sealed with a thin layer of dough and sauce on top. Please be patient, this master pizza takes 30 minutes to cook! (6 slices, serves 2-3 [trust us!])$31.50Large Stuffed Pizza
The one we're famous for. This decadent pie is loaded with sauce, toppings, and a boat-load of our signature cheese blend. Sealed with a thin layer of dough and sauce on top. Please be patient, this master pizza takes 30 minutes to cook! (10 slices, serves 4-5 [trust us!])$47.00
Medium Thin Crust Pizza
Like the classic, only thinner. This pizza is best with light toppings. (8 slices, serves 2-3)$21.50Large Thin Crust Pizza
Like the classic, only thinner. This pizza is best with light toppings. (12 slices, serves 3-4)$28.75Large Regular Crust Pizza
A classic. Not too thick, not too thin. topped generously with pizza sauce, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings, cooked until golden and crisp. (12 slices, serves 3-4)$28.75
Subs

Pizza Sub
Our own invention, brought to you from Chicago. An open-faced submarine dressed with garlic butter, topped with our housemade pizza sauce, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings.$13.50
Meatball Sub
With our sensational homemade meatballs and meat sauce.$15.50
Sausage Sub
Two links of our authentic Italian sausage, topped with meat sauce.$15.50Veal Sub
$15.50
Chicken Sub
$15.50
Dessert

Cheesecake
Made in house!$7.50
Chocolate Marble Cheesecake
Made in house!$7.50
Cherry Cheesecake
Homemade cheesecake topped with cherries$7.50
Black Forest Cheesecake
Homemade chocolate marble cheesecake topped with cherries$7.50
Tiramisu
An Italian classic, with a twist. Layers of delicate mascarpone custard and lady fingers soaked in espresso and rum on a chocolate cookie crumb base.$8.50
Lemon Tiramisu
$9.25
Side Orders

Side Order Meatball
$3.50
Side Order Sausage
$4.75
Side Order Chicken
$10.00Side Order Veal Cutlet
$10.00Side Order Eggplant w/ Mozzarella
$9.50
Side Order Chicken w/ Mozzarella
$13.50Side Order Veal w/ Mozzarella
$13.5012oz Tomato Sauce
$5.002oz Tomato Sauce
$1.0012oz Piccante Sauce
$6.502oz Piccante Sauce
$1.0012oz Meat Sauce
$5.0012oz Alfredo Sauce
$7.502oz Romano Cheese
$2.002oz Pizza Sauce
$1.002oz Magic Sauce
$1.0012oz Italian Dressing
$4.502oz Italian Dressing
$0.752oz French Dressing
$0.752oz Caesar Dressing
$1.502oz Mushroom Dip
$1.002oz Crushed Red Pepper Flakes
$1.00Extra Roll
$0.60
Drink Menu
Drinks
Beer & Wine - Online
Coors Light - Bottle
$7.25Miller Genuine Draft - Bottle
$7.25Peroni Azzuro - Bottle
$8.50Steam Whistle Pilsner - Bottle
$7.25Stella Artois - Bottle
$8.50Rickard's Red - Can (473ml)
$9.50Peroni Azzuro 0.0 (Non-alc) - Can
$5.25Bottle Adesso Merlot
$29.00Bottle Luccarelli Primitivo
$42.00Bottle Ruffino Chianti
$48.00Bottle Tommasi Ripasso Valpolicella
$69.00Bottle Masi Campofiorin Rosso
$65.00Bottle Jacob's Creek Moscato Rose
$42.00Bottle Collavini Pinot Grigio
$42.00Bottle Santa Carolina Sauvignon Blanc
$37.00
Catering
Full Tray Baked Rigatoni
$150.00Full Tray Rigatoni Meat Sauce
$95.00Full Tray Rigatoni Tomato Sauce
$95.001/2 Tray Rigatoni Meat Sauce
$50.001/2 Tray Rigatoni Tomato Sauce
$50.00Full Tray Penne Meat Sauce
$95.00Full Tray Penne Tomato Sauce
$95.001/2 Tray Penne Meat Sauce
$50.001/2 Tray Penne Tomato Sauce
$50.00Full Tray Penne Piccante Sauce
$95.001/2 Tray Penne Piccante Sauce
$50.00Full Tray Penne Alfredo
$140.001/2 Tray Penne Alfredo
$70.00Full Tray Tortellini Alfredo
$160.001/2 Tray Tortellini Alfredo
$80.00Full Tray Tortellini Meat Sauce
$140.001/2 Tray Tortellini Meat Sauce
$70.00Full Tray Tortellini Tomato Sauce
$140.001/2 Tray Tortellini Tomato Sauce
$70.00Full Tray Lasagna
$180.001/2 Tray Lasagna
$90.008pc Cannelloni
$70.0020pc Cannelloni
$175.008pc Manicotti
$80.0020pc Manicotti
$200.0020pc Chicken Parm
$220.0020pc Veal Parm
$220.0040pc Eggplant Parm
$120.0038pc Meatballs
$120.00Full Tray Garden Salad
$60.001/2 Tray Garden Salad
$30.00Full Tray Caesar Salad
$90.001/2 Tray Caesar Salad
$45.00Full Tray Antipasto Salad
$110.00

Battered Mushrooms
$11.50
Juicy battered mushrooms, deep fried until golden brown and served with a delightful dip.
Customize your item
Battered Mushroom
Select up to 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1