Delivery is not available. PICK UP ONLY.

Shapiro's Delicatessen
Main Menu
Sandwiches
Reuben
We take this traditional favorite to another gastronomical level! Our famous corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Russian Dressing, all stacked on our house-baked, hand cut rye, then grilled to a golden brown! No wonder it’s won many awards around the country!
$21.50Corned Beef Sandwich
We’ve bought our CB from Vienna Beef, Chicago since the 1930’s. It’s because we use the best cuts of beef that it has such incredible flavor. We slow-cook it in-house with our century old family recipe. Piled high on our mouthwatering rye, Swiss with mustard, it is our number one pick!
$20.45Pastrami Sandwich
No Cryovac, no processed pieces parts! We start with a navel of beef, smoke it with our secret spices and rub, and slice it hot when you order your sandwich. About 6 ounces of meat on every sandwich with our famous rye bread, or whatever you choose, create a huge, two-handed meal | 85% beef, 15% rye bread, 100% Shapiros!
$20.85NY Reuben
Our delicious, house-made corned beef piled high with two slices of German-Swiss cheese, a thick splat of Russian dressing, and Shapiro's cole slaw in the middle of the meat grilled to a golden brown served with our pickle for the perfect blending of flavors in one sandwich!
$21.50Brisket Sandwich
The best of the best cuts of beef. Freshly cooked daily, our lean beef brisket is thinly sliced and piled high on your choice of bread. Try it with Swiss, lettuce, tomato and horseradish sauce.
$20.45Pastrami Reuben
$22.45NY Pastrami Reuben
Just like our famous Reuben, but with Pastrami instead of Corned Beef. Russian Dressing, Swiss cheese, Sauerkraut and grilled to golden goodness.
$22.45PLT Sandwich
Turning our pastrami into “bacon” may have been a mistake one of our customers made by over heating their meat, but it turned into a fantastic new sandwich. Pastrami, Lettuce, (local) Indiana Tomatoes is such a great combination of flavor. You choose the bread.
$10.75Corned Beef/Pastrami Combo
A delicious sandwich that is half corned beef and half pastrami. It's best on our rye bread.
$21.75Peppered Beef Sandwich
Maybe you saw this on tv. Marc Summer’s favorite sandwich aired on his show, “Best Thing I Ever Ate” (Check us out on YouTube). Our beef round is salted, washed, cured for a few days then peppered, smoked, and dusted with a little sugar and paprika. It’s a slow process but it is definitely worthy of the wait!
$17.55Albacore Tuna Sandwich
Our all-white-meat Albacore tuna salad is made with quality fish, with just enough hard-boiled egg whites and seasoning to make a statement of its own. Try it on a flaky croissant with lettuce and tomato.
$10.15Chicken Salad Sandwich
We actually cook whole fresh, local chickens (never, ever frozen) for our homemade chicken salad, which was named “Best in America” by Gourmet magazine because, frankly, it is. It includes chicken, celery, grapes, walnuts, fancy mayo and our proprietary blend of herbs and seasonings. Try it on our freshly baked sourdough or a flaky croissant.
$10.15Rare Roast Beef Sandwich
Another fabulous sandwich in the best of the best beef category. Our rare roast beef is cooked to a beautiful pink tenderness for a moist treat on any bread. Top it off with your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato or an onion slice for optional additions. *Please note that this is served cold*. If it were hot, it would no longer be RARE roast beef. For hot roast beef, try our Brisket.
$20.45Pure Beef Burger
Our ground beef comes from Hoosier cows from DeWig Meats in Haubstadt, IN. The only FDA certified facility in the state of Indiana! We use a 3 generation old recipe from our Great Uncle Abe’s days as a chef in New York. The bread crumbs do make this not friendly to our gluten free friends.
$7.65Salami Sandwich
Custom made for Shapiro’s Delicatessen from the original Wilno recipe. They used to be a Kosher brand of salami and other meats that went the way of the big box buy-out. If you look at our salami label, you’ll see the Shapiro logo.
$8.85Chopped Liver Sandwich
Two words, chicken schmaltz. We make our own from all of the whole, fresh chickens that we get from Central Indiana and it is a key ingredient in Chopped Liver. You can get a sandwich or a “schmear” of chopped liver on top of another sandwich. My favorite is our rye bread heels, crusty and crunchy with a scoop of our creamy and rich chopped liver.
$10.25Kosher Frank
This is truly made with no filler* ~ just great beef. Vienna Beef’s all beef frank is served on a poppy seed bun – the way a real Chicago dog should be. *Gluten Free too, except for the bun, of course!
$6.00Roasted Turkey Sandwich
Oven roasted turkey breast. This is a very big seller for Shapiro’s! The Shapiro turkey sandwich has its own cult following. Hormone free and antibiotic free, you can taste why it’s a favorite.
$11.40Smoked Turkey Sandwich
Smoked turkey breast. This is a very big seller for Shapiro’s! The Shapiro turkey sandwich has its own cult following. Hormone free and antibiotic free, you can taste why it’s a favorite.
$11.40Corned Beef/Brisket Combo
This sandwich is half corned beef and half brisket. Bread of your choice.
$20.75Pastrami/Turkey Combo
A half pastrami and half turkey sandwich. Do you want smoked turkey or roasted turkey?
$20.85Corned Beef Pastrami Reuben
$21.95Turkey Reuben
Just like our famous Reuben, but with turkey instead of Corned Beef. Russian Dressing, Swiss cheese, Sauerkraut and grilled to golden goodness.
$18.00NY Turkey Reuben
Just like our famous Reuben, but with turkey instead of Corned Beef. Russian Dressing, Swiss cheese, cole slaw and grilled to golden goodness.
$18.00Beef Tongue Sandwich
Our beef tongue is very special! Only available on Thursdays.
$19.35Cold Corned Beef Sandwich
$21.65Grilled Cheese
You pick the bread, you pick the cheeses and we grill it! BAM! Lunch!
$8.501/2 Corned Beef
$12.251/2 Pastrami
$12.251/2 Brisket
$12.251/2 Rare Roast Beef
$12.251/2 Peppered Beef
$11.251/2 Roasted Turkey
$6.501/2 Smoked Turkey
$6.501/2 Salami
$5.751/2 Chopped Liver
$5.551/2 Chicken Salad
$5.901/2 Albacore Tuna
$5.901/2 Tongue
$12.251/2 Corned Beef/Pastrami Combo
Half of a sandwich that is half corned beef & half pastrami. Does that make it a 1/4 corned beef & a 1/4 pastrami???
$12.50
Sandwich (1/2) Cup Soup Combo
Soup
Cup of Soup
$3.75Bowl of Soup
$5.75Quart of Soup
$10.85Cup Chicken Noodle with Matzo
$5.25Bowl Chicken Noodle with Matzo
$7.25Quart Chicken Noodle with Matzo
$14.95Cup Chicken Broth with Matzo
$5.25Bowl Chicken Broth with Matzo
$7.25Quart Chicken Broth with Matzo
$14.95Extra Matzo Ball
$1.55Cup of Chili
$4.80Bowl of Chili
$8.15Quart of Chili
$14.95
Salad
Tossed Salad
A classic combination of crisp romaine and iceberg lettuces, red cabbage, carrots, tomatoes and your choice of dressing. This smaller size makes a perfect side salad.
$4.70Chef Salad
This large salad is made from romaine and iceberg lettuces, carrots, red cabbage, generous amounts of chopped salami, turkey, Swiss and Colby Jack cheeses, sliced hard-boiled egg, wedges or diced beefsteak tomatoes and your choice of dressing.
$9.05Greek Salad
Romaine, thinly sliced red onion, pitted Kalamata olives, cucumber, chopped tomato and crumbled feta.
$7.25California Chopped
Diced romaine and iceberg lettuces set the foundation for diced turkey, salami, and tomatoes, all dusted with sweet basil and Parmesan cheese.
$9.05Chicken Caesar
Romaine lettuce sits below a generous portion of house-roasted, herb chicken breast, Parmesan and shredded Swiss cheeses, creamy Caesar dressing and croutons, of course! Croutons are not added until purchased so this can be gluten-free.
$9.05
Bread
1/2 Dozen Bagels
NY style bagels that we've been making for over 20 years! Great flavors to choose from. Be aware that some flavors sell quickly and may not be available later in the day.
$8.50Bagels (Dozen)
NY style bagels that we've been making for over 20 years! Great flavors to choose from. Be aware that some flavors sell out quickly and may not be available later in the day.
$15.0010 Count Hot Dog Buns
$4.151 lb. Rye
Our famous rye bread! Standard is machine sliced. Let us know if you do not want it sliced.
$4.352 lb. Rye
Our famous rye bread! Standard is machine sliced. Let us know if you do not want it sliced.
$8.206 pack plain buns
$3.606 pack onion bun
$3.1012 pack plain bun
$7.0012 pack onion bun
$6.15Bagel
$2.00Croissant
$2.40Bag of Rye Heels
Because we hand slice our rye for our sandwiches, the heels remain! This is a bag of the rye bread heels. Crusty, on the outside and moist on the inside.
$5.20
Entree
Corned Beef Entree
Corned beef dinners are piles and piles of Shapiro’s famous corned beef from Vienna Beef in Chicago. We are the only place in Indy to get it, especially with our recipe and style of preparation. We slow-cook it in-house to our own exacting standards from our own 120-year-old family recipe. It is simply the best of the best. Our entree version gives you a choice of two sides and bread to complete a great meal. Many people make a corned beef sandwich and then have a lot of leftovers!
$25.25Brisket Entree
The best of the best cuts of beef. Freshly cooked daily, our lean beef brisket is thinly sliced and piled high with your choice of bread. Choose two sides and you’ve got the perfect dinner entree.
$25.25Meatloaf Entree
Our meatloaf is just like you remember it: moist, flavorful and absolutely delicious. (Your mom likes ours but, then again, she doesn’t have to clean the kitchen.) We use local ground beef from Dewig Meats in Haubstadt, Ind.
$15.75Single Chopped Steak Entree
Gourmet burger, Shapiro’s style! Our chopped steak is a one-patty Russian hamburger. We start with 1/2 pound Grade A beef from Dewig Meats, combined with eggs, bread crumbs, real onion, (no fake stuff) then add some savory seasonings, and YUM! A gourmet burger has never been better!
$11.85Double Chopped Steak Entree
Gourmet burger, Shapiro’s style! Our chopped steak is a two-patty Russian hamburger. We start with 1/2 pound Grade A beef from Dewig Meats, combined with eggs, bread crumbs, real onion, (no fake stuff) then add some savory seasonings, and YUM! A gourmet burger has never been better!
$13.55Stuffed Cabbage Entree
Shapiro’s stuffed cabbage is so delicious you’ll wonder why it’s so much better than any other! We’ll tell you the secret ingredient, besides the best ground beef from Dewig Meats in Indiana, it’s ginger snaps, but we don’t dare tell you the rest. Oh, do I see a raisin?
$16.50Baked Chicken Entree
Our chicken is local and fresh, fresh, fresh – NEVER FROZEN. And no nasties from the start. We bake it to perfection, and each order comes with 1/2 of a chicken. You will definitely need a container to go because you’ll have lunch for tomorrow!
$14.05Franks and Kraut
This is truly made with no filler* ~ just great beef. Vienna Beef’s all beef frank.
$8.75Pastrami Entree
We slow-cook it in-house to our own exacting standards from our own 100+-year-old family recipe. It is simply the best of the best. Our entree version gives you a choice of two sides and bread to complete a great meal. Many people make a Pastrami sandwich and then have a lot of leftovers!
$25.25Vegetable Plate
Choose 3 items from our sides or vegetables to create your own value platter.
$9.05
Sides
Potato Salad
Again with the hand peeling of the potatoes! It is extra labor, but it tasted so much better because it's fresh. Others buy bags of cubed potatoes that are sprayed with chemicals and we wouldn't do that!
$3.55Cole Slaw
We buy whole cabbages, chop them ourselves, and make our own Shapiro’s family recipe coleslaw from scratch.
$3.55Macaroni and Cheese
Our mac & cheese is part souffle/part creamy-cheesy goodness! Do you like the crunchy top or the creamy middle? Ask for the part you like the best!
$4.55Deviled Egg
We boil the eggs ourselves - most of the others used eggs that were boiled weeks ago and sprayed with chemicals. Only the best of the best ingredients at Shapiro's Deli.
$4.55Broccoli Salad
$4.35Green Beans
Local, Indiana produce is always the best!
$3.55Spinach
Local Indiana produce is always the best!
$3.55Potato Pancake
Great Uncle Max started making our potato latkes much larger than normal! But we still give you two anyway. The crunchy outer part is the best for dipping in apple sauce or sour cream. You pick which you want to go with your order.
$4.55German Potato Salad
Hot, seasoned, hand peeled, and (look closely) our corned beef is added for extra flavor.
$3.55Roasted Potatoes
$3.55Mashed Potatoes
$3.55Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
$3.55Boiled Cabbage
$3.55Yams
$3.55Cottage Cheese
$3.55
Fruit
Platter
Nova Lox Platter
A generous serving of Nova Lox (of course it’s generous, it’s Shapiro’s!). Includes slices of tomatoes, onion, capers, Greek olives, lemon wedge and your choice of toasted bagel* with Philadelphia cream cheese. Served on a decorative bed of lettuce.
$13.00Albacore Tuna Salad Platter
A heaping scoop of our delicious, house-made Albacore tuna salad and a second scoop of your choice of our own coleslaw, potato salad, cottage cheese or fresh cut fruit. Includes slices of tomato and onion served on a bed of lettuce.
$12.50Chicken Salad Platter
A heaping scoop of our famous chicken salad and a second scoop of your choice of our own coleslaw, potato salad, cottage cheese or fresh cut fruit. Includes slices of tomato and onion served on a bed of lettuce.
$12.50Deluxe Deli Platter for Two
Only at Shapiro’s would anyone say that this much food feeds 2 people! It’s loaded with so much delicious food that it will likely serve 3 or 4! A sampling of the best of our best: Corned Beef, Pastrami, Peppered Beef, Salami, two kinds of Turkey, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, a combination of cheeses, tomato, pickles, coleslaw, potato salad and centered with our very own chopped liver. Choose your bread and you’ve got the makings of an incredible meal…or three!
$45.00
A la Carte
Croissant
$1.45Pickle Spears (2)
$1.00Whole Pickle
$2.25Cream Cheese Extra
When 1 isn't enough. Philadelphia Cream Cheese, of course.
$0.80Extra Sour Cream
$0.80Extra Applesauce
$0.80Scoop of Tuna
$5.50Scoop of Liver
$5.50Scoop of Chicken Salad
$5.50Meatloaf A la Carte
$14.75Baked Chicken A la Carte
$13.05Hard Boiled Egg (1)
Organic, local eggs that we cook! I never understood why some restaurants buy pre-boiled eggs. How old are they???
$2.05Hard Boiled Egg (2)
Organic, local eggs that we cook! I never understood why some restaurants buy pre-boiled eggs. How old are they???
$2.75Stuffed Cabbage A la Carte
$15.50
Route 11 Chips
Beverage
Friday Menu
Friday Soup
Bakery
Cake
Slice Ann's Strawberry Cheesecake
Our famous strawberry cheesecake is one of our best sellers because we use the best ingredients!
$9.85Slice Arlene's Carrot Cake
A rich cake, full of raisins, carrots, and nuts with the best icing that is the perfect level of sweetness.
$8.20Slice Marble Cake
This Marble bundt cake is moist and delicious. A hit with any group.
$7.75Slice Lemon Cake
One of our unsung heroes! A classic Jewish deli favorite.
$7.75Slice Chocolate Cake
Rich and decadent, it's just simply delish!
$7.00Slice German Chocolate Cake
Coconut abounds! A traditional chocolate cake with milk chocolate icing with a ton of coconut flakes!
$8.20Slice Cherry Cheesecake
Our famous Philadelphia cream cheese cheesecake, but this time we put cherries on top!
$9.85Slice Plain Cheesecake
Delicious cheesecake that is made with Philadelphia Cream Cheese. That 'factory' doesn't use Philly Cream Cheese!
$9.85Slice Oreo Cheesecake
Philadelphia cream cheese plus Oreos – what could be bad?
$9.85Slice Carrot Cheesecake
Two layers of carrot cake with a layer of our famous cheesecake in the middle, it's perfect when you can't decide which one you want for dessert!
$9.85Slice Poppyseed Cake
A wonderful bundt cake that is hard to find. Moist, sweet, delicious, with poppy seeds. A Jewish deli fav!
$7.75Slice Gluten Free Chocolate Chocolate Chocalate
Gluten-free death by chocolate! The chocolate flourless torte.
$8.00
Pie
Slice Cherry Pie
$5.75Slice Apple Pie
$5.75Slice Rhubarb Pie
Struggling to keep this on the shelves, rhubarb is hard to find these days...
$5.75Slice Key Lime Pie
Amazing dessert, we even make the pie crust in-house!
$7.25Slice Coconut Cream Pie
$5.75Slice Boston Cream Pie
$6.25Slice Lemon Meringue Pie
$5.75Slice Pecan Pie
$7.25
Bars
Cookie
Rugelach
Apricot Rugelach
An Eastern European tea cookie, this classically Jewish treat is hand made and hand rolled in various flavors. This one is apricot.
$1.85Chocolate Rugelach
An Eastern European tea cookie, this classically Jewish treat is hand made and hand rolled in various flavors. This one is chocolate.
$1.20Cinnamon Rugelach
An Eastern European tea cookie, this classically Jewish treat is hand made and hand rolled in various flavors. This one is cinnamon.
$1.20Raspberry Rugelach
An Eastern European tea cookie, this classically Jewish treat is hand made and hand rolled in various flavors. This one is raspberry.
$1.85
Treat
Eclair
House made pastry, cream filling and covered with delicious chocolate!
$4.95Cream Puff
Fluffy pastry filled with pastry cream and a layer of raspberry goodness.
$4.95Cream Horn
Pastry, cream filling, then dipped in chocolate! What could be bad about this combo?
$4.10Cannoli
Yes - we make these in house as well. Our bakery is very busy!
$4.10Palmier
We use real butter in all of our baking! You can taste the difference because ours are just better.
$2.55Cake Pop
Pick your favorite flavor.
$1.95Baklava
So many layers, honey and yumminess.
$3.35Halavah Marble
$2.00Halavah Original
$2.00Halavah Chocolate
$2.00Joyva Joys
$2.00