Pie Chicks
BAKED GOODS
Pies
- 9" Pie$38.00
Deliciously tender and flaky crust generously filled with an abundance of tart fruit. Our signature product is just like Grandma’s, only better. Like everything we make—it tastes better when it’s shared! Approximately 8 servings. Flavors change daily.
- 9" GF pie$38.00
Our motto? If you can tell it’s gluten-free we won’t sell it. Just as great as our original pie, but zero gluten with a sweet and crunchy oat crumble topping. We dare you to taste test it yourself! As flavors change daily please call the shop for more information.
- 6" pie$13.00
Just the two of you? Just the one of you? Perfectly sized for the perfect treat. Flavors change daily.
- 1/2 Pie$20.00
Just a few of you? No problem! 4 beautiful slices. Based on availability. Flavors change daily!
- Pie Bites$5.00
Love our crust? Yeah, so do we. These are the beautiful trimmings left when we make our pies…why waste them when they’re just as delicious? Rolled in cinnamon sugar and bagged for a perfect little treat any time of the day! Warning—highly addictive.
9" Pie
Deliciously tender and flaky crust generously filled with an abundance of tart fruit. Our signature product is just like Grandma’s, only better. Like everything we make—it tastes better when it’s shared! Approximately 8 servings. Flavors change daily.
Pastry
- Scone$5.00
This buttery flaky piece of heaven is Chrissy’s all-time favorite thing to bake. Scones are an art form at Pie Chicks kitchen. Pairs beautifully with coffee, tea and conversation at any time of day. Apricot Ginger, Cranberry Walnut, Fig Almond, Cinnamon Date Walnut, Cherry Vanilla, Currant, Blueberry. Flavors change daily.
- GF Scone$6.00
You won’t even miss the gluten…just as flaky and tender as our original scone and equally delicious! Apricot Ginger, Cranberry Walnut, Fig Almond, Cinnamon Date Walnut, Cherry Vanilla, & Currant. Flavors change daily.
- Muffin$5.00
These homemade muffins are a crowd pleaser at the West Tisbury Farmer's Market. Classic blueberry, Monkey (chocolate banana) or cinnamon-y Peach--you can't go wrong!
- Kentucky Butter Cake Slice$5.00
We pour melted sugary butter over this deceptively decadent pound cake while it's still warm...part crueler part poundcake...100% amazing.
- Pecan Coffee Cake$5.00Out of stock
Known for selling out, this coffee cake will keep you coming back. Trust us. It's worth it.
- Blueberry Bread Pudding with Bourbon Sauce$8.00Out of stock
- Chocolate Peca Bread Pudding with Bourbon Sauce$8.00Out of stock
- Day Old$2.00
Cookies
- Single cookie$3.00
Our generously sized 4 oz. cookie is big enough to share, but if you don’t…we won’t tell! Some varieties also available in gluten-free (GF).
- Bag of cookies (6)$12.00
Is there anything better than a homemade cookie? How about 6 of them? Our signature cookies packed and ready for any occasion! Some varieties also available in gluten-free (GF).
- GF Bag of cookies$14.00
As good as our original cookies, we use Cup 4 Cup flour to make our GF version. Just as delicious, only no gluten!
Quiche
Bread
- Rustic Baguette$8.00
When you can't get to Paris, you can come to us! This pain l'ancienne is made using the Gosselin technique. Crunchy exterior, soft interior filled with holes to catch all that wonderful butter...we use our own baguettes for our sandwiches. But they're perfect alone, on a cheese board or for toast points! Come early--these sell out!
- San Fran (white) Sourdough Loaf$10.00Out of stock
Our four year old West Tisbury starter is only getting better! Fed with locally grown rye, our sourdough bread is a 2-day process and a real labor of love. You’ll taste it when you try it!
- Rye Sourdough$12.00Out of stock
- Banana Bread$8.00Out of stock
Granola
- Granola$14.00
Expertly baked for that singular crunch! Balanced, whole, crunchy, yummy. We call it “Great Granola” for a reason. Also available in gluten-free.
- GF Granola$16.00
Oats are naturally gluten-free, but the shared equipment in gluten-full processing facilities can contaminate them. These oats are 100% certified GF! Same exact recipe as our regular granola, but safe for celiacs!
FROZEN
Frozen Fruit Pies
- 9" Apple Pie--Frozen$25.00
An absolute classic. Warming cinnamon & nutmeg meet deliciously tart Granny Smith apples.
- 9" Blueberry Pie--Frozen$25.00
No matter what the season this is our best seller. Wild Maine blueberries with a hint of lemon. Perfectly tart.
- 9" Blueberry Peach Pie--Frozen$25.00
Is it a peach-y Blueberry pie or a berry-ish Peach pie? You decide.
- 9" Peach Pie--Frozen$25.00
Ooooh....Peach pie...one of Chrissy's all-time favorites and for good reason! Try it and find out what all the fuss is about.
- 9" Strawberry Rhubarb Pie--Frozen$25.00Out of stock
Rivals our Blueberry pie for best seller! Tart crisp rhubarb and sweet, juicy strawberries are mouth-wateringly amazing!
- 9" Triple Berry Pie--Frozen$25.00
Blueberry, blackberry, raspberry. Deliciously tart--this one will keep you coming back!
Frozen Pot Pies
- 9" Beef Pot Pie$42.00Out of stock
Beautifully braised shredded chuck roast amidst onions, carrots, peas with a beef stock tomato base. The perfect treat for a cold evening!
- 9" Chicken Pot Pies$42.00
Chicken, onion, carrots and peas in a rich chicken gravy served in our famous buttery crust. Our signature pot pie serves 3-4 people. Get it while you can! Offered seasonally Sept-May.
- 9" Mushroom Pot Pie$35.00Out of stock
Our vegetarian mushroom pot pie will please even the staunchest of meat eaters! Made with local MVM shiitake mushrooms (when in season), this 9" pie is packed with mushrooms, carrots, and peas in an herby mushroom gravy. Mmmm...serves 3-4. Offered seasonally Sept-May.
- 6" Beef Pot Pie$14.00Out of stock
- 6" Chicken Pot Pie$14.00