Skip to Main content
New Online Ordering!
  • Oyster Bay Steak & Seafood

Currently not accepting online orders
Banner image

Oyster Bay Steak & Seafood

615 Lafayette Street, Cape May, NJ
DINING ROOM MENU
BAR ROOM MENU

Featured Items

  • NZ Lamb Lollies

    3 seared bone-in chops over feta goddess with Mediterranean salata
    $21.50
  • Smoked Fish Dip

    Smoked whitefish served with homemade seasoned chips
    $13.00
  • Pork Carnitas Street Tacos

    Grilled pork rojo, black bean and corn salsa, pickled red onion, crema on flour tortillas (3 tacos)
    $14.25

DINING ROOM MENU

Soups & Salads

  • Spinach & Brie Salad

    Spinach, fresh strawberries, almond crusted brie croquettes, strawberry balsamic vinaigrette
    $15.75
  • Garden Salad

    spring mix, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, focaccia croutons, Oyster Bay vinaigrette
    $10.75
  • Tavern Caesar

    romaine lettuce, celery, radish, fried shallots, family recipe Caesar dressing
    $13.50
  • Crab Soup

    New Jersey tomato broth, seasonal hearty vegetables
    $11.50
  • Truffled Beets

    Thinly sliced beets, feta, arugula, pistachios, truffle vinaigrette,
    $13.75

Starters

  • Fried Tomatoes

    chilled crab salad, fried tomatoes, spicy remoulade
    $18.50
  • Bang Bang Shrimp

    fried and tossed in a mildly spiced sauce
    $15.25
  • Roasted Long Hots

    Stuffed with Italian sweet sausage & fontina cheese served with garlic bread
    $13.75
  • Charbroiled Oysters

    5 oysters classically broiled with parmesan cheese and herb garlic butter
    $18.75
  • NZ Lamb Lollies

    3 seared bone-in chops over feta goddess with Mediterranean salata
    $21.50
  • Seasonal Buratta

    Chefs seasonal preparation
    $14.50

Steaks

  • Hanger Steak - 8oz

    All steaks served with daily vegetable, mashed potatoes, and our signature Oyster Bay Steak Sauce
    $44.75
  • Center Cut Filet Mignon - 8oz

    All steaks served with daily vegetable, mashed potatoes, and our signature Oyster Bay Steak Sauce
    $54.75
  • NY Strip - 12oz

    All steaks served with daily vegetable, mashed potatoes, and our signature Oyster Bay Steak Sauce
    $56.50
  • Rib Eye - 16 oz.

    $65.00

Land

Bone-in half chicken & gravy served with homemade cranberry & sausage "stuffing", mashed potatoes & seasonal vegetables
  • Roasted Half Chicken

    Bone-in half chicken roasted with a New Jersey peach barbecue sauce served with rosemary garlic roasted fingerling potatoes & house made coleslaw
    $32.00
  • Braised Short Rib

    Natural pan gravy and roasted pearl onions & cremini mushrooms served over wide pappardelle egg noodles
    $41.75
  • Duck L'Orange

    9 oz grilled duck breast served with oven roasted fingerling potatoes & grilled asparagus finished with a semi-sweet orange sauce
    $42.75
  • Grilled Pork Chop

    12 oz. Rib Chop, mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus with Makers Mark Demi
    $37.50
  • Coconut Curry Rice Bowl

    Carrots, bell pepper, shallots & snap peas sauteed in a spicy red Thai curry coconut sauce served over coconut rice finished with shredded cabbage & sesame chili oil
    $27.50

Sea

  • Andouille Crusted Grouper

    10 oz. grouper filet, smoked andouille crust, over rice pilaf with a lemon chive beurre blanc
    $39.75
  • Miso Salmon

    Roasted over coconut rice with grilled bok choy, tuxedo sesame seeds and crispy arugula
    $36.75
  • Oyster Bay Scallop & Shrimp Jambalaya

    Local scallops, rock shrimp, andouille sausage simmered in a New Orleans Gumbo served over rice pilaf
    $39.25

Dessert

  • Bananas Foster Cheesecake

    $9.00
  • Mousse

    $9.00
  • Chocolate Cake

    $9.00

BAR ROOM MENU

Bar Starters

  • Roasted Long Hots

    Stuffed with Italian sweet sausage & fontina cheese served with garlic bread
    $13.75
  • BBQ Pulled Pork Nachos

    Black Garlic BBQ, monterey Jack, pico de gallo, crema
    $15.25
  • Fried Tomatoes

    chilled crab salad, fried tomatoes, spicy remoulade
    $18.50
  • Scallop Bites

    Crispy panko fried scallops with pepperoncini remoulade
    $17.50
  • French Onion Dip

    Smoked whitefish served with homemade seasoned chips
    $13.50
  • Bang Bang Shrimp

    fried and tossed in a mildly spiced sauce
    $15.25
  • Brussels Sprouts

    Crispy Brussels sprouts in garlic hot honey & toasted sesame glaze served with green goddess dressing
    $12.75
  • Coconut Shrimp Appetizer

    Four coconut encrusted fried shrimp served with sweet chili sauce
    $16.50
  • Smoked Fish Dip

    Smoked whitefish served with homemade seasoned chips
    $13.00

Sandwiches

  • Fried Tomato Caprese Sandwich

    Fried tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto, arugula, aged balsamic
    $14.50
  • McBay Burger

    Double smash beef patty, aged cheddar, dill tartar, shaved lettuce, red onion, OBCM steak sauce
    $16.50
  • Ahi Tuna Sandwich

    Seared yellowfin tuna, sweet soy glaze, tomato and wasabi slaw
    $19.50
  • Fried Grouper Reuben Sandwich

    Braised house sauerkraut, monterey jack, lower island tartar
    $18.50
  • Pork Carnitas Street Tacos

    Grilled pork rojo, black bean and corn salsa, pickled red onion, crema on flour tortillas (3 tacos)
    $14.25
  • Black & Blue Chicken Sandwich

    Blackened chicken, bleu cheese sauce, garlic hot honey, shredded cabbage on brioche bun
    $16.50
  • Crab Cake Sandwich

    Fresh take on our classic OB style crab cake! Served with leaf lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce on brioche
    $22.00

Bar Room Salads

  • Tavern Caesar

    romaine lettuce, celery, radish, fried shallots, family recipe Caesar dressing
    $13.50
  • Shrimp Chop Salad

    Romaine, radicchio, pico de gallo, roasted corn, black beans, crushed tortillas, topped with Bang Bang shrimp & lime vinaigrette
    $19.50
  • Spinach & Brie Salad

    Spinach, fresh strawberries, almond crusted brie croquettes, strawberry balsamic vinaigrette
    $15.75
  • Cape Cobb Salad

    Tomato, cucumber, red onion, hard boiled egg & bacon over romaine, dressed with green goddess dressing
    $15.50
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Oyster Bay Steak & Seafood Location and Ordering Hours

(609) 884-2111
615 Lafayette Street, Cape May, NJ 08204
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 4PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement