Cibik's Dairy Island Bainbridge/Chagrin Falls Ohio
Homemade Ice Creams
Cibik’s Craft Ice Creams
- Single Scoop
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors.
$5.50 - Double Scoop
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors.
$7.50 - KId's Scoop
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors.
$4.50 - Pint
Homemade, Small Batch, Hand Crafted, Weekly Flavors
$9.00 - Quart
Take home a quart of butter pecan tonight for a midnight snack.
$15.00
CREATE your own ICE CREAM - It's A Contest!
- CREATE your own Ice Cream
Win FREE Ice Cream for a Season. Don't Forget to Register your Flavor at www.dairyisland.com
$7.50 - Ambrosia by Taylor Baryak, 2023
2023 Flavor of the Year created by Taylor Baryak. Coconut and Pineapple with Mini Marshmallows whipped into Vanilla Frozen Custard. Any requests?
$7.50 - The Ultimate Banana Bread by Veronica Corsillo, 2022
2022 Flavor of the Year, curated by Veronica Corsillo. Graham crackers, honey, walnuts and banana whipped into vanilla frozen custard. An absolute ice cream masterpiece!
$7.50 - Queen Bee by Sarah Freeman, 2021
2021 Flavor of the Year created by Sarah Freeman. Vanilla Custard with Hungry Bee Honey and Lotus Biscoff Cookies
$7.50 - Peanut Butter Blast by Christine Sutter, 2020
2020 Flavor of the Year created by Christine Sutter. Enjoy her peanut butter frozen custard loaded with Nutter Butter cookies.
$7.50 - Chocolate Rice Krispy Treat by Sydney Corcoran, 2019
Rice Krispies, chocolate chips and marshmallow sauce whipped into vanilla frozen custard.
$7.50 - Chagrin S'Mores by Ella Laneve, 2018
2018 Best Flavor of the Year. Marshmallows, Graham Crackers, Hot Fudge & Caramel
$7.50 - Take Me Out To The Ballgame by Mia Conti, 2017
Mia Conti's Grand Slam winner. Cracker Jaxs, peanuts and fudge whipped into vanilla frozen custard. The 2017 contest winner.
$7.50 - Shock The Monkey
Peanut butter and bananas whipped into vanilla frozen custard.
$7.50 - Lemon
Simple and delicious. Fresh squeezed lemon whipped into vanilla frozen custard.
$7.50 - Cherry Pie
Our tribute to Sade Adu. Cherries and graham crackers mixed into vanilla frozen custard.
$7.50 - Cereal Killer
Maggie Cibik's best seller! Cpt. Crunch, Fruit Loops, Lucky Charms, and Cookie Dough carefully mixed into vanilla frozen custard.
$7.50 - Franks & Beans
Friday Night Franks!
$7.50
Frozen Custard
- Kids Vanilla
Don't forget your eyes.
$3.00 - Kids Chocolate
Rich & Creamy.
$3.00 - Kids Twist
Always Delicious.
$3.00 - Small Vanilla
Our signature product: 10% butterfat milk and cream with egg yolks added to create a smooth and creamy frozen custard experience.
$4.00 - Small Chocolate
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious.
$4.00 - Small Twist
Yum!
$4.00 - Medium Vanilla
Our signature product: 10% butterfat milk and cream with egg yolks added to create a smooth and creamy frozen custard experience.
$5.50 - Medium Chocolate
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious.
$5.50 - Medium Twist
Half & Half.
$5.50 - Large Vanilla
Our signature product: 10% butterfat milk and cream with egg yolks added to create a smooth and creamy frozen custard experience.
$6.50 - Large Chocolate
Go for it!
$6.50 - Large Twist
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious.
$6.50 - Custard Pint
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious
$8.00 - Custard Quart
Rich & Creamy, Always Delicious
$13.00 - Pup Cup
Treat your best friend tonight.
$2.00
Kids Vanilla
Don't forget your eyes.
Pineapple Dole Whip
Hurricanes
Classic Sundaes
- Turtle
Caramel, Hot Fudge & Pecans
$7.50 - E.T.
Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge & Reese's Pieces
$7.50 - Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Vanilla Custard topped with Strawberries covered in Chocolate Dip Top
$7.50 - I Love My Brownies!
Fudge Brownie with Cibik's Craft I Love Lucy Ice Cream topped with Red Raspberry topping and Hot Fudge
$7.50 - Mississippi Mud Pie
Vanilla Frozen with Crushed OREOs and Topped with Hot Fudge
$7.50 - Pina Colada
Pineapple Dole Whip topped with Shredded Coconut and Honey
$7.50 - Peanut Butter Cup
Peanut Butter, Chocolate Dip Top & Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
$7.50 - Strawberry Shortcake
Shortcake Topped with Vanilla Frozen Custard & Strawberries
$7.50 - Bainbridge Brownie
Fudge Brownie Topped with Vanilla Frozen Custard & Hot Fudge
$7.50 - Superman vs. Spiderman
Cibik's Craft Superman Ice Cream topped with Blue Raspberry and Cherry Dip Tops
$7.50 - Hero Sundae
Strawberry & Blueberry. Cibik's Donate $1 to Local First Responders
$7.50 - S’more
Hot Fudge, Marshmallow & Graham Crackers
$7.50 - Tin Roof
Chocolate Sauce & Spanish Peanuts
$7.50 - Pirate's Booty
In Honor of the Dairy Island Pirate's Baseball Team: Black & Red Raspberry, M&Ms, Capt. Crunch & Gummy Sharks
$7.50 - Sweet Corn & Cream
Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with Corn Flakes & Honey
$7.50
Parfaits
- Heathaze Parfait
Our Genesis Tribute. Caramel & Heath Bar Layered in a Parfait Glass
$8.00 - Pretzel Logic Parfait
Great album, great song, great parfait. Layers of Caramel, Hot Fudge, and Salty Pretzels.
$8.00 - Purple Haze Parfait
Vanilla and Chocolate Custard with layers of Black Raspberry and Dark Chocolate Chunks
$8.00 - Hot Fudge Peanut Parfait
Hot Fudge & Spanish Peanuts Layered in a Parfait Glass
$8.00 - Breakfast in America Parfait
Enjoy breakfast all day with frozen custard, Cocoa Puffs, Cpt. Crunch and Fruity Pebbles
$8.00 - Honolulu Luau Parfait
Let's take a vacation with frozen custard shredded coconut, pineapple and dark chocolate bits.
$8.00
Splits
- Banana Split
Chocolate & Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with Chocolate, Pineapple and Strawberry, Whipped Cream & Nuts: All in a Banana Boat
$8.50 - Hot Fudge Fantasy
The Ultimate Banana Split: Chocolate and Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with lots of Hot Fudge, Buttered Pecans and Whipped Cream in a Banana Boat
$9.50
Old Fashioned Sundaes
Slush & Brain Freezes
Shakes
Specialty Shakes
- Bamm Bamm Specialty Shake
Our creamy and delicious vanilla shake mixed with Fruity Pebbles. Yabba Dabba Doo!
$8.50 - Hawaiian Noises Specialty Shake
You've had the ice cream, now try it as a shake! Dark chocolate bits, pineapple and shredded coconut whipped into our vanilla frozen custard.
$8.50 - Salty Caramel Pretzel Specialty Shake
Salty Pretzels & Caramel with Vanilla Frozen Custard
$8.50 - Chocolate Covered Cherry
Chocolate Frozen Custard with Maraschino Cherries and Chocolate Dip Top
$8.50 - Cookie Dough Specialty Shake
Cookie Dough and Vanilla Frozen Custard
$8.50 - Mint Chocolate Chip Specialty Shake
Mint Flavored Frozen Custard with Mini Chocolate Chips & Andes Mints
$8.50 - Banana Specialty Shake
Fresh Bananas and Vanilla Frozen Custard
$8.50 - Cookies & Cream Specialty Shake
OREO Cookies and Vanilla Frozen Custard
$8.50 - Peanut Butter Banana Specialty Shake
Peanut Butter Sauce and Bananas with Vanilla Frozen Custard
$8.50 - S'Mores Specialty Shake
Chocolate Custard with Marshmallow Sauce and Graham Crackers
$8.50