Skip to Main content
Joe's Next Door logo
Cart icon0

Your order

‌
‌
‌
‌
Catering Orders- Require 24 to 48 hours notice! See items for guidelines!

Joe's Butcher Shop Sandwiches Carmel, IN

You can only place scheduled delivery orders.

Sandwiches

Catering, Drop Off or Pick Up - 24/48 hour Advance Ordering

Popular Items

Aji Amarillo Flank Steak

Aji Amarillo Flank Steak

$13.99

House marinated flank steak, cilantro aioli, pickled red onion, cotija cheese, shredded romaine, served on a warm Challah Roll

Chef's Bahn Mi

Chef's Bahn Mi

$11.99

Citrus braised caramelized pork belly, house pickled vegetables, handpicked Cilantro, fresh jalapeno, house made chili aioli, served on a French Batard

Turkey Tarantino

Turkey Tarantino

$12.99

Brined turkey, sundried tomato pesto, lemon artichoke ricotta, bacon,arugula, served on a Stirato Roll

Sandwiches

Cold Sandwiches

Turkey Pesto

Turkey Pesto

$12.99

Brined roasted turkey breast, tomato conserva, basil pesto, fresh mozzarella, shredded romaine, parm crisp, served on Stirato Roll

The French Orchard

The French Orchard

$10.99

Tulip Tree Trillium Brie, Local butter, Bourbon Fig Jam, Granny Smith Apple, served on a French Batard

The Italian Next Door

The Italian Next Door

$11.99

Spicy capicola, genoa salami, cotto ham, provolone, heirloom tomato, shredded romaine, and oregano vinaigrette, on a Stirato Roll

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Chicken Salad Sandwich

$10.99

Chicken salad, avocado, local cucumber, butter lettuce, on Challah Bun

Roast Beef and Cheddar

Roast Beef and Cheddar

$11.99

House made roast beef, scallion/horseradish cream, aged white cheddar, romaine, served on a Stirato Roll.

House BLT

House BLT

$10.99

House cured candied bacon, sweet butter lettuce, heirloom local tomatoes, sliced avocado, garlic aioli, on toasted Sourdough

Hot Sandwiches

Hot Capocollo

Hot Capocollo

$11.99

capocollo, havarti cheese, caramelized onion, sliced jalapeno, pressed and served on Sourdough

Evan's IPA Braised Beef

Evan's IPA Braised Beef

$12.99

Evan’s favorite* 12 hour IPA braised beef, havarti fondue, sweet caramelized onion, spicy arugula, red wine gastrique, warm Stirato Roll *$1 is contributed to the Merciful H.E.L.P. Center

Debris Po' Boy

Debris Po' Boy

$11.99

Blackened IPA braised beef, garlic aioli, house remoulade, romaine lettuce, fresh tomatoe, served on a French Batard

Chef's Bahn Mi

Chef's Bahn Mi

$11.99

Citrus braised caramelized pork belly, house pickled vegetables, handpicked Cilantro, fresh jalapeno, house made chili aioli, served on a French Batard

Mission Chicken Torta

Mission Chicken Torta

$10.99

House pulled chicken, roasted salsa verde, avocado, aged cotija, shredded iceberg, served on a warm Challah Roll

El Cubanito

El Cubanito

$10.99

10-hour house braised mojo pork, cotto ham, creamy swiss, house dill pickles, garlic mustard butter, served pressed on French Batard

Aji Amarillo Flank Steak

Aji Amarillo Flank Steak

$13.99

House marinated flank steak, cilantro aioli, pickled red onion, cotija cheese, shredded romaine, served on a warm Challah Roll

Hot Italian Beef

Hot Italian Beef

$11.99

Thin sliced roasted beef in our house au-jus, giardiniera, melty provolone cheese served on a Soft Roll

Sicilian Meatball

Sicilian Meatball

$10.99

Family recipe meatballs, house made sunday “gravy”, melted provolone, served on a toasted Soft Roll

Turkey Tarantino

Turkey Tarantino

$12.99

Brined turkey, sundried tomato pesto, lemon artichoke ricotta, bacon,arugula, served on a Stirato Roll

Rich Boy Scallop Sandwich

Rich Boy Scallop Sandwich

$15.99

Blackened Scallops, House made Remoulade, Tomato, Shredded Romaine, on a toasted French Batard

Grown-up Grilled Cheese

Grown-up Grilled Cheese

$9.99

Melty Havarti, Provolone, and White Cheddar, with candied bacon,and tomato on Sourdough

Main Street Meatloaf Sandwich

Main Street Meatloaf Sandwich

$10.99

Delicious homemade meatloaf, red onion, natural swiss cheese, and homemade tomato jam. Mom is jealous!

Kids Menu

Classic PBJ

Classic PBJ

$4.99

Nothing fancy, white bread,peanut butter, and choice of strawberry or grape Jelly, just as kids like it!

Turkey and Cheese Please

Turkey and Cheese Please

$6.99

Brined roasted turkey, your choice of white cheddar or white american cheese, mayo, lettuce, and tomato are optional, served on Sourdough

Salads

Grand Palace Salad

Grand Palace Salad

$11.99

Assorted mixed spring lettuce, sliced thai marinated chicken breast, snow peas, grape tomatoes, shaved brussels sprouts, and orange supremes, crowned with our house made orange sesame dressing.

Basque Steak Salad

Basque Steak Salad

$14.99

Freshly shredded romaine lettuce, sliced basque marinated flank steak, roasted red pepper, house pickled red onion, imported marcona almonds, shaved parmesan cheese, topped with our house made poblano cream dressing.

House/Side Salad

House/Side Salad

$5.99

Spring mixed lettuce, with tomatoes, fresh cucumber, shredded carrots, and herbed croutons, with Balsamic Dressing.

Chips

Broad Ripple Chips Original

Broad Ripple Chips Original

$1.99

A local classic. Hand crafted in small batches.

Broad Ripple Chips Sweet/Spicy

Broad Ripple Chips Sweet/Spicy

$1.99

Hand crafted locally, a touch of sugar and bit of spicy heat!

Joe Chips Bacon/Cheddar

Joe Chips Bacon/Cheddar

$1.99

Bacon and Cheddar flavor kettle chips, class up your sandwich with that baked spud taste!

Joe Chips BBQ

Joe Chips BBQ

$1.99

BBQ Kettle Chips seasoned with a BBQ back rib seasoning won in a poker game! Cooked in small batches.

Joe Chips Jalepeno

Joe Chips Jalepeno

$1.99

Jalapeno flavor in a crispy kettle chip. Add a little heat to your sandwich!

Joe Chips Plain

Joe Chips Plain

$1.99

Kettle Chips with sea salt, cooked in small batches. Super Crunchy. A superior chip!

Joe Chips Salt/Vinegar

Joe Chips Salt/Vinegar

$1.99

Kettle Chips seasoned with a blend of Sea Salt and Vinegar for that perfect pucker! Made in small batches.

Sides

Broccoli Salad

Broccoli Salad

$3.00

6oz, Broccoli, bacon, cran raisins, red onion, carrot, and orange dressing

Potato Salad

Potato Salad

$3.00

6oz, Home made with red potatoes, mayo, mustard, and sweet pickle relish, the classic!

Pasta Salad

Pasta Salad

$3.00

6oz, Tri-color fussili with italian herb dressing, artichoke hearts,roasted red peppers, olives and more!

Shaved Brussels Sprouts Salad

Shaved Brussels Sprouts Salad

$3.00

6 oz, Fine shaved brussels sprouts with bacon and brown sugar

Lemon Pepper Coleslaw

Lemon Pepper Coleslaw

$3.00

6oz, Fresh shaved cabbage and carrots with our homemade lemon pepper dressing

Desserts

Oatmeal Moon Pie Cookie

Oatmeal Moon Pie Cookie

$4.99

2 homemade oatmeal cookies sandwiched around our own creamy whipped center

Salted "Carmel" Brownie

Salted "Carmel" Brownie

$3.99

Home baked dark chocolate brownie cut generously then coated in our house made salted caramel cream

Drinks

Bottled Water

Bottled Water

$1.25

16.9oz, bottled water

Milk Chocolate - Dandy Breeze 12oz

Milk Chocolate - Dandy Breeze 12oz

$2.50

12oz local whole chocolate milk

Coca Cola

Coca Cola

$1.69

12 oz can

Diet Coke

Diet Coke

$1.69

12 oz can

Gatorade

Gatorade

$1.99

20oz

San Pelligrino Blood Orange

San Pelligrino Blood Orange

$1.69

11.15oz Can, Italian Sparkling Water with Natural Blood Orange Juice, an Italian Classic! 120 calories

San Pelligrino Lemonata

San Pelligrino Lemonata

$1.69

11.15oz Can, Italian Sparkling Water with Natural Lemon Flavor, 110 calories

San Pelligrino Pom Orange

San Pelligrino Pom Orange

$1.69

11.15oz Can, Italian Sparkling Water, Pomegranate Orange natural flavor, 130 calories

Sprite

Sprite

$1.69

12 oz can

Milk White - Dandy Breeze 12oz

Milk White - Dandy Breeze 12oz

$2.50Out of stock

12oz local whole white milk


Catering, Drop Off or Pick Up - 24/48 hour Advance Ordering

Gourmet Box Lunches - 24 hour notice/ 10 Box minimum - order by the Box

Catering/Gourmet Box Lunch (min 10 ea) - drinks additional charge

Catering/Gourmet Box Lunch (min 10 ea) - drinks additional charge

$14.99

Minimum of 10 Boxes, 24 hour notice. Order one at time, do not order more than one box at a time unless you have multiple persons that want identical boxes! Orders not meeting this criteria will be rejected. Please place the name of the individual receiving the box in the special instructions and we will place the name on the box, default is sandwich name on the box. Delivered to your office/location, includes box with a Gourmet Sandwich (choice), Side (choice) and Dessert (choice), Drinks are optional and cost extra. $14.99+tax/person. Servware and napkin are in the box.

1/2 Wrap Buffet - 24 hour notice/10 person minimum - order by # of persons served

Catering / Half a Wrap Sandwich Buffet

Catering / Half a Wrap Sandwich Buffet

$15.99

Minimum of 10 persons, 24 hour notice. Orders not meeting this criteria will be rejected. Delivered to your office/location, includes our ½ Gourmet Sandwiches done wrap style, family style servings of 2 sides (you choose), family style House Salad with choice of dressing, and dessert tray(choice) $14.99+tax/person, includes plates/forks/napkins/servware

Catering / Add Drinks to Half Wrap Buffet

Catering / Add Drinks to Half Wrap Buffet

Add Drinks to your 1/2 Wrap Sandwich Buffet. Additional charge.

Deli Sandwich Tray - 24 hour notice/10 person minimum - order by # of persons served

Catering / Deli Sandwich Tray

Catering / Deli Sandwich Tray

$16.99

Minimum 10 persons. Orders for less will be rejected. Delivered to your office/location, Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, and Salami with Provolone, Swiss, and Cheddar Cheese. Equal amounts of NY Sourdough, Challah Buns, and Stirato Rolls. Mayo, Mustard, PIckles, Lettuce, Sliced Tomatoes, and Red Onion. Choice of 2 Family Style Sides, and 1 Dessert Tray. Drinks optional/additional. Includes servware, plates, and bagged silverware.

Catering / Add Drinks to Deli Sandwich Tray

Catering / Add Drinks to Deli Sandwich Tray

Add drinks to your Deli Sandwich Tray. Additional charge.

Warm Buffets - Order as PICK UP, 48hr & 14 pers. min, we will call about delivery/setup

Taco Buffet

Taco Buffet

$16.99

Minimum 14 persons/ 48 hour notice. Order by the # of persons served. Orders not meeting this criteria will be rejected. Includes FREE DELIVERY. Three meats including our house marinated, seasoned, and roasted Cochinita Pilbil Pork, Citrus Barbacoa, and Tinga de Pollo, served with warm soft corn tortillas, and all the gourmet fillings and toppings you can name. A real taste treat. Served with our family style House Salad w/dressing choice. Includes delivery, servware, plates, napkins, untensils, and set up.

Pasta Buffet

Pasta Buffet

$16.99

Minimum 14 persons/ 48 hour notice. Order by the # of persons served. Orders not meeting this criteria will be rejected. Includes FREE DELIVERY. Two of our three gourmet pasta sauces, and two of our three pasta choices, served with our family style house salad (choice of dressing), grated Parmesan, and fresh Warm Garlic Bread. Includes delivery, servware, plates, napkins, untensils, and set up.

Meatball Bake Buffet

Meatball Bake Buffet

$16.99

Minimum 14 persons/ 48 hour notice. Order by the # of persons served. Orders not meeting this criteria will be rejected. Includes FREEE DELIVERY, Our homemade Meatball Bake (homemade tender meatballs with homemade marinara smothered in Picante Provolone Cheese), Lightly Buttered Penne Pasta, grated Romano, Served with our family style House Salad w/dressing choice, and fresh Warm Garlic Bread. Includes delivery, servware, plates, napkins, untensils, and set up.

Lasagna Buffet

Lasagna Buffet

$16.99

Minimum 14 persons/ 48 hour notice. Order by the # of persons served. Orders not meeting this criteria will be rejected. Includes FREE DELIVERY. Our homemade Lasagna, served with our family style House Salad w/dressing choice, and fresh Warm Garlic Bread. Includes delivery, servware, plates, napkins, untensils, and set up.

Add Drinks to your Warm Buffet

Add Drinks to your Warm Buffet

Add Drinks to your Warm Buffet. Additional charge.

Add a Dessert Tray to your Warm Buffet

Add a Dessert Tray to your Warm Buffet

Add a Dessert Tray to your Warm Buffet! Additional charge.

Trays - 48 hour notice required

Trays must be ordered a minimum of 48 hours in advance! Upon review, your order will be rejected by Joe's if ordered inside this time window!
Cheese Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

Cheese Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

$33.99

Natural Swiss Cheese, Colby Jack, and White Vermont Cheddar, then garnished with House Brined Pickles and Grape Tomatoes! As shown, tell us if you prefer all cubed or all sliced!

Cheese Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

Cheese Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

$56.99

Natural Swiss Cheese, Colby Jack, and White Vermont Cheddar, then garnished with House Brined Pickles and Grape Tomatoes! As shown, tell us if you prefer all cubed or all sliced!

Sliced Meat Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

Sliced Meat Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

$49.99

Imported Proscuitto Cotto, Oven Roasted Turkey, Rare Roast Beef, Genoa and Salami, garnished with House Brined Pickles and Grape Tomatoes!

Sliced Meat Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

Sliced Meat Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

$84.99

Imported Proscuitto Cotto, Oven Roasted Turkey, Rare Roast Beef, Genoa and Salami, garnished with House Brined Pickles and Grape Tomatoes!

Veggie Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

Veggie Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

$33.99

Broccoli Florets, Cauliflower, Baby Carrots, Grape Tomatoes, and our famous Very Veggie Dip!

Veggie Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

Veggie Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

$59.99

Broccoli, Cauliflower, Grape Tomato, and Baby Carrots are served with homemade Veggie Dip

Fruit Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

Fruit Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

$39.99

Fresh Pineapple, Strawberries, Cantaloupe, and Honey Dew Melon, garnished with Grape Tomatoes, and served with our house made Yogurt Dip!

Fruit Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

Fruit Tray - 16" Serves 16-20 persons

$79.99

Fresh Pineapple, Strawberries, Cantaloupe, and Honey Dew Melon, garnished with Grape Tomatoes, and served with our house made Yogurt Dip!

Antipasto Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

Antipasto Tray - 12" Serves 8-10 persons

$66.99

Prosciutto di Parma, Capocollo, Genoa Salami. Grana Padono, and Asiago cheeses, Kalamata Olives Peppadew Peppers with a Cantaloupe and Grape Tomato garnish!

Antipasto  Tray - 16" Serves 15-18 persons

Antipasto Tray - 16" Serves 15-18 persons

$119.99

Prosciutto di Parma, Capocollo, Genoa Salami. Grana Padono, and Asiago cheeses, Kalamata Olives Peppadew Peppers with a Cantaloupe and Grape Tomato garnish!

Shrimp Tray - 12" Serves 10-12 persons

Shrimp Tray - 12" Serves 10-12 persons

$63.99

2lbs of our U15 cooked California White Jumbo Shrimp on a bed of lettuce and served with Kickin’ Cocktail Sauce!

Shrimp  Tray - 16" Serves 15-18 persons

Shrimp Tray - 16" Serves 15-18 persons

$99.99

3lbs of our U15 cooked California White Jumbo Shrimp on a bed of lettuce and served with Kickin’ Cocktail Sauce!

Joe's Next Door Location and Ordering Hours
(317) 846-8877
111 West Main Street, Suite 110, Carmel, IN 46032
Open now • Closes at 4:45PM
Order online
This site is powered byToast logo
Terms of Service | Privacy Statement