Skip to Main content
This is the MADISON Location in Wisconsin

  • Gotham Bagels

    Gotham Bagels
Banner image

Gotham Bagels Madison, WI

112 East Mifflin Street, Madison, WI
Bagels, Lox, & More
Sandwiches
Deli & Bulk
Extras
Beverages
Catering
Grocery

Featured Items

  • BAGEL & CREAM CHEESE

    $5.25

  • BACON, EGG, & CHEDDAR

    Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon.

    $9.50

  • O.M.F.G.

    Fried egg, aged cheddar, nashville fried chicken, thick cut bacon, & Calabrian chili aioli.

    $12.75

‌

Bagels, Lox, & More

Items from the Deli can be ordered in 1/2 Pound increments. Check out our Catering Platters for your next get together.

  • Single Bagel

    Loose bagels do not come sliced.

    $2.25

  • BAGEL & CREAM CHEESE

    $5.25

  • x Dozen Bagels

    Choose 13 bagels

    $21.75

  • 8oz Container of Cream Cheese

    8oz House whipped cream cheese or 8oz Whipped Butter.

    $7.50

  • Fresh Fruit Cup

    10 oz. Pineapple, blueberries, and grapes.

    $6.00

  • Thinly Sliced Lox by the Half Pound or Pound

    With capers and red onion. *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

    $17.75

  • Traditional Matzo Ball Soup

    Served Hot

    $7.00

  • Big City Coffee Cake

    $6.25

  • Curried Hummus with Za'atar

    8 oz.

    $7.25

  • Hot Smoked Salmon

    $17.25

  • Freezer bags (1 each)

    $0.35

  • Freezer Bags (5 pack)

    Eco-friendly 5-pack of freezer bags. Bio-based film derived from Sugar Cane. Each bag hold 6 NY bagels.

    $2.25

  • Gotham Frozen Bagels

    Better than others' fresh! 6 pack assorted. Please do not request flavors on frozen bagels; flavors fluctuate daily.

    $7.25

  • Babka for One

    $6.25

  • Babka Loaf

    24 oz. Certified Kosher and Parve.

    $15.75

  • Traditional Rugelach

    14 oz bag. Certified Kosher and parve.

    $12.75

  • Traditional Hamantaschen

    12 oz box.

    $10.00
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Black and White Cookies

    Individually wrapped.

    $1.25

  • Chocolate Cookie

    $2.50

  • Caramel Apple Cookie

    $2.50

  • New England Clam Chowder

    $7.00

Sandwiches

  • BAGEL & CREAM CHEESE

    $5.25

  • BACON, EGG, & CHEDDAR

    Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon.

    $9.50

  • LOX & CREAM CHEESE

    Lox and your choice of cream cheese. *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

    $10.25

  • PASTRAMI SPICED LOX & CREAM CHEESE

    $10.25

  • SPICY ITALIAN SAUSAGE, EGG, & CHEDDAR

    Over-Easy Egg, Aged Cheddar, Gotham-made Spicy Italian Sausge.

    $11.75

  • BRIGHTON BEACH

    Lox, caper cream cheese, Greens, tomato, red onion, capers. *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

    $14.50

  • O.M.F.G.

    Fried egg, aged cheddar, nashville fried chicken, thick cut bacon, & Calabrian chili aioli.

    $12.75

  • THE ROCKY'S DELI

    The return of a Gotham Original - Fried Egg, Thick Cut Bacon, Aged Cheddar, Potato Latke, Spicy Ketchup.

    $12.75

  • LUCHADOR!

    Scrambled Eggs, Chorizo, Provolone, Cotija, Guac, Radish, Onion/Cilantro, & Spicy Red Cabbage Slaw.

    $15.25

  • THE "G"

    Capocollo, Egg, and Cheddar on your Choice of Bagel.

    $10.75

  • THE JEWISH GIRL

    Egg whites, Hot smoked salmon, Avocado mash, Creamy cucumbers, greens, Tomato.

    $15.25

  • EGG & CHEDDAR

    $9.00

  • PASTRAMI & EGG, Early Willy

    Piled high over an over easy egg

    $10.75

  • SMOKED HERITAGE HAM, EGG, & GOUDA

    Fried Egg, Locally Smoked Ham, Aged Gouda, fried egg.

    $10.75

  • THE YELLOW C.A.B.

    Cheddar, avocado, bacon, arugula, tomato & mayo.

    $11.00

  • SUPER TUSCAN

    Fried egg, Fresh Mozzarella, Heirloom Tomato, Vitruvian Greens, and Pesto.

    $12.25

  • BRONX BOMBER

    Piled High Calabrese Salami, La Quercia Prosciutto,Mortadella, Provolone, Greens, Tomato, Chicago Johnny's Hot Giardiniera.

    $11.25

  • WILLIAMSBURG HOT PASTRAMI

    Piled high Hot Pastrami with NY STRONG mustard. Served with pickle and NY deli cole slaw.

    $13.00

  • ATHENIAN

    Gyro "Style" Lamb, Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Tzatziki.

    $11.75

  • MASSAPEQUA

    Grilled Herbed Chicken Breast, Roasted Red Peppers, Fontina, Greens and pesto.

    $11.25

  • WOODLAWN CORN BEEF

    Piled High Corn Beef & NY Strong mustard. Make it a Rueben +2.75

    $13.00

  • THE ORIGINAL "V" ....THE GREAT VEGAN!

    Vegan scallion cream cheese, poblano salad, tomato, arugula, & avocado. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle

    $10.25

  • THE AMAGANSETT

    House Made Whitefish Salad, Vitruvian Baby Greens, Cucumber, Hot House Tomato, Red Onion

    $11.25

  • PORT WASHINGTON

    Hot Smoked Salmon Salad(Red Onion, Celery, Parsley, Salt & Pepper), Avocado Mash, Tomato, Baby Greens, Citrus Vinaigrette

    $12.25

  • LONG ISLAND

    House-Roasted Turkey Breast, Fontina, Greens, Tomato, Mayo

    $10.25

  • THE SAN PATRICIO a.k.a "44"

    Braised Beef Short Ribs, Jalapeno Garlic Cream Cheese, Greens, Aged Cheddar, Fried Egg, Shepard Potato Crisp on your choice of bagel.

    $14.75

  • TRADITONAL TUNA SALAD SANDWICH

    Arugula, Tomato.

    $9.50

  • NY DELI CHICKEN SALAD

    Petite Greens, Heirloom Tomatoes

    $9.50

Deli & Bulk

  • Bowtie Pesto Pasta Salad 5oz.

    8oz.

    $3.75

  • Gotham's Finest Roasted Red Peppers

    8 oz.

    $3.50
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Zingerman's Pimento Cheese Dip

    A salty, tangy, spicy mix of Cabot Vermont Cheddar, Hellmann’s mayo, pimento peppers and spices. Great w/ a bag of bagel chips.

    $10.00

  • Traditional Tuna Salad

    $5.75

  • Pastrami by the Pound

    Sold by the pound. Comes with NY Strong Mustard.

    $20.50

  • Gotham Pickles

    $6.50
    OUT OF STOCK

  • NY Deli Coleslaw

    $3.25

  • Gotham Chicken Salad

    $5.75

  • Gotham Whitefish Salad

    8 oz.

    $10.50

  • Nueske's Applewood Smoked Bacon

    12 oz. Made in Wittenberg, Wisconsin

    $10.25

  • Virtruvian Farms Baby Greens Mix

    5 OZ. Locally grown Produce, McFarland, Wisconsin

    $5.50

  • 30-Month-Old Parmigiano-Reggiano

    Per pound. The one and only.

    $18.00

Extras

  • Bag of Bagel Chips

    Made in house.

    $4.00

  • Joe Chips

    Retro potato chips.

    $2.25

  • Big Bag of Lillie's Chips

    5 oz.

    $5.00

  • Chili Rubbed Home Fries

    Single or double order.

    $5.50

  • Coffee Refill

    $0.50

  • 4 oz Fruit Cup

    $2.50

  • 12 oz Fruit Cup

    $6.00

  • Potato Latke

    A healthy pound (usually 5 or 6). Comes with sour cream.

    $12.50
    OUT OF STOCK

Beverages

Double shot of espresso diluted with water. Available iced or hot.

  • Strong Coffee

    Your Choice Light or Dark Roast Coffee served HOT in iconic NYC Coffee Cups

    $2.50

  • Iced Coffee

    $3.25

  • Dr. Brown's Soda

    $1.75

  • Powerade

    $2.50

  • Aqua Panna Water

    $2.75

  • Fresh Squeezed Juice

    $5.50

  • Coca-Cola Products

    $1.25

  • San Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water

    $3.00

  • San Pellegrino Fruit Soda

    $3.00

  • Fiji Bottled Water

    1 Liter Bottle

    $5.00

  • Better Box Water

    1 Liter Box.

    $3.50
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Small Boxed Water 500 ml

    $1.75
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Joe Tea

    $3.00

  • Poland Spring

    $1.75
    OUT OF STOCK

Catering

  • Astoria Platter

    One Pound Hummus, 1 Pound Imported Sheep's Milk Greek Feta, One Pound Baba Ghanoush, One Pound Tabbouleh, Marinated Olives, Mixed Peppers, Warm Pita. (Please order at least one day in advance-Thank you).

    $119.00

  • Riverside Park Platter

    NY Dozen®, 1 lb lox, 2-8oz spreads, Baby Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Big City Pickles, Red onion, and capers *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

    $109.00

  • Long Island Platter

    NY Dozen®, 1 lb. Traditional Tuna Salad, 1 lb. Traditional Chicken Salad, 1lb. Sliced Turkey, Tomatoes, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Big City Pickles and Gotham Finest Cole Slaw

    $100.00

  • Brighton Beach Platter

    NY Dozen®, 1 lb Lox, 8 oz Hot Smoked Salmon, 8 oz Smoked Whitefish Salad, 2- 8 oz Spreads, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Big City Pickles *Whether dining out or preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

    $139.00

  • Williamsburg Platter

    NY Dozen®, 1lb. Corned Beef, 1lb Pastrami, 1lb Smoked locally cured Ham, 8oz Deli Coleslaw, (2) 4 oz Gotham Deli Mustard, & Big City Pickles.

    $119.00

  • Big City Fruit Platter

    Pineapple - grapes - blueberries - cantaloupe

    $45.00

  • Joe to Go Coffee Service

    Collectivo Coffee service for 12 people. Includes cups, cream, and sugar.

    $45.00

Grocery

  • Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Farfalle

    17.6 oz. Product of Italy.

    $5.75

  • Busiante (Imported Sicilian Pasta)

    Joey Bagels Preferred dry pasta

    $9.94
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Mafaldine (Imported Sicilian Pasta)

    Joey Bagels Preferred dry pasta

    $8.94

  • Calamarata (Imported Sicilian Pasta)

    Joey Bagels Preferred dry pasta

    $8.94
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Pasta di Semola (Orecchiette)

    $8.84
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Venizelos Caffeine Free Strong Greek Coffee

    (SALE - 50% OFF) Imported, Greece, 8 ounces

    $3.25

  • Everything Spice

    12oz container.

    $6.00

  • Mother in Law's Kimchee

    Vegan, 16oz.

    $8.75

  • Athina GREATEST and DIRTIEST Martini Onion from Greece

    (50% OFF) Grown 2 feet below ground, 1 POUND

    $6.00
    OUT OF STOCK

  • Capers in Sea Salt

    Imported.

    $3.75

  • The Brinery Sriracha

    Traditionally Fermented hot sauce, 8 oz.

    $6.83

  • St. Elmo Steak House Shrimp Cocktail Sauce

    Very Spicy, 12 oz

    $9.95

  • Hot Giardiniera

    Olive oil based, bold and smoky flavor. 16 oz.

    $8.75

Gotham Bagels Location and Ordering Hours

(608) 467-7642
112 East Mifflin Street, Madison, WI 53703
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 8AM
Order online
This site is powered byToast logo
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement
  • |