Extraordinary Cupcakes 435 W. Duke of Gloucester
Featured Items
- Marvelous Madagascar - Requires additional Prep Time$4.45+
Baking begins in a cold oven so this creation takes a little more time but it is our most popular cupcake. Not your grocery store vanilla cupcake. This is a dense, traditional pound cake that my mom used to make, We added some Madagascar vanilla bean to it and topped it with our Madagascar buttercream icing.
- Phenonmenal Peanut Butter$4.45+
Moist chocolate cake, filled with creamy peanut butter, and topped with peanut butter buttercream icing. Feel the stress melt away.
- Remarkable Red Velvet$3.95+
Classic red velvet cake with a remarkable cream cheese icing make this cupcake a fan favorite.
4 inch special occasion cakes - 48 hour advance notice required
- 4 inch special occasion cake - Chocolate Flip - 48 hour notice required$19.95
Wicked Chocolate cake with our Marvelous Madagascar icing. We do have these in Illy Caffe daily on a first-come, first-served basis but if you want to make sure you get what you want, please order ahead.
- 4 inch special occasion cake - Wicked Chocolate$19.95
Wicked Chocolate Cake with Wicked Chocolate Icing. 48 hour advance notice required.
- 4 inch special occasion cake - Marvelous Maddie$19.95
A light vanilla cake with our Marvelous Madagascar Icing. 48 hour advance notice required. Please note - this is not the Madagascar Pound Cake.
- 4 inch special occasion cake - Luscious Lemon Raspberry cake$19.95
Light lemon cake with our Ravishing Raspberry Filling and Raspberry Icing. 48 advance notice required please
- 4 inch special occasion Uncommon Carrot Cake$19.95
Our Uncommon Carrot Cake made with fresh grated carrots, pecans, and pineapple, topped with our Uncommon Cream Cheese Icing. 48 hour advance ordering required please. Allergy Alert - This product contains pecans
- 4 inch special occasion Remarkable Red Velvet Cake$19.95
Our Remarkable Red Velvet Cake with our Uncommon Cream Cheese Icing Allergy Alert - This item contains red food coloring 48 hour Advance Ordering Time Required
Unfilled Cupcakes
- Fantastic Chocolate Flip$3.95+
Wicked chocolate cake, topped with our famous Madagascar Vanilla buttercream icing.
- Fantastic Vanilla Flip$3.95+
Moist vanilla cake, topped off with rich wicked chocolate buttercream icing.
- Marvelous Madagascar - Requires additional Prep Time$4.45+
Baking begins in a cold oven so this creation takes a little more time but it is our most popular cupcake. Not your grocery store vanilla cupcake. This is a dense, traditional pound cake that my mom used to make, We added some Madagascar vanilla bean to it and topped it with our Madagascar buttercream icing.
- Wicked Chocolate$3.95+
The only good bomb is a chocolate one and this is it. Wicked chocolate cake and a rich Wicked chocolate buttercream icing. Mic drop here.
- Uncommon Carrot$3.95+
Fresh grated carrot, crushed pineapple, walnuts, and Vietnamese Cinnamon make this cake uncommon and moist. Combine that with our amazing cream cheese icing and you are sure to be hooked.
- Remarkable Red Velvet$3.95+
Classic red velvet cake with a remarkable cream cheese icing make this cupcake a fan favorite.
- Monumental Marble$3.95+
Chocolate and vanilla marble cake with Wicked Chocolate icing.
- Wondrous Gingerbread$3.95+Out of stock
Available in December only - Gingerbread cake topped with sweet cinnamon buttercream icing.
Filled Cupcakes
- Brilliant Bananas Foster$4.95+
My Aunt Katherine's banana cake filled with our Sinfully Salted Caramel sauce and fresh banana bits, topped with our Sinfully Salted Caramel icing. Allergy alert: This product contains walnuts
- Gregarious German Chocolate$4.45+Out of stock
Available December 21 - March 19 Super-light chocolate cake with a pecan & coconut caramel frosting and a rich coconut & pecan filling.
- Luscious Lemon Raspberry$4.45+
Moist vanilla cake, filled with a rich raspberry compound, topped with raspberry buttercream icing.
- Miraculous Mint Cocoa$4.45+Out of stock
Available in January - Our Wicked Chocolate cake, filled with a fluffy mint cream and topped with a Vanilla/Mint Buttercream icing.
- Phenonmenal Peanut Butter$4.45+
Moist chocolate cake, filled with creamy peanut butter, and topped with peanut butter buttercream icing. Feel the stress melt away.
- Ravishing Raspberry Chocolate$4.45+Out of stock
- Sensational S'mores$4.45+Out of stock
Available September 21 - December 21 Vanilla cake with a dash of Vietnamese Cinnamon, filled with graham cracker, marshmallow, and chocolate then covered in melted chocolate and topped with a extraordinarily large toasted marshmallow. Best eaten warm. Put in microwave for 10 seconds on low or in the oven on 350 for 6 minutes.
- The Great Pumpkin$4.45+Out of stock
Available in November - Vanilla cake filled with pumpkin pie filling and a cinnamon cream cheese icing. Hello Thanksgiving!
- Tremendous Tree Leches$4.45+
Light vanilla cake soaked (not filled) with a traditional 3 milk mixture and iced with a fluffy 7 minute icing.
Mini Cupcakes Dozen
Special Occasion Cakes - Minimum 3 Day Advance Order Required
- 6" Cake 3- Day minimum advance order required.$45.00
3- Day minimum advance order required.
- 8" Cake 3- Day minimum advance order required.$55.00
- 10" Cake 3- Day minimum advance order required.$65.00
- 12" Cake 3- Day minimum advance order required.$85.00
- 1/2 sheet cake 3- Day minimum advance order required.$90.00
- Full Sheet Cake 3- Day minimum advance order required.$180.00
- Gluten Free Cake 3- Day minimum advance order required.$55.00+
Other Extraordinary Items
- Mom's Breathtaking Banana Pudding - requires 3 day advance ordering$6.95
My mom's recipe. Nothing fancy, just Mmm Mmm good.
- OMG NY Cheesecake$6.95Out of stock
Made from the famous recipe from Carnegie Deli in NY.
- Walnut Mousse Bar$6.95Out of stock
- Makin' Whoopie Pie - requires 2 day advance ordering$6.95
Our moist red velvet cake filled with our simply amazing cream cheese icing.
- Cake Push-Up Pops - Quantity 10 - Minimum 3 day advance ordering required$49.50
Our classic flavors presented in fun push-up pop containers. Give your events a dash of nostalgia and fun. ***Stand in picture is not included.
- Run Run As Fast As You Can Gingerbread$5.50+Out of stock
An Extraordinary customer favorite - fresh made gingerbread cookies decorated to make you smile.