Out Of The Blue Seafood 252 E Montauk Hwy
Take Out
Soups
Raw Bar
- Shrimp Cocktail - 6 pieces$12.00
Freshly steamed and peeled, served with Cocktail Sauce
- Shrimp Cocktail - 12 pieces$20.00
Freshly steamed and shelled, served with Cocktail Sauce
- Oyster 1\2 Shell - 6pc$14.00
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon
- Oyster 1\2 Shell - 12 Pc$22.00
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon
- Clam 1\2 Shell - 6pc$11.00
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon
- Clam 1\2 Shell - 12pcs$19.00
Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon
- Raw Bar Trio$32.00
6 Clams on the half shell, 6 oysters on the half shell and 6 pieces Shrimp Cocktail, Shucked to order and served with Cocktail sauce and lemon
Appetizers
- Fried Calamari$15.95
Piping hot, served with Marinara sauce
- Crab Cake App$16.95
Our house receipe, served with Remoulade sauce
- Fried Oysters App$16.95
Shucked and fried to order
- Fried Clam App$13.95
Shucked and fried to order
- Ahi Tuna App$21.95
Served with Garlic sesame sauce, seaweed salad, ginger and wasabi
- Smoked Fish App.$18.95
An assortment of our in-house artisanally smoked fish
- Baked Clams$15.95
House recipe, a favorite with our customers
- Shrimp App$15.95
- Scallop App$15.95
- Soft Shell Crab App$15.00
- Wings - 6pc$8.00
- Wings - 12pc$15.00
Salads
- Mixed Greens Salad$9.95
Fresh and simple : mesclun greens
- Caesar Salad$9.95
Romaine Lettuce, croutons and grated parmesan cheese
- Ahi Tuna Salad$21.95
Seared tuna on a bed of tomato, cucumber,onion and carrot
- Lobster Tortilla Bowl$32.95
Lobster salad over lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots and red onion, in a tortilla bowl
- Goat Cheese salad$16.95
Tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, cranberries and, of course, goat cheese
- Mixed Green Salad - Small$7.95
- Caesar Salad - Small$7.95
Entrees
- Sauteed Codfish$21.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Grilled Swordfish$19.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Blackened Swordfish$21.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Grilled Tuna$21.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Grilled Salmon$21.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Surf and Turf$75.00
NY Strip Steak and a 1 1/4lb steamed lobster, served with a choice of two sides
- Teriyaki Sea Scallops$23.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- NY Sirloin Steak$31.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Flounder Platter$21.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Sea Scallops Platter$23.95
Served with a choice of two sides
- Seafood Combo$31.95
Shrimp, scallops, flounder and clams, served with a choice of two sides
- Shrimp Platter$21.95
- Codfish$19.95
- Stuffed Flounder$26.95
- Sesame Crusted Tuna$23.95
Served with a choice of two sides
Pasta
- Shrimp Scampi$21.95
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread
- Chicken Parmesan Linguini$19.95
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread
- Mussels Fra Diavolo$19.95
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread
- Seafood Pasta$24.95
Shrimp, clams,mussels and calamari, Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread
- Lobster Mac n Cheese$21.95
As indulgent as it sounds
- Linguine w. Clams$21.95
Served over Linguini with Garlic Bread
Sides
Little Guppies
Buckets
- Littleneck Bucket$23.95
Steamed, served with broth and drawn butter
- Mussel Bucket$19.95
Steamed, served with broth and drawn butter
- Steamers Bucket$26.95Out of stock
Steamed, served with broth and drawn butter
- Shrimp Bucket$23.95
Steamed, served with broth and drawn butter
- Medley Bucket$26.95
Steamed shrimp, steamers, clams and mussels, served with broth and drawn butter
Baskets
Sandwiches
- Seared Tuna BLT$21.95
Served with french fries and coleslaw
- Fish Taco$18.95
Served with french fries and coleslaw
- Flounder Sandwich$19.95
Served with french fries and coleslaw
- Buffalo Shrimp Wrap$18.95
Served with french fries and coleslaw
- Crab Cake Sandwich$21.95
Served with Remoulade sauce, french fries and coleslaw
- Grilled Salmon Wrap$19.95
Served with french fries and coleslaw
- Oyster Po'Boy$19.95
Served with Chipotle Aioli, french fries and coleslaw
- Hot lobster Roll$36.95
Served with french fries and coleslaw
- New England Lobster Roll$36.95
Served with french fries and coleslaw
- Lobster Roll Combo$36.95
Half a Hot lobster Roll and half a New England style, served with french fries and coleslaw
- Shrimp Parmesan Sandwich$18.95
On a Seed Roll, served with french fries and coleslaw
- Angus Beef Burger$14.00
Served Lettuce and tomato, with french fries and coleslaw
- Soft Shell Crab Sandwich$21.95
- Grilled Sword Sandwich$19.95
- Tuna Salad Wrap$14.95
- Shrimp Salad Wrap$18.95
Non-alcoholic Beverages
Shelf items
Sauces
- Honey Ginger Sauce$5.95
- Sriracha Sauce$5.95
- Tartar Sauce$5.95
- Cocktail Sauce 7oz$4.95
- Cocktail Sauce OOTB 8oz$4.50
- Remoulade Sauce$5.95
- Scampi Sauce$5.95
- Lemon Dill Sauce$5.95
- Teriyaki Sauce$5.95
- Soy Sauce$5.50
- Cocktail Sauce 16oz$9.95
- Tabasco Sauce$4.95
- Cholula Hot Sauce$4.95
- Caribbean Jerk$5.95
- Marinara Sauce$12.95
- Spaghetti Sauce$11.50
- Fra Diavolo$13.50
- Wasabi$5.95
- Balsamic Glaze$12.95
- Kalamata Extra Virgin Olive Oil$23.95
- Kame Oyster Sauce$5.50
- Kame Hoison Sauce$5.50
- Kame Fish Sauce$5.95
- Iliada Olive Oil$21.95
- Spicy Black Bean Dip$6.95
- Mild Salsa Divino$6.95
- White Clam Sauce$8.95
- Lemon Juice$1.65
- Lime Juice$1.65
- Hanks Herb Infused Hot Sauce$7.95
- Hanks Heat Hot Sauce$7.95
- Hanks Cilanktro Hot Sauce$7.95
- Hanks Camouflage Hot Sauce$7.95
Pasta and Rice
- Rummo Linguine$3.95
- Rummo Angel Hair$3.95
- Rummo Penne$3.95
- Rummo Fettuccine$3.95
- Alessi Diavolo$9.95
- Sushi Rice$3.95
- Rummo Orechiette$3.95
- Virgo Yellow Rice$2.50
- Hairloom Rice$5.95
- Rummo Bucatini$4.25
- Cocina Red Quinoa$6.50
- Lotus Foods Red Rice$9.95
- Lotus Foods Forbidden Rice$9.95
- Rummo Pacceri$4.25
- Oriental Style Noodles$3.95
- Risotto Sundried Tomatoes$5.95
- Risotto Broccolini$5.95
- Risotto Mushroom$5.95
- Risotto Saffron$5.95
- Paella Valencia Vigo$8.95
- Red Beans And Rice Vigo$3.95
- Risotto Cheese And Pepper$5.95
- Barilla Linguine$3.95
- Rummo Egg Nest Fettuccine$4.95
Condiments
- Horseradish$3.95
- Jalepeno Mustrd$3.25
- Pickled Ginger$4.95
- Wasabi$5.50
- Balsamic Vinegar$4.75
- Capers$3.95
- Sea Salt$8.95
- Dijon Mustard$3.25
- Dill Mustard$1.75
- Chopped Garlic$2.95
- Tomato Bruschetta Spread$6.95
- Greek Olive Mix with Crushed$3.95
- Pitted Greek Olive Mix$4.95
- Garlic Stuffed Olives$4.95
- DP Tomato Salsa$9.50
- Salt Flakes$9.50
- Salt Flakes, Garlic$9.50
- Tuxedo Sesame Seeds$4.50
- Classic Glaze$5.25
- Kalamata Olives$6.95
- Green Olives$7.25
- Falksalt Citron$8.50
- Salsa$4.95
- Balsamic Glaze$5.50
- Sun Dried Tomatoes$9.95
- Hot Honey$10.50
- Maple Bacon Jam$9.50
- Fig Chutney$5.50
- Plum Chutney$5.50
- Pepper Jelly$5.50
- White Vinegar$5.95
- Balsamic Reduction$7.95
- Sriracha$6.95
- Red Wine Vinegar$5.95
- Malt Vinegar$4.50
- Creamy Ranch$7.95
- Honey French$7.95
- Cucumber Dill$7.95
- Three Pepper Medley$7.95
- Banana Pepper Rings$6.95
- Bread n Butter Pickles$9.50
- Garlic Dill Pickles$9.50
- Anchovy Paste Tube$3.95
- Roasted Peppers/Nuts/Raisins Raos$8.95
- Bagel Crisps$5.95
- Raos Marinara 32oz$15.94
- Raos Alla Vodka$13.95
- Fancy Oil 500mL$38.00
- Fancy Oil 1L$49.00
- Raos Arrabbiata 32oz$15.95
- Raos Arrabbiata 24oz$13.95
- Raos Marinara 24oz$13.95
- Fancy Pheasant White Balsamic vinegar$18.95
- Fancy Pheasant Aged Balsamic Vingegar$21.95
Spices and Rubs
- Old Bay 6oz$7.95
- Blackening Seasoning$5.50
- Magic Seasoning$6.50
- Old Bay 16oz$15.95
- Saffron$8.75
- Magic Shrimp$6.50
- Seafood Magic$4.95
- Old Bay Blackening Seasoning$4.95
- Hanks Rub$11.95
- Hanks Rub Hot$11.95
- Old Bay Shaker$4.95
- Natural Falk Salt$12.95
- Rosemary Falk Salt$12.95
- Lemon Falk Salt$12.95
- Falk Salt Wild Garlic$12.95
- Alessi Breadcrumbs$4.95
- Coconut Breadcrumbs$4.95
- Tempura$4.95
- Wasabi Sauce Spread$4.95
- Pink Salt$6.95
- Garlic Salt$6.95
- Sea Salt$6.95
- Pepper$6.95
- Hot Seasoning$8.95
- Bone Seasoning$8.95
- Chopped Clams 6.5oz$7.95
Old Bay Blackening Seasoning
Other
- Artichoke Hearts$4.75
- Cajun Fish Fry$4.95
- Capers$3.50
- Chopped Clams$13.50
- Clam Juice$3.95
- Clam Knife$11.95
- Express Thai Rice Noodles$6.50
- Fish Batter$4.75
- Fish Fry$4.75
- Fish N Chips$4.75
- Fish Scaler$4.25
- Garlic Mushrooms$8.50
- Lobster Cracker$9.95
- Lobster Pick$6.50
- Nori$5.95
- Oyster Knife$13.95
- Panko$4.95
- Seafood Skewers$5.95
- Sesame Seeds Black$5.95
- Sesame Seeds White$4.50
- Shrimper$5.95
- Sushi Kit$4.50
- Sushi Making Kit$54.95
- Vigo Bread Crumbs$3.50
- Virgo Olive Oil$6.10
- Scungilli Sluced In Can$44.00
- Hals Buffalo Ranch Small$1.95
- Hals Original Small$1.95
- Hals Pepper Small$1.95
- Hals Sourcream Small$1.95
- Hals BBQ Small$1.95
- Hals Original Large$3.95
- Hals Vinegar Large$3.95
- Hals Sourcream Large$3.95
- Hals BBQ Large$3.95
- Hals Buffalo Ranch Large$3.95
- Hals Small Vinegar$1.95
- NYS Panetini Crisps$6.95
- Sushi Mat And Paddle$4.95
- Bar Harbor Clam Juice$5.95
Produce
Prepared Food
Salads (price/lb)
Prepared
- Baked Clams (price/pc)$3.25
- Shrimp Peel n Eat 41\50$8.95
- Clams Casino (price/pc)$3.25
- Crab Cakes (price/pc)$7.95
- Fish Cakes$5.95
- Lobster Eggroll (price/pc)$7.95
- Lobster Pot Pie$15.00
- Octopus Legs, cooked$26.95
- Oysters Rockefeller (price/pc)$3.25
- Portobello Mushroom$6.95
- Salmon Cakes$5.95
- Salmon Gravlax$32.95
- Sesame Tuna (price/lb)$28.95
- Shrimp Cocktail (price/lb)$28.95
- Stuffed Shells (price/pc)$7.25