Pewter Spoon Cafe
FOOD
Breakfast Sandwiches
- SPECIAL: The Mabel Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg on toasted cheddar-oregano focaccia with local butter and Gouda cheese.
- Classic Egg Sandwich$5.00
Fried local egg, local butter, NY cheddar on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Peppery Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg, local butter, pepper jelly, roasted red peppers, NY provolone on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Southwestern Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg, chipotle aioli, bacon/vegetarian sausage, NY cheddar on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Swiss Egg Sandwich$6.00
Fried local egg, local butter, spinach, NY swiss on toasted ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich option!
- Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich$4.00
Egg Scrambles
- Burrito Egg Scramble$7.00
Three local eggs, black beans, salsa, NY cheddar in a wrap or bowl. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Scramble option!
- Alpine Egg Scramble$7.50
Three local eggs, sautéed mushrooms, spinach, NY Swiss in a wrap or bowl. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Breakfast Scramble option!
- Build Your Own Egg Scramble$5.50
Greens
- Mediterranean Greens$10.00
Lettuce, feta, olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, creamy tahini dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Granny Greens$10.00
Lettuce, apples, goat cheese, walnuts, raisins, homemade balsamic dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Chicken Caesar Greens$10.00
Romaine, chicken, tomatoes, homemade croutons, parmesan, caesar dressing. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Italian Market Greens$10.00
Lettuce, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, homemade croutons, italian dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Curried Chicken Salad Greens$10.00
Lettuce, chicken salad with raisins, pecans, celery, homemade balsamic dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Veggie Hummus Greens$10.00
Lettuce, homemade hummus, cherry tomatoes, roasted red peppers, roasted red onions, cucumbers, Italian dressing as a wrap or salad. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Greens option!
- Build Your Own Greens$6.50
Panini
- Caprese Panini$8.00
Pesto aioli, tomato, mozarella, balsamic dressing on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Garden Panini$9.00
Kalamata olive spread, roasted red peppers, roasted red onions, arugula, goat cheese OR homemade hummus on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Mushroom Panini$9.00
Sautéed mushrooms, roasted red onions, garlic aioli, arugula, NY swiss on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Chipotle Panini$10.00
Chicken, bacon, chipotle aioli, NY cheddar on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Grilled Cheese Panini$6.00
Local butter, NY cheddar cheese on ciabatta. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Pesto Chicken Panini$10.00
Chicken, pesto aioli, tomato, roasted red onion, arugula, NY provolone. For any substitutions or additions, please see our Build Your Own Panini option!
- Build Your Own Panini$6.50
COFFEE, TEA, & OTHER DRINKS
Coffee
- SEASONAL: Ginger-Molasses Nitro Cold Brew$5.50
- Nitro Cold Brew$4.75
Our Gimme! cold brew on Nitro for a creamier mouthfeel and smooth flavor.
- Cold Brew$3.50+
Cold-brewed coffee using Stargazer Blend from Gimme! Coffee.
- 64 oz. Cold Brew Jug$16.00
24 HOURS NOTICE MAY BE REQUIRED! Depending on stock, we may not be able to guarantee same-day pickup.
- Drip Coffee$2.50+
Your choice of our house blend, Rally, or our featured brew of the week, both roasted by the folks at Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca. *PLEASE NOTE: We are not currently brewing decaf on drip. Try a decaf Americano or decaf cold brew instead!
- Cafe Au Lait$2.75+
Drip coffee with steamed milk.
- Pour Over$3.75
Specialized, slow-pour drip coffee using Rally Blend from Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca. Smooth, balanced, nutty medium roast.
- Espresso$2.75
1.5 oz double shot of Leftist Espresso Blend by Gimme! Coffee in Ithaca. Hints of dark chocolate, cherry, sweet toffee.
- Hot Americano$3.00
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with hot water.
- Iced Americano$3.25
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with cold water over ice.
- Macchiato$3.25
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso just slightly marked with steamed milk. *PLEASE NOTE: Our macchiatos are served in the traditional Italian style. Not to be confused with the large milky drink made by a big coffee franchise ;)
- Cortado$3.50
1.5 oz double shot of espresso with about 3 oz. steamed milk.
- Cappuccino$3.75
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with about 6.5 oz. steamed milk.
- 12 oz. Hot Latte$4.10
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with about 10.5 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Latte$4.60
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with about 14.5 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Latte$4.50
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with cold milk.
- 20 oz. Iced Latte$5.00
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with cold milk.
- 12 oz. Hot Mocha$4.60
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and about 10 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Mocha$5.10
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and about 14 oz. steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Mocha$5.00
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and cold milk over ice.
- 20 oz. Iced Mocha$5.50
1.5 oz. double shot of espresso with homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) and cold milk over ice.
Tea
- Hot Tea$3.00
Hot loose-leaf teas from Samovar Tea Lounge in San Francisco.
- Black Iced Tea$2.50+
Unsweetened English Breakfast
- 12 oz. Hot Chai Latte$4.10
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with about 4 ounces steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Chai Latte$4.60
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with about 6 ounces steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Chai$4.50
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with cold milk over ice.
- 20 oz. Iced Chai$5.00
Homemade chai concentrate made with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, star anise, cardamom, caffeinated black tea, and sugar, with cold milk over ice.
- 12 oz. Hot Matcha Latte$4.60
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Matcha Latte$5.10
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Iced Matcha Latte$5.00
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with cold milk over ice.
- 20 oz. Iced Matcha Latte$5.50
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with cold milk over ice.
- 12 oz. London Fog$4.10
Hot Earl Grey tea with vanilla syrup and steamed milk. Topped lightly with cinnamon.
- 16 oz. London Fog$4.60
Hot Earl Grey tea with vanilla syrup and steamed milk. Topped lightly with cinnamon.
16 oz. Iced Matcha Latte
Lightly sweetened matcha green tea powder with cold milk over ice.
Other
- San Pellegrino$2.50
- Water Bottle$2.25
- 8 oz. Hot Chocolate$2.50
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with steamed milk.
- 12 oz. Hot Chocolate$3.00
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with steamed milk.
- 16 oz. Hot Chocolate$3.50
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with steamed milk.
- 8 oz. Steamer$2.25
Steamed milk with your choice of organic flavor shot. Lightly topped with cinnamon!
- 12 oz. Steamer$2.75
Steamed milk with your choice of organic flavor shot. Lightly topped with cinnamon!
- 16 oz. Steamer$3.00
Steamed milk with your choice of organic flavor shot. Lightly topped with cinnamon.
- 8 oz. Milk$2.00
- 8 oz. Chocolate Milk$2.25
Homemade chocolate ganache (not vegan) with milk.
BEER, WINE, HARD CIDER
Wine
- Pinot Noir$8.00
Canned Oregon -- 12 oz. -- 13.5% ABV.
- Pinot Gris$8.00
Canned Oregon -- 12 oz. -- 12.5% ABV.
- Riesling Bottle$17.00
750mL bottle of Heron Hill Winery's Riesling, Finger Lakes, NY. This is a semi-dry white wine with notes of green apple, lime, cantaloupe, and green plum. *MUST PRESENT ID AT PICKUP*
- Chardonnay Bottle$16.00
750mL bottle of Maggio Family Vineyards' Chardonnay, Lodi, CA. This is a dry white wine with a vanilla and tropical fruit aroma. *MUST PRESENT ID AT PICKUP*
Beer
- Haus Lager$3.00
16 oz. light-bodied lager brewed in Utica, NY by Saranac/F.X. Matt Brewing Co. *MUST PRESENT ID AT PICKUP*
- Fika Stout$6.00
16 oz. Milk stout brewed with cholaca, cardamom with Gimme! Coffee & vanilla beans. Brewed by Nap Time Liquid Creations in Blauvelt, NY.
- Citra Session IPA$6.00
Common Roots Brewing Company - South Glens Falls, NY -- 16 oz. -- 5% ABV.
MERCH & RETAIL
Coffee Beans
- Base Layer (12oz.)$14.00
Tasting Notes: chocolate toffee, brown sugar, baking spice, cranberry cobbler.
- Brazil Cerrado (12oz.)$12.00
Tasting notes: rich toasted nuts, brown butter, dark cocoa finish
- Colombia La Primavera Decaf (12oz.)$15.00
DECAF. Rich and dense like sweet bread cocoa, currant, brown sugar.
- Guatemala Guaya'b (12oz.)$14.00
Milk chocolate, almond, cherry, tangerine.
- Rally Blend (12oz.)$16.50
This fairly traded organic blend is mild and smooth, with a comforting milk chocolate base. Crowd-pleasing flavor makes this the perfect blend to kickstart any rally. Tasting Notes: toasted hazelnut, dried cherry, milk chocolate
Loose Teas
Merchandise
- Indigo Blue 87 Albany St. Crewneck$22.00
Unisex
- Garnet 87 Albany St. Crewneck$22.00
Unisex
- Black 87 Albany St. T-Shirt$15.00
Unisex Gildan brand. 87 Albany St. design on front.
- Pewter Spoon Travel Mug$28.00
16 oz. Miir custom Pewter Spoon travel mug with medical grade stainless steel interior.
- Faded Blue Pewter Spoon Hat$20.00
- Faded Red Pewter Spoon Hat$20.00
- Red Logo T-Shirt$15.00
Unisex - Logo on front
- Black Logo T-Shirt$15.00
Logo on front.
- Light Grey Logo T-Shirt$15.00
X-Large unisex. Logo on front.
- Gimme! Coffee Iron-On Patch$2.00
- EcoJarz Reusable Cold Cup
Lids fit on any wide-mouth jar.
- Happy Roaster Camp Cup$25.00
12 oz. Miir custom Happy Roaster Camp Cup made with medical grade stainless steel.
- Gimme! Coffee Travel Tumbler$25.00
12 oz. Double-Wall Vacuum Insulated Thermos.
- 32 oz. Cold Brew Growler$8.00
32 oz. Cold Brew Growler with Gimme! Coffee design
- 32 oz. Cold Brew Growler$8.00
with Gimme! Coffee design.