Sarah's on Central - Eureka 127 South Central Avenue

Made from scratch big biscuit, egg, sausage OR bacon, choice of cheese, served with shredded hash browns. Smothered your biscuit with sausage gravy for $2

2 junior pancakes, bacon or sausage

Bring Santa to the party with our adorable Santa Claus Cupcake! Choose between vanilla or chocolate cake, topped with a fluffy buttercream frosting and a jolly Santa face design. These festive treats are perfect for your holiday celebrations! Pre-order only—order yours today before they’re gone! We require a full 48 hours to complete Christmas Cupcake orders.

Spread holiday cheer with our deliciously festive Christmas Decorated Butter Cookies! We have an assortment of adorable designs, including mugs, trees, gingerbread men, and snowmen. Each cookie is hand-decorated with care, making them the perfect treat for your holiday gatherings or as a sweet gift. Available in store now!

Spread holiday cheer with our deliciously festive Christmas Decorated Butter Cookies! We have an assortment of adorable designs, including mugs, trees, gingerbread men, and snowmen. Each cookie is hand-decorated with care, making them the perfect treat for your holiday gatherings or as a sweet gift. Available in store now!

Spread holiday cheer with our deliciously festive Christmas Decorated Butter Cookies! We have an assortment of adorable designs, including mugs, trees, gingerbread men, and snowmen. Each cookie is hand-decorated with care, making them the perfect treat for your holiday gatherings or as a sweet gift. Available in store now!

Spread holiday cheer with our deliciously festive Christmas Decorated Butter Cookies! We have an assortment of adorable designs, including mugs, trees, gingerbread men, and snowmen. Each cookie is hand-decorated with care, making them the perfect treat for your holiday gatherings or as a sweet gift. Available in store now!

Celebrate the season with our festive 6” Christmas Cake! This beautifully designed cake features smooth white icing, elegant red and green flowers, and a cheerful “Merry Christmas” message in bold red script. It’s the perfect centerpiece for your holiday table and serves 8 to 10 people. Choose your favorite flavor and make your Christmas extra sweet! 🎄 Pre-order yours today- require minimum 3 days!

Add a touch of holiday cheer to your celebration with our stunning 8” Christmas Cake! Decorated with smooth white icing, festive red and green flowers, and a joyful “Merry Christmas” message in bold red script, this cake is as delicious as it is beautiful. Perfect for larger gatherings, it serves 18 to 20 people. Choose your favorite flavor and make this holiday season unforgettable! 🎄 Pre-order yours today- require 3 day minimum to prepare cake orders.

18 cookies. Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Double chocolate, Oatmeal Cranberry. We require a 48 hours to complete cookie boxes.

Wheatberry toast, fresh avocado slices, over-easy egg, spring mix and cherry tomato salad served with fresh fruit

Made from scratch big biscuit, egg, sausage OR bacon, choice of cheese, served with shredded hash browns. Smothered your biscuit with sausage gravy for $2

Our made from scratch biscuit topped with sausage gravy, served with 2 eggs and breakfast potatoes. (Not shredded hashbrowns) Make it double biscuits for $3 more

Scrambled eggs, cheddar, hash browns, sausage, OR bacon, served with seasonal fruit and salsa. Try it smothered with sausage gravy for $2

Shaved ham, poached eggs, toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce. Served with fruit.

2 eggs your way, breakfast potatoes, bacon or sausage, toast.

Eggs, tomato, bacon, spinach & cheddar, scrambled together, served over wheatberry toast, served with fresh fruit.

Our vanilla malted waffle topped with a fried hand-bread chicken breast, served with honey butter and maple syrup.

Certified Angus Beef chicken fried steak, fried and topped with sausage gravy, served with 2 eggs, breakfast potatoes, and toast.

Shredded hashbrowns topped with grilled onions, house-made cheese sauce, bacon, and two over-easy eggs.

Shaved ham, swiss cheese, house made strawberry jam sandwiched between thick sliced white bread dipped in a cinnamon vanilla egg batter, pan fried, served with fruit

Our popular bread pudding, sliced, battered, pan-fried, topped with bourbon creme anglaise and fresh strawberries. Served with bacon OR sausage.

Our vanilla malted waffle is topped with whipped cream and strawberries served with bacon or sausage.

Three buttermilk pancakes served with bacon or sausage.

Three slices of cinamon vanilla custard dipped bread, pan-fried, topped with powdered sugar and butter.

Our made from scratch biscuit topped with sausage gravy. Make it a double for $3 more

House made pretzels with our signature cheese sauce.

Thick-cut pickle chips breaded in-house with our specialty cornmeal breading, served with red pepper aioli.

Garlic, white wine, lemon, shrimp, and a 3-cheese blend, baked until hot. Served with crostini.

served with ranch. Try them tossed in Sarah's signature hot honey buffalo sauce!

Crispy fried potstickers filled with spinach, pepper jack, chicken, corn, red pepper & black beans served with salsa ranch.

Romaine & red onion tossed in a lemon basil vinaigrette, topped w/ parmesan encrusted potatoes, roasted asparagus, shaved parmesan, pistachios and grilled chicken.

romaine tossed in caesar dressing topped with roasted grape tomatoes, croutons, parmesan crisps, and crispy fried chicken

Romaine, iceberg, zucchini, carrots, red pepper, edamame, cucumber, grilled chicken, fried wontons, served with Thai Peanut dressing.

Mixed greens tossed in a honey vinaigrette topped with strawberries, red onion, candied pecans, goat cheese, and grilled chicken.

Wedges of iceberg lettuce, blue cheese, roasted corn, pickled red onion, tomato, bacon, hard-boiled egg, served with BBQ ranch dressing.

Two 4 oz smash patties, bacon, white cheddar, over-easy egg, and garlic aioli on grilled white bread.

8oz certified angus beef patty served with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle….ADD cheese & bacon! Aged cheddar, American, Cheddar Spread

8oz certified angus beef patty topped with BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar spread, and a jumbo onion ring.

Two 4oz CAB smash burgers, layered with american cheese & bacon, topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, and 1000-island dressing.

8 oz CAB patty topped with bleu cheese, balsamic onion jam, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, all served on a glossy bun. Served with fries or chips.

Turkey, bacon, white cheddar, avocado mayo on wheat berry bread. Served with fries or chips.

Marinated breaded chicken breast hand-breaded, fried and topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle and Sarah’s Secret Sauce.

Pecan-smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, fried egg, avocado and garlic aioli on wheatberry toast.

Seasoned grilled chicken topped with bacon, white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and Sarah's Secret Sauce.

Turkey, ham, bacon, white cheddar cheese on a toasted glossy bun with garlic aioi, lettuce, and tomato. Served with fries or chips.

Pan-seared salmon, pecan smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato,pickled red onion, avocado, roasted red pepper aioli on a glossy bun

Brown rice, zucchini, red onions, broccoli, red pepper, carrots, mushrooms, GLUTEN-FREE teriyaki glaze. ADD Salmon, Shrimp or Chicken*

3 flour tortillas with grilled blackened mahi mahi, roasted corn pico, pickled red onion, lettuce, and avocado aioli served with fries.

Cheesy chive grits topped with garlicky shrimp, worcestershire cream sauce and a jumbo onion ring.

Pan-seared mahi mahi topped with zesty pineapple chutney, served alongside grilled asparagus and creamy garlic whipped potatoes.

Fried egg, sausage, ham, potato hash, sauteed mushrooms, roasted tomatoes, white cheddar cheese all served on a glossy bun. Served with breakfast potatoes

French fries tossed and served with roasted peppers, goat cheese, artichokes, and basil

Ham, swiss cheese, and dijonaisse on a pretzel bun. Served with fries or chips.

Chopped shrimp, veggies, and herbs in a light and creamy bay seasoned sauce served on a fluffy, toasted roll. Comes with fries or chips.

Tossed in cinnamon & sugar. Served with marshmallow fluff.

Our Gluten and Dairy Free white chicken chili is a customer favorite!

See Server for Selection

1 egg, bacon or sausage, toast

2 junior pancakes, bacon or sausage

The best way to describe this cookie is crispy, buttery, chewy, chocolatey, the smell alone will get you excited for one bite. Customers drive from afar to get their fix and it has quickly become a favorite.

Our signature chocolate chip cookie is crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Packed with semi-sweet chocolate chips, with hints of caramelized sugar and butter.

Enjoy our chewy Toffee Chocolate Chunk Cookie, featuring rich chocolate and creamy white chocolate chunks, all blended with crunchy toffee pieces. It’s a delightful treat with a perfect balance of flavors in every bite!

Celebrate with our Birthday Macaroon! A colorful treat filled with fun sprinkles and a sweet vanilla cream center, perfect for any special occasion.

Satisfy your chocolate cravings with our Chocolate Macaroon, crafted with rich cocoa and filled with a smooth chocolate ganache for a decadent experience.

Indulge in our Strawberry Macaroon, featuring a delightful strawberry-flavored filling sandwiched between two light and chewy almond meringues.

A rich, buttery bar with a soft, chewy texture, topped with creamy butterscotch icing and drizzled with caramel for an extra sweet finish. A delightful twist on a classic!

A decadent dessert made with our house-made cinnamon rolls and French bread from The Hill. Each bite offers a warm, comforting blend of flavors, infused with spices and topped with a luscious sauce for a truly indulgent treat.

3 layers of double chocolate cake filled with sweet frosting and chocolate cookie crumbles, iced in chocolate buttercream and topped with chocolate cookie crumbles.

Three layers of moist vanilla almond cake filled with our signature buttercream. Created back in 2006 when a customer said he just wanted a slice of wedding cake. Definitely one of top sellers for over 17 years!

Pumpkin cake studded with chocolate chips, filled with dark chocolate buttercream, iced in vanilla buttercream, and drizzled with chocolate ganache, topped with mini chocolate chips. Perfect for fall!

Raspberry cake filled with dark buttercream and raspberry jam, iced in chocolate buttercream, and topped with raspberry ganahe drop, raspberry buttercream, and chocolate curls.

Our rich decadent brownies will have you forgetting that it is Gluten-Free. Each brownie is topped with ganache and a swirl of our signature chocolate buttercream and chocolate curls.

This St. Louis specialty cake is a staple at every holiday celebration in our house. It’s slightly gooey, buttery and sweet. We take it a step further and add a dollop of our signature cream cheese frosting on top. You just have to try it to appreciate the obsession....

Chocolate cake truffle dipped with chocolate and topped with rainbow sprinkles.

Vanilla cake truffle dipped in white chocolate and topped with rainbow sprinkles.

Our signature Glitter Bites are 2 layers of white cake filled with vanilla buttercream, dipped in white chocolate and rolled in sanding sugar. These decadent bites are a customer favorite and a guaranteed crowd pleaser. Truly magical and one of a kind!

These decadent bites are a customer favorite and a guaranteed crowd pleaser. Our signature Glitter Bites are 2 layers of white cake filled with vanilla buttercream, dipped in pink chocolate and rolled in sanding sugar. These decadent bites are a customer favorite and a guaranteed crowd pleaser. Truly magical and one of a kind!

Enjoy our Churro Glitter Bite, a delightful cinnamon cake sphere filled with creamy cinnamon cream cheese. Coated in a smooth white ganache and rolled in cinnamon sugar, it’s a sweet treat that captures the essence of churros in every bite!

Three layers of almond cake filled with champagne buttercream and strawberry jam, covered in white chocolate ganache.

Our Classic Frosting is the perfect pairing of two of our popular frosting. Our sweet frosting mixed with a bit of cream cheese frosting created this unbelievable twist on a classic. 2 pints of our classic frosting is enough for 2 cupcakes or 1-6" round cake.

Our signature vanilla buttercream is light and creamy with just a touch of sweetness. 2 pints of our buttercream is enough for 12 cupcakes or a 6" 2 layer cake.

Our signature traditional buttercream is light and creamy with just a hint of almond. 2 pints is enough to ice 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake.

We've added chocolate to our signature vanilla buttercream for all of those chocolate lovers! 2 pints is enough to ice 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake.

Includes: 1 Everyday Wedding Cake Slice, 1 Gooey Butter Square, 1 Snack Cake Cupcake, 4 Original Glitter Bites, 2 Double Chocolate Petit Fours, 2 Strawberry Champagne Petit Fours, 2 Chocolate Cake Pops, 2 Vanilla Cake Pops, & 4 Chocolate Chip Cookies Requires at least 24 hours to assemble and cannot be substituted.

Graham cracker crust, vanilla cheesecake, whipped cream topping. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, vanilla cheesecake topped with apple cinnamon conpote and crumb topping. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, vanilla cheesecake, blueberry compote swirl, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, vanilla cheesecake, strawberry swirl, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, vanilla cheesecake, mixed berry compote, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Chocolate cookie crust, vanilla cheesecake mixed with chocolate cookie and topped with chocolate whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Chocolate cookie crust, chocolate cheesecake, chocolate ganache drizzle, chocolate whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, raspberry swirled cheesecake, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Chocolate shortbread crust, vanilla cheesecake, red velvet cheesecake swirl, cream cheese frosting, red vevet crumb. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, lime cheesecake, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, vanilla cheesecake, toasted pecans, chocolate and caramel drizzle, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Shortbread crust, lemon vanilla cheesecake, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Chocolate graham cracker crust, chocolate and vanilla cheesecake swirled, whipped cream. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Gooey butter crust, vanilla cheesecake with gooey butter bites mixed in, whipped cream, gooey butter crumb. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Pecan graham crust, brown butter vanilla cheescake, whipped cream, caramel drizzle, candied brown butter pecans. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Shortbread crust, strawberry & vanilla swirl cheesecake, whipped cream, strawberry crumb. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Graham cracker crust, maple flavored cheesecake, maple cream, whipped cream, crispy candied maple bacon bits. FULL 3 DAY NOTICE is required to complete all cheesecake orders!

Knob Creek Rye, Campari, Sweet Vermouth, cranberry, cranberry bitters.

Candy cane infused Tito's Vodka, Kahlua, Bailey's, chocolate, cream

Tito's Vodka, Zing Zang, Pickle, Olive, Celery

Zing Zange, pickle, olives, lime, lemon

Ultimate Bloody Mary Kit Make 6 drinks (vodka not included) with Sarah’s House mix, shrimp, bacon, cheese, pretzel bites, veggies, olives, hot sauce, horseradish, and garnishes. Individually wrapped for freshness. Perfect for parties, get-togethers, or gifts! NEED AT MINIMUM 24 HOURS TO PREPARE ORDER

Malibu Rum, pineapple juice, Blanc de Blanc

Vanilla Pearl Vodka, cranberry, Blanc de Blanc

Mixed Berry Pallini, mint, blackberry syrup, Blanc de Blanc

Deep Eddy Grapefruit Vodka, rosemary syrup, Blanc de Blanc

Aperol, Blanc de Blanc, club soda

Mozart Chocolate Liquor, Vanilla Vodka, Baileys, chocolate, and a mini chocolate cupcake.

Pearl Vanilla Vodka, Kahlua, Espresso. Served with Chocolate Petit Four!

Caramel Vodka, Rum Chata, sea salt caramel sauce. Served with a mini salted caramel cupcake.

Pearl Vanilla Vodka, Creme de Caca White, Bailey's, Butterscotch Schnapps, and Cream. Served with a small Gooey Butter Bite.

Tres Agave Tequila, Triple Sec, orange marmalade, orange juice, agave, lime juice.

Tres Agave Tequila, Triple Sec, Tres Agave Margarita Mix, lime juice.

Tres Agaves Tequila, Grapefruit Juice, Lime, Club Soda

Tres Agaves, Jalapeño Simple Syrup, Strawberry Puree, Tres Agaves Margarita Mix

Strawberry Puree, Muddled mint, lime, hibiscus, ginger beer

Muddled mint, orange, simple syrup, lemonade & grapefruit

Bulleit Bourbon, Mint, Lime Juice, Ginger Beer

Tito's, Lime Juice, Pineapple Juice, Ginger Beer

Tito's Vodka, Lime Juice, Ginger Beer

Tito's Vodka, lime, grapefruit juice, ginger beer, club soda.

Bulleit Bourbon, Sweet Vermouth, Bitters, Orange, Cherry

Gray Whale Gin, Tempus Fugit Liqueur de Violettes, Luxardo, lemon juice

Aperol, Sparkling Freixenet, Club Soda, Orange Slice

Bulleit Bourbon, Honey, Lemon Juice, Lavendar

Malibu Rum, Cake Vodka, OJ, Pineapple

Hendrick's Gin, Seasonal Jam, Lemon Juice

Deep Eddy Grapefruit, grapefruit juice, mint, honey, lime, club soda.

Bacardi Rum, muddled mint & lime, lime juice, simle syrup, club soda.

Deep Eddy Lemon, Peach Pallini, Raspberry Pallini, OJ, cranberry juice

Citrus vodka, St. Germain liquor, cranberry, lemon

Jameson Cold Brew, Creme de Cocoa, Grand Marnier, white chocolate suace, coffee, orange bitters, whipped cream.

Meili Vodka, Berry Pallini, pineapple juice, sprite, rainbow sherbert.