Skip to Main content
  • Sherrill New York Pizzeria

Sherrill New York Pizzeria

125 East Seneca Street, Sherrill, NY
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • Large 16 Inch

    16” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.
    $17.85
  • Large Pizza & 20 Wings Special

    $43.50
  • Medium 14 Inch

    14” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.
    $16.10

Pizza

Specials

  • Medium Pizza & 10 Wings Special

    $29.55
  • Large Pizza & 20 Wings Special

    $43.50
  • Large Pizza & 50 Wings Special

    $73.50
  • Large Pizza & Boneless Wings Special

    $26.70

Pizza

  • Large 16 Inch

    16” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.
    $17.85
  • Medium 14 Inch

    14” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.
    $16.10
  • Small 12 Inch

    12” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.
    $13.40
  • Personal 10 Inch

    10” Build your own classic New-York-style pizza. Made with hand-stretched dough, signature tomato sauce, and gooey, bubbling mozzarella. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.
    $10.00
  • Cauliflower 12 Inch

    A lighter take on pizza: a crisp cauliflower-based crust topped with sauce and melted cheese. Great for folks looking for something a little easier on wheat but still rich in flavor. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors.
    $14.75
  • Slice Pizza 18 Inch

    A giant 18-inch pizza ideal for feeding a group or saving a slice for later. Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors to make it your own.
    $20.75
  • Sicilian 11x13

    A thicker, square-shaped pizza with a soft, doughy base.Choose from a variety of meats, veggies, and signature flavors to make it your own.
    $22.25
  • Calzone

    Pizza ingredients folded neatly inside soft dough with molten cheese, savory tomato sauce and your choice of fillings, baked until golden.
    $12.25
  • Stromboli

    All the goodness of pizza wrapped inside a golden, baked crust. Easy to slice, share, and enjoy. Choose your choice of cheese and toppings.
    $26.50
  • Ham Pizza Roll

    A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and ham. Comforting and perfect for dipping.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.05
  • Pepperoni Pizza Roll

    A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and classic pepperoni. Comforting and perfect for dipping.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.05
  • Sausage Pizza Roll

    A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and sausage. Comforting and perfect for dipping.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.05
  • Meatball Pizza Roll

    A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese and classic meatballs. Comforting and perfect for dipping.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.05
  • Chicken Wing Pizza Roll

    A bite-sized roll packed with melted cheese, wing sauce, and chicken wing filling. Comforting and perfect for dipping.
    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.25
  • Pizza Dough

    $3.50

Food

Appetizers

  • Mac & Cheese Bites

    Golden, crispy shells filled with creamy, cheesy macaroni. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $10.00
  • Arancini

    Italian-style fried rice balls with a gooey mozzarella center and a crisp exterior. Warm, savory, and perfect for dipping. Comes with your choice of sauce.
    $10.00
  • Boneless Wings

    Tender, juicy chicken bites with a lightly crispy coating. Tossed with your choice of sauce.
    $10.85
  • Chicken Tenders

    Crispy, golden chicken strips served hot and ready to dip. Includes your choice of sauce
    $10.00
  • Chicken Tenders W/ Fries

    Crispy, golden chicken strips served hot and ready to dip. Includes your choice of sauce.
    $11.25
  • Fried Dough

    Warm, fluffy fried dough lightly crisped on the outside.
    $9.00
  • Fried Mushrooms

    Battered mushrooms fried to a golden crunch. Served with your choice of sauce
    $10.00
  • Small French Fries

    Crispy coated, lightly salted fries with a soft, fluffy center. Comes with your choice of sauce.
    $4.75
  • Large French Fries

    Crispy coated, lightly salted fries with a soft, fluffy center. Comes with your choice of sauce.
    $5.50
  • Bacon Cheese Fries

    A loaded plate of crispy fries topped with melted cheese and savory bacon crumbles. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $10.15
  • Garlic Bread

    Toasted bread brushed with garlic butter, finished plain. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $4.25
  • Garlic Bread W/ Cheese

    Toasted bread brushed with garlic butter, topped with melted cheese. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $4.75
  • Garlic Knots

    Soft, buttery knots baked until golden and brushed with garlic and herbs. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $6.25
  • Mozzarella Stix

    6 Crispy breaded sticks filled with hot, stretchy mozzarella. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $10.00
  • Mozzarella Stix W/ Fries

    6 Crispy breaded sticks filled with hot, stretchy mozzarella. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $11.25
  • Onion Rings

    Thick-cut, sweet onions in a crunchy breading. Fried to a golden finish and served with your choice of sauce.
    $10.00
  • Onion Rings W/ Fries

    Thick-cut, sweet onions in a crunchy breading. Fried to a golden finish and served with your choice of sauce.
    $11.25
  • Poppers

    Crispy, golden poppers filled with smooth, creamy cheese and a gentle kick of jalapeño heat. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $10.00
  • Poppers W/ Fries

    Crispy, golden poppers filled with smooth, creamy cheese and a gentle kick of jalapeño heat. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $11.25
  • Fried Meatballs

    Hearty, seasoned meatballs fried for a crisp exterior with a juicy center. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $11.25
  • Fried Cauliflower

    Lightly battered cauliflower florets fried until crispy yet tender. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $10.00
  • Butterfly Shrimp W/ Fries

    Plump shrimp coated in a crispy breading and fried to perfection, paired with french fries. Comes with your choice of sauce.
    $11.00
  • Fried Ravioli

    Cheese-filled ravioli pockets fried until golden and crisp on the outside with a melty interior. Served with your choice of sauce.
    $10.00
  • Onion Petals

    Crispy, golden fried onion petals with a tender, sweet center. Perfect for dipping and sharing.
    $10.00

Chicken Wings

  • 10 Wings

    Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $14.95
  • 20 Wings

    Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $27.40
  • 30 Wings

    Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $38.40
  • 40 Wings

    Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $49.40
  • 50 Wings

    Classic bone-in chicken wings cooked to a tender, crispy, flavorful finish and tossed in your choice of sauce.
    $60.40
  • Boneless Wings

    Tender, juicy chicken bites with a lightly crispy coating. Tossed with your choice of sauce.
    $10.85
  • celery and blue cheese

    $1.30

Cold Subs

  • Turkey Sub

    Sliced turkey layered on fresh sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00+
  • Roast Beef Sub

    Tender roast beef served on soft sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00+
  • Italian Mixed Sub

    A traditional duo of Italian cold cuts stacked for full, savory flavor. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00+
  • Tuna Fish Sub

    Creamy, homemade-style tuna salad served cold on fresh sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00+
  • Ham Sub

    Thinly sliced ham served on soft sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00+
  • Salami Sub

    Rich, tangy salami served on soft sub bread. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00+
  • Veggie Sub

    A fresh, colorful mix of vegetables for a lighter option. Finish it off with cheese and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00+

Hot Tunnels

  • Chicken Parm Tunnel

    A hot sandwich filled with breaded chicken, marinara, and melted cheese, served in a tunneled out sub bun.
    $9.50+
  • Chicken Tender Tunnel

    A hot sandwich featuring crispy chicken tenders and melted cheese inside a tunneled out sub bun. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.50+
  • Eggplant Parm Tunnel

    A hot sandwich with breaded eggplant, marinara, and melted cheese tucked into a tunneled out sub bun.
    $9.50+
  • Meatball Tunnel

    A hot sandwich loaded with savory meatballs, marinara, and melted cheese inside a tunneled out sub bun.
    $9.50+
  • Pepperoni Tunnel

    A hot sandwich packed with pepperoni and melted cheese, served in a tunneled out sub bun.
    $9.50+
  • Sausage Tunnel

    A hot sandwich filled with savory sausage and melted cheese inside a tunneled out sub bun.
    $9.50+
  • Steak Tunnel

    A hot sandwich layered with tender steak and melted cheese, served in a tunneled out sub bun.
    $9.50+

Salads

  • Small Anitpasto

    Small classic Italian-style salad with a mix of pepperoni, ham, black olives, tomatoes, and pepperoncini. Includes choice of salad dressing. Perfect as a side- salad.
    $8.35
  • Large Antipasto

    Large classic Italian-style salad with a mix of pepperoni, ham, black olives, tomatoes, and pepperoncini. Includes choice of salad dressing. Perfect for a meal.
    $11.25

Sauces

  • 2oz Sauce

    Add extra sauce for dipping or drizzling — perfect for wings, breadsticks, pizza crusts, or any fried item.
    $0.65
  • 4oz Sauce

    Add extra sauce for dipping or drizzling — perfect for wings, breadsticks, pizza crusts, or any fried item.
    $1.25
  • 8oz Sauce

    Add extra sauce for dipping or drizzling — perfect for wings, breadsticks, pizza crusts, or any fried item.
    $1.85

Wheat Wraps

  • Chicken Wheat Wrap

    Crispy, golden chicken strips wrapped in a soft wheat tortilla. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00
  • Ham Wheat Wrap

    Thinly sliced ham wrapped in a soft wheat tortilla. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00
  • Roast Beef Wheat Wrap

    Tender roast beef wrapped in a soft wheat tortilla. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00
  • Turkey Wheat Wrap

    Sliced turkey wrapped in a soft wheat tortilla. Top it with your choice of veggies, cheese, and sauces to tailor to your taste.
    $9.00

Beverage

  • Can

    $1.35
  • 16oz Bottle

    $2.35
  • 2 Liter

    $3.50
  • Bottled Water

    $1.35
  • Bottle Water-Large

    $2.35
  • Gatorade

    $2.60
  • Snapple

    $2.60
  • Milk

    $2.50

Sherrill New York Pizzeria Location and Ordering Hours

(315) 363-2189
125 East Seneca Street, Sherrill, NY 13461
Closed • Opens Saturday at 10:45AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement