Enter via our back door and find your online order on our big green table. Just grab & go!

Firefly Coffeehouse
DRINKS
Seasonal Specials
Be My Valentine Raspberry Mocha
with Ghiradelli Dark Chocolate & Raspberry Flavor, topped with Whipped Cream and Valentine Candy Conversation Hearts
$5.60Vanilla Cupcake Latte
with Monin Cupcake Flavor
$5.30Sticky Bun Latte
with Organic Raw Honey, Cinnamon & Monin Salted Caramel Flavor
$5.30Shortbread Cookie Latte
with Monin Cookie Butter syrup
$5.30Cloud City Cold Brew
House-made Cold Brew with Cold Foam Topping
$3.50Peppermint Bark Mocha
Ghiradelli White Chocolate & Peppermint Flavor with choice of Milk
$5.60Horchata
A creamy Mexican drink made with rice, milk, and cinnamon. Contains dairy.
$4.25
Espresso
Mocha Latte
Ghirardelli Chocolate with choice of Milk
$5.60White Mocha Latte
Ghirardelli White Chocolate with choice of Milk
$5.60Caramella Latte
Ghirardelli Caramel & Vanilla with choice of Milk
$5.60Flavored Latte
Your Syrup Choice, Hot or Iced, with choice of Milk
$5.30Latte
Hot or Iced with choice of Milk
$4.90Cappuccino
Espresso with choice of Foamed Milk
$4.90Miel
Honey & Cinnamon Latte with choice of Milk
$5.50Americano
Espresso with Hot or Iced Water
$3.50White Zombie
Lightly-roasted Espresso Beans with White Chocolate with choice of Milk
$5.50Espresso
Anodyne's Dark Roast Sumatra
$2.75Flat White
8 oz, Two Shots Espresso with Choice of Milk
$4.50Cortado
4.5 oz, Two Shots of Espresso with 2 oz Steamed Whole Milk
$3.50
Coffee
Firefly Blend
Medium Roast from Wonder State
$2.75Oregon's Living Room
Medium Roast from Anodyne
$2.75Today's Dark Roast
Varies Daily
$2.75Today's Single Origin Medium Roast
Varies Daily
$2.75Today's Decaffeinated
Varies Daily
$2.75Red Eye
Firefly Blend with Espresso
$3.50Au Lait
Firefly Blend with choice of Milk
$3.25Iced Coffee
$2.75Cold Brew Coffee
Smoother & less acidic than regular iced coffee, made in house
$3.00Cloud City Cold Brew
House-made Cold Brew with Cold Foam Topping
$3.50Coffee To Go for 8 People
Cardboard Carafe with No-Spill Plastic Pour, 90 oz of Firefly Blend coffee with eight, 12-oz compostable to go cups and lids. Cream & Sugar not included - you provide your own.
$25.00
Tea & Lemonade
Iced Tea
Choose from Black, Mango Green or Elderberry Hibiscus
$2.50Hot Tea
Choice of our Rishi Organic teas
$3.50London Fog
Rishi Organic Earl Grey tea, Vanilla and choice of Milk
$3.95Honey Matcha Tea Latte
Unsweetened Matcha Tea with Raw Honey & choice of Milk
$5.30Raspberry Lemonade, 16 oz
Lemonade with Raspberry Flavor, 16 oz
$3.00Lavender Lemonade, 16 oz
Lemonade with Lavender Flavor, 16 oz
$3.00All Natural Lemonade, 16 oz
16 oz
$3.00Arnold Palmer, 16 oz
Black Ice Tea & Premium Lemonade, 16 oz
$3.00Pineberry Lemonade Refresher, 16 oz
Lemonade, Pineberry Syrup (strawberry + pineapple) & Ice, Blended to make a refreshing slushy drink
$4.00The Pink Flamingo, 16 oz
New! All Natural Lemonade, Frozen Strawberries, Frozen Bananas & Pineberry (Pineapple+Strawberry) flavor, blended in a smoothie
$5.50
Chai
Chai Tea Latte
Chai Tea, Hot or Iced, with choice of Milk
$5.25Dirty Chai Tea Latte
Espresso, Chai Tea, Hot or Iced, with choice of Milk
$6.00Pumpkin Chai
Pumpkin Spice Flavoring, Chai Tea, Hot or Iced, with choice of Milk
$5.50Flavored Chai Tea Latte
Chai Tea, Hot or Iced, with choice of Milk & Flavor
$5.50
Blended
Coffee Frappe
Coffee, Ice & choice of Flavor. 16 oz.
$5.00Milk Frappe
Skim Milk, Ice & choice of Flavor. 16 oz
$5.00The Pink Flamingo, 16 oz
New! All Natural Lemonade, Frozen Strawberries, Frozen Bananas & Pineberry (Pineapple+Strawberry) flavor, blended in a smoothie
$5.50Chai Spice Smoothie
We used to call this the Power Smoothie. Bananas, Honey, Spiced Chai, Skim Milk. 16 oz.
$6.25Pineberry Lemonade Refresher, 16 oz
Lemonade, Pineberry Syrup (strawberry + pineapple) & Ice, Blended to make a refreshing slushy drink
$4.00Tropical Dream Smoothie
Pineapple, Mango, Orange Juice. 16 oz.
$6.25Berry Banana Smoothie
Strawberries & Bananas, Orange Juice. 16 oz.
$6.25Blended Elvis Smoothie
Peanut Butter & Cocoa Powders, Bananas & Honey w/Skim Milk. 16 oz
$6.25Green Machine Smoothie
Bananas, Pineapple, Mango, Spinach & Spirulina, Orange Juice. 16 oz
$6.25Maple Monkey Smoothie
Bananas, Maple Syrup, Cinnamon, Coconut Milk, 16 oz.
$6.25
More
Hot Chocolate
Ghirardelli Chocolate with choice of Steamed Hot Milk
$3.50Chocolate Milk
Ghirardelli Chocolate with choice of Milk
$2.25Milk
Choice of Milk including Whole, 2% and Skim from Sassy Cow Creamery
$1.25Mexican Spiced Hot Chocolate
Azteca D'oro 1519 Mexican Spiced Ground Chocolate, with choice of Milk
$3.65Mayan Mocha
2 Shots Espresso & Mexican Spiced Cocoa, with choice of Milk
$5.50Horchata
A creamy Mexican drink made with rice, milk, and cinnamon. Contains dairy.
$4.25Steamer
Hot Milk with Choice of Syrup Flavor
$3.50Italian Soda
Sanpellegrino Sparking Water with choice of Syrup Flavor
$3.50
Cooler
Gift Cards for Pick-Up
$5 Gift Card
A Firefly gift card makes a great thank you gift! We'll even mail it for you - enter the recipient address in Special Requests!!
$5.00$10 Gift Card
Did you know you can use a Firefly gift card to pay when ordering online by going to fireflycoffeehouse.com?
$10.00$25 Gift Card
Check the balance of a gift card by scanning the code on the back with your phone!
$25.00$50 Gift Card
Is it a gift? We'll mail it for you for free! Just enter the recipient address in Special Requests!
$50.00$100 Gift Card
Thank you for supporting us!
$100.00
BAKERY
From-Scratch Daily Bakery
9 AM: Cinnamon Roll 2-Pack
On sale at 9 AM sharp! Brioche Cinnamon Rolls sold in packs of 2. Also available in our lobby at any quantity.
$9.90OUT OF STOCKBear Claw
With sweet almond filling.
$4.95Boston Cream PopTart
With pastry cream filling and chocolate ganache
$2.75Almond Biscotti
Contains Almonds, Butter, Flour, Eggs & all the good stuff. Made to dip in your hot coffee or latte!
$1.95Valentine 4-Pack Cakelettes: Creative Confections by Alicia
Four Cakelettes of assorted flavors packaged in an attractive pink box with Happy Valentine's Day tag & ribbon. Hand-crafted by Creative Confections by Alicia, Brooklyn, Wis.
$16.99Coffee Cake / Raspberry
With pecans
$3.75Coffee Cake / Blueberry
With pecans
$3.75Coffee Cake / Apple Cinnamon
With pecans
$3.75Fruit Crumble / Door County Cherry
$3.75Fruit Crumble / Blueberry
$3.75Muffin / Blueberry
$3.50Muffin / Lemon Poppyseed
$3.50Muffin / Chocolate Lava Cake
$3.50Scone / Maple Bacon White Chocolate
$3.60Scone / Raspberry Lemon
$3.60Scone / Chocolate Covered Cherry
$3.60
Vegan & Gluten-Free
Firefly Granola Bars: 3 for $12
Firefly Granola Bars made daily from scratch. Vegan, Gluten-Free, 10 g Protein per bar. Oats, Almonds, Pecans, Peanut Butter, Pepitas, Sunflower Seeds, Agave, Coconut Oil, Strawberries, Cherries, Blueberries, Maple Syrup
$12.00Firefly Famous Granola Bar
Vegan, Gluten-Free, 10 g Protein per bar. Oats, Almonds, Pecans, Peanut Butter, Pepitas, Sunflower Seeds, Agave, Coconut Oil, Strawberries, Cherries, Blueberries, Maple Syrup
$4.50Avery's Vegan Banana Choc Chip Bread
With fresh, ripe bananas. Nut free.
$3.75GF, Dairy-Free Peanut Butter
$3.25Vegan, GF Choc Chip Cookie
$3.25Vegan, GF Breakfast Cookie
Bananas, Raisins, Dried Cranberries, Pumpkin Seeds, Almond Butter, Apple Butter, Maple Syrup, Oats & Cinnamon
$2.25GF Monster Cookie
$3.25Vegan, GF Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
$3.75
Firefly Homemade Cookies
Jumbo Frosted Heart Cut-Out Cookie
Our famous Valentine Heart Cookies!
$3.25NEW: Sea Salt Caramel Chocolate Chip
$2.95Ginger Molasses Cookie
$2.95M&M Cookie
$2.95PBOCC (Peanut Butter, Oatmeal & Choc Chip) Cookie
$2.95Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.95Snickerdoodle Cookie
$2.95GF Monster Cookie
$3.25GF, Dairy-Free Peanut Butter
$3.25Vegan, GF Breakfast Cookie
Bananas, Raisins, Dried Cranberries, Pumpkin Seeds, Almond Butter, Apple Butter, Maple Syrup, Oats & Cinnamon
$2.25Vegan, GF Choc Chip Cookie
$3.25Vegan, GF Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
$3.75
Breakfast & Lunch
Today's Specials
Breakfast & More
Steel Cut Oatmeal
Cooked low & slow. Made with organic steel cut oats, almond milk, vanilla, cinnamon & nutmeg. Vegan & Gluten-Free.
$5.95Cup of Fresh Fruit
$3.00Toast/Bagel
Choice of Bagel, English Muffin, Sourdough or Country Bread. Served with Butter, Cream Cheese, Peanut Butter or Jelly.
$3.50Cheddar BELT
Usinger's Bacon, Freshly Cracked, Over-Hard Cage-Free Egg, Organic Greens, Tomato & Hook's 1-Year Cheddar
$7.95Egg & Cheddar
Freshly Cracked, Over-Hard Cage-Free Egg & Hook's 1-Year Cheddar
$6.75Farmer
Usinger's Bacon, Freshly Cracked, Over-Hard Cage-Free Egg & Hook's 1-Year Cheddar
$7.75Rabbit
Cucumber, Tomato, Carrots and Philadelphia Cream Cheese
$6.50Firefly Yogurt Parfait
Greek Yogurt with Housemade Granola and Dried Cherries, Cranberries & Apricots
$4.25
Sandwiches
BLT on Toasted Ciabatta
Usinger's Bacon, Tomato, Mayo & Organic Greens on toasted Ciabatta
$9.95Firefly Signature Wrap
Warm Chicken, Avocado, Smoked Gouda & Pesto in whole grain wrap, served hot
$11.95Turkey Pesto Panini
Our Signature Sandwich! Turkey, Usinger's Bacon, Wisconsin Smoked Gouda, Tomato, Organic Greens & Pesto on Madison Sourdough
$9.95Glorious Grilled Cheese
Hook's 1-Year Cheddar, Usinger's Bacon, Tomato on Madison Sourdough
$8.95The G.O.A.T. Panini
LaClare Creamery Fresh Chevre Goat Cheese, Hook's 1-Year Cheddar, Pesto & Tomato on Madison Sourdough
$9.95
Soup & Salad
Soup
Salad
Sweet Apple Chèvre Salad
Organic Greens, LaClare Creamery Fresh Goat Cheese, Candied Pecans, Granny Smith Apple Slices, Dried Cranberries & Organic Greens with choice of dressing
$11.95Chicken Cheddar Cashew Salad
Organic Greens, Tomatoes, Carrots, Cashews, Cool Chicken Breast Strips, Shredded Hook's 1-Year Cheddar with choice of dressing
$12.95
Retail
Coffee Beans 12 oz Bags
Firefly Tumbler & 12 oz Firefly Whole Bean Coffee Gift Set
Black Klean Kanteen with Shiny Silver Firefly Logo, paired with a bag of Firefly Blend Coffee. The perfect gift!
$35.00Firefly Blend, Wonderstate, 12 oz
$14.99Oregon’s Living Room, Anodyne, 12 oz
$14.99Dark Sumatra, Anodyne, (House Espresso) 12 oz
$14.99Driftless, Medium, Wonderstate, 12 oz
$14.99Big Dipper, Dark Roast, Wonderstate, 12 oz
$14.99Decaf MWP Mexico, Anodyne, 12 oz
$14.99
Off The Shelf
Wisconsin Cheese
Carr Valley Black Sheep Truffle, 5 oz
$6.99Carr Valley Goat Cardona Cocoa, 5 oz
$6.50Carr Valley Goat Cheddar Snack Stick, 1 oz
$2.00Carr Valley Cranberry Chipotle Cheddar, 5 oz
$4.99Carr Valley 3-Year Cheddar, 8 oz
$5.79Carr Valley Garlic Cheddar Spread, 8 oz
$4.99Carr Valley Southern Pimento Spread, 8 oz
$4.99Carr Valley Spicy Beer Cheese Spread, 8 oz
$4.99Carr Valley Swiss Almond Cheese Spread, 8 oz
$4.99Carr Valley Late Harvest Wine Cheddar Spread, 8 oz
$4.99Carr Valley Smoked Gouda, 5 oz
$4.59Deer Creek Rattlesnake Cheddar, 7 oz
$5.99Deer Creek Vat 17 Aged Cheddar, 6 oz
$5.99Hoard's Dairyman Belaire, 7 oz
$6.99Hook's 1-Year Cheddar, 8 oz
$4.99Hook's 3-Year Cheddar, 8 oz
$5.99Hook's 5-Year Cheddar, 8 oz
$7.99Hook's 10-Year Cheddar, 8 oz
$15.99Hook's Colby, 8 oz
$4.99Hook's Sheep Milk Butterkase, 8 oz
$7.59Hook's Sheep Milk Gouda, 8 oz
$7.99Hook's 2-Year Swiss, 8 oz
$6.59Hook's Triple Play Extra Innings, 8 oz
$8.99Little Lucy Brie, 6 oz
Our only non-Wisconsin cheese! This farmstead beauty comes from our friends at Redhead Creamery in Brooten, MN
$7.99OUT OF STOCKMarieke Foenegreek Gouda, 5 oz
$4.99OUT OF STOCKMarieke Honey Clover Gouda, 5 oz
$4.99Marieke Truffle Gouda, 5 oz
$4.99Meister Creamery Wild Morel & Leek Jack, 6 Oz
$3.99Meister Creamery Dill Havarti, 6 oz
$3.99Nordic Creamery Grumpy Goat, 8 oz
$6.99Nordic Creamery Capriko, 8 oz
$5.99Renards Natural Cheddar with Door County Cherries, 8 oz
$4.99Velvet Bees Honey Butter, 8 oz
$7.99