Skip to Main content
WELCOME!!! PLEASE SETTLE DOWN, EVERYONE. :)
  • The Settle Down Tavern

SETTLE DOWN TAVERN Downtown Madison

117 S Pinckney St, Madison, WI
Pickup Only
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • Good Idea

    Our House Burger! The one you have always been waiting for! Locally raised beef. House pickles. Fried onions. Butterkase cheese from Cedar Grove, WI. Settle Down Sauce. It's a Good Idea to have one - and having two is certainly not a bad idea! "A Good Idea always attracts other Good Ideas. Go Bucky!" -- Thomas Edison Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Eggs, Gluten, Nightshade, Soy, Seafood (worcestershire in Settle Sauce)
    $13.00
  • LUNCH BASKET!

    TUESDAY-FRIDAY LUNCH ONLY Sandwich, fries and a beverage for only $18! Choose a sandwich and a beverage from the available options. Upgrade to ghost fries for $1.
    $18.00
  • French Fries Reg

    French fries. Gluten free! Do they need a description? They don't need a description. They need dipping sauce! Ours are served with ketchup and paprika mayo and free high fives. Allergies: Eggs, Nightshade (both in mayo)
    $4.50

ENTREES

  • LUNCH BASKET!

    TUESDAY-FRIDAY LUNCH ONLY Sandwich, fries and a beverage for only $18! Choose a sandwich and a beverage from the available options. Upgrade to ghost fries for $1.
    $18.00
  • Good Idea

    Our House Burger! The one you have always been waiting for! Locally raised beef. House pickles. Fried onions. Butterkase cheese from Cedar Grove, WI. Settle Down Sauce. It's a Good Idea to have one - and having two is certainly not a bad idea! "A Good Idea always attracts other Good Ideas. Go Bucky!" -- Thomas Edison Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Eggs, Gluten, Nightshade, Soy, Seafood (worcestershire in Settle Sauce)
    $13.00
  • The Fundamental

    We're bringing it back to basics with this one y'all. Quarter pound patty made from 100% locally farmed beef. American cheese. Lettuce. Tomato. Onion. Pickles. Burger Sauce. The fundamentals never tasted better
    $13.00
  • Jalapeño Hot Rod

    Two beef patties smashed with raw onion, topped w/ jalapeño, American cheese, and burger sauce on a potato bun.
    $13.00
  • The Cowboy

    Two beef patties smashed with bacon bits, topped with Pickled Jalapeños, American Cheese, Crispy Onion Straws, BBQ Sauce
    $15.00
  • Classic Chopped Cheese

    Inspired by the NYC Original! 100% Locally Farmed Beef, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Settle Sauce, Hero Roll
    $14.00
  • Green Machine

    This is our house-made chickpea falafel patty fried to a crispy crust with a moist interior. Pickled tomato, cucumber, onion medley, shredded lettuce, Tahini Sauce, and Herby Spicy Green Sauce! A slam dunk of vegetarian flavors! P.S. - Vegan w/out the bun P.P.S. - Gluten-free w/out the bun. AND you can opt for a lettuce wrap. Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Gluten, Soy
    $14.00
  • MAGIC Grain Bowl (GF - Veggie)

    Oat Groats, Jammy Egg, Humus, Crispy Oyster Mushrooms, Roasted Broccoli, Sunflower Seeds, Pea Butter Spread, Lemon Mustard Vinaigrette
    $16.00
  • Wedge Salad

    Iceberg lettuce, french and blue cheese dressing, blue cheese crumble, thick cut bacon bits, jammy egg, cherry tomato, chives
    $12.00
  • Plain Hot Dog

    Underground Meats 100% Beef Hot Dog, Ripper Style!
    $8.00
  • Green & Gold Dog

    Underground Meats All Beef Hot Dog, House Beer Cheese Sauce, Pickled Jalapeno, Crispy Onion Straws- YUM.
    $12.00
  • Uff Da Dog

    Underground Meats Beef Hot Dog, Beef 'n' Bean Chili, House Beer Cheese Sauce!
    $13.00
  • Plain Cheeseburger (Beef)

    Sometimes peeps don't want pickles, onions and delicious house sauce. So we're making this one easy on the peeps, cuz life is hard, and sometimes we need to enjoy the simple things. A simple, classic Cheeseburger, with nothing else on it. Beef + Cheese + Bun = Fun.
    $9.50
  • Kid's Burger (No seasoning)

    Plain smashed beef patty with no salt or pepper on the beef.
    $9.50
  • Grilled Cheese

    $6.50

DAILY SPECIAL

  • Chicken Basket

    MONDAYS ONLY! Pasture raised chicken battered & double fried! Includes a thigh, drumstick, whole wing, and a tender. Comes with a side of fries!
    OUT OF STOCK
    $18.00
  • Chicken Sando

    TUESDAY SPECIAL! Korean double fried chicken breast, sweet and spicy gochujang glaze, coleslaw, house pickles, sesame seeds, and scallions on a potato bun. **sauce contains sesame
    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.00
  • Chicken Fries

    We loaded our crispy fries with Korean double fried chicken strips, gochujang glaze, sesame seeds, scallions, and a side of pickles
    OUT OF STOCK
    $15.00
  • Patty Melt

    Two smash patties with swiss cheese, grilled onions, and our house Burger Sauce served on rye bread!
    $14.00
  • Cuban Sandwich

    Thursday only! Underground Meats ham and pulled pork topped with mustard, house-made pickles, and Swiss cheese on a pressed hoagie.
    $15.00
  • BBQ Pork Fries

    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.00
  • Fish Platter

    FRIDAY FISH FRY! Big time fish time welcome to Wisconsin. Two delectable pieces of Settle Down Lager-battered and fried Atlantic Cod, tartare sauce, cocktail sauce, and picnic style slaw! As Hamlet once said, "This above all - to thine own fish be true."
    OUT OF STOCK
    $19.00
  • Fish Sandwich

    FISH FRY FRIDAYS! Ahhh...welcome to Wisconsin. Settle Down Lager-battered and fried Atlantic Cod, tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, picnic style slaw on a pleasant potato bun. (Can be done without the bun!) As John Steinbeck once said, "I remembered not that I had been told Wisconsin is a lovely state, but the telling had not prepared me. It was a magic day."
    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.00

SIDES

  • Cheese Puppies (gs)

    Cheese curds + Hush Puppies = Welcome to Settle Down Tavern Country, population: Meow. These puppies are here to rock your world. Deep-fried and tossed with smoked tomato powder, served with a side of ranch sauce. Dogs and Cats! Living together! Mass hysteria!!! Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Eggs, Nightshade, Soy
    $11.00
  • Pickle Puppies

    Cornmeal battered and fried house pickle chips.
    $5.00
  • French Fries Lg

    Big time order of fries whooooooo! Ours are served with ketchup and paprika mayo and free high fives. Allergies: Eggs, Nightshade (both in mayo)
    $9.00
  • French Fries Reg

    French fries. Gluten free! Do they need a description? They don't need a description. They need dipping sauce! Ours are served with ketchup and paprika mayo and free high fives. Allergies: Eggs, Nightshade (both in mayo)
    $4.50
  • Ghost Fries Lg

    "Forget about the curveball, Ricky. Give 'em The Heater." FYI - Served with our Blue Cheese Dip. If you would like ketchup please select to add. Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Nightshade.
    $10.00
  • Ghost Fries Reg

    Our regular French fries tossed in ghost pepper dust - spicy, yes, but not too intense. Think Flamin' Hot Chee-tos. Then think, I'm a champion. FYI - Served with our Blue Cheese Dip. If you would like ketchup please select to add. Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Nightshade
    $5.50
  • Uff Da Fries Small

    $6.50
  • Uff Da Fries Lg

    $12.00
  • Chili (Cup)

    $4.00
  • Chili (Bowl)

    $7.00
  • Mixed Greens

    The freshest, healthiest, tastiest mixed greens under the moon. Coming to us from Lovefood Farms, 25 miles from Madison on Pleasant Hill Road. Ours are served with a lemon tarragon vinaigrette and will always just call to say they love you, and will always just call to say how much they care.
    $5.00
  • Devil Birds

    These Devil Birds come to you courtesy of Bryant Family Farms! This jammy egg is served with our fluffy mustard and is topped with crispy paprika panko.
    $4.00
  • Pickled Medley

    One friendly round of house pickles, served with assorted market vegetables. Always a surprise. Stop. Hammer Time. Allergies: Allium, Nightshade
    $5.00
  • Calabrian Ghost Pepper Pickle Spears

    $5.00
  • Garlic Dill Pickle Spears

    $5.00
  • Betty's Party Mix

    Do you like Chex Mix? (I know right? Who doesn't?!) This is a classic homemade family mix, created by Joslyn's Grandma Betty. Crispex, pretzels, peanuts, cheerios, and rye crisps, baked in a buttery mix of worcestershire and other spices. Spoiler alert: Addictive!!!
    $5.00
  • Broccoli Salad

    Broccoli Florets, Underground Bacon Bits, Monterey Jack Cheese, Red Onion, Roasted Sunflower Seeds, Golden Raisins, Mayo
    $5.00

HOUSE SAUCES

Is it tomato? Or is it jam? It's both! And it has apple cider vinegar to go with the seasoning. Enjoy yourself! We only get one of these things called life. Allergies: Nightshade
  • Beer Cheese

    House made Beer Cheese Sauce - Made with our House Lager!
    $3.00
  • Settle Sauce

    The house special sauce! A secret-recipe mix of tomato jam, J-1 sauce (our version of A-1), and mayo. Allergies: Allium, Eggs, Nightshades
    $1.00
  • Smoked Paprika Mayo

    Smoked sweet paprika with homemade mayo and seasoning. As tasty as clapping your hands to a Neil Diamond song. Allergies: Eggs, Nightshade
    $1.00
  • The Ranch

    The one and only Ranch for the cattle wrassler in all of us. Sour cream, buttermilk, eggs, garlic, leeks and seasoning. Giddy-up! Allergies: Allium, Dairy, Eggs
    $1.00
  • Blue Cheese Dip

    We're not saying you're going to tell everyone and their cousins that this is the best blue cheese dip around, but we're not not saying we would be the first to recommend saying that to everyone. And their cousins. Allergies: Dairy
    $1.00
  • Fluffy Mustard

    We take mustard made with mustard powder and horseradish and fluff it up with spice for the whole fam damily. Save some for grandpa! Allergies: Dairy, Eggs "Life is a gift, and the moments are always a little better with Settle Down's Fluffy Mustard." -- Julia Child
    $1.00
  • Burger Sauce

    $1.00
  • BBQ

    $1.00

REFRESHMENTS

  • Coca-Cola

    Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
    $4.00
  • Diet Coke

    Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
    $4.00
  • Sprite

    Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
    $4.00
  • A&W Rootbeer

    $4.00
  • Squirt (grapefruit soda)

    $4.00
  • Ginger Beer

    $4.50
  • Cranberry Juice

    "Cranberry Juice. Ahhhh...." Just say it out loud. You'll feel better! Little Known: Wisconsin produces more cranberries than the rest of the United States. Antioxidants for the win!
    $4.00

SHOP

  • United States of Cocktails Book (Signed Copy)

    BRAND NEW!! Written by Settle Down's own Brian Bartels! Equal parts recipe collection, travelogue, historical miscellany, bartender's manual, and guide to the nation's best watering holes, THE UNITED STATES OF COCKTAILS is a celebration of the cocktail culture of every state in America. Signed copies available!
    $25.00
  • Bloody Mary Book (Signed Copy)

    A signed copy of The Bloody Mary book from Reedsburg, WI, native Brian Bartels. Nominated for an IACP Award and featuring fun facts, Bloody Mary history, hosting a party technique, and over 50+ recipes. One fan: "This book is the best book ever! I don't know who raised this kid, but gold stars to you!" -- Lynn Bartels (aka Brian's Mom)
    $20.00
  • Bitters - House Black Squirrel Toasted Pecan

    These are made with toasted pecans (nut allergy!), baking spices, sassafras (yasss…), various roots, and citrus. Please know the Black Squirrel Bitters are always ready to impart unique flavor to any beverage beyond the famous Black Squirrel Old Fashioned. They can be used in a variety of cocktails and other beverages, such as Hot Toddies, Manhattans, or any cocktail using a brown spirit. Take a couple drops and adventure forever! • Sold as one 4oz bottle
    $26.00

DESSERTS

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    $3.00

The Settle Down Tavern Location and Ordering Hours

(608) 442-6335
117 S Pinckney St, Madison, WI 53703
Open now • Closes at 2:15PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement