Currently not accepting online orders
Goodfellas Pizza
103 Colonels Way E, Henryville, IN
Featured Items
16" Pizza
$14.5014" Pizza
$13.5010" Pizza
$9.50
FOOD
Pizza
10" Pizza
$9.5014" Pizza
$13.5016" Pizza
$14.50Friday $9.99 1 topping
$9.99
Grinders/Hoagies
Meatball
$8.50Grilled Chicken Grinder
$8.50Honey Mustard Chicken
$8.50Chicken Bacon Ranch
$8.50Stromboli
$8.50Veggie Sub
$8.50Philly Steak
$8.50Pork Tenderloin
$8.50Ham-n-Cheese
$8.50Steak Hoagie
$8.50Italian
$8.50
Sandwiches
Slider
$2.00Hamburger
$5.50Cheeseburger
$6.00Bacon Cheeseburger
$7.00BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
$7.00Mushroom Swiss Burger
$7.00Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$7.49Club Sandwich
$8.00Fish Sandwich
$10.00
Goodfellas Favorites
Baked Spaghetti
$9.50Chicken Alfredo
$9.505 Tenders & FF
$9.50
Appetizers
8 Bone In Wings
$8.0016 Bone In Wings
$16.0024 Bone In Wings
$24.00Boneless Wings 1/2 Pound
$7.00Boneless Wings Pound
$14.00Boneless Wings 2 Pound
$26.00Cheese Bread
$8.00Bread Sticks
$6.00Pretzel Sticks
$7.00Jalapeno Poppers
$5.00Onion Petals
$4.00Loaded Cheese Fries
$6.00Mozzarella Sticks
$5.00Fried Cauliflower
$4.00Fried Mushrooms
$4.00Fried Pickles
$4.00Corn Nuggets
$4.00Onion Rings 8 To An Order
$5.00Cheese Curds
$5.00Mac and Cheese Bites
$4.00
Salads
House Salad
$4.00Chef Salad
$10.00Grilled Chicken Salad
$12.00
Calzones
Calzone
$13.00
Sides
Fries-Separate Box
$2.00Add Cheese to Fries
$1.49Add Bacon And Cheese To Fries
$2.09Cottage Cheese
$2.092 Slices Of Bread
$0.99Side Of Grilled Chicken
$4.004 Meatballs W/Sauce
$4.004 Mtballs W/ Sauce & Cheese
$4.99Marinara
$0.75Pepperocinis
$0.75Crushed Red Pepper
$0.75Parmasean Cheese
$0.75Bag Of Chips
$1.00Garlic Bread
$1.00Ketchup
Tater Tots-Separate Box
$2.00Waffle Fries- seperate box
$2.00
Children’s Menu
2 Tend & FF Kids
$5.00Mini Burger & FF Kids
$5.00Grilled Ham & Cheese & FF
$5.00Grilled Cheese & FF Kids
$5.00Personal Pan Kids
$5.00Kids Spaghetti (Sauce & Noodles Only)
$5.00
Dessert
Apple Cinnamon Dessert Pizza
$9.00Cinna - Stix
$6.00Half Apple/Half Cherry Pizza
$9.00Cherry Dessert Pizza
$9.00Ice Cream
$1.99
Extra Sauce Options
Extra Sauce Options
DRINKS
Beverages
Pepsi 2lt
$4.00Diet Pepsi 2lt
$4.00Starry 2lt
$4.00Mountain Dew 2lt
$4.0020 Oz Pepsi Zero
$2.5020 Oz Diet Pepsi
$2.5020 Oz Pepsi
$2.5020 oz Cherry Pepsi
$2.5020 oz Crush
$2.5020 oz Starry
$2.5020 oz Dr.Pepper
$2.5020 Oz Mug Rootbeer
$2.50Propel Grape
$2.50Apple juice
$2.50Aquafina
$2.5020 oz Diet Mtn Dew
$2.5020 oz Mountain Dew Zero
$2.5020 Oz Mountain Dew
$2.50Small milk
$2.00
FOOD (Copy)
Pizza
10" Pizza
$9.5014" Pizza
$13.5016" Pizza
$14.50Friday $9.99 1 topping
$9.99
Grinders/Hoagies
Meatball
$8.50Grilled Chicken Grinder
$8.50Honey Mustard Chicken
$8.50Chicken Bacon Ranch
$8.50Stromboli
$8.50Veggie Sub
$8.50Philly Steak
$8.50Pork Tenderloin
$8.50Ham-n-Cheese
$8.50Steak Hoagie
$8.50Italian
$8.50
Sandwiches
Slider
$2.00Hamburger
$5.50Cheeseburger
$6.00Bacon Cheeseburger
$7.00BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger
$7.00Mushroom Swiss Burger
$7.00Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$7.49Club Sandwich
$8.00Fish Sandwich
$10.00
Goodfellas Favorites
Baked Spaghetti
$9.50Chicken Alfredo
$9.505 Tenders & FF
$9.50
Appetizers
8 Bone In Wings
$8.0016 Bone In Wings
$16.0024 Bone In Wings
$24.00Boneless Wings 1/2 Pound
$7.00Boneless Wings Pound
$14.00Boneless Wings 2 Pound
$26.00Cheese Bread
$8.00Bread Sticks
$6.00Pretzel Sticks
$7.00Jalapeno Poppers
$5.00Onion Petals
$4.00Loaded Cheese Fries
$6.00Mozzarella Sticks
$5.00Fried Cauliflower
$4.00Fried Mushrooms
$4.00Fried Pickles
$4.00Corn Nuggets
$4.00Onion Rings 8 To An Order
$5.00Cheese Curds
$5.00Mac and Cheese Bites
$4.00
Salads
House Salad
$4.00Chef Salad
$10.00Grilled Chicken Salad
$12.00
Calzones
Calzone
$13.00
Sides
Fries-Separate Box
$2.00Add Cheese to Fries
$1.49Add Bacon And Cheese To Fries
$2.09Cottage Cheese
$2.092 Slices Of Bread
$0.99Side Of Grilled Chicken
$4.004 Meatballs W/Sauce
$4.004 Mtballs W/ Sauce & Cheese
$4.99Marinara
$0.75Pepperocinis
$0.75Crushed Red Pepper
$0.75Parmasean Cheese
$0.75Bag Of Chips
$1.00Garlic Bread
$1.00Ketchup
Tater Tots-Separate Box
$2.00Waffle Fries- seperate box
$2.00
Children’s Menu
2 Tend & FF Kids
$5.00Mini Burger & FF Kids
$5.00Grilled Ham & Cheese & FF
$5.00Grilled Cheese & FF Kids
$5.00Personal Pan Kids
$5.00Kids Spaghetti (Sauce & Noodles Only)
$5.00
Dessert
Apple Cinnamon Dessert Pizza
$9.00Cinna - Stix
$6.00Half Apple/Half Cherry Pizza
$9.00Cherry Dessert Pizza
$9.00Ice Cream
$1.99
Extra Sauce Options
Extra Sauce Options
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.