Skip to Main content
Super Nice Pizza - 72hr fermented dough for happier bellies
  • Super Nice Pizza

Super Nice Pizza

975 AMSTERDAM AVE, New York, NY
‌
‌

Featured Items

  • Pepperoni Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, Ezzo pepperoni
    $27.80
  • Regular Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $24.20
  • Caesar Salad

    romaine hearts, shaved parmigiano reggiano, housemade croutons
    $21.40

Evening delivery menu

Small Plates

  • Seasonal Vegetable Plate

    Currently roasted eggplant, zucchini, kabocha and/or acorn squash, broccoli rabe, and portobellos, served with a white bean puree
    $25.20
  • Meatballs and Sauce

    Chuck. brisket, short rib meatballs with GF breadcrumbs, parmigiano reggiano, pecorino, eggs. Tomato sauce. Ricotta.
    $20.40
  • Whipped ricotta

    Fresh ricotta whipped with lemon, crushed red pepper, fresh herbs, and extra virgin olive oil. Served with fresh bread.
    $14.95
  • Fried Calamari

    Xs and Os, cherry peppers, parsley, peppadew super sauce.
    $22.80
  • House beans

    House-seasoned beans, served warm.
    $26.30

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    romaine hearts, shaved parmigiano reggiano, housemade croutons
    $21.40
  • Little Gem Salad

    little gem, rainbow radish, buttermilk dill dressing
    $21.60
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Fennel Salad

    shaved fennel, red onion, green apple, ricotta salata, toasted pistachios, lemon, olive oil
    $22.60
  • Grain Salad

    Probably the most popular salad on the menu. Al dente farro, roasted squash, cherry tomatoes, radishes, shaved red onion, toasted pepitas, arugula, and crumbled feta. Lightly dressed with lemon and olive oil. Apple cider vinegar cooked in with the farro (and so cannot be omitted - any other item can be removed).
    $23.10
  • Melon Salad

    Seasonal melon salad with fresh herbs and a light dressing.
    $24.20
    OUT OF STOCK

Pizza (12" pies)

  • Regular Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $24.20
  • Tomato Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh garlic, oregano, extra virgin olive oil
    $21.80
  • Pepperoni Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, Ezzo pepperoni
    $27.80
  • Sausage Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, shaved red onion, housemade fennel sausage, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $29.00
  • Eggplant Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, roasted eggplant, ricotta salata, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $27.80
  • Vegan pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, violife mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $24.20
  • White Clam Pie

    clams, garlic, oregano, pecorino, fresh mozzarella, parsley, lemon
    $33.80
  • Zucchini Pie

    roasted organic zucchini, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, parmigiano reggiano
    $27.80
  • Mushroom Pie

    mozzarella, fontina, fresh market mushrooms
    $29.00
  • Potato Pie

    potato, fontina, onion, smoked fresh mozzarella, fresh herbs
    $30.20
  • House white pie

    Fresh mozzarella, shredded mozzarella, pecorino, fresh garlic, oregano, parsley, shaved ricotta salata after the bake.
    $24.00
  • Hot Italian Beef

    an italian beef sandwich, but pizza. shaved prime sirloin, jp graziano hot giardinera, organo, maldon sea salt, mozzarella, pecorino
    $31.90
    OUT OF STOCK

Large Plates

  • Steak frites

    Classic 10oz Lafrieda steak, cooked to temp, with our frites sauce (contains dairy), served with hand cut fries
    $46.00
  • Burger and fries

    Double patty smashburger, onions, cooper's sharp american cheese, pickles, and house sauce on a Martin's potato roll with fries on the side
    $27.60
  • Chicken Parm

    Chicken cutlet, sauce, cheese. Served with some bread on the side. Coincidentally gluten free.
    $36.00
  • Pork chop with vinegar peppers

    Pork chop topped with tangy vinegar peppers.
    $33.00
  • Eggplant Parm

    Possibly the best eggplant parm I've ever had. Eggplant "cutlet", sauce, cheese. Eggplant is GF. Served with some bread on the side.
    $36.00
  • Chicken special

    Tonight’s chicken special - ask about the current preparation.
    $38.50
  • Spaghetti and Meatballs TO GO

    spaghetti and meatballs. google it if you're not sure what it is.
    $33.00
  • Spaghetti and Scampi TO GO

    shrimp scampi over pasta.
    $38.50

Sides

  • Fries

    Crispy fries with your choice of dipping sauces.
    $12.00
  • Side sauce

    Side of house sauce.
    $6.00
  • Side sesame bread (Copy)

    Side of sesame bread.
    $9.60

Extra sauces

  • Side Chili oil

    Side of chili oil for extra heat.
    $2.40
  • Side Garlic oil

    Side of garlic oil for dipping or drizzling.
    $2.40
  • Side ranch

    Side of ranch dressing.
    $3.60
  • Side peppadew Aioli

    Side of peppadew aioli.
    $3.60
  • Side Lemon Caper Aioli

    Side of lemon caper aioli.
    $3.60

Desserts

  • Chocolate Cake

    Rich chocolate layer cake with chocolate frosting.
    $26.40
  • Tiramisu

    Espresso-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone cream and cocoa.
    $21.60
  • Cannoli

    Crisp cannoli shell filled with sweet ricotta.
    $15.60
  • Carrot cake

    Carrot cake, carrot whip, toasted walnuts on the outside. No raisins.
    $26.40

Drinks

  • Diet Coke

    Diet Coke.
    $4.80
  • Mexican Coke

    Mexican Coca-Cola made with cane sugar.
    $6.00
  • Stappi Chinotto

    Italian chinotto soda with a bittersweet citrus finish.
    $6.00
  • Mexican Sprite

    Mexican Sprite made with cane sugar.
    $7.00
  • Club Soda

    Sparkling club soda.
    $4.80

Sunday night delivery menu

Small Plates

  • Seasonal Vegetable Plate

    Currently roasted eggplant, zucchini, kabocha and/or acorn squash, broccoli rabe, and portobellos, served with a white bean puree
    $25.20
  • Meatballs and Sauce

    Chuck. brisket, short rib meatballs with GF breadcrumbs, parmigiano reggiano, pecorino, eggs. Tomato sauce. Ricotta.
    $19.00
  • Whipped ricotta

    Fresh ricotta whipped with lemon, crushed red pepper, fresh herbs, and extra virgin olive oil. Served with fresh bread.
    $12.00
  • Fried Calamari

    Xs and Os, cherry peppers, parsley, peppadew super sauce.
    $19.00
  • Seasonal risotto

    English peas and roasted asparagus
    $18.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Mozzarella and peppers

    Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, sun dried tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil
    $16.00
  • House beans

    House-seasoned beans, served warm.
    $23.00

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    romaine hearts, shaved parmigiano reggiano, housemade croutons
    $19.00
  • Little Gem Salad

    little gem, rainbow radish, buttermilk dill dressing
    $18.00
    OUT OF STOCK
  • Fennel Salad

    shaved fennel, red onion, green apple, ricotta salata, toasted pistachios, lemon, olive oil
    $22.60
  • Fall Grain Salad

    Farro grain salad with roasted squash, tomatoes, pepitas, arugula, feta, and lemon-olive oil.
    $23.10

Pizza

  • Regular Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $21.00
  • Tomato Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh garlic, oregano, extra virgin olive oil
    $19.00
  • Pepperoni Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, Ezzo pepperoni
    $24.00
  • Sausage Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, shaved red onion, housemade fennel sausage, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $29.00
  • Eggplant Pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pecorino, 24 month parmigiano reggiano, roasted eggplant, ricotta salata, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $24.00
  • Vegan pie

    Bianco di Napoli organic tomatoes, violife mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil
    $21.00
  • White Clam Pie

    clams, garlic, oregano, pecorino, fresh mozzarella, parsley, lemon
    $29.00
  • Zucchini Pie

    roasted organic zucchini, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, parmigiano reggiano
    $24.00
  • Mushroom Pie

    mozzarella, fontina, fresh market mushrooms
    $25.00
  • Potato Pie

    potato, fontina, onion, smoked fresh mozzarella, fresh herbs
    $26.00
  • House white pie

    Fresh mozzarella, shredded mozzarella, pecorino, fresh garlic, oregano, parsley, shaved ricotta salata after the bake.
    $24.00

Large Plates

  • Steak frites

    Classic 10oz Lafrieda steak, cooked to temp, with our frites sauce (contains dairy), served with hand cut fries
    $46.00
  • Burger and fries

    Double patty smashburger, onions, cooper's sharp american cheese, pickles, and house sauce on a Martin's potato roll with fries on the side
    $26.30
  • Chicken Parm

    Chicken cutlet, sauce, cheese. Served with some bread on the side. Coincidentally gluten free.
    $36.00
  • Pork chop with vinegar peppers

    Pork chop topped with tangy vinegar peppers.
    $36.00
  • Eggplant Parm

    Eggplant cutlet baked with tomato sauce and melted cheese, served with bread.
    $36.00

Sides

  • Fries

    Crispy fries with your choice of dipping sauces.
    $10.00
  • Side sauce

    Side of house sauce.
    $5.00
  • Side everything bread

    Side of everything-seasoned bread.
    $8.00

Extra sauces

  • Side Chili oil

    Side of chili oil for extra heat.
    $2.00
  • Side Garlic oil

    Side of garlic oil for dipping or drizzling.
    $2.00
  • Side ranch

    Side of ranch dressing.
    $3.00
  • Side peppadew Aioli

    Side of peppadew aioli.
    $3.00
  • Side Lemon Caper Aioli

    Side of lemon caper aioli.
    $3.00

Desserts

  • Chocolate Cake

    Rich chocolate layer cake with chocolate frosting.
    $26.40
  • Tiramisu

    Espresso-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone cream and cocoa.
    $21.60
  • Cannoli

    Crisp cannoli shell filled with sweet ricotta.
    $15.60
  • Coconut cake

    Moist coconut layer cake with creamy frosting and toasted coconut.
    $24.20
  • Carrot cake

    Classic carrot cake with cream cheese frosting.
    $24.00
    OUT OF STOCK

Drinks

  • Diet Coke

    Diet Coke.
    $4.00
  • Mexican Coke

    Mexican Coca-Cola made with cane sugar.
    $5.00
  • Stappi Chinotto

    Italian chinotto soda with a bittersweet citrus finish.
    $6.00
  • Mexican Sprite

    Mexican Sprite made with cane sugar.
    $6.00
  • Club Soda

    Sparkling club soda.
    $4.00

Super Nice Pizza Location and Ordering Hours

(347) 793-8338
975 AMSTERDAM AVE, New York, NY 10025
Open now • Closes at 9PM
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement