The Bagel Mill 212 Western Ave

build your own bagel sandwich here. All bagels are sliced and toasted (unless noted otherwise). For a bagel and cream cheese, please select a spread. For bagels not sliced or toasted, please go to the 'Bagels To Go' section.

organic egg, yellow cheddar

organic egg, yellow cheddar, thick cut bacon, smashed avocado, tomato

build your own bagel sandwich here. All bagels are sliced and toasted (unless noted otherwise). For a bagel and cream cheese, please select a spread. For bagels not sliced or toasted, please go to the 'Bagels To Go' section.

smashed avocado, lemon vinaigrette, pickled red onion, scallions, sprouts, everything mix (served open-faced)

organic egg, yellow cheddar

organic egg, yellow cheddar, thick cut bacon, smashed avocado, tomato

cream cheese, 1 oz salmon lox, red onion, capers, fresh dill

cream cheese, 2 oz salmon lox, red onion, capers, fresh dill (served open-faced)

scallion cream cheese, radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, sprouts

seasonal veggie frittata, smashed avocado, melted yellow cheddar

thick cut bacon, butter lettuce, smashed avocado, tomato, mayo

organic egg salad, butter lettuce, chopped scallions

black forest ham, melted swiss, salted honey butter, arugula

pastrami, melted swiss, sauerkraut, russian dressing

smoked turkey, thick cut bacon, monterey jack, avocado, tomato, lettuce, sriracha mayo

smoked turkey, sauteed bell pepper, red onion, jalapenos, melted swiss, sriracha mayo

albacore tuna mixed with mildly spicy Sriracha mayo, celery & onions. Served with butter lettuce and tomato

house made cashew cheese, roasted bell pepper, pickled red onion, cucumber, radish, smashed avocado, sprouts

an assortment of fresh fruit

organic oats soaked overnight, honey, cinnamon

seasonal veggie frittata served warm with arugula

butter lettuce, arugula, watermelon radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, & lemon vinaigrette

butter lettuce, arugula, watermelon radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, & lemon vinaigrette

organic Straus whole milk yogurt (unsweetened) & housemade granola

1 large kosher dill pickle

Six strand challah made with organic ingredients. Hybrid recipe with sourdough starter and instant yeast (dairy free)

Please allow 48 hours notice for orders over 2 dozen.

Please allow 48 hours notice for orders over 2 dozen.

from Mamamel's Bread in Petaluma

a weekly special that is only available Mondays

a weekly special bagel that is only available on Thursdays

a weekly special bialy with caramelized onions and poppy seeds that is only available on Fridays

a weekly special bagel that is only available on Saturdays

a weekly special that is only available Sundays

8 oz of our house made organic egg salad

8 oz of our house made flavored cream cheeses & spreads, serves 4-6 people

8 oz of cream cheese, serves 4-6 people

4 oz of our premium smoked salmon lox from Santa Barbara Smokehouse

8 oz of our albacore tuna salad with Sriracha mayo, red onion & celery

*NOT VEGAN* cafe au lait with our lemon cake syrup made with lemon curd, almond extract and vanilla bean.

*NOT VEGAN* lemon cake syrup made with lemon curd, almond extract and vanilla bean

*NOT VEGAN* lemon cake syrup made with lemon curd, almond extract and vanilla bean

organic syrup made with our house-made apple butter with local, organic apples

organic chai from Chico Chai

tea varieties from Blue Will Tea

unsweetened matcha latte with matcha from Blue Willow Tea

unsweetened tea from Blue Willow Tea

made with our house-made Guittard white chocolate syrup *not available vegan* white chocolate contains dairy

Choice of 1/2 dozen sliced bagels in a box. Add on schmears. We recommend 1-2 per 1/2 dozen bagels (serves 6 people).

Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels in a box. Add on schmears. We recommend 2-3 per dozen bagels (serves 12 people).

Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels, 3 tubs of schmear, sliced cucumbers, watermelon radish, pickled red onion, tomatoes, red onion, sprouts, lemon wedges. Served on disposable platters with disposable tongs. Utensils, napkins & trays included.

Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels, 3 tubs of schmear, 16 oz. sliced premium salmon lox from Santa Barbara Smokehouse, red onion, dill, capers, lemon wedges (serves 12 people).

Choice of 1 dozen sliced bagels, 3 tubs of schmear, 24 oz. sliced premium salmon lox from Santa Barbara Smokehouse, red onion, dill, capers, lemon wedges, sliced cucumber, tomato, watermelon radish, sprouts, pickled red onion (serves 12 people).

96 oz. of brewed Ritual coffee. Comes with half and half, oat milk, whole milk, sweetener, cups, and wooden stirrers (serves 8-12 people)

Assorted rugelach platter of 36 rugelach cookies with Chocolate Apricot, Cinnamon Walnut, & Caramel Apple (all cookies contains nuts)

charcoal beanie with logo on front

Bella + Canvas charcoal hoodie with logo on front and back

Bella + Canvas charcoal Tee with logo on front and back

organic canvas tote

trucker hat with logo

Bella + Canvas Tee with logo on front and bag

Bella + Canvas Tee with logo on front and bag

2 oz container of tea from Blue Willow Tea Company in Berkeley, CA.

2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour

a jar of our organic Everything Mix. Perfect for seasoning salads, veggies, eggs, meat and more!

local Petaluma product made with upcycled barley