Skip to Main content

  • Sarah's on Main

Sarah's on Main

2122 Main St., Wheeling, WV
Pickup Only
‌
‌

Breakfast

Breakfast Main Items

  • Salty Bread Breakfast Sandwich

    Our Signature Sandwich & Most Popular. Scrambled Eggs, Caramelized Onion, Cheddar and Bacon on our signature house-made Salty Bread.
    $8.00

  • Brioche Breakfast Sandwich

    Mild Hot Sausage patty topped with Spinach, Maple Aioli, Cheddar, and an Over Hard Egg on a Brioche Bun.
    $8.00

  • Sweet Potato Hash

    Roasted Sweet Potatoes, Warm Spices, Red Onion, Chorizo Sausage, and Sautéed Spinach all topped with an Over Easy Egg. The Large hash is twice the size of our regular portion with two eggs.
    $8.00

  • Breakfast Burrito

    Spinach, Chorizo, Scrambled Egg, Seasoned Potatoes, Cheddar Cheese, Pickled Onion & Chipotle Crema wrapped in a Flour Tortilla.
    $9.50

  • Quiche

    Made from Scratch - All butter Pastry Crust, quiche custard made with eggs, cream, milk & seasonings. Quiche Lorraine: bacon, caramelized onion & cheese. Quiche Florentine: sauteed fresh spinach & cheese.
    $8.00

  • Avocado Toast on salty bread

    Our House made Sourdough Bread, toasted & topped with fresh avocado, house blend seasonings and two eggs.
    $10.00

  • DELUXE Avocado Toast on salty bread

    Avocado Toast with House Seasonings and two Over Easy Eggs topped with house made Chili Oil, Feta, and French Onion.
    $12.00

  • Ham & Cheese Croissant w/ Egg

    An Over Easy Egg served on one of our house made Ham & Cheese Croissant.
    $7.00

  • Yogurt Parfait

    Organic Whole Milk Yogurt topped with fresh Strawberries, Blueberries and our house made Granola.
    $4.50

  • Breakfast Bunch

    Build your own Breakfast Platter!

Breakfast Side Items

  • Side of Bacon

    Three pieces of Bacon.
    $3.75

  • Side of Sausage

    Three Sausage Links.
    $3.75

  • Toast

    Three pieces of Salty Bread Toast or one slice of Sourdough Toast buttered.
    $2.50

  • Eggs

    $2.00

  • Side of Sweets

    Side of roasted Sweet Potatoes.
    $4.50

  • Fruit Cup

    Small cup of Strawberries and Blueberries.
    $2.50

Bakery

Pastries

  • Morning Bun

    Our Croissant Dough rolled up with a cinnamon sugar blend and topped with Cream Cheese Icing.
    $4.00

  • Croissant

    Regular Croissant, made fresh daily.
    $4.00

  • Ham & Cheese Croissant

    Ham and Jarlsberg Cheese baked in a Croissant.
    $6.00

  • Chocolate Croissant

    Chocolate Batons baked in a Croissant.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.50

  • Banana Muffin (GF)

    Made with fresh bananas, oat and brown rice flours and topped with almond streusel...so delicious and Gluten Free!
    $3.50

  • Spicy Italian Afternoon Buns

    Two Spicy Italian Afternoon Buns with Prosciutto, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone, Parmesan & chopped hot cherry peppers with Pepperoncini Sauce.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.50

  • Pepperoni Afternoon Buns

    Two Pepperoni Afternoon Buns with Marinara Sauce.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.50

  • Brown Sugar Coffee Cake

    Classic Sour Cream Coffee Cake topped with Brown Sugar & Cinnamon Streusel.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.00

  • Pumpkin Loaf

    Housemade Pumpkin Cake with fresh cream cheese icing and sugared and toasted pepitas!
    OUT OF STOCK
    $11.00

  • Pumpkin Muffin

    House made Pumpkin Cake topped with Cream Cheese Icing. A smaller version of our popular Pumpkin Loaf!
    $3.50

Cookies

  • 6 Pack - Chocolate Chip

    $6.00

  • 6 Pack - Oatmeal Chocolate

    $6.00

  • Cookie

    $1.50

  • Granola - 14 oz. Bag

    Our Signature House made Granola with Oats, Almonds, Pecans, Sunflower Seeds, Sesame Seeds, Coconut Flakes, Raisins, Craisins, Honey & Maple Syrup
    $7.00

  • Oatmeal Cream Pie

    Vanilla Bean Icing between two Oatmeal Cookies. Made fresh from scratch and individually packaged.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00

Breads

  • Salty Bread

    Full loaf of our famous house made bread.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.50

  • Sourdough - Available after 8am

    Available in a half loaf or full loaf. Baked fresh daily.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.50+

  • Focaccia Loaf

    Our house made sandwich bread. Baked fresh daily.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.00

  • Specialty Focaccia

    Slice of one of our Specialty Focaccia.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00

Spreads

  • Honey Butter

    $1.00

  • Regular Butter

    $1.00

  • Nutella

    $1.00

  • Jam

    Tiny jar of Strawberry Jam.
    $1.00

  • Peanut Butter

    Small cup of creamy peanut butter.
    $1.00

  • Cream Cheese Icing

    Small cup of plain cream cheese icing.
    $1.00

Lunch

Salads (Available 11:00a - 2:00p)

  • House Salad

    Spring Mix tossed in our house made Balsamic Vinaigrette and topped with Shaved Parmesan, Craisins, and Sunflower Seeds. Served with two buttered Salty Bread Crostini. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $9.00

  • Kale Caesar Salad

    Chopped Kale tossed in Caesar dressing and topped with Breadcrumbs, Shaved Parmesan and Grated Parmesan. Served with two buttered Salty Bread Crostini. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $12.00

  • Side Salad

    Choose from our House, Kale Caesar, or Weekly Specialty Salads. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $5.50

  • SALAD of the Week: Fall Salad

    Fresh Spring Mix with our House Honey Mustard Vinaigrette topped with Apples, Craisins, White Cheddar, Candied Pecans and Roasted Squash.
    $14.50

Sandwiches (Available 11:00a - 2:00p)

  • Turkey Bacon Club

    House Roasted Turkey, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato and Bacon topped with Mayonnaise. Served on our house made Focaccia Bread. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $8.50

  • Chicken Salad Sandwich

    House made Chicken Salad served on a Croissant with Romaine Lettuce. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $8.50

  • BLT

    Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato topped with Pesto Mayonnaise. Served on our Salty Bread. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $7.50

  • Caprese

    Fresh Mozzarella slices, Tomato, and Fresh Basil topped with Balsamic Vinaigrette. Served on our Salty Bread. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $7.50

  • The Grinder & Chips

    Roasted Turkey, Ham, Salami and Cheddar Cheese are toasted then topped with Pepperoncini Mayonnaise, Lettuce and Onion. Served on our house made Focaccia Bread. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $12.50

  • Turkey with Brie and Apple Butter & Chips

    Roasted Turkey, Brie Cheese and Apple Butter all toasted together on our house made Focaccia Bread. Served with a bag of chips. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $12.50

  • Italian Beef Sandwich with Chips

    Chicago-style Italian Beef shredded topped with Giardinera, Peppers & Provolone. Served warm on Salty Bread with a side of broth. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $13.50

  • Peanut Butter & Jelly

    Peanut Butter and Jelly served on our house made Focaccia Bread. **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $6.00

Pizza (Available 11:00a - 2:00p)

  • Cheese Pizza & Side Salad

    Two slices of Pizza served with a Side Salad. Toppings: Mozzarella Cheese & Herbs Sauce: Marinara **LUNCH ITEM: Available after 11:00 AM**
    $10.50

  • PIZZA of the Week: Hot Honey Pepperoni

    Toppings: Pepperoni & Hot Honey Sauce: Marinara Cheese: Mozzarella Two slices of Pizza served with a Side Salad.
    $10.50

Bowls (Available 11:00a - 2:00p)

Available Thursday and Friday

  • BOWL: Buffalo

    Buffalo Grilled Chicken or Fried Cauliflower on Rice and Spinach topped with Cabbage, Carrot, Celery, Scallions and Ranch.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $15.50

Soup (Available 11:00a - 2:00p)

  • Soup Cup

    One 12 oz cup of our soup of the week. Served with two salty bread crostini.
    $5.00

Other Lunch Items (Available 11:00a - 2:00p)

  • Chicken Salad Containers

    Our House-made delicious chicken salad includes fresh chicken, celery, grapes and a little onion. A perfect ready to go lunch, just add a couple of our regular croissants. Pint - 16oz Quart - 32oz
    $9.00+

  • Bag of Chips

    $2.00

  • Condiments

    Small side cup of condiment or salad dressing.

Drinks

Coffee

  • House Coffee

    Medium roast, fair trade organic.
    $3.00

  • Latte

    Two shots of espresso and your choice of milk. Flavored syrups optional.
    $4.50

  • Butterscotch Latte

    Latte with two shots and our house made butterscotch.
    $5.50

  • Honey Lavender Latte

    Latte with two shots and our house made Honey and Lavender syrup.
    $5.50

  • Cappuccino

    Two shots of espresso with Steamed Milk and Foam.
    $4.00

  • Cold Brew

    Coffee brewed slowly in cold water, served over ice. Great with Sweet Cream.
    $4.00

  • Americano

    Shots of espresso and hot water. (Small - Two Shots; Large - Three Shots)
    $3.00

  • Red Eye

    One shot of espresso in our house coffee.
    $3.50

  • Cortado

    Equal parts steamed milk and espresso.
    $4.00

  • Espresso SHOT

    Medium to Dark roast, fair trade organic.
    $1.00

  • Hot Chocolate

    Milk and Ghirardelli chocolate.
    $3.50

  • Cherry Mocha

    Latte with two shots of espresso, Cherry syrup and Mocha. SEASONAL - Limited Time Only
    $5.50

Tea

  • Hot Tea

    Cup of hot water and your choice of tea flavor.
    $3.25

  • Iced Black Tea

    House brewed Black tea served over ice. Served sweet or unsweetened.
    $2.75

  • Iced Green Tea

    House Brewed Green Tea. Served Sweet or Unsweetened.
    $4.25

  • Chai Tea Latte

    Sweetened Dona Chai blend and steamed milk.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.75

  • Medicine Ball

    Cinnamon spice tea, green tea, honey and steamed lemonade.
    $5.00

  • London Fog

    Earl gray tea, vanilla syrup and steamed milk.
    $4.50

  • Iced Pomegranate Green Tea

    House Brewed Green Tea and pomegranate syrup served over ice
    $4.50

  • Cherry Blossom Hot Tea

    Hot water with Cherry Blossom Tea. SEASONAL - Limited Time Only
    $3.75

  • French Country Side Tea

    Paris Tea, Lavender Syrup, Hot Milk, Hot Water. SEASONAL - Limited Time Only
    $4.00

Drinks

12oz can of flavored sparkling water.

  • Bottled Water

    $1.50

  • Bubly

    $1.25

  • Orange Juice

    12 oz cup of Orange Juice
    $2.50

  • Milk

    Cup of Milk
    $2.50

  • Hot Chocolate

    Milk and Ghirardelli chocolate.
    $3.50

  • Coke

    12oz can of Coke.
    $1.25

  • Diet Coke

    12oz can of Diet Coke.
    $1.25

  • Coke Zero Sugar

    12oz can of Coke Zero.
    $1.25

  • Sprite

    12oz can of Sprite
    $1.25

  • Lemonade

    $3.25

  • Strawberry Lemonade

    $4.00

  • Lavender Lemonade

    $4.00

  • Pomegranate Lemonade

    $4.00

  • Watermelon Lemonade

    $4.00

  • Blackberry Lemonade

    $4.00

Pre-Orders

Special Order Items

Items within this category are pre-order only. Each item requires a different preorder notice, please pay attention when placing your order!

  • PRE-ORDER: Chicken Salad Containers

    PRE-ORDER ITEM: Requires a ONE WEEK notice. Order may be cancelled if placed within notice period. Our House-made delicious chicken salad includes fresh chicken, celery, grapes and a little onion. A perfect ready to go lunch, just add a couple of our regular croissants. Pint - 16oz Quart - 32oz
    $9.00+

  • PRE-ORDER: Take and Bake Morning Buns

    PRE-ORDER ITEM: Requires a 48 HOURS notice. Order may be cancelled if placed within notice period. Four unbaked Morning Buns with Cream Cheese Icing. (Frozen)
    $12.00

  • PRE-ORDER: Take and Bake Signature Chocolate Chip Cookies

    PRE-ORDER ITEM: Requires a 48 HOURS notice. Order may be cancelled if placed within notice period. One dozen of our Signature Chocolate Chip Cookies dough balls, ready to take and bake at home. (Instructions for Baking: Set frozen cookies out 30 mins before baking, oven 325, bake for 8-10 mins)
    $10.00

Catering Menu

All items on this menu require a mandatory 48 HOUR notice. If you have any questions or would like to order more than two weeks ahead please call the shop (304) 905-6881. Thank you!

  • Pepperoni Afternoon Bun Tray

    18 Pepperoni Afternoon Buns arranged on a tray with plastic lid. Includes pint of Marinara. **Requires a 48 HOUR notice**
    $60.00

  • Morning Bun Tray

    18 Morning Buns arranged on a tray with plastic lid. Garnished with fruit. **Requires a 48 HOUR pre-order notice**
    $55.00

  • Assorted Pastry Tray

    A tray of one dozen assorted homemade pastries garnished with fresh fruit. (2 Chocolate Croissant, 2 Regular Croissant, 2 Ham & Cheese Croissant, 3 Banana Muffin, 3 Morning Buns) **Requires a 48 HOUR pre-order notice**
    $55.00

  • Cookie Tray

    A tray of our house-made cookies. **Requires a 48 HOUR pre-order notice**
    $20.00+

  • Bowl of Salad

    Half Pan of Salad – about 10 side servings, pint of dressing on side. Varieties: House Salad – Spring Mix, Shaved Parmesan, Craisins, Sunflower Seeds (Served with Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing) Kale Caesar – Chopped Kale, Shaved Parmesan, Garlic Breadcrumbs (Served with Caesar Dressing) **Requires a 48 HOUR pre-order notice**
    $35.00

  • Sandwich Tray

    One dozen sandwiches cut in half and arranged on a platter tray with a clear plastic lid. Variety includes 6 Turkey Bacon Club, 2 Caprese, and 4 Chicken Salad Sandwich. **Requires a 48 HOUR pre-order notice**
    $65.00

Utensils

  • Silverware

  • Napkins

SWAG

T-shirts

  • Tshirt

    $20.00

  • Soft Style

    $20.00
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 3.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Sarah's on Main Location and Ordering Hours

(304) 905-6881
2122 Main St., Wheeling, WV 26003
Open now • Closes at 2PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement