
Hayners Ice Cream, Food & Country Store 148 NY-236
Desserts & More (Order & pick up next *available day)
10" Fruit Pies (Order & pick up next *available day)
- 10" Apple Caramel Walnut Pie$18.95
- 10" Apple Pie$16.95
- 10" Blueberry Crisp Pie$17.95
- 10" Blueberry Pie$19.95
- 10" Caramel Apple Pie$17.95
- 10" Cherry Pie$18.95
- 10" Dutch Apple Crisp Pie$16.95
- 10" Fruits of the Forest Pie$18.95
- 10" Peach Praline Pie$17.95
- 10" Pumpkin Pie$16.95
- 10" Raspberry Pie$19.95
- 10" Southern Pecan Pie$21.95
- 10" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie$18.95
9" Ice Cream Pies (Order & pick up next *available day)
- 9" Cappuccino Cookies & Cream Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup & Snickers Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Cookie Monster Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$26.95
- 9" Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Midnight Caramel River Ride Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9” Milk & Cookies Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9" Peanut Butter Cookies & Cream Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$24.95
- 9” Strawberries & Cream Deluxe Ice cream Pie$24.95
- 9” Trash Can Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$26.95
- 9” Vinny Boom Bots Deluxe Ice Cream Pie$25.95
Cookies & Apple Dumplings (Order & pick up next *available day)
Mini Cannolis (Available December 23 & 24 only)
Apple Cider Doughnuts. (Available December 23 & 24 only)
- Apple Cider Donuts (Half Dozen) avail 12/23 & 12/24 only$7.50
- *Plain (No Sugar) Apple Cider Donuts (Half Dozen) avail 12/23 & 12/24 only$7.50
- Apple Cider Donuts Cinn Sugared (Dozen) available 12/23 & 12/24 only$13.95
- *Plain (No Sugar) Apple Cider Donuts (Dozen) available 12/23 & 12/24 only$13.95
- Bucket of Donut Holes - approx 48 per available 12/23 & 12/24 only$11.95
- *Plain (No Sugar) Bucket of Donut Holes - approx 48 per available 12/23 & 12/24 only$11.95
- Apple cider donut (Each) available 12/23 & 12/24 only$1.40
- Cider Donut Holes (4/$1) available 12/23 & 12/24 only$1.00
Fresh Local Apple Cider (Available December 23 & 24 only)
Hard Ice Cream
Scoops (Hard)
- Buckaroo Scoop$2.29
A perfect toddler size cone or dish with your favorite flavor of Hayner's Hard Ice Cream!
- Single Scoop$4.29
A single scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream served in a cone or dish!
- Double Scoop$6.29
A double scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream flavor(s) served in a cone or dish!
- Triple Scoop$7.99
A triple scoop of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream flavor(s) served in a cone or dish!
- Vanilla Pupparoo Scoop for Dog$2.29
Sundaes (Hard)
- Buckaroo Size Sundae$2.99
A perfect toddler size sundae with Hayner's soft ice cream and your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
- Single Scoop Sundae$4.99
Single scoop of Hayner's hard ice cream with your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
- Double Scoop Sundae$7.99
Two scoops of Hayner's hard ice cream with your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
- Triple Scoop Sundae$9.99
Three scoops of Hayner's hard ice cream with your favorite topping, whip cream, nuts and a cherry!
- Custom 3 Scoop Banana Split$10.99
Choose any three flavors of our delicious Hayner's hard ice cream with three toppings, whip cream, nuts & a cherry!
- Apple Cider Donut Sundae (seasonal)$6.95
Hayner's fresh homemade cider donut sundae with your favorite hard ice cream flavor, favorite topping with whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top!
- Apple Pie al A Mode Sundae$10.95
A warmed slice of Hayner's Apple Pie with a scoop of your favorite ice cream, favorite topping with whip cream, nuts and a cherry on top.
- Apple Dumpling Delight$10.99
Shakes (Hard)
- Custom Large Shake$7.49
Our custom thick milk shake made with 2 scoops of your favorite flavor(s) of hard ice cream blended with our heavy vanilla or chocolate mix!
- Custom X-Large Shake$9.49
Our custom thick milk shake made with 3 scoops of your favorite flavor(s) of hard ice cream blended with our heavy vanilla or chocolate mix!
Fresh Brew Coffee Float (Hard)
Ice Cream Floats (Hard)
- Custom 2 Scoop Large Ice Cream Float$7.49
Two scoops of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream floated in Mug Rootbeer or Orange Crush soda!
- Custom 3 Scoop X-Large Ice Cream Float$9.49
Three scoops of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream floated in Mug Rootbeer or Orange Crush soda!
- Custom 2 Scoop Large Shirley Temple Float$8.49
Two scoops of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream floated in Mug Rootbeer or Orange Crush soda!
- Custom 3 Scoop X-Large Shirley Temple Float$10.49
Three scoops of your favorite Hayner's hard ice cream floated in Mug Rootbeer or Orange Crush soda!
Quarts
Acai Bowls & Smoothies
Acai Bowls
- Power Acai Bowl$10.99+
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, STRAWBERRIES & BANANA BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED VANILLA ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH SLICED STRAWBERRIES, CHIA SEEDS, RAW PEANUT BUTTER & LOCAL HONEY.
- Haynerietta Acai Bowl$10.99+
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, BANANA & PEANUT BUTTER BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED CHOCOLATE ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH SLICED STRAWBERRIES, BANANA, ALMOND SLIVERS AND LOCAL HONEY.
- Tropical Acai Bowl$10.99+
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, MANGO, PINEAPPLE, STRAWBERRIES & BANANA BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED VANILLA ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH STRAWBERRIES, BANANAS, CHIA SEEDS & RAW COCONUT.
- Very Berry Acai Bowl$10.99+
RAW ORGANIC BRAZILIAN AÇAÍ BERRY, BLUEBERRIES, RASPBERRIES, STRAWBERRIES, BLACKBERRIES & BANANAS BLENDED WITH UNSWEETENED VANILLA ALMOND MILK & TOPPED WITH GLUTEN FREE GRANOLA, FRESH STRAWBERRIES, FRESH BLUEBERRIES & CHIA SEEDS.
Real Fruit Smoothies
- 16oz. Paradise Smoothie$6.99
Mango, Pineapple, Bananas & Strawberries blended with Dole Flavor Soft Serve flavor of the day and a Mango base.
- 16 oz. Sunrise Smoothie$6.99
Peanut Butter, bananas, gluten free granola & honey blended with low fat vanilla frozen yogurt & unsweetened vanilla almond milk base.
- 16 oz. Harvest Moon Smoothie$6.99
Raspberries, blueberries, strawberries & blackberries blended with low fat frozen vanilla yogurt and a very berry base.
- 16 oz. Sunset Smoothie$6.99
Strawberries & Bananas blended with low fat frozen vanilla yogurt and a strawberry banana base.