
Sugar Mama Cafe
Featured Items
Hummus Plate
Fluffy, house-made hummus, kalamata olives, crudité, and pita
$15.00Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms
Baked baby bella mushroom caps filled with spicy sausage and cream cheese GF
$13.00Muffaletta Hoagie
New Orleans inspired hoagie. 3 meats-ham, mortadella, and hot capicola-grilled and layered with melted provolone, house-made olive tapenade, pickled red onion, shredded lettuce with vinaigrette, and mayo on a toasted hoagie roll. Served with chips or crudité and ranch.
$16.50
Main Menu
Shareables
Whipped Feta with Honey Roasted Tomatoes & Crostini
Creamy whipped feta topped with warm, savory tomatoes roasted in honey and thyme. Served with warm sourdough toast
$16.00Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms
Baked baby bella mushroom caps filled with spicy sausage and cream cheese GF
$13.00Bloody Mary Deviled Eggs
Rimmed with colorful seasonings and garnished with spicy pickled green beans. They’ve got everything but the vodka GF
$16.00Boursin Deviled Eggs
Creamy garlic and herb cheese yolks topped with crispy fried onion bits
$16.00Dueling Deviled Eggs
Half Boursin, Half Bloody Mary
$16.00Hummus Plate
Fluffy, house-made hummus, kalamata olives, crudité, and pita
$15.00Hummus Feast
$21.00
Salads and Soup
Candied Bacon Wedge
Crisp iceberg lettuce topped with fresh buttermilk blue cheese dressing, crumbled blue cheese, grape tomatoes, pickled red onion, and our signature hickory smoked,brown sugar candied bacon. GF
$16.00House Salad
Mixed greens tossed in a house-made balsamic and dijon vinaigrette with grape tomatoes, croutons, and a light dusting of thin grated parmesan.
$12.00Roasted Acorn Squash Salad
Seasonal acorn squash roasted and tossed with mixed greens, quinoa, candied pecans, apple, and feta tossed in a house-made apple cider and orange vinaigrette. GF
$16.00CUP Tomato Bisque
Tomato and roasted vegetable puree with cream.
$6.00CUP Soup of the Day (weekdays)
Scratch made and delicious. Ask for Vegan or GF Option. Wednesday-Chipotle Black Bean with Roasted Sweet Potato (GF, Vegan without crema topping) Thursday- Roasted butternut squash (Vegan, GF without croutons) Friday- Creamy Chicken and Dumpling
$6.00OUT OF STOCKBOWL Tomato Bisque
Tomato and roasted vegetable puree with cream.
$9.00BOWL Soup of the Day (weekdays)
Scratch made and delicious. Ask for Vegan or GF Option. Wednesday-Chipotle Black Bean with Roasted Sweet Potato (GF, Vegan without crema topping) Thursday- Roasted butternut squash (Vegan, GF without croutons) Friday- Creamy Chicken and Dumpling
$9.00OUT OF STOCK
Savory Plates
Signature Grilled Cheese
Crunchy sourdough filled with a blend of melted Gouda, cheddar, and Jarlsberg cheeses and our homemade spicy tomato jam
$14.00Chicken Asada Quesadilla
Tender chicken, carrots, sweet corn, and black beans marinated in a savory citrus sauce, our delicious melty cheese blend, and a tomato chile tortilla. Served with spicy or mild remoulade.
$16.00Tofu Asada Quesadilla
Crumbled tofu, carrots, sweet corn, and black beans marinated in a savory citrus sauce, our delicious melty cheese blend, and a tomato chile tortilla. Served with spicy or mild remoulade. Vegan Option
$16.00Candied Bacon BLT
Hickory smoked bacon candied in spices and brown sugar, layered with fresh tomato, lettuce, and mayo on fluffy Texas toast. Served with potato chips or crudité with ranch.
$14.00Mediterranean Hummus Wrap
Our delicious house-made hummus, creamy havarti, olive tapenade, onion, tomato, and mixed greens tossed in Greek vinaigrette. Vegan option.
$14.00Muffaletta Hoagie
New Orleans inspired hoagie. 3 meats-ham, mortadella, and hot capicola-grilled and layered with melted provolone, house-made olive tapenade, pickled red onion, shredded lettuce with vinaigrette, and mayo on a toasted hoagie roll. Served with chips or crudité and ranch.
$16.50Macaroni and Cheese
Creamy 3-cheese sauce over shell pasta, topped with sharp cheddar cheese and seasoned potato chip crumbles and baked to perfection.
$16.00Tex Mex Macaroni and Cheese
Creamy 3-cheese and cumin sauce over shell pasta, topped with fire-roasted hatch chilis, sharp cheddar cheese and seasoned potato chip crumbles and baked to perfection.
$18.00Cheeseburger Sliders
Three 2 oz smash burger patties with American cheese, mayo, French fried onions, and our signature hot tomato jam on toasted Hawaiian rolls and served with kettle style potato chips.
$18.00Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac and Cheese
Grilled chicken breast, our creamy house-made cheese sauce, ranch spiced crispy topping, hickory smoked bacon crumbles and a drizzle of buttermilk ranch over it all. It’s the ultimate comfort food indulgence and there’s plenty to share!
$22.00OUT OF STOCKPasta Primavera with Roasted Pine Nuts and Crispy Basil
Shell pasta sauteed in creamy shallot sauce with fresh spinach and grape tomatoes, then topped with roasted pine nuts and crispy fried basil.
$18.00OUT OF STOCK
Sides
Kid's Selections
Kids Grilled Cheese
Our signature cheese blend on Texas toast. Served with potato chips or crudité with ranch.
$8.00Kids PB&J
Fluffy Texas toast, creamy peanut butter, and strawberry jelly. Served with potato chips or crudité with ranch. Vegan option.
$8.00Shells with Butter & Parmesan
Shell pasta sauteed with butter, salt, and pepper and topped with shaved parmesan cheese. Served with potato chips or crudité with ranch.
$8.00
Cookies
Brown Butter Salted Chocolate Chip Cookie
Brown butter cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips and pecans inside, dark chocolate chunks and flaky salt on top. Our most popular cookie!
$4.00Oreo Smash Cookie
A chocolatey, chewy delicious cookie filled and topped with Oreo pieces and chocolate chips.
$4.00OUT OF STOCKPeanut Butter Cookie GF and Vegan
Simply delicious peanut butter goodness!
$4.00Strawberry Pop Tart Cookie
Shortbread cookie filled with house-made strawberry jam and drizzled with icing
$4.00Sugar Cookie with Rosewater Almond Butter Cream
Our delicious sugar cookie with delicate rosewater and almond buttercream. Available for a limited time only!
$4.00OUT OF STOCK
Pastries and Muffins
Cranberry Streusel Muffin
Cranberries, orange zest, and white chocolate chips with buttery crumble
$5.00OUT OF STOCKBanana Nut Muffin Gluten Free
Bananas, pecans, and buttery crumble
$5.00OUT OF STOCKHam and Havarti Puff Pastry
Thin sliced ham, creamy havarti, and onion jam rolled in a flaky puff pastry shell
$5.00OUT OF STOCKRoasted Tomato Havarti Puff Pastry
Delicious puff pastry folded around creamy havarti and honey roasted tomatoes with thyme and garlic.
$5.00OUT OF STOCKBlueberry Cream Cheese Danish
Delicious puff pastry layered with sweetened cream cheese and house-made jam.
$5.00OUT OF STOCK
Dessert
Affogato
A scoop of Lopez Island Sweet Cream Ice Cream and two shots of espresso
$8.00Fruit Cobbler
Deliciously warm fruit compote under a fluffy, crispy top crust. Ask for today’s flavor.
$10.00Ice Cream Sundae
Lopez Island Sweet Cream ice cream, chocolate syrup, caramel, fresh whipped cream, roasted almonds GF
$10.00Lemon Cheesecake
Fluffy cheesecake bursting with fresh lemon flavor, garnished with fresh cranberry raspberry whipped cream
$12.00Salted Caramel Butter Crumble
Sweet and salty crumb cake with a delicious caramel core served warm with a scoop of Lopez Island Sweet Cream. Our most popular dessert.
$12.00Mocha Me Crazy Cake
Moist chocolate cake layered with milk chocolate ganache and cappuccino buttercream, coated with chocolate cake crumble, Moka Joe espresso beans and mini chocolate chips.
$12.00Caramel Apple Spice Cake
Washington-grown apples in a delicious spice cake, layered with brown butter cream cheese frosting and our house-made caramel drizzle.
$12.00OUT OF STOCKCoke Float
Mexican Coca Cola with Lopez Sweet Cream ice cream
$7.00Root Beer Float
Old Keg Root Beer with Lopez Sweet Cream ice cream
$7.00Mead Float
Bee Haven Peach Mead and Lopez Sweet Cream Ice Cream
$16.00Butterscotch Beer Float
Butterscotch Beer (non-alcoholic, seasonal) and Lopez Sweet Cream ice cream
$7.00
Coffee & Tea
Affogato
A scoop of Lopez Island Sweet Cream Ice Cream and two shots of espresso
$8.00Americano
$4.00Cappucino
$5.00Caramel Macchiato
$7.00Chai
$6.00Drip Coffee
$2.50Hot Chocolate
$4.00Iced Tea
$2.50Latte
$6.00London Fog Latte
$6.00Matcha Latte
$6.00Mocha
$6.50Steamer
$4.00Tea Chamomile
$5.00Tea Earl Gray
$5.00Tea Evening Comfort
$5.00Tea Irish Breakfast
$5.00Tea Sunset in Seattle
$5.00White Mocha
$6.50Espresso
$4.00
Beverages
Non-alcoholic Beverages
Arnold Palmer
$3.00Bottled Water
$2.00Butterscotch Beer
$3.00Chocolate Milk
$3.00Cranberry Juice
$3.00Diet Coke
$3.00Grapefruit Kiss Soda
$3.00Lemonade
$3.00Martinelli's Sparkling Apple Juice
$3.00Mexican Coca Cola
$3.00Milk
$3.00Tost Sparkling White Tea Cranberry Ginger
$5.00Orange Juice
$3.00Topo Chico Sparkling Water
$3.00Coke Float
Mexican Coca Cola with Lopez Sweet Cream ice cream
$7.00Root Beer Float
Old Keg Root Beer with Lopez Sweet Cream ice cream
$7.00Root Beer
$3.00