Currently not accepting online orders

The Bay Butcher
96 South Street, Oyster Bay, NY
Cheese
Ambrosi Parmigiano Reggiano 24 Month Wedges
$18.00Ambrosi Pecorino Romano Wedges
$15.00Belgioioso Fontina Cheese Wedge
$7.50Chevre Goat Cheese Log
$15.00Diretta Grass-Fed Brie
$11.00Grafton Village Cheese 2 Year Cheddar Bars
$20.00Kynthos Halloumi Cheese
$12.00Lioni Latticini Inc Stracciatella
$15.00Liuzzi Burrata Cheese 4 oz
$12.00Liuzzi Caciocavallo
$12.00Murray's Cheese Marcona Almonds
$12.00Origin Creamery Smoked Gouda
$14.00Caseificio dell'Alta Langa Robiolina
$8.00
Pantry / Grocery
Crackers
Spices & Rubs
Calicutts Everyday Spice Blend
$14.00Calicutts Fish Spice Blend
$14.00Calicutts Herbes de Provence Spice Blend
$14.00Calicutts Mediterranean Spice Blend
$14.00Calicutts Salt & Pepper Spice Blend
$14.00Calicutts Spiceology Fire Salt Spice Blend
$14.00Calicutts Steakhouse Spice Blend
$14.00Calicutts Sweet & Smoky BBQ Spice Blend
$14.00Spiceology Black Magic Cajun Blackening Rub
$15.00Spiceology Cowboy Crust Espresso Chile Rub
$15.00Spiceology Greek Freak Mediterranean Rub
$15.00Spiceology Korean BBQ All Purpose Korean Rub
$15.00Spiceology Smoky Honey Habanero Sweet & Spicy Rub
$15.00
Antipasto
D'Amico Capers in Salt
$6.00D'Amico Capers in Vinegar
$6.00Partanna Mediterranean Olives Mix
$12.00Sogno Toscano Artichoke Hearts
$16.00Sogno Toscano Mediterranean Fantasy
$12.00Sogno Toscano Peppers Bruschetta Spread
$12.00Sogno Toscano Pesto Genovese
$11.00Sogno Toscano Sun-Dried Tomatoes in Oil
$11.00Partanna Castelvetrano Olives
$12.00Pearl Onion
$6.00
Partanna Pitted Mediterranean Olive Mix, 9 oz
Partanna Pitted Mediterranean Olive Mix is a flavorful assortment of olives, perfect for snacking or adding to dishes. This 9 oz mix includes a variety of olives that highlight the rich taste of the Mediterranean.$12.00Divina Pepperoncini
$8.00
Divina Cornichons
Divina Cornichons are small, crunchy pickles perfect for adding a tangy kick to your meals. These 11.8-ounce jars are great for snacking or complementing a charcuterie board.$6.00
Divina Feta Stuffed Olives
Divina Feta Stuffed Olives are savory green olives filled with creamy feta cheese, making them a perfect snack or addition to salads and charcuterie boards. These olives bring together a tangy flavor with a smooth, cheesy center.$12.00
Divina Smoked Kalamata Olives - 7.8 Oz
These are Kalamata olives that have been smoked for an added depth of flavor. They come in a 7.8 oz jar, making them perfect for adding to salads or enjoying as a savory snack.$12.00
Divina Tangerine & Chili Olives
Divina Tangerine & Chili Olives are a unique blend of savory olives infused with the zesty flavors of tangerine and a hint of chili heat. They're perfect for adding a bold twist to your favorite dishes or enjoying as a standalone snack.$12.00Divina Pickled Red Onions
$6.50
Partanna Pitted Castelvetrano Green Olives, 9 oz
Partanna Pitted Castelvetrano Green Olives are known for their mild and buttery flavor, making them a tasty snack or addition to salads. These olives are already pitted for your convenience and come in a 9 oz package.$12.00
Infused Salt
Sauces & Dips
Kinder's Honey Hot BBQ Sauce
$7.00Shemps Old Fashioned Steak Sauce
$8.00Suzie's Organic Honey Mustard Dipping
$6.50Suzie's Organic Hot Sauce
$6.50Suzie's Organic Ketchup
$6.50Suzie's Organic Real Mayonnaise
$6.50Suzie's Organic Yellow Mustard
$6.50Kinder's Gold Label Founder's Reserve BBQ Sauce
$9.00Kinder's Hickory Brown Sugar BBQ Sauce
$7.00
Shemps Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce
Shemps Old Fashioned Whiskey Pepper Steak Sauce is a flavorful addition to your grilled or pan-seared meats. It combines the rich taste of whiskey and the kick of black pepper to enhance your steak dishes.$8.00
The Original Australian Awesome Steak Sauce 8.5oz
The Original Australian Awesome Steak Sauce is a flavorful condiment that adds a delicious kick to your grilled meats. It's perfect for enhancing the taste of steaks, burgers, or even as a marinade.$8.00
Paladini Louis Dressing - 8 OZ
Paladini Louis Dressing is a creamy and tangy salad dressing that's perfect for seafood dishes. This 8-ounce bottle is a convenient addition to your kitchen, adding a touch of flavor to salads and other meals.$9.00
Paladini Tartar Sauce
Paladini Tartar Sauce is a creamy condiment featuring a blend of tangy flavors and bits of pickles. It's perfect for pairing with seafood dishes or using as a zesty dip.$9.00
Paladini Seafood Sauces All-Natural Hot & Spicy Cocktail Sauce - 8 Oz
Paladini Seafood Sauces Hot & Spicy Cocktail Sauce is a zesty condiment perfect for adding a kick to your seafood dishes. Made with all-natural ingredients, this 8 oz bottle packs just the right amount of heat to enhance your favorite shrimp cocktail or seafood platter.$7.50
Colavita Original Glaze, 32 fl oz
Colavita Original Glaze is a versatile condiment that adds a tangy sweetness to your dishes. It's perfect for drizzling over salads, roasted vegetables, or grilled meats.$20.00
Paladini All-Natural Cocktail Sauce
Paladini All-Natural Cocktail Sauce is a flavorful blend perfect for enhancing the taste of seafood dishes. Its natural ingredients add a zesty kick without overpowering the main dish.$7.50
Pasta
Preserves
Oil & Vinegar
Sogno Toscano Basil Infused Olive Oil
$26.00Sogno Toscano Garlic Infused Olive Oil
$26.00Sogno Toscano Lemon Infused Olive Oil
$26.00Sogno Toscano Spicy Infused Olive Oil
$26.00
Partanna Robust Fruity & Vibrant Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Partanna Robust Fruity & Vibrant Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a versatile cooking oil known for its rich and fruity flavor profile. It's perfect for drizzling over salads or enhancing the taste of your favorite dishes.$20.00
Partanna Robust Fruity & Vibrant Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 33.8 fl oz
Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a flavorful oil that's great for enhancing the taste of your dishes. It's known for its rich, fruity, and vibrant profile, making it a versatile addition to any kitchen.$35.00
Colavita Balsamic Vinegar of Modena IGP
Colavita Balsamic Vinegar of Modena IGP is a tangy and rich vinegar that's perfect for salads, marinades, or drizzling over roasted vegetables. Made in Modena, Italy, it adds a touch of authentic Italian flavor to your dishes.$8.00Beef Tallow
$25.00
Charcuterie Meat
Borgo Antipasto Prosciutto Crudo/Salame Milano/Napoli
$14.00Borgo Classic Italian Mortadella
$8.00Borgo Classic Mild Salami Milano
$8.00Borgo Cotto Prosciutto
$8.00Borgo Crudo Prosciutto
$8.00Golfera Classic Salami Chubs
$12.00Golfera Spicy Salami Chubs
$12.00Sliced Finocchiona
$15.00Sliced Sweet Soppressata
$15.00Sliced Hot Soppressata
$15.00Sliced Chorizo
$15.00
Value-Added Meat
Bay Butcher Burgers
$28.00/lbChorizo
$10.95/lbHot Sausage
$9.95/lbKobe Hot Dogs
$18.00/lbMarinated Filet Mignon Skewers
$42.00/lbMarinated Hamburgers
$28.00/lbMarinated Pork Tenderloin
$10.95/lbPancetta
$16.95/lbSweet Sausage
$9.95/lbBreaded Chicken Cutlets
$12.99/lbFilet Mignon Skewers
$42.00/lbFlank Steak Pinwheels
$21.95/lbSlab Bacon
$18.95/lbPrime Burgers
$21.00/lbBone Marrow
$12.00/lb
Produce
Driscoll's Organic Blackberries
$8.00Driscoll's Organic Raspberries
$8.00Driscoll's Organic Strawberries
$10.00Driscoll's Organic Sweetest Batch Blueberries
$14.00Organic Yellow Onion Bag
$7.00Pero Family Farms Broccoli Florets
$6.50Pero Family Farms Organic Mini Sweet Peppers
$8.00Pero Family Farms Organic String Beans
$9.00Satur Farms Mesclun Salad
$5.50Sugar Snap Peas
$6.50Sunset Organic Flavor Bombs Cherry Tomatoes
$10.00Urban Roots Baby Zucchini
$8.00Urban Roots Gold Pee Wee Potatoes
$7.00carrot
$5.00California Blend Frozen Vegetables
$14.00Root Vegetables Frozen
$18.00
Seafood
Stuffed Clam Box
$25.00Topneck Clams
$1.50Cooked Octopus
$31.95/lbCrabmeat Colossal Indo
$60.00/lbDry Sea Scallops
$42.00/lbHalibut Fillet Skin Off Wild
$25.00/lbKing Salmon
$38.99/lbMussels
$6.00/lbShrimp 16/20 Ocean Garden Wild
$20.00/lbShrimp 21/25 Brown Wild Prime Meridian
$20.00/lbShrimp 8/12 Brown Wild Pacific Gourmet Prime Meridian
$30.00/lbLittle Neck Clams
$1.50Lobster Tails
$30.00Oysters Peconic Gold
$2.0014/17 King Crab Legs
$100.00/lb21/25 Snow Crab Claws
$38.95/lbCalamari Breaded
$18.00/lbChilean Sea Bass
$40.00/lbOrganic Scottish Salmon
$24.00/lbFrozen Mahi
$16.00Frozen Snapper
$12.00Frozen Salmon
$12.00
Butcher Meat
Baby Back Pork Ribs
$13.95/lbCAB Brisket
$16.00/lbChicken Cutlets
$6.99/lbChop Meat
$12.00/lbColorado Lamb Chops
$42.00/lbDry Aged Porterhouse Prime
$45.00/lbDry Aged Ribeye Bone Prime
$48.00/lbDry Aged Sirloin Prime
$45.00/lbDry Aged T-Bone Prime
$45.00/lbFilet Mignon CAB
$45.00/lbFlank Steak CAB
$28.00/lbGrass Fed New York Strip GF
$45.00/lbGround Beef
$12.00/lbLamb Chops (New Zealand)
$31.95/lbOrganic Air Chilled Whole Chicken
$15.00/lbPork Belly
$13.95/lbPork Chop
$18.95/lbPork Tenderloin
$10.95/lbPork/Beef Meatballs
$20.00/lbPrime Filet
$55.00/lbRibeye Boneless Prime
$35.00/lbShort Rib Bone-In CAB
$25.95/lbShort Rib Boneless CAB
$21.95/lbSirloin Boneless CAB
$29.95/lbSkirt Steak CAB
$30.00/lbTomahawk Ribeye CAB
$40.00/lbVeal Chop
$42.00/lbVeal Cutlets
$40.00/lbVeal Osso Buco
$36.95/lbVeal/Beef Meatballs
$30.00/lbPork Loin
$15.99/lbPork Loin Stuffed
$15.99/lb
The BBQ Premium
$325.00
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
Stellina Hospitality Locations and Hours
Casa Stellina - Farmingdale
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 4PM
Stellina Ristorante - Oyster Bay
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 5PM
The Audrey: Kitchen & Bar
Closed • Opens Monday at 11:30AM
The Bay Butcher
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 12PM