The Bagel Bar Cafe

Choose from our wide selection of Lancaster county-made cream cheeses

Eggs, crispy bacon and perfectly melted cheese on your favorite NY bagel!

A new york classic. On your favorite bagel, croissant, or toast

organic matcha layered with sweet blueberry nectar and Tahitian vanilla-infused milk over ice, crowned with pillowy whipped cream dusted with delicate blueberry powder, creating a refreshing purple-green gradient as captivating as its garden namesake.

a iced symphony of spiced chai, bold espresso, and velvety almond milk kissed with blackberry sweetness and crowned with whipped cream and candied almonds.

a hot maple cinnamon caramel macchiato - featuring layers of espresso, maple syrup, steamed milk and a luscious Ghirardelli caramel swirl topped with a dusting of cinnamon

an iced maple cinnamon caramel macchiato - featuring layers of espresso, maple syrup, milk and a luscious Ghirardelli caramel swirl topped with a dusting of cinnamon

a shaken iced lavender lemonade with fresh lemon and a sprinkle of lavender. Try adding a shot of espresso and prepare to have your mind blown!

a delicate blend of premium tea infused with fragrant Tahitian vanilla beans, velvety steamed milk, and subtle notes of macarons, finished with a silky foam reminiscent of spring's most elegant

Open-face bagel with tomatoes, avocado, goat cheese spread, and feta cheese crumbles drizzled with a sweet balsamic glaze

House-made scallion cream cheese, fresh smoked salmon, onions, capers and dill! Served open-faced with a lemon wedge.

Brace yourself for 'THE BEE STING'! One bite of this fiery combo—crispy bacon, melty cheese, perfect scrambled eggs, hot honey, and scallion cream cheese on your favorite bagel—and you'll feel the sweet and savory sting. Dare to take a bite?

Perfectly cooked eggs with melty cheese between your choice of 24 bagel varieties, croissants, or toast

Eggs, green pepper, onion, tomato, and cheese between two halves of your favorite bagel, a croissant, or toast

Eggs, ham, and beautifully melted cheese on your choice of bagel, croissant, or toast

Eggs, crispy bacon and perfectly melted cheese on your favorite NY bagel!

A new york classic. On your favorite bagel, croissant, or toast

You might know it as "Taylor ham." We love it with egg and cheese on your favorite NY bagel!

Two sausage patties with cheese on your favorite bagel, croissant, or toast

Crispy bacon and cheese between two halves of your favorite bagel, croissant, or toast

Plenty of pork roll (or 'taylor ham', depending on where you're from) with cheese. On your choice of bagel, croissant, or toast

Egg whites, turkey, tomato, and cheese with french's yellow mustard. On your choice of bagel, croissant, or toast

Eggs, ham, green pepper, tomato, and onion with cheese. Yeah, like the omelet, only this comes on a bagel, croissant, or toast

The brain-child of a local gym owner, fitness guru, and ku athletics coach, this bagelwich has eggs, sausage, ham, turkey, and cheese. Plus... Wait for it... Strawberry cream cheese!

If you thought our pink flamingo was over the top, try adding pork roll and bacon. This breakfast conglomeration has eggs, sausage, ham, turkey, bacon, pork roll, and cheese with strawberry cream cheese. All, somehow, stacked between to halves of your favo

Toasted open-faced bagel with butter, smashed avocado and a sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning

Grilled chicken breast, buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, and blue cheese dressing on your favorite NY bagel

Grilled chicken breast, Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, and mayo on your favorite NY bagel

The classic italian dish, bagel bar style. Breaded chicken breast, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese on your favorite NY bagel

A simple and tasty local favorite! Chicken salad with lettuce and tomato on your favorite NY bagel

Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onion, and honey mustard on your favorite NY bagel

Fresh hot Virginia ham and melted cheese with honey mustard on your favorite NY bagel

Open-faced with homemade red-pepper hummus, cucumber, tomatoes and sprouts on your favorite NY bagel

Nova Scotian smoked salmon with freshly sliced tomatoes, onions and cream cheese on on your favorite NY bagel

The classic...with tons of crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, tomatoes and mayo on your favorite NY bagel

Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, and Caesar dressing on your favorite NY bagel

Open-face with tomatoes, avocado, goat cheese spread, and feta cheese crumbles drizzled with a sweet balsamic glaze on your favorite NY bagel

Named after and created by our founder, Christine. Hot Virginia ham, turkey breast, and melted cheese on an egg bagel with a side of strawberry preserves

Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onions and ranch dressing on your favorite NY bagel

No relation to its molecular homonym. This sandwich includes Turkey breast, Virginia Ham & Cheese with our cheddar horseradish cream cheese on your favorite NY bagel

American, swiss, and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo on your favorite NY bagel

Open-faced NY bagel, homemade tuna salad & cheese melted in the oven, to perfection

Our famous, homemade tuna salad with lettuce and tomato on your favorite NY bagel

This skyscraper of a sandwich includes thin-sliced local turkey breast, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, cheese & mayo on your favorite NY bagel

The owner's personal favorite! Your choice of fresh NY bagel with fresh sliced green peppers, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, sprouts, and veggie cream cheese! Try hummus instead of cream cheese for the perfect vegan treat!

Open-faced bagel with fresh mozzarella and pizza sauce, oven-baked to perfection

Breaded chicken breast, chopped onion, mozzarella, provolone cheese, and bbq sauce. Oven-baked to perfection on your choice of an open-faced bagel

Bread chicken breast, mozzarella, provolone, and buffalo sauce with a side of blue cheese dressing. Oven-baked on an open-faced bagel of your choice

Breaded chicken breast, crispy bacon and cheese. Oven-baked to perfection on your choice of an open-faced bagel

Please order before 2pm the day before pickup. We cannot fulfill large bagel orders the same day they are ordered. Thank you! This bundle includes 18 bagels with a half pound of plain cream cheese and your choice of two half-pounds of flavored cream cheese

Please order before 2pm the day before pickup. We cannot fulfill large bagel orders the same day they are ordered. Thank you! The baby bagel bundle includes a baker's dozen (13) bagels with half a pound of plain cream cheese and a half pound of your choice

Advance order required. Please order before 2 pm the day before pickup. We are unable to fulfill large bagel orders the same day they are ordered. Thank you! Our brunch in box bundles includes a 160 ounce box of hot coffee, 10 assorted bagels, 6 large assorted muffins, 1/2 lb Plain cream cheese, 1/2 lb. cream cheese of your choice and all the fixins- knives, napkins, cups, cream and sugar!

Toasted open-faced bagel with butter, smashed avocado and a sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning

Choose from our wide selection of Lancaster county-made cream cheeses

Chose your favorite toasted bagel topped with just the right amount of butter

Our house-made, secret family recipe, roasted red pepper hummus spread atop your favorite fresh NY bagel!

Butter, cinnamon, and sugar spread atop your favorite toasted bagel

Preserves on your choice of toasted bagel

Grape jelly on your choice of toasted bagel

The classic, smooth treat artfully spread atop your favorite toasted bagel

Peanut butter and jelly between two halves of the best-toasted bagel in town. It's a simple classic for a reason!

That smooth, chocolatey hazelnut spread on your favorite toasted bagel! It's messy but it's so worth it!

Just toasted

Just a plain-ole bagel! For a toasted bagel with a spread (cream cheese, butter, etc.), head over to the menu section called "Toasted bagels, split and topped"!

Indulge in the delicious and comforting flavors of our gluten free NY Style bagels. A true delight for your taste buds! Always gluten-free, top 9 allergen-free, vegan plant-based, non-GMO project verified, and kosher. So good you'll be wondering whether they're actually gluten-free. Just a plain-ole GF bagel in a bag, to go! It comes frozen for freshness. Heat in microwave for 50 seconds and then toast and ENJOY! For a toasted bagel with a spread (cream cheese, butter, etc.), head over to the menu section called "Toasted bagels, split and topped"!

Please order before 2pm the day before pickup. We may not have your favorites on-hand. Your chosen assortment of six authentic new york bagels. List your picks in "Special requests."

Please order before 2pm the day before pickup. We may not have your favorites on-hand. We don't know why bakers decided to start throwing an extra bagel in with every dozen, but we figure we'll follow along. Pick your assortment of thirteen authentic New York bagels

A smallish side of cream cheese makes a great companion for those bagels with commitment issues

What's a bagel without its cream cheese? Honestly... Still pretty good. But you definitely won't regret getting some

A half-pound of any of our wide assortment of fresh lancaster-made cream cheeses

One pound of your choice from our wide assortment of fresh, locally-made cream cheeses

Better Than Mom’s Brown Butter Rice Krispie Treats! It’s true, promise, these rice krispie treats are like no other. House made with salted browned butter, double the marshmallows and just a touch of vanilla. They’re sweet, salty, buttery, extra gooey, and just a little bit addicting.

You are going to love this old-fashioned New York recipe ...a mountain of brown sugar crumbs piled high on top of a rich and buttery cake

Our friend, Ruthie, makes the best cinnamon rolls you'll ever sink your teeth into! Our ooey gooey cinnamon buns are made locally with a slow rise, sweet yeast dough that's combined with the perfect combination of brown sugar and cinnamon, topped with delectable cream cheese icing! Ask us to warm it up if you're eating it now!

Fresh-baked banana muffin

Fresh-baked blueberry muffin!

Fresh-baked chocolate chip muffin!

Freshly baked double chocolate chip muffins

Soft, chewy, and truly indulgent

Anita's homemade biscotti are made locally with recipes that are packed with wholesome ingredients -- real butter, real eggs, real chocolate, real flavorings, real dried fruits... Rich in flavor, light and crunchy in texture and delicately sweet.

Belgium chocolate covered espresso beans!

Belgium chocolate covered espresso beans

Walley's Sweets & Treats has done it again! Jess hand-crafted these Christmas cookies that melt in your mouth and look adorable too!

Strawberry buttercream with a pistachio Katafi (shredded filo dough) filling

Chocolate with cookie dough buttercream topped with a mini chocolate chip cookie!

Birthday cake filling with a rainbow sprinkles on top!

Blackberry chai buttercream filling. Pairs perfectly with this month's Orchid drink special!

Lavender buttercream with lemon curd filling. Pairs perfectly with this month's Lavender Lemonade drink special!

Blueberry matcha filling topped with blueberry flavored chocolates. Pairs perfectly with this month's Iris drink special!

Tahitian Vanilla Bean Filling. Pairs perfectly with this month's Tulip drink special!

Marshmallow filling with topped with a chocolate graham cracker

Maple cinnamon cream filling with a caramel center topped with a cinnamon sugar pretzel. Pairs perfectly with this month's Taurus drink special!

A local favorite, Crafted with specialty coffee beans from Brazil, Colombia, Ethiopia, and Nicaragua Milk Chocolate, Graham Cracker, Black Cherry.

**Decaf** coffee flavored with an enticing island blend of luscious caramel, vanilla, and creamy Mexican liqueur

Silky-smooth steamed milk mixed perfectly with our famous La Colombe Nizza espresso!

Foamed milk with espresso. Like drinking a coffee-flavored pillow. In a good way, obviously

Nizza is a medium roast blend that hits at the heart of sweet. It’s named for the city of Nice, France, hometown of La Colombe's co-founder JP and home to some of the best honey in the world. True to its name, this coffee exemplifies a honey-sweet, roasted nuttiness. It’s one of our favorites! Add whipped cream and make it an Espresso Con Panna!

Our smooth, full-bodied, robust La Colombe Nizza espresso with hot water

Latte with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce stirred in and drizzled on top. You're welcome! Add whipped cream for a decadent treat!

Our perfectly steamed latte with gourmet Ghirardelli caramel sauce stirred in and drizzled on top! Add whipped cream for a decadent treat!

Cafe Mocha meets Cafe Caramella. Together they create the perfect balance of sweetness! Add whipped cream for a decadent treat!

This is not a traditional macchiato, this is a sweet and creamy delight! We combine La Colombe's Nizza espresso with steamed milk and vanilla and top it off with our decadent Ghirardelli Caramel drizzle!

A blend of milk chocolate and Ghirardelli chocolate sauce in steamed milk, topped with whipped cream. Smooth, creamy, and unbelievably rich!

Our on-the-go carafe is filled with 160 fl oz of your favorite coffee (equivalent of twelve 8 fl oz cups) and all the fixins' {cups, lids, stir sticks, cream & sugar-a perfect pick me up for meetings, holiday gatherings or whenever you want to make some new friends!

Our on-the-go carafe is filled with 96 fl oz of your favorite coffee (equivalent of twelve 8 fl oz cups) and all the fixins' {cups, lids, stir sticks, cream & sugar-a perfect pick me up for meetings, holiday gatherings or whenever you want to make some new friends!

Fresh-roasted, single-origin fully washed, sun-dried coffee beans from Brazil, this medium roast retains the naturally bold and nutty flavors of Brazilian coffee. Our cold brew is steeped in cold water for precisely twenty-one hours for a smooth, clean sip.

Brewed hot, cooled and poured over ice. Not as good as Cold Brew, but a classic nevertheless

Our smooth espresso meets creamy oat milk in a perfectly shaken symphony of flavor and caffeine!

Cold-brew concentrate and milk over ice, creating an ultra-smooth iced beverage

Monin dark chocolate syrup, cold-brew-concentrate (espresso), and milk over ice

Monin caramel syrup, espresso, Ghirardelli caramel drizzle, and milk over ice

Chocolate and Caramel syrup, cold-brew-concentrate (espresso), and milk over ice

1 Gallon of our smooth, La Colombe Nizza Cold Brew Coffee. Please order before 2 pm the day before! We steep our cold brew to perfection for 24 hours!

1 Gallon of our smooth, La Colombe Nizza Cold Brew Coffee. Please order before 2 pm the day before! We steep our cold brew to perfection for 24 hours!

Our cold-brew-concentrate (espresso) with milk, blended with ice to smooth, creamy perfection. Topped with whipped cream

Frozen latte with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce, blended smooth with ice and topped with whipped cream

Our frozen latte with rich, sweet Ghirardelli caramel, over ice and blended smooth. Topped with whipped cream

The best of both worlds: our frozen latte with rich Ghirardelli chocolate and caramel sauces blended smooth with ice and topped with whipped cream

A bit of an oxymoron, but delicious nevertheless. Cream, milk chocolate, and Ghirardelli chocolate sauce with ice, blended smooth and topped with whipped cream

Hot tea to warm your fingertips. Earl Grey, English breakfast, zen, passion, mint, apricot, chamomile. Please let us know what flavor you would like in special requests

Loose-leaf early Grey tea steeped in piping hot steamed milk and sweetened with vanilla syrup

Earl Grey tea steeped in piping hot steamed milk sweetened with lavender syrup!

Matcha green tea vigorously mixed with steamed milk!

Organic matcha green tea vigorously mixed into milk over ice!

Shaken, not stirred iced green tea with a hint of lemon grass! ***Pictured here is a lavender iced green tea

Passionfruit tea over ice. Shaken vigorously (yes, it's necessary)

Iced green tea with lemon grass and lemonade

Shaken lemonade with fresh lemon

Organic Oregon Chai steamed with milk! Our sweet and mildly spiced signature flavor features a blend of black tea, honey, smooth vanilla and chai spices in every delicious sip!

Organic oregon chai tea latte over ice

Choose from strawberry, strawberry banana, wildberry, peach, Caribbean colada, mango, and frozen lemonade

This retro t-shirt with a 90's design was inspired by Jimmy to celebrate our 30th Anniversary! - Est. 1994

Finally, a crew neck sweatshirt with a retro 90's design inspired by Jimmy to celebrate our 30th Anniversary! Est. 1994

Bella-Canva soft tee is a must have!

This is our most popular hoodie! Soft, warm & cozy...you've gotta have one!

"You can wear my sweatshirt cuz you're the only one I hold and I don't want you to be cold so baby wear mine" - Jacob Sartorius. Give us a call to ask about available sizes!

Black baseball cap with our infamous bagel icon embroidered on the front and "Bagel bar" on the back!

Dark Heather Grey, Gildan Unisex Full-Zip Hoodie {50% cotton / 50% polyster) with our iconic owl on the front and our logo on the back

This stainless steel tumbler is perfect for taking your favorite hot beverage on the go

Get cozy with a coffee at home or at the bagel bar with this ceramic mug. Because slowly nose-inhaling the steam from a fresh cup a' joe just isn't as satisfying from a paper cup

The design on this insulated tumbler resembles that of rich mahogany

You'll be stylin' with this 24 ounce clear cold tumbler

These stylin' 18 ounce travel tumblers are made of double-wall stainless steel with vacuum-insulation keeping drinks hot or cold for longer and features a non-skid foam bottom. The push-on acrylic lid has a thumb-slide closure. Look good while you're drinking the best coffee!

These adorable keychains make the perfect gift for your bagel bar lovin' friends! Or - treat yo'self!

These adorable keychains make the perfect gift for your bagel bar lovin' friends! Or - treat yo'self!

Our in-house artist, Kylie McG, designed this bad boy! Get yours today before they sell out!

Dimensions: 15" w x 16" h. Material: Eco-friendly recycled canvas tote bags are made from 100% recycled fabric. This reusable multipurpose tote bag has one spacious main compartment, bag has 21" soft self-fabric handles so you can comfortably carry by hand

Decaf coffee flavored with an enticing Island blend of luscious caramel, vanilla and creamy Mexican liqueur

Decaf coffee flavored with an enticing Island blend of luscious caramel, vanilla and creamy Mexican liqueur

Decaf coffee flavored with notes of cinnamon, Jamaican dark rum and fresh-roasted Southern pecans

Decaf coffee flavored with notes of cinnamon, Jamaican dark rum and fresh-roasted Southern pecans

"Decaf" A local favorite, our proprietary blend of South American, African and Indonesian beans is sweet and floral with a complex acidity and a clean, crisp finish

"Decaf" A local favorite, our proprietary blend of South American, African and Indonesian beans is sweet and floral with a complex acidity and a clean, crisp finish

Nizza is a medium roast blend that hits at the heart of sweet. It’s named for the city of Nice, France, hometown of La Colombe's co-founder JP and home to some of the best honey in the world. True to its name, this coffee exemplifies a honey-sweet, roasted nuttiness. It’s one of our favorites!

Nizza is a medium roast blend that hits at the heart of sweet. It’s named for the city of Nice, France, hometown of La Colombe's co-founder JP and home to some of the best honey in the world. True to its name, this coffee exemplifies a honey-sweet, roasted nuttiness. It’s one of our favorites!

Monaco’s decadent and bold, smooth blend shines no matter how you brew. Named for a small principality with a huge historical impact, it fulfills the chocolatey tradition of coffee while verging into exciting fruit flavors. Tasting notes: milk chocolate, g

Flavored with notes of cinnamon, Jamaican dark rum and fresh-roasted Southern pecans

Flavored with notes of cinnamon, Jamaican dark rum and fresh-roasted Southern pecans

Flavored with an enticing Island blend of luscious caramel, vanilla and creamy Mexican liqueur

Flavored with an enticing Island blend of luscious caramel, vanilla and creamy Mexican liqueur

A special treat, spinkled with cinnamon and fresh-roasted hazelnuts, then blended with farm-fresh cream

A special treat, spinkled with cinnamon and fresh-roasted hazelnuts, then blended with farm-fresh cream

An iced, fiery blend of raspberry passionfruit tea lemonade, ablaze with the vibrant energy of frozen raspberries.

This delicious pb & chocolate cold brew is crowned with velvety peanut butter cold foam finished with luxurious swirls of chocolate & peanut butter ***cold foam contains dairy***

Iced honey-sweetened, lavender-kissed oat milk latte, crowned with whipped cream and delicate lavender petals

a hot honey-sweetened, lavender-kissed oat milk latte, crowned with whipped cream and delicate lavender petals

a sweet symphony of Ghirardelli caramel and mocha swirled with espresso & steamed milk, the iconic taste of Cadbury topped with a decadent caramel drizzle

a sweet symphony of Ghirardelli caramel and mocha swirled with espresso & steamed milk, the iconic taste of Cadbury topped with a caramel drizzle

Silky Ghirardelli chocolate-infused matcha and whole milk, topped with a dreamy cloud of pistachio cold foam. **contains dairy**