Skip to Main content
Order ahead to make sure you get your favorites! Same Day orders subject to availability!
  • Michael's Bakery

Banner image

Michael's Bakery - 145 W Market St

145 W Market St., Orrville, OH
ā€Œ
ā€Œ

Featured Items

  • Mike's Mix - We Pick

    Introducing 'Mike's Mix' – an assortment of our classic must-try donuts that pay homage to our late founder's favorites. From the signature creamsticks, renowned for their creamy indulgence, to our heavenly glazed donuts, cinnamon rolls, cake donuts, and irresistible bismarks, this collection encapsulates the essence of what our loyal customers have come to love and cherish. Indulge in the best of our timeless flavors, curated in honor of our founder's passion for exceptional taste. This mix consists of 3 Creamsticks, 2 Bismarks, 3 Glazed, 2 Cinnamon Rolls, and 2 Cake Donuts.
    $18.95
  • Sausage Breakfast Bomb

    Soft baked rolls packed with seasoned sausage and gooey cheese — the perfect grab-and-go breakfast.
    $3.25
  • Donut Holes

    $2.15+

Limited Time Only!

Bakery

  • Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Muffin

    Enjoy the essence of autumn with our Pumpkin Spice Muffin. Infused with aromatic spices and chocolate chips, it's a delightful treat to savor, perfect for those seeking the warm flavors of fall.
    $3.25
  • Apple Fry Pie

    $3.25

Drinks

  • Hot Apple Cider Chai

    A warm, cozy sip of fall — rich, locally sourced apple cider blended with nourishing chia and spices, finished with an aromatic cinnamon stick.
    $5.00+
  • Iced Apple Cider Chai

    Crisp and refreshing — smooth, locally sourced apple cider and spiced chai poured over ice, topped with a cinnamon stick.
    $5.00+
  • Pumpkin Pecan Latte

    A cozy classic — smooth espresso blended with pumpkin, warm spices, and velvety steamed milk.
    $5.00+
  • Iced Pumpkin Pecan Latte

    Fall flavors on ice — pumpkin, spices, and espresso mixed with cold milk
    $6.50+
  • Autumn Sunrise

    A refreshing blend of strawberry, vanilla, and orange juice—a bright, fruity taste of fall.
    $5.50+

Donuts

Assortments

  • Mike's Mix - You Pick

    Introducing 'Mike's Mix' – an assortment of our classic must-try donuts that pay homage to our late founder's favorites. From the signature creamsticks, renowned for their creamy indulgence, to our heavenly glazed donuts, cinnamon rolls, cake donuts, and irresistible bismarks, this collection encapsulates the essence of what our loyal customers have come to love and cherish. Indulge in the best of our timeless flavors, curated in honor of our founder's passion for exceptional taste. This mix consists of 3 Creamsticks, 2 Bismarks, 3 Glazed, 2 Cinnamon Rolls, and 2 Cake Donuts.
    $21.25
  • Mike's Mix - We Pick

    Introducing 'Mike's Mix' – an assortment of our classic must-try donuts that pay homage to our late founder's favorites. From the signature creamsticks, renowned for their creamy indulgence, to our heavenly glazed donuts, cinnamon rolls, cake donuts, and irresistible bismarks, this collection encapsulates the essence of what our loyal customers have come to love and cherish. Indulge in the best of our timeless flavors, curated in honor of our founder's passion for exceptional taste. This mix consists of 3 Creamsticks, 2 Bismarks, 3 Glazed, 2 Cinnamon Rolls, and 2 Cake Donuts.
    $18.95
  • Creme de la Creme - You Pick

    A dozen of the best creamsticks around!
    $22.45
  • Creme de la CrĆØme - We Pick

    A dozen of the best creamsticks around! We pick a variety of our signature creamsticks for you to enjoy.
    $20.45
  • Glazed Delight 45-Pack

    Indulge in the ultimate sweet treat with our Glazed Delight 45-Pack! Perfect for gatherings, celebrations, or simply sharing the love, this box is packed with 45 of our irresistible, melt-in-your-mouth glazed donuts. Whether you're hosting a party or just craving something sweet, this jumbo pack is sure to satisfy every donut lover!
    $65.00

