Skip to Main content
SugarBakers Cakes Online Ordering -- Monday - Thursday 23 Mellor Ave. -- Friday - Saturday 752 Frederick Rd.
  • SugarBakers Cakes

SugarBakers Cakes

23 Mellor Avenue, Catonsville, MD
Pickup Only
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • Amaretto Raspberry Cake

    SugarBakers "signature" flavor. Almond cake filled with a layer of amaretto buttercream and European Raspberry preserves, covered in french buttercream.
    $48.00+
  • Smith Island Cake

    Voted Baltimore's Best! Nine layers of moist yellow cake filled with fudge icing and optional peanut butter cups.
    $65.00+
  • Red Velvet Smith Island

    Nine layers of red velvet cake filled with fudge. Iced in cream cheese icing.
    $65.00+

Thanksgiving Desserts

  • Turkey Cake

    A cute 6 inch turkey cake that will be the star of your Thanksgiving table! Iced in chocolate french buttercream and decorated with chocolate feathers.
    $95.00
  • Caramel Apple Pie - 10 inch

    Homestyle Apple pie drizzled with caramel.
    $32.00
  • Home Style Apple Pie -10 inch

    Traditional double crust apple pie dusted with cinnamon sugar.
    $32.00
  • Blueberry Pie - 10 inch

    9-inch blueberry pie with a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar on the crust.
    $35.00
  • Peach Pie - 10 inch

    9-inch Peach Pie with a cinnamon sugar sprinkle baked into the crust.
    $35.00
  • Pumpkin Pie 9-inch

    Creamy pumpkin pie spiced with the flavors of fall and a whip cream garnish.
    $32.00
  • Southern Pecan Pie - 9 inch

    Rich caramel and pecan filling baked in a flaky crust. Drizzled with chocolate ganache and finished with fudge rosettes.
    $35.00
  • Peanut Butter Pie - 9 inch

    Chocolate cookie crust filled with a light and creamy peanut butter mousse. Drizzled with ganache and topped with white chocolate curls.
    $32.00
  • Key Lime Pie - 10 inch

    A graham cracker crust with smooth creamy slightly tart key lime filling.
    $32.00
  • Apple Pie Cheesecake -10 inch

    Apple swirled through cheesecake batter baking in a shortbread crust. Topped with caramel and crunchy streusel.
    $64.00
  • Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake

    Creamy pumpkin cheese cake with vanilla cheesecake swirl with pumpkin spiced graham cracker crust.
    $63.00
  • Pumpkin Smith Island Cake

    Nine layers of moist pumpkin cake filled and covered in cream cheese icing.
    $65.00+
  • Snickerdoodle Smith Island Cake

    Nine layers of yellow cake, filled with a cinnamon cream cheese icing. Iced in cream cheese, and adorned with cinnamon crystal sugar.
    $65.00+

Specialty Cakes

  • Let's Go O's!

    A perfect cake for any Orioles fan!
    $70.00+
  • Purple Pride

    The perfect cake for a Ravens fan! This cake is iced in American Buttercream and a great addition to your tailgate.
    $70.00+
  • Vintage Vibes

    $79.00+
  • Neopolitan Cake

    Layers of devil's food, strawberry and yellow cake filled with German buttercream. Iced with chocolate, pink and white buttercream.
    $65.00+
  • Pretty in Pink

    Cake is extra tall, iced in light pink German Buttercream finished with a white drip, white chocolate shavings and a pink sugar sprinkle.
    $91.00+
  • Triple Chocolate Cake

    Extra tall chocolate cake, filled with chocolate mousse, iced in chocolate buttercream draped with dark chocolate ganache and a chocolate candy garnish like the photo.
    $91.00+
  • Peachy Keen

    Cake is iced in light peach German Buttercream, garnished with peach and ivory rosettes. Pick from five of our top cake flavors. If getting an inscription on the 6 inch, it will be put on the board.
    $70.00+
  • Confetti Birthday Cake

    Pick one of our 5 preset cake flavors. The cake will be iced in German Buttercream and decorated with confetti sprinkles like the picture.
    $66.00+
  • Pink and Pearl's Cake

    A 5 layer, 6 inch cake iced in American Buttercream. Decorated with pink icing and pearls.
    $70.00+

Smith Island Cakes

  • Smith Island Cake

    Voted Baltimore's Best! Nine layers of moist yellow cake filled with fudge icing and optional peanut butter cups.
    $65.00+
  • Lemon Coconut Smith Island Cake

    9 layers of lemon cake filled with toasted coconut buttercream. Iced in American buttercream and covered in coconut flakes.
    $65.00+
  • Oreo Smith Island

    Nine thin layers of our chocolate cake, filled with American buttercream and crushed Oreo cookies. Iced in American Buttercream.
    $65.00+
  • Red Velvet Smith Island

    Nine layers of red velvet cake filled with fudge. Iced in cream cheese icing.
    $65.00+
  • Strawberry Smith Island Cake

    Nine layers of light pink strawberry cake filled and iced with a light cream cheese icing.
    $65.00+
  • Snickerdoodle Smith Island Cake

    Nine layers of yellow cake, filled with a cinnamon cream cheese icing. Iced in cream cheese, and adorned with cinnamon crystal sugar.
    $65.00+
  • Pumpkin Smith Island Cake

    Nine layers of moist pumpkin cake filled and covered in cream cheese icing.
    $65.00+

Fine Line Cakes

  • Amaretto Raspberry Cake

    SugarBakers "signature" flavor. Almond cake filled with a layer of amaretto buttercream and European Raspberry preserves, covered in french buttercream.
    $48.00+
  • Classic Ivory Cake

    Yellow cake filled and iced with French buttercream.
    $48.00+
  • Chocolate Mousse Cake

    Devils food cake layered with chocolate mousse, iced in American buttercream.
    $48.00+
  • Pimlico Cake

    A Baltimore Tradition. Most yellow cake layered with fresh pastry cream, covered in fudge icing.
    $48.00+
  • Country Carrot Cake

    A dense moist combination of carrots, walnuts, pineapples, and spice, with our cream cheese icing, finished with toasted coconut and walnuts.
    $48.00+
  • Red Velvet Fudge Cake

    Light chocolate sour cream cake colored a soft red and filled with fudge and cream cheese icing.
    $48.00+
  • Lemon Mousse Cake

    Light layers of lemon cake layered with lemon mousse. Iced with French buttercream and fresh lemon curd.
    $48.00+
  • Yellow Cake w/ Fudge Icing

    A classic! Yellow cake covered with fudge icing.
    $48.00+
  • Chocolate Decadence

    Devils food cake layered with bittersweat ganache and chocolate chips simply finished with ganache and mini chocolate chips.
    $58.00+
  • Cannoli Cake

    Layers of yellow and chocolate cake filled with cannoli cream covered in French buttercream.
    $59.00+
  • You've Got Chocolate in my Peanut Butter

    Yellow and Chocolate cake layered with fudge and peanut butter buttercream. Iced in fudge, decorated with a peanut butter drizzle.
    $58.00+
  • Raspberry Ribbon Cake

    Multiple layers of delicate yellow and devils food chocolate cake heightened by alternate fillings of raspberry buttercream and dark ganache, with a poured chocolate finish.
    $63.00+
  • Chocolate Truffle Torte (Gluten Free) - 10 inch

    Flourless semi sweet chocolate cake with a ganache glaze. This torte is made in a facility that is not gluten free. Cross contamination is possible.
    $72.00
  • Coconut Cake

    Yellow cake layered with American buttercream and sweetened coconut.
    $48.00+
  • Pack Gold Candles

    $5.00
  • Pack Silver Candles

    $5.00
  • Pack Multicolored Candles

    $5.00

Tiered Cake

  • Two Tier Celebration Cake

    Two tier comes as pictured, iced in German buttercream with one pearl dusted peony sugar flower. Serves 45 people. No adjustments can be made.
    $405.00

Gender Reveal

  • Gender Reveal with "Boy or Girl?"

    Cake is layered with either blue or pink German Buttercream. Get this to add a little surprise to such a joyous occasion.
    $70.00+

Cupcakes

  • Box of 6 Cupcakes

    Choose one of our cupcake flavors.
    $24.00
  • Box of 12 Cupcakes

    Choose two of our cupcake flavors.
    $44.00

Gluten Free Desserts

  • Chocolate Truffle Torte (Gluten Free) - 10 inch

    Flourless semi sweet chocolate cake with a ganache glaze. This torte is made in a facility that is not gluten free. Cross contamination is possible.
    $72.00

Cheesecake

  • Vanilla Cheesecake

    Grahamcracker crust topped with our creamy West Coast style Cheesecake.
    $65.00
  • Chocolate Top Cheesecake - 10 inch

    Shortbread crust with creamy cheesecake and chocolate top cookies. Topped with fudge icing.
    $65.00
  • Apple Pie Cheesecake -10 inch

    Apple swirled through cheesecake batter baking in a shortbread crust. Topped with caramel and crunchy streusel.
    $64.00
  • Black Bottom Cheesecake - 9 inch

    A layer of chocolate fudge cake covered with chocolate chip cheesecake.
    $56.00
  • Cherry Cheesecake

    Vanilla cheesecake topped with cherries.
    $65.00
  • Turtle Pecan Cheesecake

    Vanilla cheesecake, iced in fudge, topped with caramel and pecans.
    $65.00
  • Strawberry Cheesecake

    Vanilla cheesecake topped with fresh strawberries.
    $74.00
  • Fresh Fruit Cheesecake

    Vanilla cheesecake topped with seasonal fruit.
    $74.00
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake

    10 inch Creamy vanilla and pumpkin swirled cheesecake. Chocolate sprinkles on the sides with a cream cheese rosette.
    $65.00

Pies

  • Fresh Strawberry Pie - 9 inch

    Pastry cream covered by glazed fresh strawberries.
    $42.00
  • Peanut Butter Pie - 9 inch

    Chocolate cookie crust filled with a light and creamy peanut butter mousse. Drizzled with ganache and topped with white chocolate curls.
    $32.00
  • Key Lime Pie - 10 inch

    A graham cracker crust with smooth creamy slightly tart key lime filling.
    $32.00
  • Caramel Apple Pie - 10 inch

    Homestyle Apple pie drizzled with caramel.
    $32.00
  • Peach Pie - 10 inch

    9-inch Peach Pie with a cinnamon sugar sprinkle baked into the crust.
    $35.00
  • Home Style Apple Pie -10 inch

    Traditional double crust apple pie dusted with cinnamon sugar.
    $32.00
  • Southern Pecan Pie - 9 inch

    Rich caramel and pecan filling baked in a flaky crust. Drizzled with chocolate ganache and finished with fudge rosettes.
    $35.00
  • Pumpkin Pie - 9 inch

    Traditional pumpkin pie topped with whipped cream and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.
    $32.00
  • Blueberry Pie - 10 inch

    9-inch blueberry pie with a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar on the crust.
    $35.00

Coffee Cake, Cookies, Slices and Bars

  • Pecan Coffee Cake - Square

    $6.50+
  • Cinnamon Pecan Coffee Cake

    $47.00+
  • A Dozen Chocolate Top Cookies

    A Baltimore Classic! A sugar cookie topped with a swirl of chocolate fudge icing.
    $28.00
  • A Dozen Homestyle Cookies

    Minimum doz
    $25.00
  • Amaretto Raspberry Cake Slice

    $7.00
  • Smith Island Cake Slice

    $9.00
  • Fudge Brownie Bars

    6 of our delicious fudge brownies cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.
    $27.00
  • Luscious Lemon Bars

    6 of our delicious lemon bars cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.
    $27.00
  • Blondies

    6 of our delicious blondies cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.
    $27.00
  • Pecan Bars

    6 of our delicious pecan bars cut in 3 inch by 3 inch squares.
    $27.00
  • Cherry Cheesecake Bars

    Four creamy cherry cheesecake squares, with a graham cracker crust.
    $27.00

Pimlico Cake

$0.00

A Baltimore Tradition. Most yellow cake layered with fresh pastry cream, covered in fudge icing.

Customize your item

Pimlico Size

Required
Select 1

Inscription

Required
Select 1

Colors

Required
Select 1

Additional Decorations

Select up to 1

Want an additional slice?

Optional

Want any candles?

Optional
Request advisory
Add inscription information here (for Cakes ONLY). Inscriptions may be a MAXIMUM of 6 words.
1

SugarBakers Cakes Location and Ordering Hours

(410) 788-4170
23 Mellor Avenue, Catonsville, MD 21228
Closed • Opens Friday at 10AM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement