Skip to Main content
  • Jeremiahs Tavern - Penfield 2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd

Jeremiahs Tavern - Penfield 2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd

2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, Fairport, NY
‌
‌
Specials
Shareables
Soups & Salads
Chicken Wings
Pizza
Sandwiches, Wraps & Burgers
Entrees
Dessert
Kids Menu
Sauces, Extras, Dressings

Featured Items

  • Single

    10 Wings
    $18.99
  • Jeremiah's Chicken Wing Platter

    our famous (10)chicken wings, served with corn bread and choice of side
    $21.99
  • The Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

    Crispy chicken, bacon, ranch, cheddar jack cheese and lettuce in a flour tortilla
    $17.99

Specials

  • Greek Salad

    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.99

Shareables

  • Birria Tacos

    flour tortillas stuffed with tender shredded beef, pico de gallo, melted cheddar jack cheese, seared and served with sour cream and consommé for dipping
    $16.99
  • Nacho 3 Cheese Nevadomski

    Corn Chips Smothered with Our Buffalo Cheese Sauce, Melted Cheddar Jack, Diced Tomatoes, Pickled Jalapenos, Sour Cream and Salsa. *Add Chicken, Chili, or Pulled Pork $5*
    $15.99
  • Pow Pow Shrimp

    Panko Breaded Shrimp tossed in a Creamy Spicy Sauce. Also available with any of Our Wing Sauces. *Allergy Alert: Contains Peanuts*
    $15.99
  • Steak Quesadilla

    Mushrooms, Caramelized Onions, Mozzarella Cheese, served with Sour Cream and Salsa.
    $18.99
  • Homemade Tavern Pretzels

    Baked with Butter and Salt, served with Honey Dijon Mustard.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.99
  • Jerry's Queso Dip N' Chips

    Creamy Queso Blanco served with Flash Fried Corn Tortilla Chips and a side of Salsa.
    $12.99
  • Chicken Wing Dip

    Buffalo Chicken and a Three Cheese Blend served with Tortilla Chips and celery.
    $16.99
  • Poutine

    crispy steak fries topped with yancey’s fancy local cheese curds and gravy
    $13.99
  • Chicken Fingers

    (4)Breaded Chicken Breast Strips with choice of dipping Sauce. Served with Fries.
    $15.99
  • Basket of Onion Rings

    $9.50
  • Basket of Steak Fries

    $9.50
  • Basket of Sweet Fries

    $9.50
  • Basket of Curly Fries

    $9.50

Soups & Salads

  • Ellie's French Onion Soup

    The BEST French Onion Soup you'll ever have! with Croutons and Melted Provolone Cheese.
    $8.50
  • Homestyle Chili

    Our own secret recipe made in-house from scratch.
    $5.99+
  • Boston Clam Chowda

    A Classic Soup Perfected by Us!
    $5.99+
  • Wayne's World

    A bowl of our Soup Du Jour and a House Salad with your choice of Dressing, served with Toasted Garlic Bread.
    $14.99
  • Kenny's Salad

    Grilled Pita Bread, Crumbled Feta Cheese, Steamed Broccoli, Artichoke Hearts, and Roasted Red Peppers, tossed in Seasoned Olive Oil, served over Fresh Romaine Lettuce. Add Chicken $5.00 - Add Shrimp or Steak $7.00
    $15.50
  • Mandarin Salad

    Romaine Lettuce, Shredded Carrots, Madarin Oranges and sliced almonds drizzled with Thai Peanut Sauce and topped with crispy Wonton Strips, served with a Honey-Lime Vinaigrette **ALLERGY ALERT-CONTAINS PEANUTS** Add chicken $5.. Add steak or shrimp $7
    $15.50
  • Black and Blue Tenderloin Salad

    Tenderloin tips, Romaine Lettuce, Red Onion, Grape Tomatoes, Pepperoncini and Crumbled Bleu Cheese served with a Horseradish Ranch Dressing.
    $21.99
  • Chicken Milanese

    Panko Breaded Chicken Breast, Arugula, Sliced Almonds, Shaved Parmesan, Grape Tomatoes served with a Citrus-Cider Vinaigrette.
    $20.99
  • Beesting Salad

    Breaded Chicken tossed in our Famous Bee Sting™ Sauce, with Shredded Cheddar-Jack Cheese, Virginia Ham, Red Onions, Grape Tomatoes, and Pepperoncini served over Romaine Lettuce with our House-Made Bleu Cheese Dressing.
    $19.99
  • Southwest Bowl

    Romaine Lettuce, Cheddar jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Black Bean-Corn Relish, Avocado, Lime Sour Cream Salsa Ranch Dressing, Crunchy Tortilla Strips. Add Chicken $5.00 - Add Shrimp or Steak $7.00
    $15.99
  • Classic Caesar Salad

    A bed of Fresh-Cut Crisp Romaine Lettuce tossed in Creamy Caesar Dressing with Homestyle Garlic Croutons and Shaved Parmesan Cheese. Add Chicken $5.00 - Add Shrimp or Steak $7.00
    $15.50
  • Side Salad

    $6.99
  • Side Caesar Salad

    $6.99

Chicken Wings

  • Half Team

    5 Wings
    $10.75
  • Single

    10 Wings
    $18.99
  • Double

    20 Wings
    $36.99
  • Boneless 1/2 Team

    Six Wings off the bone with all the flavor of our signature Sauces, without the mess!
    $9.50
  • Boneless Wings

    12 Boneless Wings
    $17.00
  • Extra Blue Cheese

    $0.75
  • Extra Celery

    $0.75
  • Extra Sauce

    $0.75
  • Extra Ranch

    $0.75

Pizza

  • Bruschetta

    Fresh Chopped Tomatoes, Garlic, Olive Oil, Mozzarella and Romano Cheese.
    $16.99
  • BBQ Chicken

    Tavern BBQ Sauce, Chicken Breast, Sauteed Onions, Bacon and Mozzarella Cheese.
    $16.99
  • The Standby

    Jerry’s Red Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella and Pepperoni.
    $16.99
  • The Beesting

    Crispy Chicken Tossed in Bee Sting Sauce with Mozzarella Cheese and Ranch drizzle
    $16.99

Sandwiches, Wraps & Burgers

  • Apple-Pecan Chicken Salad Wrap

    NY State local apples, Roasted Pecans,, Dried Cranberries, Celery, Seasoned Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato in a Flour Tortilla
    $17.99
  • Bee Sting Fried Chicken

    Buttermilk Marinated Chicken Breast Double Dredged in our Seasoned Breading and deep-fried golden brown with Arugula, Pickles and Garlic Aioli served on a Grilled Brioche Roll.
    $18.99
  • Beyond Burger

    $16.99
  • Blue Cheese & Chive Burger

    ground chuck seasoned smashburger topped with a bacon-chive-bleu cheese butter, bacon and shredded lettuce
    $17.99
  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    Breaded Chicken tosses in Jeremiah's Buffalo Sauce, Lettuce, Blue Cheese Crumbles and Creamy Bleu Cheese in a Cheddar Jalapeno Tortilla
    $17.99
  • Build a Better Burger

    Fresh Ground Sirloin On Brioche.. Add your toppings
    $14.00
  • California Chicken Pita

    Grilled Chicken Breast on Toasted Pita with Avocado, Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Fresh Spinach, Sliced Tomato and Chipotle Mayo.
    $17.99
  • French Dip

    House Roasted Beef and Swiss Cheese on a Toasted Artisan Baguette served with Au Jus for dipping.
    $17.99
  • Iron Smoke Whiskey Brisket Melt

    Smoked Beef Brisket, Iron Smoke™ Whiskey BBQ Glaze, Cheddar and Pepper Jack on Grilled Sourdough Bread.
    $18.99
  • Jerry's Cheese Steak

    Choice Steak chopped and grilled “Philly Style” with our specialty Sam Adams Peppers and Onions, topped with Aged Cheddar Cheese Sauce and Melted Provolone on a Hoagie Roll.
    $18.99
  • Morgan Meltdown

    Smashburger with Amercian Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Russian Dressing and sauteed onions on grilled sourdough bread.
    $17.50
  • Sherwin's Russian Mistress

    Oven Roasted Turkey, Sliced Tomato, Bacon, Fresh Spinach, Swiss Cheese and Russian Dressing on Grilled Sourdough Bread.
    $17.99
  • Thai Chicken Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Shredded Carrots and Cabbage, Thai Peanut Sauce and Korean BBQ Sauce in a Flour Tortilla **ALLERGY ALERT: CONTAINS PEANUTS*
    $16.99
  • The Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

    Crispy chicken, bacon, ranch, cheddar jack cheese and lettuce in a flour tortilla
    $17.99
  • The Smashburger

    Ground Chuck seasoned and pressed to perfection with melted American cheese, pickles, shredded lettuce, bacon and topped with our smash sauce on brioche
    $18.99
  • Turkey Bacon Avacado Wrap

    $17.99
  • Turkey Burger

    Hand-Formed Turkey Burger blended with peppers and onions topped with Spinach, Sliced Tomato, Provolone and Lemon Garlic Aioli on Brioche
    $18.50
  • Webb's Rueben

    Turkey or Corned Beef, Russian Dressing, Sauerkraut, and Swiss Cheese on Grilled Rye Bread.
    $17.99
  • BBQ Pork Melt

    House- smoked pork, onion straws , cheddar jack served on sourdough bread
    $17.99
  • Pork Schnitzel Sandwich sub chicken cutlett

    OUT OF STOCK
    $16.99

Entrees

  • Friday Fish Fry

    $18.99
  • Friday Fish Sandwich

    $17.99
  • Friday Broiled Fish

    $19.99
  • Fish and Chips

    Beer battered cajun seasoned haddock served with steak fries, cole slaw and tarter sauce
    $20.99
  • Big Red's Boston Steak Tips

    Grilled choice tenderloin tips in a steak sauce served with garlic roasted mashed potatoes and broccoli.
    $25.99
  • The "1104" Plate

    The BEST Plate in Town! two cheeseburgers, mac salad, fries topped with burger meat hot sauce, topped with mustard and chopped onion
    $18.50
  • Jeremiah's Chicken Wing Platter

    our famous (10)chicken wings, served with corn bread and choice of side
    $21.99
  • Boneless Wing Platter

    Our famous boneless wings (10) served with corn bread and choice of side
    $21.99
  • Shrimp Tacos

    Grilled Shrimp, cilantro slaw ,diced avacado and cojito cheese in flour tortillas (3) served with choice of side.
    $20.99
  • 4-Cheese Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese

    Radiatore Pasta with 4-cheese sauce tossed with diced grilled chicken and topped with our medium sauce
    $20.99
  • Momma's Mealoaf

    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.99

Dessert

  • Brownie Sundae

    A big hunk of our homeade Brownie and a scoop of creamy Vanilla Ice Cream. Finished with Chocolate Sauce.
    $9.99
  • Peanut Butter Pie

    A layer of Milk Chocolate and a layer of Peanut Butter Mousse in a Chocolate Cookie Crumb Crust.
    $9.99
  • Cookie Dough cake

    OUT OF STOCK
    $10.99

Kids Menu

  • Kids Mac and Cheese

    Served with a choice of side
    $8.99
  • Kids Marinara Pasta And A Meatball

    Served with a choice of side
    $9.99
  • Kids Grilled Cheese

    Served with a choice of side
    $9.99
  • Kids Cheeseburger

    Served with a choice of side
    $9.99
  • Kids Hamburger

    Served with a choice of side
    $9.99
  • Kids Cheese Pizza

    Served with a choice of side
    $9.99
  • Kids Dino Chicken Nuggets

    Served with a choice of a side
    $9.99
  • Kids Mozarella Sticks

    Served with a choice of a side
    $9.99
  • Kids Pepperoni Pita Pizza

    Pepperoni , red sauce, mozzarella cheese served with choice of side
    $9.99

Sauces, Extras, Dressings

  • Wing Sauces

    $0.75
  • Salad Dressings

    $0.75
  • Proteins

  • Add Ons

    $0.75
  • Add Cheese

    $1.75
  • Add Bacon

    $3.00
  • Add Avocado

    $2.75
  • Side Blue Cheese

    $0.75
  • Side Gravy

    $2.75
  • Side Queso

    $2.75
  • Side Beer Cheese

    OUT OF STOCK
    $2.75
  • Side Chimi

    $0.75
  • Side Marinara

    $0.75
  • Side Buff Cheese

    $2.75
  • Side Meat Hot

    $2.75
  • Horseradish

    $1.75
  • Mushrooms

    $1.75
  • Grilled onions

    $1.75
  • Roasted red peppers

    $1.75
  • Banana peppers

    $1.75
  • Pico de Gallo

    $1.75
  • Crumbly blue

    $1.75
  • Jalapeño peppers

    $1.75
  • Garlic Bread

    $2.99
  • Celery

    $0.75
  • Malt Vinegar

  • Salsa

    $0.75
  • Sour cream

    $0.75
  • Steak Sauce

    $0.75
  • Ketchup

  • Mustard

  • Xtra Tartar

    $0.75
  • Bee Sting Sour Cream

    OUT OF STOCK
    $0.75
  • Peanut Sauce

    $0.75

Extra Sauce

$0.75

Customize your item

Wing Sauces

Required
Select 1

Sub Ranch

Select up to 1

Kitchen Commands

Select up to 1
1

Jeremiahs Tavern - Penfield 2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd Location and Ordering Hours

(585) 377-2233
2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, Fairport, NY 14450
Open now • Closes at 9PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement