New York Super Subs Squirrel Hill
Subs
- Regular Italian (whole)$20.95
Classic Italian with provolone, ham capicola, salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & oregano and our special pepper relish.
- House Super Special (whole)$22.95
Classic Italian with provolone, ham capicola, salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & oregano and our special pepper relish. With 30% more meat and cheese than the regular Italian.
- Steak (whole)$24.95
Real prime rib meat with sauteed mushrooms, peppers and onions.
- Cheese Steak (whole)$24.95
Real prime rib meat with provolone, sauteed mushrooms, peppers and onions.
- Turkey (whole)$20.95
Deli Turkey with provolone lettuce and tomato.
- Hot Sausage (whole)$22.95
Local Hot Sausage from Henry Grasso in our homemade sauce with sautéed peppers & onions.
- Genoa Salami (whole)$20.95
Salami with provolone, lettuce and tomato.
- Tuna Fish (whole)$20.95
Generous scoops of tuna with lettuce and tomato.
- Chicken Salad (whole)$20.95
Generous scoops of homemade chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.
- Cheese (whole)$16.95
American and provolone cheese with lettuce and tomato.
- Veggie (whole)$18.95
Sauteed mushrooms, onions and peppers with sauteed spinach & garlic as well as provolone, lettuce, raw onion and tomato.
- Pepper & Egg (whole)$18.95
Scrambled eggs with sauteed peppers and american cheese.
- Boiled Ham (whole)$20.95
Ham with provolone, lettuce and tomato.
- Xtra Meat$6.00
- City Bag Fee$0.10
- Grilled Chicken (whole)$22.95
Fresh cut chicken with provolone, lettuce and tomato.
- Chicken Florentine (whole)$22.95
Fresh cut chicken with provolone, sauteed spinach and garlic with hollandaise sauce.
- Chicken Cacciatore (whole)$22.95
Fresh cut chicken with sauteed peppers, onions and mushrooms with red sauce and provolone cheese.
- Buffalo Chicken (whole)$22.95
Fresh cut chicken with buffalo sauce and provolone cheese.
- Chicken Cheese Steak (whole)$22.95
Fresh cut chicken chopped up with sauteed onions, mushrooms, green peppers and provolone cheese.
- CHICKEN BACON RANCH$25.95
- Antoinette's Italian (whole)$20.95
A classic Italian beef meatball.
- Lisa Calabrese (whole)$20.95
A special spicy beef and sausage meatball.
- Stuffed Pepper (whole)$20.95
A beef and sausage meatball with peppers and onions baked in. Like eating a stuffed pepper in one bite.
- Regular Italian (half)$10.95
Classic Italian with provolone, ham capicola, salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & oregano and our special pepper relish.
- House Super Special (half)$11.95
Classic Italian with provolone, ham capicola, salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & oregano and our special pepper relish. With 30% more meat and cheese than the regular Italian.
- Steak (half)$12.95
Real prime rib meat with sauteed mushrooms, peppers and onions.
- Cheese Steak (half)$12.95
Real prime rib meat with provolone, sauteed mushrooms, peppers and onions.
- Turkey (half)$10.95
Deli Turkey with provolone lettuce and tomato.
- Hot Sausage (half)$11.95
Local Hot Sausage from Henry Grasso in our homemade sauce with sautéed peppers & onions.
- Genoa Salami (half)$10.95
Salami with provolone, lettuce and tomato.
- Tuna Fish (half)$10.95
Generous scoops of tuna with lettuce and tomato.
- Chicken Salad (half)$10.95
Generous scoops of homemade chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.
- Cheese (half)$8.95
American and provolone cheese with lettuce and tomato.
- Veggie (half)$9.95
Sauteed mushrooms, onions and peppers with sauteed spinach & garlic as well as provolone, lettuce, raw onion and tomato.
- Pepper & Egg (half)$9.95
Scrambled eggs with sauteed peppers and american cheese.
- Boiled Ham (half)$10.95
Ham with provolone, lettuce and tomato.
- Xtra Meat$3.00
- City Bag Fee$0.10
- Grilled Chicken (half)$11.45
Fresh cut chicken with provolone, lettuce and tomato.
- Chicken Florentine (half)$11.45
Fresh cut chicken with provolone, sauteed spinach and garlic with hollandaise sauce.
- Chicken Cacciatore (half)$11.45
Fresh cut chicken with sauteed peppers, onions and mushrooms with red sauce and provolone cheese.
- Buffalo Chicken (half)$11.45
Fresh cut chicken with buffalo sauce and provolone cheese.
- Chicken Cheese Steak (half)$11.45
Fresh cut chicken chopped up with sauteed onions, mushrooms, green peppers and provolone cheese.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch$13.45
- Antoinette's Italian (half)$10.25
A classic Italian beef meatball.
- Lisa Calabrese (half)$10.25
A special spicy beef and sausage meatball.
- Stuffed Pepper (half)$10.25
A beef and sausage meatball with peppers and onions baked in. Like eating a stuffed pepper in one bite.
Deli
- Deli Sandwich$8.95
Any of our subs as a quarter pound sandwich with choice of bread and 2 sides.
- Reuben$14.95
½ lb Corned beef on toasted rye with sauerkraut, swiss and thousand island.
- Cold Corned Beef$14.95
½ lb Corned beef on rye with swiss, lettuce, tomato and dijon.
- Pastrami$14.95
½ lb Grilled Pastrami on rye with swiss and dijon.
- Long Island BLT$9.95
Bacon, lettuce and tomato with provolone.
- Tuna Salad Sandwich$8.95
Tuna with Cheese, lettuce & tomato.
- Chicken Salad Sandwich$8.95
Homemade chicken salad with lettuce & tomato.
- 1/2 lb. Upper West Side$10.95
1/2 Pound Blend with american cheese, lettuce and tomato.
- 1/4 lb. Lower East Side$7.95
1/4 Pound Blend with american cheese, lettuce and tomato.
- Beyond Burger$11.95
A Veggie Burger made with Beyond Meat. Delicious and meatless. Comes with american cheese, lettuce and tomato.
- Veggie Sandwich$8.95
Sauteed mushrooms, onions and peppers with sauteed spinach & garlic as well as provolone, lettuce, raw onion and tomato.
- Deli Sand. Quarter Size For NO SIDES ONLY$7.95
- City Bag Fee$0.10
Seafood
- Boston Lobster Roll$16.95Out of stock
Coldwater Northern lobster with butter and lemon.
- Maryland Crab Sandwich$12.95
Homemade breaded Crab Cake with a splash of lemon.
- Lobster Salad$16.95Out of stock
Lobster on a bed of lettuce, tomato, onion and spinach. Choice of dressing.
- Crab Cake Salad$12.95
Homemade crabcake on a bed of lettuce, tomato, onion and spinach. Choice of dressing.
Sides
- X Small Chips$1.00
Variety of individual chip bags.
- Dill Pickle$1.99
Large deli style dill pickle.
- Cole Slaw$0.65+
Fresh made Cole slaw.
- Potato Salad$0.65+
Fresh made potato salad,
- Utz Small$2.49
- Battered French Fries$3.25
- Mac N Cheese$3.75+Out of stock
- Home Fries$4.00Out of stock
- Home Fries With Cheese$4.50
- Small Pasta Salad$4.00Out of stock
- Medium Pasta Salad$8.00Out of stock
Drinks
Bakery
- Cannoli$1.99
A special recipe using mascarpone mixed with our own bakery cream.
- Brownie$4.25
Iced or peanut butter fresh baked brownies.
- Peanut Butter Brownie$4.25
- Eclair$3.50
A classic pastry filled with Bavarian cream and topped with fudge.
- Strawberry Shortcake$5.25
Delicious vanilla cake with strawberry filling.
- Triple Chocolate Cake$5.25
Dense chocolate cake with silky dark chocolate icing.
- Tiramisu$4.50
A delicious classic Italian dessert.
- Lemon Bar (GLUTEN FREE)$2.35Out of stock
- Potato Chip Cookie (3pack)$4.00Out of stock
- old fasion donut$2.25
Salad
Ala Carte
- Chicken Salad$4.00+
Our homemade Chicken salad.
- Tuna Salad$6.00+
Our homemade Tuna salad
- Crabcake$11.95
Individual serving of our homemade Crabcake
- Meatball$2.25
Individual homemade meatballs.
- Gluten Free Bun$1.79
- BENJIE CHIX$5.50
- Chili 16oz$8.00
- chili 8oz$4.50
- Soup 8 Ounce$4.25Out of stock
4 oz portion of our coldwater Lobster.
- Soup 16ounce$8.00Out of stock
- Soup 32oz$11.90Out of stock
- chili cheese fries$6.00
- cheese sauce$0.75
Sauces & Packets
- Sweet Pepper Mayo Mayonnaise$0.59
Mayonnaise with a jolt of roasted red peppers.
- Spicy Pepper Mayo Mayonnaise$0.59
Mayonnaise with a kick of our special pepper relish.
- Dijonaise Mayonnaise$0.59
Mayonnaise with a blast of Dijon mustard and a hot sauce kicker.
- 1000 Island$0.59
A classic 1000 Island recipe.
- Hollandaise$0.59
Bright lemony flavored white sauce.
- Tomato Vinaigrette$0.59
The perfect blend of tomato, oil and spices. Tastes like Pittsburgh.
- Ranch Dressing Packet$0.39
Packet of Ranch dressing.
- Bleu Cheese Dressing Packet$0.39
Packet of Bleu Cheesedressing.
- Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing Packet$0.39
Packet of Balsamic Vinaigrette dressing.
- Italian Dressing Packet$0.39
Packet of Italian dressing.
- Dijon$0.59
- Pappy’s Fish Sauce$0.59Out of stock
Tartar Sauce with quite a bit more kick!
- Tartar Sauce$0.59
A salvaged recipe from an iconic Pittsburgh fish store, gone but not forgotten.