Skip to Main content
  • Old Town Pizza

Currently not accepting online orders

Old Town Pizza 691 Old Town Rd

691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY
Main Menu
Monthly Specials
Pizza Menu
Soft Drinks

Featured Items

  • Thai Chili Pizzette

    Crispy chicken, Thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheddar blend, green onion, sesame seeds.
    $16.95
  • Burrata and Meatball Pizzette

    Chunks of homemade meatball, fresh burrata, marinara sauce, whole milk mozzarella, and hot honey drizzle.
    $17.95
  • Pasta Fagioli

    Crushed Italian tomato broth, garlic, cannellini beans, basil, and ditalini pasta
    $7.50

Main Menu

Fast Service

  • Small Fountain Soda

    $2.85
  • Large Fountain Soda

    $3.50
  • 20 OZ SODA

    $3.49
  • Bottle Water

    $2.50
  • Garlic Knots

  • Slice

    $3.45
  • Sicilian Slice

    $3.65
  • Grandma Slice

    $3.65
  • Brooklyn Slice

    $4.35
  • Marinara Slice

    $4.00
  • Specialty Slice

    $6.00
  • Salad Slice

    $6.50
  • Specialty Salad Slice

    $7.50
  • Grandma Vodka Slice

    $3.90
  • Deep Dish Slice

    $6.00
  • Pinwheels

  • Italian Sliders

    $3.25
  • Italian Siders

  • Chicken Caesar Counter

    $9.95
  • Buffalo Knots

  • Side of Tomato Sauce

    $1.50
  • Cinna Knots

  • Side of Dressing

    $1.75
  • Extra Dressing

    $1.95
  • Side of Hot Honey

    $2.75
  • Rice Ball

  • Side of Vodka Sauce

    $1.50
  • Cheese Stick

    $1.50
  • Bottle of House Dressing

    $6.95
  • Large Pellegrino

    $5.75
  • Potato Croquet

  • Capelini Cake

Rolls

  • Calzone

    $9.50
  • Buffalo Chicken Roll

    $9.50
  • Chicken Roni Vodka Roll

    $9.50
  • Chicken Parm Roll

    $9.50
  • Eggplant Rollatini Roll

    $9.50
  • Meatball Parm Roll

    $9.50
  • Sausage Pepper Onion Roll

    $9.50
  • Sausage Pepperoni Stromboli

    $9.50
  • Spinach Broccoli Roll

    $9.50
  • Spinach Ricotta Roll

    $9.50
  • Pizzone

    Sausage, pepperoni, meatball, pizza sauce, whole milk mozzarella.
    $9.50
  • Mama Mia Roll

    Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, red roasted peppers, pesto, and balsamic reduction.
    $9.50
  • Chicken Cowboy Roll

    Crispy chicken, BBQ, bacon, onion, and cheddar cheese blend.
    $9.50
  • Chicken Marsala Roll

    $9.50
  • Family Calzone

    $27.95

Appetizers

  • Baked Clams

    $12.95
  • Burrata and Meatballs

    $14.95
  • Caccio Pepe Balls

    (4) fried Italian mac & cheese balls "spaghetti, ricotta, mozzarella & pecorino romano cheese crispy fried served with alfredo & tomato dipping sauces."
    $12.95
  • Chicken Finger Platter

    $12.95
  • Crispy Artichoke

    (8) Crispy panko-coated baby artichoke hearts served with horseradish aioli.
    $12.95
  • 6 Classic Wings

    $10.95
  • 10 Boneless Wings

    $10.95
  • Cauliflower Wings

    $10.95
  • Garlic Bread

    $4.95
  • Fried Calamari

    $16.95
  • French Fries

    $5.95
  • Garlic Mozzarella Pearls

    Fresh mozzarella pearls coated in Italian breadcrumbs and crispy fried, served with tomato dipping sauce.
    $12.95
  • Italian Shrimp Cocktail

    $14.95
  • Mini Cheese Fried Ravioli

    $11.95
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    $10.95
  • Mussels APP

    $16.95
  • Rice Ball Parm

    $8.95
  • Zucchini Fries

    $11.95
  • Italiano Quesadillas

    Chopped crispy chicken, arugula, fontina, fig jam, crispy prosciutto, caramelized onions, sweet balsamic drizzle, served with garlic aioli dipping sauce and a choice of fries or chips
    $15.95
  • Chicken Quesadilla

    $13.95
  • Shrimp Quesdailla

    $16.95

Soup

  • Chicken Noodle

    Shredded chicken breast, celery, carrot, onion, chicken broth, and noodles.
    $7.50
  • Chicken Pastina

    Shredded chicken, pastina, vegetable brodino, and pecorino Romano cheese
    $7.50
  • Vegetable Minestrone

    Red beans, ditalini pasta, tomato broth, assorted chopped vegetables
    $7.50
  • Pasta Fagioli

    Crushed Italian tomato broth, garlic, cannellini beans, basil, and ditalini pasta
    $7.50
  • Italian Wedding

    Spinach, meatball, beef broth, egg drop, Romano cheese.
    $7.50
  • Stracciatella Romano

    $7.50+

Salad

  • Antipasto Salad

    Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, salami, ham, pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, artichoke, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette.
    $11.95
  • Beet & Goat Cheese Salad

    Mixed greens & baby arugula, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, crumbled goat cheese, roasted red beets, red onions, served with balsamic vinaigrette.
    $12.95
  • Buffalo Chicken Salad

    Buffalo chicken, iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette
    $10.95
  • Burrata Salad

    Arugula, tomato, roasted pepper, dried cranberries, toasted almonds, balsamic reduction, topped with burrata.
    $12.95
  • Burrata & Tomato Salad

    Arugula, vine-ripened sliced tomato, roasted peppers, creamy burrata, and balsamic fig glaze.
    $10.95
  • Caesar Salad

    Chopped romaine heart, homestyle crouton, shaved asiago cheese, creamy Tuscan Caesar dressing.
    $9.95
  • Caprese Salad

    Sliced fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, garnished with roasted red peppers, kalamata olive, pesto, and balsamic reduction.
    $11.95
  • Campania Salad

    Romaine, crispy chicken, crumbled bacon, cherry tomato, chick peas, broccoli, candied pecan, shredded cheddar jack blend, croutons, honey dijon dressing
    $12.95
  • Crispy Chicken Salad

    Crispy chicken, iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette
    $10.95
  • Grilled Chicken Salad

    Grilled chicken, iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette
    $10.95
  • Greek Salad

    Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, stuffed grape leaves, feta cheese, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette.
    $10.95
  • Italian Cobb Salad

    Romaine, cherry tomato, red onion, crispy prosciutto chips, crumbled gorgonzola cheese, grilled chicken, chick peas, house balsamic vinaigrette.
    $12.95
  • Italian Salad

    Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette
    $8.95
  • Mediterranean Salad

    Mixed greens, grilled shrimp, cherry tomato, bell peppers, chick peas, red onion, feta cheese, tomato vinaigrette.
    $12.95
  • Monterey Salad

    Baby spinach, candied pecan, mandarin oranges, fresh strawberries, shredded Monterey cheese, and house balsamic vinaigrette.
    $11.95
  • Orange Almondine Salad

    Baby arugula, mandarin oranges, sliced almonds, crumbled goat cheese & mandarin orange dressing.
    $13.95
  • Pizzeria Salad

    Iceberg romaine blend, cherry tomato, cucumber, shredded mozzarella cheese, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette.
    $9.95
  • Roma Steak Salad

    Romaine, grilled flank steak, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted peppers, red onion, and balsamic vinaigrette.
    $13.95
  • Strawberry Fields Salad

    Mixed greens, grilled chicken, strawberries, grape tomatoes, toasted almonds, crumbled feta cheese, and raspberry vinaigrette.
    $12.95
  • Spinach Gorgonzola Salad

    Baby spinach, cherry tomato, crumbled gorgonzola, candied pecan, sun-dried cranberries, and raspberry vinaigrette.
    $12.95

Hot Heroes

  • Meatball Parm Hero

    $13.95
  • Meatball Hero No Cheese

    $13.50
  • Chicken Cutlet Parm Hero

    $13.95
  • Chicken Cutlet Hero No Cheese

    $13.95
  • Sausage Parm Hero

    $13.95
  • Sausage Hero No Cheese

    $13.50
  • Sausage and Meatball Parm Hero

    $12.95
  • Sausage and Meatball Hero No Cheese

    $12.95
  • Veal Cutlet Parm Hero

    $15.95
  • Veal Cutlet Hero No Cheese

    $15.50
  • Sausage and Peppers Parm Hero

    $12.95
  • Sausage and Peppers Hero No Cheese

    $12.95
  • Eggplant Parm Hero

    $12.95
  • Eggplant Hero No Cheese

    $12.95
  • Grilled Chicken Parm Hero

    $13.95
  • Grilled Chicken Hero No Cheese

    $13.95
  • Shrimp Parm Hero

    $15.95
  • Shrimp Hero No Cheese

    $15.95
  • Chicken Marsala Parm Hero

    $15.95
  • Chicken Marsala Hero No Cheese

    $15.95
  • Frittata Hero

    $12.95
  • Chicken Cheesesteak Hero

    $14.95
  • Potato And Egg Hero

    $12.95

Pasta

  • Baked Penne

    Penne pasta, ricotta, tomato sauce, and melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $17.95
  • Pasta alla Vodka

    $19.50
  • Pasta Alfredo

    Fettuccine pasta, parmesan cream sauce • Add Chicken or Shrimp +$6.00
    $17.95
  • Pasta Tomato Sauce

    $16.95
  • Braised Bolognese

    Fresh pappardelle pasta, red wine braised ground beef & veal in a slow-cooked tomato sauce • Add Fresh ricotta +$2.00
    $17.95
  • Stuffed Shells

    $17.95
  • Pasta Carbonara

    Penne pasta, pancetta, mushrooms, peas, onions, Romano cheese cream sauce • Add Chicken or Shrimp +$6.00
    $18.95
  • Sunday Pasta

    Rigatoni pasta, oven-roasted Italian sausage, meatball & braised pork in an old school Italian tomato sauce, topped with warm ricotta.
    $20.95
  • Authentic Lasagna

    $17.95
  • Pasta di Christina

    Whole wheat penne, grilled chicken, baby spinach, pink Cadillac sauce, and melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $19.95
  • Nonnos Gnocchi

    Potato gnocchi pasta, ground beef and veal meat sauce, touch of cream • Add Ricotta +$3.00
    $18.95
  • Cavatelli Sicilia

    Fresh cavatelli pasta, crumbled Italian sausage, shallots, green peas, pink tomato cream sauce, and Romano cheese.
    $20.50
  • Mac and Cheese Italiano

    Ditalini pasta, white cheddar, fontina, pecorino, melted whole milk mozzarella, toasted Italian bread crumbs • Add crispy chicken tenders +$6.00
    $18.95
  • Pesto Pasta Purses

    6 cheese sacchettini pasta, pesto cream sauce • Add Grilled chicken or Shrimp +$6.00
    $20.95
  • Harvest Tortellini

    Cheese tortellini pasta, crumbled sausage, baby spinach, roasted tomato, roasted garlic cream sauce.
    $19.95
  • Stuffed Rigatoni

    Ricotta-filled rigatoni, braised ground beef, tomato sauce, a touch of cream, and melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $20.50
  • Pasta with Garlic and Oil

    $16.95
  • Borsette Romano

    $19.95
  • Blackened Salmon Pasta

    Penne pasta, shaved asparagus, oven-roasted cherry tomato, baby spinach, lemon dill cream sauce, chunks of blackened salmon, topped with scampi bread crumbs.
    $21.95
  • Farm to Table

    Fresh orecchiette pasta, chicken, broccoli, oven-roasted tomato, artichoke, kalamata olive, roasted garlic white wine sauce.
    $19.95
  • Pasta Chicken Gorgonzola

    Chicken, truffle mushrooms, arugula, gorgonzola cream sauce, orecchiette pasta.
    $19.95
  • Stuffed Rigatoni

    $19.95
  • Stuffed Rigatoni Florentina

    $19.95

Panini

  • Cittero

    Ham, burrata cheese, sliced tomato, and arugula.
    $13.95
  • Chicken Florentina

    Grilled or crispy chicken, burrata, baby spinach, sliced tomatoes, roasted garlic aioli, and balsamic reduction.
    $13.95
  • Mama Mia

    Crispy chicken, grilled chicken, or fire-roasted turkey, fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, tomato, basil, and balsamic reduction.
    $13.95
  • Bella Donna

    Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella, broccoli rabe, tomato, red roasted peppers, pesto, balsamic reduction, and balsamic dressing.
    $13.95
  • The Club

    Crispy chicken, grilled chicken, or fire-roasted turkey, American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
    $13.95
  • Chicken Ranch

    Crispy or grilled chicken, melted American, ranch, bacon, and tomato.
    $13.95
  • Chicken Guido

    Crispy or grilled chicken, broccoli rabe, cherry peppers, and melted provolone.
    $13.95
  • Little Italy

    Broccoli rabe, burrata, tomato, prosciutto, balsamic glaze.
    $13.95
  • Portobello Capri

    Grilled marinated portobello caps, baby spinach, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, red roasted peppers, pesto, balsamic reduction • Add Chicken +$3.00
    $13.95
  • Italiano

    Salami, ham, prosciutto, pepperoni, provolone, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, red roasted peppers, red onion, oil & vinegar.
    $13.95
  • Barca

    Crispy Italian breaded flounder, melted mozzarella, arugula, tomato, Tuscan lemon garlic aioli.
    $13.95
  • Flank Steak

    Grilled marinated flank steak, caramelized onions, mushrooms, melted provolone
    $13.95
  • Chicken Caesar

    Grilled or crispy chicken, chopped romaine, shaved asiago, caesar dressing.
    $13.95
  • Chicken Paisano

    Grilled or crispy chicken, crispy prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, arugula, tomato, house vinaigrette.
    $13.95
  • The Goat

    Grilled or crispy chicken, goat cheese, arugula, red roasted peppers, tomato, and fig jam.
    $13.95
  • The Avenue

    Grilled or crispy chicken, breaded eggplant, burrata, garlic aioli, pesto, red roasted peppers, arugula, and balsamic reduction.
    $13.95
  • The Hot Chic

    Grilled or crispy chicken, spicy vodka, grilled pepperoni, mozzarella melt, and sriracha honey.
    $13.95
  • The PLT

    Sliced prosciutto, leaf lettuce, sliced tomato, burrata smash, and roasted garlic aioli.
    $13.95
  • Angry Nonna

    Grilled or crispy chicken, spicy marinara, cherry peppers, melted mozzarella, and Calabrian chili oil drizzle.
    $13.95
  • Balsamico Chicken

    Balsamic grilled or crispy chicken, baby spinach, tomato, burrata, mozzarella, and balsamic reduction.
    $13.95
  • The Belitza

    Crispy or grilled chicken, spinach, tomato, melted mozzarella, feta, red onion, oil, and vinegar.
    $13.95
  • Chicken Buffalo

    Crispy or grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, melted mozzarella, tomato, and blue cheese.
    $13.95

Chicken

  • Chicken Cutlet Parm Dinner

    Tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $20.95
  • Chicken Cutlet Carbonara

    Pancetta, onion, peas, Parmesan cream sauce.
    $21.95
  • Chicken Francese

    Egg battered, lemon, white wine sauce.
    $21.95
  • Chicken Marsala

    Cremini & button mushrooms, marsala demi.
    $21.95
  • Chicken Martini

    Panko parmesan crusted, hot cherry peppers, chopped broccoli rabe, lemon white wine sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $22.95
  • Chicken Vodka Parm Dinner

    House vodka sauce, melted fresh mozzarella, and pecorino cheese.
    $21.95
  • Grilled Chicken Parm Dinner

    Marinara sauce, melted mozzarella, and Fresh basil.
    $20.95
  • Chicken Milanese

    Panko-crusted, topped with mixed greens, tomato, red onion, roasted pepper, and shredded cold mozzarella.
    $22.95

Veal and Eggplant

  • Veal Carbonara

    Pancetta, onion, peas, Parmesan cream sauce.
    $23.95
  • Veal Milanese

    Panko-crusted, topped with mixed greens, tomato, red onion, roasted pepper, and shredded cold mozzarella.
    $24.95
  • Veal Marsala

    Cremini & button mushrooms, marsala demi.
    $23.95
  • Veal Cutlet Parm Dinner

    Tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $22.95
  • Veal Martini

    Panko parmesan crusted, hot cherry peppers, chopped broccoli rabe, lemon white wine sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $24.95
  • Veal Francese

    Egg battered, lemon, white wine sauce.
    $23.95
  • Veal Vodka Parm Dinner

    House vodka sauce, melted fresh mozzarella, and pecorino cheese.
    $23.95
  • Eggplant Parm Dinner

    Skinless breaded eggplant, tomato sauce, and melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $18.95
  • Eggplant Rollatini Dinner

    Skinless breaded eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce, and melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $19.95

Ravioli

  • Cheese Ravioli

    Ricotta-filled ravioli, tomato sauce, and melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $16.95
  • Beef Short Rib Ravioli

    Short rib & ricotta-filled ravioli, cremini mushrooms, madeira wine demi.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $21.95
  • Lobster Ravioli

    Lobster & ricotta-filled ravioli served in a pink sauce with chopped shrimp & asparagus.
    $22.95

Sides

  • Side Meatballs

    $8.95
  • Side Sliced Sausage

    $7.95
  • Side Chicken Cutlet

    $8.95
  • Side Grilled Chicken

    $8.95
  • Side Mac Italiano

    $10.95
  • Side Broccoli

    $7.95
  • Side Broccoli Rabe

    $8.95
  • Side Spinach

    $7.95
  • Side Mixed Vegetables

    $7.95
  • Side Pasta

    $7.95
  • Plain Bread

    $2.75
  • Side Roasted Potato

    $7.95
  • Side Asparagus

    $7.95
  • Side Grilled Shrimp

    $12.95
  • Side Grated Cheese

    $1.95
  • Side of Ricotta

    $3.00
  • Small Side of Mozzarella

    $1.95
  • Side of Anchovy

    $1.95
  • Side Risotto

    $9.95
  • Side Salmon

    $13.95

From the Grill

  • Fire Grilled Balsamic Chicken

    Grilled balsamic chicken served with broccoli rabe & cherry peppers.
    $20.95
  • Fire Grilled Flank Steak

    Grilled marinated flank with onions and mushrooms over sauteed baby spinach, topped with melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $22.95
  • Fire Grilled Shrimp

    Jumbo grilled shrimp served with roasted broccoli, asparagus & carrots.
    $22.95
  • Fire Grilled Salmon

    Lightly seasoned salmon served with roasted broccoli, asparagus & carrots.
    $23.95
  • Blackened Salmon and Jumbo Shrimp

    Blackened salmon & jumbo shrimp served with garlic cream spinach.
    $29.95

Burgers

  • Americano Burger

    American Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion
    $9.95
  • Italiano Burger

    Topped With 2 Mozzarella Sticks, Melted Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce, Garlic Bun
    $10.95
  • Diavolo Burger

    Melted Cheddar, Jalapeno, Spicy Ranch, Lettuce, Tomato
    $9.95
  • Fuoco Burger

    Topped With Barbecue Sauce, Melted American Cheese, Bacon, Crispy Potato Chips
    $10.95
  • Cipolla Burger

    Caramelized Onion, Horseradish Aioli, Melted Provolone
    $10.95
  • Black & Blue Burger

    Cajun Seasoned Crusted, Bacon, Blue Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato
    $11.95

Kids Menu

  • Kids Chicken Fingers and Fries

    $12.95
  • Kids Ravioli (3)

    $9.95
  • Kids Penne Pasta

    $6.95
  • Kids Mac $ Cheese

    $10.95

Seafood

  • Calamari Marinara

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $20.95
  • Calamari Bianco

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $20.95
  • Calamari Fra Diavlo

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $20.95
  • Shrimp Marinara

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $20.95
  • Shrimp Bianco

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $20.95
  • Shrimp Fra Diavlo

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $20.95
  • Mussels Marinara

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $21.50
  • Mussels Bianco

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $21.50
  • Mussels Fra Diavlo

    Served with a choice of pasta
    $21.50
  • Linguini with White Clam Sauce

    Chopped fresh L.I. clams & whole baby clams, roasted garlic, chardonnay wine, fresh basil, served with linguine pasta.
    $19.95
  • Linguini with Red Clam Sauce

    Chopped fresh L.I. clams & whole baby clams, roasted garlic, chardonnay wine, fresh basil, served with linguine pasta.
    $19.95
  • Shrimp Scampi

    Broiled jumbo shrimp, roasted garlic, lemon, white wine sauce, toasted breadcrumbs, served over a choice of pasta.
    $21.95
  • Shrimp Parmigiana Dinner

    Breaded jumbo shrimp, tomato sauce, melted whole milk mozzarella.
    $21.95
  • Cadillac Shrimp

    Shrimp, shaved asparagus, artichoke, pink tomato cream sauce, shaved asiago cheese garnish served over penne pasta.
    $21.95
  • Zuppa Di Pesce

    Chopped shrimp, clams, & calamari, touch of tomato, basil, roasted garlic, white wine sauce, linguine pasta.
    $22.95
  • Salmon Crostino

    Panko parmesan crusted salmon, light dill creamy sauce, served with vegetables and a choice of pasta or risotto.
    $23.95
  • Calabrian Salmon

    Calabrian chili-glazed salmon, served with vegetables and a choice of pasta or risotto.
    $23.95
  • Tuscan Salmon

    Blackened salmon, oven-roasted tomato, artichoke, beurre blanc sauce, served over wilted garlic spinach.
    $25.50
  • Flounder Milanese

    Pan-fried breaded flounder topped with mixed greens, tomato, red onion, kalamata olive, roasted red pepper, shredded whole milk mozzarella, balsamic reduction, served with mixed v
    $24.95
  • Seafood Fra Diavlo

    Shrimp, mussels, calamari, clams, spicy marinara, served over linguine pasta.
    $24.95

Specialty

  • Steak Pizzaiola

    Grilled flank steak, tri-color bell peppers, caramelized onion, melted whole milk mozzarella, and sherry plum tomato sauce.
    $23.50
  • Chicken Arrabbiata

    Crispy chicken cutlets, grilled pepperoni, spicy vodka sauce, melted fresh mozzarella, and a hot honey drizzle.
    $24.50
  • Chicken alla Forno

    Oven-baked chicken breast topped with prosciutto cotto, melted fresh mozzarella, asparagus & mushroom Madeira Demi sauce.
    $24.50
  • Chicken Tre Colore

    Crispy chicken cutlets, mozzarella, fontina, Gouda melted, topped with marinara, vodka, and pesto sauce.
    $25.50
  • Chicken Limone

    Chicken breast, capers, spinach, red roasted peppers, melted fresh mozzarella with a lemon butter white wine sauce.
    $25.50

Homemade Sauces

  • Vodka Sauce

    $6.95+
  • Tomato Sauce

    $5.95+
  • Marinara Sauce

    $5.95+
  • Alfredo Sauce

    $6.95+
  • Bolognese Sauce

    $7.95+
  • Clam Sauce

    $8.95+

Dessert

  • NY Cheesecake

    $6.95
  • Italian Rainbow Cheesecake

    Rainbow cookie layered cake with cheesecake center.
    $6.95
  • Chocolate Lovin' Cake

    Chocolate pudding layered between chocolate cake, chocolate icing.
    $6.95
  • Cannoli

    Crispy cannoli shell filled to order with creamy cannoli cream and chocolate chips.
    $3.95
  • Tiramisu

    Espresso dipped lady finger cookies, mascarpone cream, and cocoa powder.
    $6.95
  • Cinnamon Squares

    (6) fried dough dusted with cinnamon sugar, chocolate syrup drizzle.
    $6.95
  • Rainbow Chookie Cheesecake

    Chocolate-dipped vanilla and chocolate ice-cream with crushed black cherry nuts center.
    $6.95
  • Red Velvet

    $6.95
  • Zeppoli

    $1.95

Monthly Specials

Soup

  • Chicken & Rice Soup

    Chopped escarole, roasted garlic, vegetable broth
    $7.95

Salad

  • Ranchero Salad

    Mixed greens, grape tomato, crispy shallots, tender poached-style pears, candied walnuts, Gorgonzola cheese, raspberry vinaigrette
    $14.95

Appetizer

  • Bang Bang Shrimp

    Breaded Maryland clam, Tuscan tarter dipping sauce, charred lemon
    $12.95

Sandwich

  • Burger Special

    Flame broiled shrimp, bell pepper, & shallot burger, melted fontina cheese, avocado smash, mixed greens, tomato, lemon herb aioli, red onion, on a soft potato roll served with house made old bay dusted chips
    $16.95

Quesadilla

  • Italiano Quesadillas

    Chopped crispy chicken, arugula, fontina, fig jam, crispy prosciutto, caramelized onions, sweet balsamic drizzle, served with garlic aioli dipping sauce and a choice of fries or chips
    $15.95

Pasta

  • Septbre Primavera

    Charred sweet corn, baby clams, chopped chowder clams, grape tomato, celery, shallots, scallions, white wine, served over Bucatini pasta
    $21.95

Entree

  • Chicken Contadina

    Buttery orange roughy filets, capers, sun-dried peppers, artichokes, blistered grape tomato, Sicilian green olives served in white wine sauce over orzo pasta
    $24.95

Pizzette

  • Chicken Pineapple Jalepeno

    Vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, chili crisp, cup and char pepperoni, sriracha honey drizzle, fresh basil, fresh grated Locatelli
    $15.95

Dessert

  • Black & White Cookie Cake

    A decadent chocolate cake, gooey marshmallow cream frosting, and sweet chocolate chips.
    $7.95

Pizza Menu

Pizzas

  • Cheese Pie

    $19.95
  • Cheese Pie (T)

    $19.95
  • Sicilian Pie

    Pan-cooked thick-crust 10 slices.
    $23.95
  • Sicilian Pie (T)

    $23.95
  • Grandma Pie (T)

    $22.95
  • Grandma Pie

    Pan-cooked, chunky tomato sauce, oregano, fresh garlic, basil, pecorino & whole milk mozzarella cheese.
    $22.95
  • Small Pie (T)

    $17.95
  • 12'' Ultra Thin (T)

    $10.95
  • Cauliflower Crust (T)

    $14.95
  • Detroit Pizza (T)

    Thick crust, pan-cooked, whole milk mozzarella, cup & char pepperoni, Mike’s hot honey drizzle.
    $21.95
  • Pizza Dough

    $6.00
  • Pizza Kit

    $18.95
  • Large Pan Pizza

    Round 8 slice pan cooked.
    $23.95
  • Gluten Free Pie

    $13.95
  • Custom Gourmet Pizza (T)

    $20.25

Gourmet Pizza

  • Custom Gourmet Pizza (T)

    $20.25
  • Grandma Vodka

    $28.95
  • Buffalo Chicken Pie

    Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce, whole milk mozzarella, and cheddar cheese blend, and ranch drizzle.
    $29.95
  • BBQ Pie

    Crispy chicken, BBQ sauce, Bacon, onion, whole milk mozzarella cheddar cheese blend
    $29.95
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie

    Crispy chicken, bacon, tomato, ranch, whole milk mozzarella & cheddar cheese blend.
    $29.95
  • Chicken Parm Pie

    Crispy chicken, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella
    $29.95
  • White Pie

    Ricotta, whole milk mozzarella, garlic-infused EVOO
    $26.95
  • Large Margarita Pie

    Plum tomato sauce, sliced fresh mozzarella, torn fresh basil.
    $29.95
  • Large Chipotle Chicken

    Crispy chipotle chicken, jalapeños, mozzarella and cheddar.
    $29.95
  • Chicken Vodka Pizza

    Crispy chicken, vodka sauce, whole milk mozzarella.
    $29.95
  • Meat Supreme Pie

    Pepperoni, meatball, sausage, bacon, pizza sauce, and whole milk mozzarella.
    $29.95
  • Everything Pie

    Meatball, pepperoni, sausage, onion, pepper, mushroom, pizza sauce, and extra whole milk mozzarella.
    $29.95
  • Chicken Marsala Pie

    $29.95
  • Chicken Francese Pie

    $29.95
  • Salad Pie

    Iceberg romaine blend, tomato, cucumber, olive, red roasted pepper, red onion, shredded whole milk mozzarella, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette.
    $30.95
  • Salad Pie with Chicken

    Iceberg romaine blend, tomato, cucumber, olive, red roasted pepper, red onion, shredded whole milk mozzarella, served with our house-made tomato vinaigrette.
    $36.95
  • Baked Ziti Pie

    Penne pasta, ricotta, mozzarella cheese.
    $29.95
  • Rigatoni Vodka Pie

    Rigatoni pasta, house-made vodka sauce, pecorino romano, and whole milk mozzarella.
    $29.95
  • Eggplant Rollatini Pie

    Eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella.
    $29.95
  • Crispino Pie

    Thin pan-cooked, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, shaved Asiago, red roasted pepper, pesto, and balsamic reduction.
    $33.95
  • Marinara Pie

    $24.95
  • Large Thai Chili

    Crispy chicken, Thai chili sauce, whole milk mozzarella, scallions, sesame seeds.
    $29.95
  • Veggie Supreme Pie

    Broccoli, spinach, eggplant, sweet bell peppers, mushrooms, caramelized onion, marinara sauce, and whole milk mozzarella.
    $29.95
  • Mama Mia Pizza

    Grilled chicken, tomato, roasted pepper, whole milk mozzarella, pesto, and balsamic reduction.
    $29.95
  • Balsamic Chicken Pie

    Crispy chicken, chopped tomato, red roasted peppers, balsamic vinaigrette, arugula, whole milk mozzarella.
    $29.95
  • Chicken Broccoli Pie

    Crispy chicken, broccoli, tomato, basil oil
    $29.95
  • Lasagna Pie

    $29.95
  • Chicken Cheesesteak Pie

    Chopped chicken, caramelized onions, peppers, whole milk mozzarella & cheddar cheese blend.
    $29.95
  • Tomato Basil Pie

    Crushed whole plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, EVOO, whole milk mozzarella, basil.
    $29.95
  • Chicken Parm Pizza

    $29.95
  • Brooklyn

    $29.95
  • Tre Colore Pie

    Pan-cooked thick crusted topped with whole milk mozzarella & 3 house-made sauces, vodka, marinara, and pesto.
    $28.95
  • Stuffed Meat Pie

    $36.95
  • Stuffed Everything Pie

    $36.95
  • Stuffed Veggie Pie

    $36.95

Pizzette

  • Angry Vodka Pizzette

    Crispy chicken, pepperoni, spicy vodka, fresh mozzarella.
    $15.95
  • Arthur Avenue Red Pizzette

    Broccoli rabe, Italian sausage, and fresh mozzarella in marinara sauce.
    $16.95
  • Arthur Avenue White Pizzette

    Broccoli rabe, Italian sausage, and fresh mozzarella.
    $16.95
  • Bianco Pizzette

    Creamy ricotta, whole milk mozzarella, garlic-infused EVOO.
    $15.95
  • Blue Cheese Buffalo Pizzette

    Blue cheese coated crust, buffalo crispy chicken, whole milk mozzarella cheddar blend.
    $16.95
  • Burrata and Meatball Pizzette

    Chunks of homemade meatball, fresh burrata, marinara sauce, whole milk mozzarella, and hot honey drizzle.
    $17.95
  • Cheese Stick Pizzette

    Strips of cheesy pizza dough served with garlic butter and tomato sauce.
    $14.95
  • Chipotle Chicken Pizzette

    Crispy chipotle chicken, jalapeños, mozzarella and cheddar.
    $16.95
  • Cowboy Pizzette

    BBQ crispy chicken, onion, bacon, whole milk mozzarella cheddar blend.
    $17.95
  • Fra Diavlo Pizzette

    Crumbled sausage, cherry peppers, spicy marinara, and fresh mozzarella.
    $15.95
  • Greens and Burrata Pizzette

    Mixed greens, red onion, prosciutto, Romano cheese, burrata, and balsamic glaze.
    $16.95
  • Honey Spiced Pepperoni Pizzette

    Tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella, cup & char pepperoni, hot honey drizzle.
    $15.95
  • Italian Stallion Salad Pizzette

    Pizza sauce crust, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, shredded whole milk mozzarella house dressing.
    $17.95
  • JoJo Pizzette

    $17.95
  • LI Clams Casino Pizzette

    Fresh chopped clams, roasted garlic, chopped peppers, bacon, scampi sauce, and whole milk mozzarella.
    $16.95
  • Mamma's Pizzette

    Grilled chicken, fresh tomato, fresh mozzarella, red roasted pepper, basil, and balsamic glaze.
    $16.95
  • Margarita Pizzette

    Crushed plum tomato, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, EVOO.
    $14.95
  • New Yorker Pizzette

    Pizza sauce, whole milk mozzarella.
    $14.95
  • Nonna's Pizzette

    Ground beef, sausage, tomato sauce, ricotta and mozzarella.
    $16.95
  • OG Chicken Pizzette

    Classic chicken parm.
    $16.95
  • Spinach Artichoke Pizzette

    Creamy parmesan sauce, spinach, artichoke, whole milk mozzarella, roasted tomato.
    $16.95
  • Thai Chili Pizzette

    Crispy chicken, Thai chili sauce, mozzarella cheddar blend, green onion, sesame seeds.
    $16.95
  • Tutto Pizzette

    Meatball, pepperoni, sausage, onion, pepper, mushroom, pizza sauce, and extra whole milk mozzarella.
    $16.95
  • Veggietini Pizzette

    Spinach, broccoli, onion, mushroom, roasted pepper, eggplant, marinara sauce, and whole milk mozzarella.
    $16.95
  • Vodka-Rita Pizzette

    House-made vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and Romano cheese.
    $15.95
  • White Mushroom Truffle Pizzette

    Truffle mushrooms, ricotta, mozzarella cheese.
    $16.95
  • Red Mushroom Truffle Pizzette

    Wild mushrooms, caramelized onion, marinara, whole milk mozzarella, truffle oil drizzle.
    $16.95

Soft Drinks

  • Coke 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • Diet Coke 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • Sprite 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • Dr. Pepper 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • Barq's Root Beer 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • Fanta 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • Cherry Coke 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • Seagram's Ginger Ale 2 Liter

    $4.25

Side Pasta

$7.95

Customize your item

Pasta Choice

Select up to 2

Side Pasta Sauce

Optional
1

Old Town Pizza Location and Hours

(631) 473-3712
691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Closed • Opens Sunday at 10AM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement