Online Ordering; Now more fun than ever before!!

The Old Mill Inn
1 depot street, Alfred Station, NY
BEVERAGES
From The Bar
Miller Lite
$4.00Michelob Ultra
$4.00Coors Light
$4.00Moosehead Canadian Lager
$4.50Labatt Blue Light
$4.00Budweiser
$4.00Labatt Blue
$4.00Pabst Blue Ribbon
$3.50Keystone Light
$3.50Busch light
$3.75Bud Light
$4.00Bud Lt Next
$4.00Budweiser
$4.00Busch
$3.75Busch light
$3.75Coors Banquet
$4.00Coors Light
$4.00Corona Extra
$5.50Corona Premier
$5.50Genesee Brewing Genny Light
$3.25Heineken
$6.00Keystone Light
$3.50Killians Irish Red
$4.25Landshark
$4.25Michelob Ultra
$4.00Michelob Ultra Pure Gold
$4.50Miller Lite
$4.00Molson Canadian
$4.00Moosehead Canadian Lager
$4.50Pabst Blue Ribbon
$3.50Sam Adams Boston Lager
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Sam Adams Octoberfest
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Sam Adams Winter Lager
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Stroh's
$3.00Yuengling Lager
$4.00Southern Tier Brewing IPA
$5.50Founders All Day IPA
$5.25Sierra Nevada Brewing Hazy Little Thing
$6.75Big Ditch Hayburner
$5.50Resurgence Green Heart IPA
OUT OF STOCK$6.00Voodoo Ranger IPA
OUT OF STOCK$7.50Deschutes Fresh Squeezed IPA
$6.50Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA
OUT OF STOCK$5.75Sierra Nevada Brewing Big Little Thing
Bigger, Hazier, Juicier! This Hazy Imperial IPA is packed with juicy hop flavors and a big 9.5% ABV, all wrapped up in smooth drinkability. Notes of orange are prominent, along with more citrus from the huge hop lineup—is that a hint of yuzu? There’s also a nice underlying sweetness of berry.OUT OF STOCK$6.75Voodoo Ranger Juice Force IPA
$9.25Angry Orchard
$6.25Blackbird Cider Estate Reserve
$7.00Blackbird Cider Dry Oaked
OUT OF STOCK$7.00Blackbird Cider Rose
OUT OF STOCK$7.00Blackbird Cider Red Barn
OUT OF STOCK$7.00Blackbird Cider Winter Berry
OUT OF STOCK$7.00Blackbird Cider Loganberry
OUT OF STOCK$7.001911 Cider Black Chery
$9.501911 Cider Honeycrisp
$9.501911 Cider Original
$9.501911 Cider Cranberry
OUT OF STOCK$9.501911 Cider Pineapple Mango
OUT OF STOCK$9.50Blackbird Cider Cosmo
OUT OF STOCK$7.00Bombshell Concord Grape
$9.50Bombshell Original
Hard cider from New York State apples with aromas of fresh cut apples, bright crisp flavors, and a refreshing semi-dry finish.$9.50Blackbird Summer Cider
$7.00
Blackbird Cider Paloma
This Paloma cocktail-themed hard cider blends crisp apple character with bright grapefruit citrus and a squeeze of fresh lime. Lightly sparkling and refreshing, it balances tart fruit acidity and sweet agave syrup notes for that authentic cocktail vibe. The result is a vibrant cider that delivers zesty, thirst-quenching flavor with a smooth, easy finish.$7.00Fat Tire Ale
$6.00Blue Moon
$5.75Blue moon light sky
$5.75Ellicottville Brewing Blood Orange
$6.00Ellicottville Brewing Bluebery Wheat
$6.00Four Mile Brewing Raspberry wheat
$6.00Sam Adams Cherry Wheat
$6.50Sam Adams Summer Ale
$6.50Redds Apple Ale
$5.50Genesee Ruby Red Kolsch
$4.00Busch Light Apple
$4.00Busch Light Lime
$4.00Labatt Blue
$4.00Labatt Blue Light
$4.00Stella Artois
$6.00Smithwicks Red Ale
$8.00Three Heads Rochestafarian scotch ale
OUT OF STOCK$6.00Rohrbach Brewing Scotch Ale
$9.50Dogfish Head Sea Quench Ale
OUT OF STOCK$6.00Guinness
$7.75Leinenkugel Summer Shandy
$5.50Rohrbach Brewing Vanilla Porter
$9.50White Claw Mango
$5.75White Claw Blackberry
$5.75White Claw Black Cherry
$5.75White Claw Raspberry
OUT OF STOCK$5.75Twisted Tea
$5.50Mikes Hard Lemonade
$5.50Jack Daniels Country Cocktail Southern Peach
$5.00Arizona Original Hard Lemonade
$5.00Arizona Mango Hard Lemonade
$5.00Lucky One Hard Tea Original
$8.00High Noon Pineapple
OUT OF STOCK$7.00High Noon Black Cherry
OUT OF STOCK$7.00High Noon Tangerine
OUT OF STOCK$7.00High Noon Cranberry
$7.00High Noon Grapefruit
$7.00High Noon Peach
$7.00White claw vodka soda Watermelon
$7.00White claw vodka soda Pineapple
$7.00Nutrl vodka soda Orange
$7.25Nutrl vodka soda Pinapple
$7.25High Noon Kiwi
$7.00High Noon Pear
$7.00Nutrl Vodka Soda Black Cherry
$7.25Surfside Lemonade Original
$6.50Surfside Lemonade Black Cherry
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Surfside Lemonade Raspberry
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Surfside Lemonade Strawberry
$6.50Surfside Peach Iced Tea
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Surfside Raspberry Iced Tea
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Surfside Lemonade Iced Tea
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Surfside Original Iced Tea
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Lucky One Blueberry Vodka Lemonade
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Sun Cruiser
$6.50Carbless Cranberry Vodka
$6.50Carbless Black Raspberry Vodka
OUT OF STOCK$6.50Jose Cuervo margarita (mini Bottle)
$9.50Carbless Black Cherry
$6.50Surfside Blueberry Vodka
$6.50Veuve du vernay Ice Rose
$10.00Collicini Lambrusco
$6.50Heineken 0.0 (Non Alcoholic)
$6.00Guinness 0.0 (Non Alcoholic)
$7.75Labatt Blue (Non Alcoholic)
$4.00Michelob Ultra ZERO (Non Alcoholic)
$4.25
NA Beverages
Drink Chips
Halloween
RIBS DAY
RIBS SANDWICH
FOOD
Appetizers
Clam Strips
A four-ounce plate of clam strips served with a side of cocktail sauce$7.75Corn Fritters
A blob of corn filled batter fried till golden brown$8.25French Fries
Fresh cut to order in-house and fried golden brown$5.50Mill Fries
Our fresh cut fries tossed in our Mill Streak Seasoning$5.75Garlic Parmesan Fries
Our fresh cut fries tossed in butter, granulated garlic, and Parmesan cheese$7.50Jalapeno Poppers
Six cream cheese filled poppers served with ranch dressing$9.75Tacopeno Poppers
6 cream cheese-filled poppers tossed in our Taco Rub, drizzled with 'Hotter Sauce,” and served with sour cream$11.25Mac ‘n Cheese Bites
A plate of triangular noodle ‘n cheese filled blobs, served with a side of ranch dressing$9.75Mozzarella Sticks
Five deep fried cheese sticks served with a side of marinara sauce$8.75Hot Rods
Five deep fried cheese sticks tossed in Frank’s Red Hot and served with a side of blue cheese dressing$9.50Onion Rings
A half-pound of battered onion rings fried till golden brown$8.75Soft Pretzels
Two or five jumbo pretzel twists served with honey mustard sauce for dipping$10.75+Fried Pierogies
Nine mini pierogies covered in sautéed onions and drowned in butter, served with sour cream$10.50Cheesy Garlic Bread
A garlicky, buttery and cheesy flat bread cut into dippable strips and served with marinara sauce (for dipping)$15.50Onion Petals
Battered onion pieces served with a side of petal sauce$9.25Junior Sampler Platter
Two each of Jalapeño Poppers, Mac Bites, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Tenders, and some Onion Rings$18.50Sampler Platter
Three each of Jalapeño Poppers, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Tenders, and Mac Bites–plus a Soft Pretzel, and a pile of Fries and Onion Rings$29.75Build Your Own Sampler Plate
Select three or more items to create your own Sampler Plate! 3.50 per item! (Limit 1 of each item)Blue Cheese and celery
$6.75Fried Mini Tacos
A basket of crunchy mini chicken tacos served with salsa and sour cream$13.75Chicken pot pie egg roll
$7.50Eggplant eggroll
$7.50
Hamburgers
Classic Hamburger
Our classic hand pressed, locally sourced burger, seasoned to perfection and topped with your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese at no additional cost. Served with a side of our hand cut to order French fries.$14.50
All-American Burger
A bacon cheeseburger$15.75Bacon and Blue Burger
A burger with onions, blue cheese crumbles, and bacon$16.50Mushroom Swiss Burger
A burger with Swiss cheese and sauteed mushrooms$15.50Roadhouse Burger
A burger topped with onion rings and barbecue sauce$15.50Mill Stack Burger
A burger bun piled high with lettuce, pickles, chicken tenders, cheese, a quarter-pound burger, cheese again, bacon, onion rings, and another bun--served with a side of Garlic Parmesan French Fries$28.50The Double Mill Stack Burger
A Mill Stack Burger stacked on top of a Mill Stack Burger—served with a side of Garlic Parmesan French Fries and a whole order of onion rings$56.50
Fried Chicken Sandwich
$14.25Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$14.75
Seafood
Seafood Basket
Eight Yuengling-battered shrimp, plus breaded clam strips and fried calamari, served with an order of Cajun fries, cocktail sauce, coleslaw, and lemon wedges—perfect for sharing!$32.50Fried Shrimp Basket
Sixteen Yuengling-battered shrimp served with a full-sized order of fries, a dish of cocktail sauce, and coleslaw$29.50Wild Alaskan Pollock "Wings"
$19.75
Kids Meal
Kids Grilled Cheese
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!$8.50Kids Mac ‘n Cheese
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!$8.50Kids Chicken Nuggets
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!$9.50Kids chicken wings
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!$11.50Kids Buttered Noodles
$7.75Kids Cheese Pizza
$9.50Kids Pepperoni Pizza
$11.50kids Taco Meal
$8.50kids steak
$18.50Kids Small Bites
$2.50+
Pasta
Baked Ziti
Ziti with pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese baked till melted, served with garlic bread$14.50Chicken Tender Parmesan
A bed of penne topped with chicken tenders, pasta sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese—served with garlic bread$18.75Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese
Mix in any one of our chicken rubs or sauces for a bit more bang!$12.50
Buffalo Chicken Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with Frank’s Red Hot, chicken, and a scoop of blue cheese dressing on top$16.75Taco Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with our own taco-seasoned beef, topped with lettuce, tomato, and a dollop of sour cream$17.75
Cheeseburger Mac
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with burger mixed in and topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion$17.75BBQ Ribs Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with a healthy scoop of pulled barbecue pork rib meat mixed in$16.50Philly Cheese Steak Mac
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with shaved beef, roasted red peppers, and onions mixed in$16.75Roadhouse Mac ‘n Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese topped with a generous portion of onion rings and drizzled with barbecue sauce$14.75Sauteed Pierogie Entree
$16.75
Pizzas & Calzones
Cheese Pizza
Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, and seasoned to perfection$12.75Pepperoni Pizza
A Cheese Pizza but with pepperoni on it!$16.25Cheeseburger Deluxe Pizza
A pizza with a Thousand Island base covered in mozzarella cheese, ground beef, pickles, lettuce, tomato, and onion$22.50Beef on Weck Pizza
A pizza with a horseradish sauce base and Weck crust covered in mozzarella cheese and roast beef$18.75Meat Lover’s Pizza
A pizza covered with pepperoni, sausage, and ground beef$24.50Veggie Supreme Pizza
A pizza covered in onions, mushrooms, olives, and roasted red peppers$19.25Taco Pizza
A pizza with a taco sauce base, mozzarella, ground beef, lettuce, tomato, and sour cream on top$22.50BBQ Chicken Pizza
A pizza with a barbecue sauce base, mozzarella cheese, chicken, and a sprinkling of Mill Steak Seasoning$17.50Bruschetta Pizza
A white pizza covered in diced tomatoes and seasoned to perfection$15.25Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
A white pizza covered in shaved beef, roasted peppers, and onions$21.25Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
A pizza with a ranch dressing base, mozzarella cheese, diced bacon, and chicken on top$20.50Pesto, Cheese, and Tomato Pizza
A pizza with a pesto base, mozzarella cheese, and whole slices of tomato$18.25Chicken Wing Pizza
Our fresh crust covered in blue cheese dressing, Buffalo chicken, and buried in mozzarella cheese$17.50
Salads
Buffalo Chicken Salad
A bed of fresh greens with Buffalo chicken bits, mozzarella cheese, tomato, onion, and blue cheese dressing$13.75Chef Salad
A heaping mound of lettuce, tomato, onion, turkey, ham, black olives, banana peppers, Swiss cheese, Parmesan cheese, and croutons—served with choice of dressing$17.75Greek Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumbers, kalamata olives, banana peppers, feta cheese, croutons, and Greek dressing$16.75
Sandwiches
Deli Sub
Build your dream sub on an 8” Costanzo roll or as a wrap. Select your hand-sliced meats, cheese, veggies, and whatever else floats your boat for a fresh and delicious sub-venture.$13.50Cheese Steak
Shaved prime rib with provolone cheese covered in sautéed onions and peppers on a sub roll$17.50BLT
A sub roll with a bunch of bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise$13.25Grilled Cheese Platter
Two grilled cheese sandwiches, a bowl of our soup of the day, and a bag of potato chips$12.75
Sides

Side Of Mac
A side order of our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese$6.25Tomato Soup (cup)
Its a cup of tomato soup.$4.50Tomato Soup (bowl)
Its a bowl of tomato soup.$6.50Soup of the day (cup)
Ask us about our soup of the day!$4.50Soup of the day (bowl)
Ask us about our soup of the day!$6.50Coleslaw
Cabbage and carrots shredded in-house and tossed in our homemade slaw dressing$4.00Mac Salad
A side dish of our house made pasta salad$4.00Side Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, croutons and your choice of salad dressing$4.50
Potato Chips
A bag of potato chips$2.50Cottage cheese
Two scoops, not one$4.00Garlic bread
Two pieces of out garlic bread$3.50Side of fries (half Order)
A smaller portion of our fresh cut fries$3.50CHILI and Cornbread
$8.75+
French onion soup
$7.50
Wings & Tenders

6 Boneless Wings
6oz of our world (ish) famous boneless wings$7.7512 Boneless Wings
12oz of our world (ish) famous boneless wings$14.0018 Boneless Wings
18oz of our world (ish) famous boneless wings$20.50Boneless Wings Party Box (5 LB)
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$78.503 Chicken Tenders
Great for dipping$8.255 Chicken Tenders
Great for dipping$13.508 Chicken Tenders
Great for dipping$22.00Chicken Tenders 5lb. Party Box
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$87.756 Wings
Literally 6 of the best wings in Alfred Station$7.7512 Wings
Literally 12 of the best wings in Alfred Station$14.0018 Wings
Literally 18 of the best wings in Alfred Station$20.50
50 Wings
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$55.50Polish Wings
12 deep fried Pierogies tossed in any wing sauce or rub$14.0012 Chicken Nuggets
Oh, We have the Nugs!$11.5036 Chicken Nuggets
That is a lot of Nugs!$27.7573 Chicken Nuggets
Practically a lifetime supply of Nugs!!$49.75Chicken Tender Dinner
3 chicken tenders fried golden brown and served with a side of our fresh cut fries$13.75
Desserts
Cannoli
Two crispy and crunchy cannoli piped to order and dusted with confectioner’s sugar$8.50Fried Dough
A heaping pile of our pizza dough fried golden brown and tossed in sugar$6.50Apple Pie Logs
Three Apple Pie Logs covered in sugar and drowned in caramel sauce$8.50Fried Oreos
Three Oreos wrapped in fried dough and covered in powdered sugar with your choice of chocolate, salted caramel, or white chocolate sauce$7.50Cheese cake
$8.50
Party platters
Party Platers
1/2 Pan Baked Ziti
Noodles, tomato sauce, cheese, what more could you need? Oh, BEEF!. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$59.75Mac n' Cheese (1/2pan)
Our classic Three Cheese Mac n Cheese! Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$62.501/2 pan Cavatappi Aurora
Pasta tossed in out house made creamy tomato sauce. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$72.501/2 pan Cavatappi Pesto
Pasta tossed in basil pesto. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$67.501/2 pan Cavatappi Alfredo
Pasta tossed in our house made Alfred Sauce. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$69.501/2 pan Buffalo Chicken Mac
Our classic Mac but with a bit more chicken... and SPICY, Topped with Blue Cheese.$78.501/2 pan Bbq Ribs Mac
Our classic mac loaded with pulled BBQ ribs meat and BBQ sauce. Each pan serves about 6-8 as an entree or about 12-15 as a side dish$79.501/2 pan toss salad
$46.001/2 pan chef salad
$74.751/2 pan Greek Salad
$71.751/2 pan Crispy Chicken Salad
$56.00Boneless Wings Party Box (5 LB)
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$78.50Chicken Tenders 5lb. Party Box
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$87.75Chicken Nugget Party Box (6lb)
Each order feeds 12-15 people as a meal, or more as a side dish! about 240 nuggets per box$87.50
50 Wings
Each order feeds 6-8 people as a meal, or more as a side dish!$55.501/2 pan Pasta Salad
Serves about 12-15 as a side dish$46.00Mashed Potatoes (1/2 pan)
Serves about 12-15 as a side dish$46.00Bread stick
Per Roll, Includes butter (2)$1.75Garlic Bread Sticks (Dozen)
Buttery and delicious$26.00Coleslaw (qt)
Feeds about 6$15.00Pasta Salad (qt)
Feeds about 6$15.00Shrimp Cocktail (2lb)
$69.001/2 pan Green Bean Casserole
Thanksgiving would be ruined without it$42.00Dinner Napkins (150)
$7.50Silverware kits
$0.65Paper Plates (100)
$6.5010" black serving spoon
$1.506" black tong
$1.50black salad tongs
$3.50
ID REQUIRED
White Claw Raspberry
$5.75
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
