Skip to Main content
Milky Way

Your order

‌
‌
‌
‌

Milky Way Cleveland

You can only place scheduled delivery orders.

Popular Items

  • 18" Pizza
    18" Pizza
    $23.95

    Our Largest pizza! Feeds 4-6. Delicious every time

  • Spicy Fries
    Spicy Fries
    $6.95+

    Can't be kosher pizza without Spicy fries.

  • Plain French Fries
    Plain French Fries
    $5.95+

    Shoe string fries. The Milky Way! Fried to a crispy finish, salted to perfection.

Food

Pizza

  • Slices
    $3.50+

    Choose from our freshly baked every day Milky way slices. Always changing always fresh!!

  • 10" Pizza
    $14.95

    Our personal style Milky Way pie. Fresh and delicious every time

  • 14" Pizza
    $18.95

    Hand Crafted. All in House! Milky way Build it your way! Serves 3

  • 18" Pizza
    18" Pizza
    $23.95

    Our Largest pizza! Feeds 4-6. Delicious every time

  • Vegan Pizza
    $18.95+

    Our all Vegan pizza. Handcrafted vegan dough. Freshly grated vegan cheese. Fresh vegan sauce. Customize your pizza with our delicious vegan toppings!

  • Gluten Free 10" Personal Pie
    $14.95

    Our Gluten free thin crust pizza.

Calzones

  • Mushroom Calzone
    $13.95

    Our signature dough. Filled with mushrooms, cheese and sauce. Baked to perfection.

  • Vegetable Calzone
    $13.95

    Our in house signature dough stuffed with tomatoes, green peppers, onions, and of course our house blended cheese.

  • Cheese Calzone
    $13.95

    Our in house made dough stuffed with cheese! Oh so delicious.

  • Create Your Own Calzone
    $15.95

    Got to have it your way. That's the Milky Way! Create your own calzone. Choose up to 4 toppings

Pretzels

  • Plain Pretzel
    Plain Pretzel
    $6.95

    A great Vegan option. Hand braided vegan pretzels. Don't forget to dip it into our in house marinara.

  • Cheese Pretzel
    Cheese Pretzel
    $8.95

    A Milky Way must try! Cheese, Dough, dipping sauce!!!!

  • Spinach and Feta Pretzel
    Spinach and Feta Pretzel
    $9.95

    In house blend of spinach garlic and feta cheese.

  • Garlic and Pepper Jack Pretzel
    Garlic and Pepper Jack Pretzel
    $9.95

    In house blend of garlic and pepper jack cheese. Our one of a kind pretzel!

  • Jalapeño and Schug Pretzel
    Jalapeño and Schug Pretzel
    $9.95

    Hand twisted pretzels filled with jalapeño and schug

Salad and Soups

  • Salad Bar
    Salad Bar
    $15.95
  • Side Of Tuna
    $7.95

    2 Scoops of Tuna served with Lettuce and Tomato

  • Side Of Egg Salad
    $6.95

    2 scoops of Egg salad, served with lettuce and toamto

  • Side of Israeli Salad
    $5.95

    Our in house, hand chopped Israeli salad. (Cucumber, tomato, oil, seasoning)

  • Side of Purple Cabbage Salad
    Side of Purple Cabbage Salad
    $5.95

    Milky Way original recipe, made from scratch.

  • Soup
    Soup
    $5.95+

    All made in house. Handcrafted recipes! We rotate so make sure to try them all!

Fries

  • Plain French Fries
    Plain French Fries
    $5.95+

    Shoe string fries. The Milky Way! Fried to a crispy finish, salted to perfection.

  • Spicy Fries
    Spicy Fries
    $6.95+

    Can't be kosher pizza without Spicy fries.

  • Sweet Potato
    $7.95+
  • Mixed Fries
    Mixed Fries
    $6.95+

Sides & Breads

  • Mozzarella Sticks
    Mozzarella Sticks
    $10.95+

    In house breaded mozzarella sticks.

  • Jalapeno Poppers
    Jalapeno Poppers
    $10.95+

    Cool cream cheese with spicy jalapeno. Breaded and fried! Garlic dipping sauce.

  • Nachos
    $6.95+

    In house made tortilla chips. Smothered in cheddar sauce finished with mozzarella cheese.,

  • Nachos Deluxe
    $9.95+

    In house made tortilla chips. Smothered in cheddar sauce, tomato, red onion, Jalapenos, avocado, with a side of sour cream. Topped with mozzarella cheese

  • Onion Rings
    Onion Rings
    $7.95+

    Crispy on the outside, soft and oniony on the inside.

  • Potato Cigars (10)
    $8.95

    A great Vegan option. Crispy on the outside, soft delicious mashed potato on the inside.

  • Pizza Rolls
    Pizza Rolls
    $3.95+

    Pizza in a roll! so Soft, cheesy, saucy!

  • Bread Sticks
    $8.95

    Milky Way, the only way. Fresh bread sticks made to order. Also vegetarian!

  • Cheese Bread Sticks
    $12.95

    Fresh cheese bread sticks anyone?

  • Garlic Knots
    Garlic Knots
    $0.95+

    You gotta have a garlic knot.

  • Vegetarian Chicken Nuggets
    $9.95

    Chicken nuggets, plain fries. A great kid meal option, and Vegetarian!

  • Side of Hummus with(6) Falafel Balls
    $8.95

    In house made Hummus, in house made falafel balls. How does milky way do it?

  • Falafel Ball (single)
    $1.25

    Try one your going to get another!

  • Bread
    $2.50

    Try one of our in house made breads or pita.

  • Side Secret Sauce
    $0.50

Paninis

  • The "Battleship"
    The "Battleship"
    $14.95

    In house made sub, filled with breaded eggplant, pesto, sundried tomatoes, and cheese. Panini'd.

  • The "Olympus"
    $14.95

    In House baked sub filled with, Black and Green Olives, feta cheese, roasted red peppers, red onion, topped with a balsamic glaze. Panini'd

  • "Holy Guacamole"
    "Holy Guacamole"
    $14.95

    Calling all Avocado Lovers! In house fresh sub filled with FRESH avocado, garlic mayo, tomato and cheese. Panini'd

  • The "Fire Bird"
    The "Fire Bird"
    $14.95

    Wait, spicy chicken and cheese! Yup. In house sub filled with vegetarian chicken, red onion, tomato, Buffalo sauce, ranch drizzle, and cheese. Panini'd

  • The "Easy Caprese"
    The "Easy Caprese"
    $14.95

    In house made sub, marinated fresh mozz, sliced tomato, pesto, and fresh basil leaf. Panini'd. We present, the Easy Caprese

  • "Pop-Eye"
    $14.95

    In house made sub, spinach, feta, garlic mayo, red onion, and balsamic drizzle. Panini'd

  • "Oh My Cod"
    $14.95

    In House sub, freshly fried breaded fish, tartar sauce, tiger sauce, sliced onions, tomato, and American cheese. Panini'd

  • The "Pazzini"
    $14.95

    Fresh sub, in house pizza sauce, cheese, tomato, onion, green pepper. Panini'd

  • "Tunariffic"
    $14.95

    In house sub, filled with tuna, avocado, tomato, and cheese. Panin'd

  • "Terri-Yummy"
    $14.95

    In house sub. Filled with portabella mushrooms, onions, green peppers, teriyaki sauce, tomatoes, and cheese

Sandwiches and Wraps

  • Tuna Salad Sandwich
    Tuna Salad Sandwich
    $10.95

    Our creamy in house made tuna topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles.

  • Egg Salad Sandwich
    Egg Salad Sandwich
    $9.95

    Egg salad topped with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickle.

  • Vegetarian Chicken Sandwich
    Vegetarian Chicken Sandwich
    $11.25

    Vegetarian chicken cutlet, topped with lettuce tomato pickle

  • Tuna Melt
    $12.50

    Our creamy tuna topped with isreali salad and cheese. Melted to perfection. Served IN a sandwich or ON a pita

  • Portabella Mushroom Sandwich
    $11.50Out of stock

    Sautéed portabella mushrooms, caramelized onions and peppers. Seasoned with soy sauce.Topped with lettuce and tomato.

  • Greek Wrap
    $10.95

    Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, black olives, feta cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette served in a wrap of your choice.

  • ALT Wrap
    $10.95

    Avocado, lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo and cheese

  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich
    $9.95

    An American classic! made with American and mozzarella cheese

  • Fried Fish
    $12.95

    Perfectly fried breaded cod. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles, oh and Tartar sauce!

  • Whole Falafel
    Whole Falafel
    $10.95

    Our signature homemade falafel balls, stuffed inside a large pita bread. Accompanied by Israeli salad, purple cabbage, pickles, hummus and tehina.

  • Vegetarian Chicken Avocado Pesto Wrap
    $11.95

Hoagies

  • Tuna Salad Hoagie
    $12.50

    Our creamy in house made tuna, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle

  • Eggplant Parmesan Hoagie
    $13.95

    Our signature breaded eggplant. Layered with marinara sauce and cheese. Melted!

  • ALT Hoagie
    $12.50

    Avocado, lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo and cheese

  • Vegetarian Meatball Hoagie
    $12.75

    Its all Vegan! Our all vegan bread, homemade vegan meatballs topped with caramelized onions and peppers. Glazed with marinara sauce

  • Portabella Hoagie
    $12.50

    Its Vegan! Sautéed portabella mushrooms, onions, peppers. Seasoned with soy sauce. Topped with fresh lettuce and tomato

  • Fried Fish Hoagie
    $13.25

    Breaded Cod fried to perfection. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. Served with a side of tartar sauce.

  • Vegetarian Chicken Hoagie
    $12.75

    Vegan Chicken Cutlet topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle

  • Vegetarian Chicken Parmesan Hoagie
    $13.95

    Vegetarian chicken cutlet topped with marinara sauce and cheese

  • Vegetarian Chicken Avocado Pesto Hoagie
    $13.95

    Its Vegan! Vegetarian chicken cutlet topped with avocado, lettuce, tomato and pesto

Burgers

  • The Impossible Burger
    The Impossible Burger
    $16.95

    An amazing plant based burger served on a toasted pretzel bun. Melted american cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle. Secret sauce finishes it off!

  • The "Cowboy"
    $14.95

    Ranch dressing, onion rings, lettuce, tomato and American cheese

  • The "Fun-Guy"
    $14.95

    Caramelized mushrooms and onions, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and BBQ Sauce

  • The "Dynamite"
    $14.95

    Sliced Jalapenos, crispy onions, pepper jack cheese, Asian ginger hot sauce, and sliced tomato's

  • The "Sweet-Pete"
    $14.95

    Caramelized Onions, sweet potato fries, mozz cheese and Cesar dressing

Entrees

  • Baked Ziti
    $12.95+

    Ziti pasta baked with sauce and cheese

  • Eggplant and Ziti
    $13.95+

    A hybrid. Delicious breaded eggplant crossed with ziti noodles. Sauced and cheese'd

  • Eggplant Parmesan
    $13.95+

    Breaded eggplant layered with sauce and cheese!

  • Falafel Plate
    $13.95

    Its Vegan! Israeli salad, purple cabbage salad, pickles, hummus, tahina, falafel balls and a side of pita bread.

  • Fried Fish Plate
    $14.95

    Breaded cod fried. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, and a side of tartar.

  • Noodles and Cheese
    $12.95+

    Ziti noodles mixed with our homemade cheddar sauce, covered in cheese and baked to perfection

  • Plain Noodles
    $8.95
  • Portabella Melt
    $13.95

    Sautéed portabella mushrooms with onions, peppers, seasoned soy sauce, topped with cheese.

  • Tuna Melt in a TIN(no bread)
    $14.95

    Creamy tuna, topped with Israeli salad, and cheese. Melted to perfection

  • Vegetarian Chicken Parmesan
    $13.95

    Vegetarian Chicken mixed with ziti noodles sauce and cheese

  • Vegetarian Meatball Parmesean
    $14.95

    Vegetarian meatballs served with caramelized onions and peppers, finished with marinara sauce and cheese!

Combos

  • Combo 1 - 2 Slices FF
    $14.95

    2 Slices of pizza. Your choice of plain, spicy or mixed fries. Also a fountain drink

  • Combo 2 - Fish FF Hoagie
    $19.95

    Fried fish hoagie with fries of your choice, and a fountain drink.

  • Combo 3 - Burger FF
    $18.95

    Vegy Burger with your choice of fries and a drink

  • Combo 4 - Soup & Roll
    $9.95

    Soup of your choice and a roll. Also a fountain drink

  • Combo 5 - Veg Ckn FF
    $17.95

    Vegy chicken sandwich your choice of fries and a drink

  • Combo 6 - Falafel FF
    $17.95

    Whole falafel, your choice of fries and a fountain drink

  • Combo 7 - Pie Family FF
    $34.95

    1-18" plain cheese pizza. Choice of a family fries.

  • Combo 8 - 2 Pies Family plain/spicy FF
    $66.95

    2-18" Plain cheese pizza, 1 family fries plain, 1 spicy family fries.

Desserts

  • Ice Cream
    $3.95+
  • Soft serve Sundae cup
    $7.95
  • Milkshake
    $9.95

    Its a Milky way Classic!

For Limited Time Only

  • Mac N' Cheese Bombs
    $9.95+Out of stock

    Its all from scratch. Mac n' cheese breaded and fried.

  • Avocado Eggrolls
    $6.95+Out of stock

    Fresh guacamole rolled into a eggroll wrapper.

  • Potato Knish
    $3.95+

All Day Brunch

Bagels

  • Single
    $1.50
  • Half Dozen
    $9.00
  • Baker's Dozen
    $18.00

Bagel Sandwiches

  • Bagel W/ Lox & Cream Cheese
    $9.95
  • Cream Cheese Bagel
    $4.25
  • Egg Salad Bagel
    $6.95
  • Eggs on a Bagel
    $6.95
  • Tuna Salad Bagel
    $7.95

Sourdough Toasts

  • Avocado Toast
    $14.95

    Our in house baked sourdough. Toasted to perfection. Topped with freshly diced avocado, tomato, red onion and feta cheese. Seasoned with olive oil salt and pepper. Topped with a sunny side up

  • Sabich Toast
    $14.95

    Our in house baked sourdough bread. Toasted to perfection. A light schmear of our in house hummus, schug. Topped with fried eggplant, Israeli salad, and a fried egg. Drizzled with Tahini


DRINKS

Cold Drinks

  • Fountain Soda
    Fountain Soda
    $2.95
  • 20 Oz Bottle
    20 Oz Bottle
    $2.95
  • Gatorade
    Gatorade
    $2.95
  • Snapple
    Snapple
    $2.95
  • Seltzer Can
    Seltzer Can
    $1.95
  • Chocolate Milk 12 Oz

  • Chocolate Milk 12 Oz
    Chocolate Milk 12 Oz
    $3.95
  • Orange Juice (small)
    $3.50
  • 2-Liter
    $4.95
  • Milkshake
    $9.95
  • Coffee Shake
    $11.50
  • Small Slushy 12 Oz
    $4.95
  • Naked Smoothie
    $3.95

Coffee Drinks

  • Hot Coffee
    Hot Coffee
    $3.50
  • Iced coffee
    Iced coffee
    $3.95
  • Hot Latte
    Hot Latte
    $5.95
  • Iced Latte
    $5.95
  • Cappuccino
    $5.95
  • Hot Tea
    $2.95
  • Espresso Shot
    $2.95
  • Hot Chocolate
    $5.95

Milky Way Location and Ordering Hours

(216) 417-4202
1982 warrensville center rd, cleveland, OH 44121
Open now • Closes at 8PM
Order online
This site is powered byToast logo
Terms of Service | Privacy Statement