Select - A la carte

  • Donut Holes

    $2.15+
  • Glazed

    $1.75
  • Plain Cake Donut

    $1.75
  • Vanilla Iced Cake Donut

    $1.75
  • Chocolate Iced Cake Donut

    $1.75
  • Maple Iced Cake Donut

    $1.75
  • Vanilla Iced Sprinkled Cake Donut

    $1.75
  • Chocolate Iced Sprinkled Cake Donut

    $1.75

Signature - A la carte

  • Old Fashioned

    $2.15
  • Twists

    $2.15
  • Cinnamon Roll

    $2.15
  • Long John

    An unfilled Creamstick with your choice of icing
    $2.15
  • Maple Creamstick

    $2.15
  • Chocolate Creamstick

    $2.15
  • Vanilla Creamstick

    $2.15
  • Powdered Sugar Creamstick

    $2.15
  • Peanut Butter Creamstick

    $2.15
  • Glazed Creamstick

    $2.15
  • Raspberry Bismark

    $2.15
  • Lemon Bismark

    $2.15
  • Strawberry Bismark

    Strawberry Filling
    $2.15
  • Blueberry Bismark

    $2.15
  • Cream Cheese Bismark

    $2.15
  • Custard Bismark

    $2.15
  • Apple Cinnamon Bismark

    Apple filling, cinnamon sprinkled and iced Bismark
    $2.15
  • Custom Bismark

    Pick your own combination of filling and icing to create the perfect Bismark creation!
    $2.15

Specialty - A la carte

  • Bowtie

    $2.50
  • Nut Roll

    $2.50
  • Gluten and Dairy Free Donut

    A soft, delicious donut finished with our classic glaze. ***Recipe is gluten and dairy free; produced in a kitchen that is not.
    $2.50

Bakery

Cookies

  • Cut-out Cookie

    Cut-out cookie. **Shape varies by month: January - Snowflake February - Heart March - Clover April - Bunny May - Butterfly June - Flower July - Flower August - September - October - Pumpkin November - Pumpkin December - Christmas Trees **Shape may vary from above listings.
    $2.50
  • Custom Cut-out Cookie

    Customize your cookies with a corporate logo, photo, or custom design of your choosing. ** Send print-ready file to michaelsbakeryorrville@gmail.com ** 2 day lead time required
    $2.75+
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    $2.50
  • Peanut Butter Cookie

    $2.50
  • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

    $2.50
  • Chocolate Supreme Cookie

    Double Chocolate Chip Cookie
    $2.50
  • Monster Cookie

    $2.50
  • Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie

    So good, you won't believe it's gluten free. Loaded with chocolate chips and baked to perfection. ***Recipe is gluten and dairy free; produced in a kitchen that is not.
    $3.25+

Brownies

  • Brownie

    A rich, fudgy brownie topped with smooth chocolate icing—perfectly sized for a sweet, satisfying treat.
    $2.50
  • Brownie Pan

    Our rich, fudgy chocolate brownie—topped with smooth chocolate icing—now in a shareable 8"x8" pan. Perfect for splitting… or not.
    $16.00

Muffins

  • Assorted 4 Pack of Muffins

    Mix and match your favorites! An assorted 4-pack of our delicious muffins, featuring any of our available flavors, at a special discounted price.
    $9.00
  • Bacon JalapeƱo Muffins

    Our first-ever savory muffin! Loaded with crispy bacon and fresh jalapeƱo for a lightly spicy, flavorful bite. Sold as a pair.
    $5.75
  • Sausage Pancake Muffins

    An classic combination presented as a muffin. Sausage, and pancakes in every bite, easy to take on the go. Sold as a pair.
    $5.75
  • Blueberry Muffin

    A tender, buttery muffin bursting with juicy blueberries and finished with a sweet streusel topping.
    $3.25
  • Chocolate Chip Muffin

    Our classic muffin batter studded with rich, melty chocolate chips for a timeless treat in every bite.
    $3.25
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Muffin

    A cocoa-infused muffin base swirled with creamy peanut butter for the perfect balance of chocolatey and nutty goodness.
    $3.25
  • Banana Nut Muffin

    Moist and fluffy banana muffin loaded with crunchy nuts for the perfect balance of sweet and nutty goodness. šŸŒšŸŒ°
    $3.25
  • Apple Cinnamon Muffin

    A moist and fluffy muffin packed with warm cinnamon spice and sweet apple pieces, perfect for a cozy treat.
    $3.25
  • Deluxe Chocolate Muffin

    When a decadent muffin is pure chocolate bliss or is it a personal cake? This muffin pairs well with a hot cup of coffee from our coffee bar. Our bakers created this recipe exclusively for Michael’s Bakery.
    $3.25

Breads

  • Orr Valley Hamburger Buns (8-Pack)

    Our soft, golden burger buns—developed exclusively for Orr Valley—are now available in an 8-pack for your home grill nights. Light, airy, and perfect for your favorite sandwiches or burgers.
    $6.85

Other Baked Goods

  • Sausage Breakfast Bomb

    Soft baked rolls packed with seasoned sausage and gooey cheese — the perfect grab-and-go breakfast.
    $3.25
  • Energy Bites

    Chewy, protein-packed bites made with oats, peanut butter, maple syrup, protein powder, and chocolate chips. Sweet, satisfying, and energizing.
    $2.00+
  • Coffee Cake

    $9.45

Drinks

Signature Creations

  • Mike's Mocha

    Introducing the Mike’s Mocha, our irresistible blend of rich caramel and velvety mocha, handcrafted to perfection. A signature favorite that’s bold, sweet, and totally craveable.
    $5.00+
  • Iced Mike's Mocha

    Introducing the Iced Mike’s Mocha, our irresistible blend of rich caramel and velvety mocha, handcrafted to perfection and served over ice. A signature favorite that’s bold, sweet, and totally craveable.
    $5.00+
  • Frozen Mike's Mocha

    A bold blend of espresso, rich chocolate, and smooth caramel—frozen and whipped into a creamy, crave-worthy treat.
    $6.00+
  • Blackberry Cheesecake Iced Latte

    White Chocolate + Cheesecake + Blackberry Cold Foam
    $6.50+
  • Salted Maple Latte

    Rich espresso and creamy milk blended with sweet maple and a touch of salt for a smooth, cozy finish.
    $4.50+
  • Iced Salted Maple Latte

    Espresso, creamy milk, sweet maple, and a touch of salt served over ice for a refreshing twist.
    $5.50+
  • Frozen Salted Maple

    Espresso, maple, and creamy milk blended into a smooth frozen treat with the perfect touch of salt.
    $5.50+

Coffee and Espresso

  • Michael's House Blend

    Fresh brewed coffee
    $3.00+
  • Joe-To-Go - Michael's House Blend

    96oz of our Michael's House Blend Fresh brewed coffee in a Joe-To-Go carrier.
    $24.00
  • Espresso

    Double Shot of Espresso
    $2.50
  • Americano

    Fresh espresso and hot water
    $4.00+
  • Cortado

    Equal parts espresso and steamed milk, served only in 8oz
    $4.50
  • Cappuccino

    Espresso, half steamed milk, half foam
    $4.50+
  • Latte

    Espresso, steamed milk, small layer of foam
    $4.50+
  • Macchiato

    Steamed milk, fresh espresso on top
    $5.00+
  • Cafe Mocha

    Chocolate, espresso, steamed milk
    $5.00+
  • White Mocha

    Creamy white chocolate, espresso, steamed milk
    $5.00+
  • Michael's House Cold Brew

    Smooth, low-acidity coffee slow brewed with cold water to preserve taste and caffeine content, served over ice
    $5.00+
  • Iced Americano

    Fresh espresso and water over ice
    $4.00+
  • Iced Latte

    Espresso, milk, ice
    $4.50+
  • Iced Macchiato

    Milk, ice, fresh espresso layered on top
    $5.00+
  • Iced Cafe Mocha

    Chocolate, espresso, milk, ice
    $5.00+
  • Iced White Mocha

    Creamy white chocolate, espresso, milk, over ice
    $5.00+
  • Frozen Latte

    Espresso, milk, frozen
    $5.50+
  • Frozen Cafe Mocha

    Chocolate, cold brew shots and milk blended together
    $6.00+
  • Frozen White Mocha

    White chocolate, cold brew shots and milk blended together
    $6.00+

Lemonades

  • Classic Lemonade

    Classic, crisp, and perfectly refreshing—our house-made lemonade is the ultimate thirst-quencher.
    $3.00+
  • Strawberry Lemonade

    A bright, fruity blend of strawberry and classic lemonade—sweet, tangy, and made for summer sipping.
    $3.00+
  • Blue Orange Lemonade

    Bright blue, bold orange—this vibrant lemonade surprises with citrusy sweetness and tropical flair.
    $3.00+
  • Lavender Lemonade

    Floral, fragrant, and refreshingly different. A soothing spin on the classic summer sipper.
    $3.00+
  • Half & Half Iced Tea Lemonade

    A perfectly balanced blend of classic iced tea and tart lemonade—refreshing, smooth, and endlessly sippable.
    $3.00+
  • Strawberry Iced Tea Lemonade

    A fruity twist on a favorite—our iced tea lemonade infused with bright strawberry flavor for a sweet, tangy kick.
    $3.00+

Teas and More

  • Harney & Sons Hot Tea

    $3.00+
  • Matcha Latte

    Ground green tea leaves and steamed milk, not pre-sweetened
    $5.00+
  • Chai Latte

    Cinnamon spiced chai tea and steamed milk
    $5.00+
  • Hot Chocolate

    $4.25+
  • Steamer

    Steamed, frothed milk that can be flavored
    $4.00+
  • Iced Matcha Latte

    Ground green tea leaves and milk over ice, not pre-sweetened
    $5.00+
  • Iced Chai Latte

    Cinnamon spiced chai and milk over ice
    $5.00+
  • Iced Tea

    $2.50+
  • Frozen Matcha Latte

    Ground green tea leaves and milk blended together, not pre-sweetened
    $6.00+
  • Frozen Chai Latte

    Cinnamon spiced chai and milk blended together
    $6.00+
  • Frozen Chocolate

    Rich, creamy, and ice-cold—our frozen twist on classic hot chocolate is blended to perfection for a smooth, chocolatey treat you can sip all summer.
    $5.25+

Energies

  • Sliced Apple Energy

    Green apple, club soda, lotus base with a Carmel drizzle.
    $5.50+
  • The Gummy Bear Energy

    Blue-orange, raspberry, and citrus flavors come together in this candy-inspired energy drink topped with gummy bears.
    $5.00+
  • Bubble Yum Energy

    Banana, dragon fruit, and vanilla flavors combine for a nostalgic, candy-inspired energy drink topped with vanilla cold foam.
    $6.00+
  • Cherry Almond Bliss Energy

    Pink Lotus, cherry and almond flavors, finished with a creamy cherry almond cold foam.
    $6.50+
  • Desert Prickly Pear Energy

    Prickly pear and lemonade create a bright, refreshing energy drink with a touch of desert-inspired flavor.
    $5.00+
  • Dragon Chill Energy

    Dragon fruit, raspberry, pineapple, and citrus flavors blended into a tropical energy refresher.
    $5.00+
  • Peachy Blue Energy

    White peach and peach flavors with a refreshing energy boost, finished with blueberry cold foam.
    $6.00+
  • PiƱa Colada Energy

    Pineapple and coconut come together in this island-inspired energy drink, topped with whipped cream and a cherry.
    $5.50+
  • Purple Elixir Energy

    Blueberry, lavender, and vanilla shortbread flavors topped with cheesecake cold foam for a sweet and creamy twist.
    $6.00+

Bottled Drinks

  • Hartzler Vanilla Milk

    12 fl oz, Hartlzer Family Dairy Naturally Flavored Milk
    $3.50
  • Hartzler Chocolate Milk

    12 fl oz, Hartlzer Family Dairy Naturally Flavored Milk
    $3.50
  • Hartzler Strawberry Milk

    12 fl oz, Hartlzer Family Dairy Naturally Flavored Milk
    $3.50
  • Hartlzer Eggnog Milk

    12 fl oz, Hartlzer Family Dairy Naturally Flavored Milk
    $5.00
  • Health-Ade Blueberry Pomegranate Kombucha

    16 fl oz, A delicious natural treat! Kombucha is fermented tea that contains probiotics, healthy organic acids, and just the right amount of bubbles. Taste Sensation: Sweet, tangy, and floral notes. Experience the perfect combination of naturally sweet and deliciously tart. Sweet, rich, and juicy like ripe fruit!
    $5.00
  • Health-Ade Passion Fruit-Tangerine Kombucha

    16 fl oz, A delicious natural treat! Kombucha is fermented tea that contains probiotics, healthy organic acids, and just the right amount of bubbles. Taste Sensation: Fruity, tangy, and floral notes. This dynamic duo of naturally sweet passion fruit and deliciously tart tangerine serves up a well-balanced tropical taste.
    $5.00
  • Health-Ade Pink Lady Apple

    16 fl oz, A delicious natural treat! Kombucha is fermented tea that contains probiotics, healthy organic acids, and just the right amount of bubbles. Taste Sensation: Sweet, tangy, and floral notes. Experience the perfect combination of naturally sweet and deliciously tart. Sweet, rich, and juicy like ripe fruit!
    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00
  • Health-Ade Mango Lemonade

    16 fl oz, A delicious natural treat! Kombucha is fermented tea that contains probiotics, healthy organic acids, and just the right amount of bubbles. Taste Sensation: Sweet, tangy, and floral notes. Experience the perfect combination of naturally sweet and deliciously tart. Sweet, rich, and juicy like ripe fruit!
    $5.00
  • Minute Maid Orange Juice

    10 fl oz, 100% pure squeezed sunshine.
    $2.25
  • Apple & Eve 100% Apple Juice

    10 fl oz, Apple & Eve 100% Apple Juice delivers big fruit flavor without any added sugar. It's a fantastic daily source of Vitamin C, free from artificial flavors or colors
    $2.25
  • Water

    $1.50
  • Coca-Cola

    16.9 fl oz, There's nothing quite like the crisp, refreshing taste of an ice-cold Coca-Cola. Carefully crafted in 1886, Coca-Cola's great taste has stood the test of time.
    $2.50
  • Diet Coke

    16.9 fl oz, Enjoy a break with the one and only Diet Coke. This diet soda is your perfect no-sugar, no-calorie companion. With its bold taste, Diet Coke is an everyday hero when it comes to refreshing your day.
    $2.50
  • Dr. Pepper

    16.9 fl oz, Satisfy your craving for flavor with the unique taste of Dr Pepper! It’s not your ordinary soda and it’s definitely not a cola.
    $2.50
  • Pepsi

    16.9 fl oz, Pepsi - the bold, refreshing, robust cola.
    $2.50
  • Diet Pepsi

    16.9 fl oz, Light. Crisp. Refreshing and 0 calories. Nothing refreshes like a Diet Pepsi.
    $2.50
  • Sprite

    16.9 fl oz, Sprite Lemon Lime
    $2.50
  • Sparkling Orange CELSIUS Energy Drink

    12 fl oz CELSIUSĀ® was created to help people LIVE FIT, exceed their goals and elevate their everyday lives. Made with proven, premium ingredients, 7 Essential Vitamins and zero sugar, no artificial colors, no aspartame, no high fructose corn syrup and non-GMO. CELSIUSĀ® is vegan, gluten-free and Kosher.
    $3.25
  • Sparkling Kiwi Guava CELSIUS Energy Drink

    12 fl oz CELSIUSĀ® was created to help people LIVE FIT, exceed their goals and elevate their everyday lives. Made with proven, premium ingredients, 7 Essential Vitamins and zero sugar, no artificial colors, no aspartame, no high fructose corn syrup and non-GMO. CELSIUSĀ® is vegan, gluten-free and Kosher.
    $3.25
  • Sparkling Wild Berry CELSIUS Energy Drink

    12 fl oz, CELSIUSĀ® was created to help people LIVE FIT, exceed their goals and elevate their everyday lives. Made with proven, premium ingredients, 7 Essential Vitamins and zero sugar, no artificial colors, no aspartame, no high fructose corn syrup and non-GMO. CELSIUSĀ® is vegan, gluten-free and Kosher.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.25

Merch

Shirts

  • T-Shirt 'Best Creamsticks'

    $14.95+
  • T-Shirt 'Michael's Bakery Logo'

    $14.95+

Miscellaneous

  • Michael's Ceramic Mug

    $10.00
  • Michael's Glass Tumbler

    $12.00

Grab & Go

  • Coffee Beans 12oz

    Our House Blend Drip Coffee Beans, ground or whole bean bags, to enjoy at home.
    $12.50

Michael's Bakery Location and Ordering Hours

(330) 682-4648
145 W Market St., Orrville, OH 44667
Closed • Opens Friday at 5:45AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement