Currently not accepting online orders

The Butcher & Market
214 South Main Street, Bellefontaine, OH
Brats & Patties
Brat
Regular Brat
Classic bratwurst perfect for grilling or frying.$7.99Cheese Brat
Cheesy bratwurst with a creamy, savory center.$7.99/lbMac & Cheese Brat
Mac and cheese-stuffed bratwurst for cheesy indulgence.$7.99/lbAndouille Sausage Brat
Spicy and smoky Andouille sausage brats with Cajun seasoning.$7.99/lbJalapeno & Cheese Brat
Zesty jalapeno and cheese bratwurst for a flavorful kick.$7.99/lbItalian Brat
Classic Italian sausage brats with a rich, herbaceous flavor.$7.99/lbPizza Brat
Pizza-flavored bratwurst for a fun, cheesy twist.$7.99Teriyaki Pineapple Brat
Sweet and tangy teriyaki pineapple bratwurst for tropical flair.$7.99/lbSmoked Sausage
Juicy smoked sausage bursting with savory spices.$6.99/lbGarlic Parm Brat
$7.99Beef Brat
$7.99
Hot Dogs
Hot Dogs
Classic hot dogs with juicy, savory flavor for grilling or quick meals.$6.99/lb
Hamburger Patties
Half Pound Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.49 | Approximate cost per pack: $12.98 Thick and juicy, these ½ lb burger patties are perfect for those who love a hearty, flavorful bite straight off the grill. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$7.99Third Pound Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.49 | Approximate cost per pack: $12.98 For those who love a ⅓ lb burger, these patties provide the ideal size for a flavorful, juicy burger with every bite. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$7.99Quarter Pound Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.49 | Approximate cost per pack: $12.98 Our ¼ lb patties are a classic burger choice, offering the perfect balance of thickness and tenderness for any cookout. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$7.99House Seasoned Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $7.99 | Approximate cost per pack: $15.98 A customer favorite, these house-seasoned patties are blended with just the right touch of seasoning, making them perfect for the grill. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$8.99Bacon & Cheese Patties
Juicy burger patties loaded with smoky bacon and cheddar cheese.$8.99/lbBacon Cheese & Jalapeno Patties
Bold and spicy jalapeno-infused bacon and cheese burger patties.$8.99/lbBBQ Bacon Blue Cheese Patties
Savory BBQ bacon and blue cheese patties for gourmet grilling.$8.99Chili Cheese Patties
Chili cheese patties for a spicy, cheesy grilling experience.$8.99/lbJalapeno & Cheese Brat Patties
Spicy and cheesy brat patties with jalapenos and cheddar.$6.48Mushroom Swiss Patties
Juicy patties topped with mushrooms and Swiss cheese.$8.99Pizza Patties
Juicy patties with classic pizza-inspired flavors.$8.99/lbSmokehouse BBQ Patties
$8.99
Grab & Go
Farmhouse Subs
Ham & Swiss Sub
Smoked Ham and Swiss topped lettuce and tomato.$6.25Turkey & Cheddar Sub
Oven roasted Turkey with Cheddar cheese topped with lettuce and tomato.$6.25Roast Beef Sub
Roast beef piled high with Swiss cheese, topped with lettuce and tomato.$6.25House Bologna Sub
House made and smoked bologna topped with Swiss cheese, tomato and lettuce$6.25
Jerky & Sticks
Smoked Beef Strips
Savory smoked beef strips, ready for snacking made fresh from Stembles Meat, these are a customer favorite!$25.99/lbSmoked Beef Strips Garlic Pepper
Garlic pepper smoked beef strips with a bold kick.$25.99/lbSmoked Jalapeno Beef Strips
Smoked jalapeño beef strips with a fiery, savory bite.$25.99/lbBeef Stick Original
Savory original beef sticks for a high-protein snack.$13.99/lbCheese Beef Stick
Rich beef sticks infused with creamy cheese for extra flavor.$14.99/lbJalapeno & Cheese Beef Stick
Zesty beef sticks packed with cheese and jalapeno spice.$15.99/lbSummer Sausage
Classic summer sausage with a robust, tangy taste.$13.99/lbCheese Summer Sausage
Tangy cheese summer sausage for snacks or charcuterie.$14.99/lbJalapeno & Cheese Summer Sausage
Spicy summer sausage with jalapeño cheese for bold flavor.$15.99/lb
Bundles & Trays
Meat Bundles
All Steaks Bundle Box
Items Include: 4 Ribeye Steaks, 4 New York Strips, 2 Filet Mignon, 2 Sirloin Steaks$175.00Ground Beef Bundle
20 lbs Ground Beef (1lb Packages)$120.00The Lunch Box Bundle
2lbs any deli meat, 2lbs any deli cheese. Fresh sliced, Sandwich sliced.$25.00Pork Box Bundle
2 packages bacon, 4 chops, 4lbs ground pork, 1 pork roast, 1 package either brats or links$55.00Chicken Box Bundle
4 Breast, 5lbs ground, 2 packages thighs, 2 packages wings, 1 marinated breast$50.00Beef Box Bundle
1 Beef Roast, 2 Ribeye, 2 Sirloins, 1 Package patties, 1 package stew meat or beef tips$95.00Smokehouse Box Bundle
1lb smoked beef strips, 2 packages of sticks, 1 log of summer sausage$65.00
Trays & Platters
Farmhouse Sub Platter (Large)
Perfect for feeding a crowd! Our fresh-made farmhouse subs are piled high with premium deli meats and cheeses, all topped with crisp lettuce and tomato. Each platter includes 16 subs with a mix of: - Turkey & Cheddar - Ham & Swiss - Farmhouse Club - Roast Beef & Swiss Choose between white or wheat sub buns, or enjoy a mix of both! Served with an assortment of condiments, this platter is made to bring people together around the table. Want to make it a full meal? Upgrade yours to include kettle chips, cookies, and bottled waters—because we believe every gathering should feel like family! *We kindly ask for 24-48 hours' notice on all platter orders so we can prepare everything fresh and just right for your gathering!*$50.00Farmhouse Sub Platter (Small)
Perfect for smaller gatherings! Our fresh-made farmhouse subs are piled high with premium deli meats and cheeses, all topped with crisp lettuce and tomato. Each platter includes 8 subs with a mix of: Turkey & Cheddar Ham & Swiss House Bologna & Swiss Farmhouse Club Choose between white or wheat sub buns, or enjoy a mix of both! Served with an assortment of condiments, this platter is made to bring people together around the table. Want to make it a full meal? Upgrade yours to include kettle chips, cookies, and bottled waters—because we believe every gathering should feel like family! We kindly ask for 24-48 hours' notice on all platter orders so we can prepare everything fresh and just right for your gathering!$40.00Gather & Graze Platter (Small)
A hearty mix of our famous beef stick bites, an assortment of cheese cubes, fresh fruits, and crisp veggies, creating the perfect balance of savory and fresh flavors. Our large platter comes piled high on an 12” covered tray, making it the ultimate shareable snack board for any gathering. Whether you're hosting a party, meeting, or family get-together, this platter is made for sharing—because the best moments happen around good food! We kindly ask for 24-48 hours' notice on all platter orders so we can prepare everything fresh and just right for your event!$50.00Gather and Graze Platter (Large)
A perfectly portioned mix of our famous beef stick bites, an assortment of cheese cubes, fresh fruits, and crisp veggies, offering a delicious balance of savory and fresh flavors. Our small platter is beautifully arranged on a 18” covered tray, making it the ideal choice for smaller gatherings, office meetings, or a cozy night of snacking with friends and family. We kindly ask for 24-48 hours' notice on all platter orders so we can prepare everything fresh and just right for your event!$80.00Butcher’s Sliced Meat & Cheese Tray (Large)
A classic spread of freshly sliced meats and cheeses, perfect for making sandwiches or enjoying as a snack! This large 18” covered tray serves 20-30 people and includes a delicious selection of: Colby Cheese Colby Jack Cheese Swiss Cheese Smoked Ham Smoked Turkey Dried Beef Want to customize your platter? Swap any item for one of our other premium sliced cheeses or deli meats, including American, Provolone, Hot Pepper, Sharp Cheddar, Horseradish, Homemade Salami, or All-Beef Bologna. Additional meats can be added for an extra charge. We kindly ask for 24-48 hours' notice on all platter orders so we can prepare everything fresh and just right for your event!$75.00Butcher’s Sliced Meat & Cheese Tray (Small)
A perfectly portioned selection of sliced meats and cheeses, ideal for smaller gatherings, office meetings, or family snacking! This small 12” covered tray is great for assembling sandwiches or enjoying as a snack and includes: Colby Cheese Colby Jack Cheese Swiss Cheese Smoked Ham Smoked Turkey Dried Beef Want to make it your own? Swap any item for one of our other premium sliced cheeses or deli meats, including American, Provolone, Hot Pepper, Sharp Cheddar, Horseradish, Homemade Salami, or All-Beef Bologna. Additional meats can be added for an extra charge. We kindly ask for 24-48 hours' notice on all platter orders so we can prepare everything fresh and just right for your event!$35.00
Deli
Fresh Deli Meat
All Beef Bologna
Flavorful all-beef bologna for sandwiches or snacks.$12.39/lbBlack Forest Ham
Smoked Black Forest ham with a classic, rich flavor.$9.98/lbSmoked Ham
Delicately smoked ham with a rich, savory taste.$5.89/lbDutch Loaf
Dutch loaf with a soft texture and hearty flavor.$7.49/lbHam Loaf
Traditional ham loaf made with a rich blend of ground ham and spices.$6.63/lbHard Salami
Perfect for charcuterie boards or lunch time snacking.$9.39/lbHomemade Salami
Classic salami with robust flavor for snacking or sandwiches.$11.39/lbKB Bologna
Savory bologna with classic flavor and smooth texture.$3.49/lbPickle Loaf
Savory loaf with tangy pickles and spices for bold flavor.$7.49/lbSmoked Turkey
Juicy smoked turkey with deep, savory notes.$6.69/lbWaldos German Bologna
A flavorful, easy-to-cook deli meat made with quality ingredients, perfect for sandwiches or quick meals.$8.29/lbDried Beef
$11.79/lbRoast Beef
$8.39/lb
Fresh Deli Cheese
Colby Cheese
Creamy and mild Colby cheese for sandwiches or snacking.$8.15/lbColby Jack Cheese
Rich Colby Jack cheese with a perfect blend of flavors.$7.49/lbSwiss Cheese
Swiss cheese with a nutty, smooth texture.$7.89/lbHot Pepper Cheese
Rich and creamy cheese with a bold, spicy pepper kick.$7.86/lbSharp Cheddar
$9.58/lbAmerican Cheese
$7.29/lbProvolone
$6.99/lb
Turkey
Turkey Breast
Turkey breast is a lean, tender cut of poultry, perfect for roasting, slicing, or shredding, offering a versatile and flavorful option for any meal.$8.49/lbTurkey Links
$9.29/lb
Dairy & Eggs
Milk
A2/A2 Milk
Indian Creek Creamery, fresh local, half gallon$5.50Chocolate Milk
Creamy, chocolate-flavored milk for a delicious refreshment.$5.75Whole Milk
Fresh, whole milk with a creamy texture and rich flavor, perfect for drinking or adding to your favorite recipes.$4.75
Eggs
Farm Fresh Eggs (1 Dozen)
Local farm fresh! These eggs are fresh off the Farm in Bellefontaine, OH 1 Dozen$5.00Eggs 18 count
$7.50
Bakery
Jolly Acre - Bagels
$11.00Jolly Acre Sourdough
Traditional sourdough from Rise Bakehouse, preservative-free, fresh, with a tangy crust.$10.00Jolly Acre Sourdough - flavored
Sliced sourdough loaf from Rise Bakehouse, preservative-free, fresh, perfect for sandwiches.$12.00/lb
Beef
Steaks
Ribeye Steak
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $19.99 | Approximate cost per steak: $19.99 Rich, juicy, and full of flavor, our Ribeye Steak is known for its generous marbling that delivers a buttery texture and bold taste. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$22.78New York Strip
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $18.59 | Approximate cost per steak: $18.59 A perfect balance of tenderness and robust beef flavor, the New York Strip is leaner than a Ribeye while still juicy and satisfying. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$18.86Filet Mignon
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $30.29 | Approximate cost per steak: $20.99 The most tender cut of beef, our Filet Mignon is known for its buttery texture and mild, delicate flavor—perfect for special occasions. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$32.90T Bone Steak
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $14.99 | Approximate cost per steak: $16.99 The best of both worlds—this cut features both tenderloin and strip steak, separated by a bone that enhances its bold, beefy flavor. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$16.30Porterhouse Steak
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $14.99 | Approximate cost per steak: $21.25 A thick, meaty steak that combines the filet mignon and New York strip, offering both tenderness and bold flavor in one premium cut. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$16.30Sirloin Steak
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $10.29 | Approximate cost per steak: $10.29 A leaner option packed with flavor, Sirloin Steak is perfect for grilling, stir-frying, or slicing for salads and sandwiches. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$13.99
Ground Beef
Ground Beef (80/20)
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.69 | Packaged in 1 lb bags Our 80/20 Ground Beef offers the perfect balance of lean meat and fat, delivering rich flavor and juiciness. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$6.70Seasoned Taco Meat
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.99 | Packaged in 1 lb bags A customer favorite, our pre-seasoned Taco Meat is expertly blended with a bold, flavorful taco seasoning—just brown, serve, and enjoy! Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$7.70Seasoned Meatloaf
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.99 | Packaged in 1 lb bags Our seasoned Meatloaf takes the prep work out of dinner! Just thaw, place in a pan and bake for a delicious, home-cooked meal with minimal effort. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$9.99
Hamburger Patties
Half Pound Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.49 | Approximate cost per pack: $12.98 Thick and juicy, these ½ lb burger patties are perfect for those who love a hearty, flavorful bite straight off the grill. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$7.99Third Pound Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.49 | Approximate cost per pack: $12.98 For those who love a ⅓ lb burger, these patties provide the ideal size for a flavorful, juicy burger with every bite. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$7.99Quarter Pound Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $6.49 | Approximate cost per pack: $12.98 Our ¼ lb patties are a classic burger choice, offering the perfect balance of thickness and tenderness for any cookout. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$7.99House Seasoned Hamburger Patties
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $7.99 | Approximate cost per pack: $15.98 A customer favorite, these house-seasoned patties are blended with just the right touch of seasoning, making them perfect for the grill. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$8.99Bacon & Cheese Patties
Juicy burger patties loaded with smoky bacon and cheddar cheese.$8.99/lbBacon Cheese & Jalapeno Patties
Bold and spicy jalapeno-infused bacon and cheese burger patties.$8.99/lbBBQ Bacon Blue Cheese Patties
Savory BBQ bacon and blue cheese patties for gourmet grilling.$8.99Chili Cheese Patties
Chili cheese patties for a spicy, cheesy grilling experience.$8.99/lbJalapeno & Cheese Brat Patties
Spicy and cheesy brat patties with jalapenos and cheddar.$6.48Mushroom Swiss Patties
Juicy patties topped with mushrooms and Swiss cheese.$8.99Pizza Patties
Juicy patties with classic pizza-inspired flavors.$8.99/lb
Steak Bites & More!
Steak Bites
Steak bites are tender, juicy pieces of seasoned steak, perfectly seared for a flavorful and protein-packed snack or appetizer. *All products are vacuum-sealed for freshness. Average package size is 1 lb, though slight variations may occur.$14.99Stew Meat
Tender stew meat, perfect for hearty soups or casseroles. *All products are vacuum-sealed for freshness. Average package size is 1 lb, though slight variations may occur.$9.99Fajita Strips
Juicy fajita strips, perfect for stir-frying or tacos. These strips are unseasoned and cut from our fresh New York Strips and Ribeye Steaks *All products are vacuum-sealed for freshness. Average package size is 1 lb, though slight variations may occur.$12.99
Chicken
Breast
Chicken Breast
Plain chicken breasts, perfect for grilling or roasting. These are not small chicken breasts and one chicken berast weighs about 1lb$3.99/lbChicken Breast - Garlic Parmesan
Garlic Parmesan chicken breasts for a burst of savory flavor.$5.49/lbChicken Breast - Santa Fe Salsa
Santa Fe salsa chicken breasts with bold, tangy flavors.$5.49/lbChicken Breast - Texas Fajita
Texas fajita chicken breasts for a southwestern flair.$5.49/lbChicken Breast Bourbon Peppercorn
$5.49/lbChicken Breast Lemon Butter
$5.49/lbChicken Breast Honey Teriyaki
$5.49/lb
Thighs
Boneless Skinless Chicken Thighs
Tender chicken thighs, versatile for grilling or roasting.$4.99/lbMarinated Boneless Skinless Chicken Thighs
$5.99/lb
Wings
Chicken Wings
Juicy chicken wings perfect for frying or baking.$3.39/lbChicken Wings - Garlic Parmesan
Garlic Parmesan chicken wings for a crispy, savory treat.$4.39/lbChicken Wings - Cajun
$4.39/lbHoney Teriyaki Chicken Wings
$4.39/lbChicken Drumstick
$2.99/lb
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tenders
Crispy chicken tenders, great for dipping or snacking.$3.99/lbChicken Tenders - Santa Fe Salsa
Santa Fe salsa chicken tenders for tangy, bold flavor.$4.49/lbChicken Tenders - Garlic Parmesan
Garlic Parmesan chicken tenders for a savory, crispy bite.$4.49/lbChicken Tenders Honey Teriyaki
$4.49/lbChicken Tenders Bourbon Peppercorn
$4.49/lb
Ground Chicken
Ground Chicken
Lean ground chicken for healthy and versatile meals. In convenient 1 lb packages frozen.$3.99/lb
Pork
Pork Chops
Boneless Pork Chops
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $3.99 | Approximate cost per chop: $1.89 Tender and juicy, our Boneless Pork Chops are easy to cook and perfect for grilling, pan-searing, or baking. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$3.49Butterfly Pork Chop
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $2.69 | Approximate cost per chop: $4.25 A thick, butterflied cut that stays extra juicy, making it a great option for stuffing, grilling, or pan-frying. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$3.49Bone In Pork Chop
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $3.99 | Approximate cost per chop: $1.89 Packed with flavor, our Bone-In Pork Chops stay tender and juicy, perfect for grilling or oven-roasting. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$3.49Smoked Pork Chop
Sold per pound | Price per lb: $4.49 | Approximate cost per chop: $3.45 Smoked to perfection, our Smoked Pork Chops offer a rich, savory flavor—just heat and serve for an easy, delicious meal. Prices and weights may vary at pickup. All sales are final, and final costs will be determined at pickup.$5.79
Pork Roasts
Pork Roast
Hearty pork roast perfect for slow-cooking or baking.$4.49/lb
Brats
Regular Brat
Classic bratwurst perfect for grilling or frying.$7.99Cheese Brat
Cheesy bratwurst with a creamy, savory center.$7.99/lbJalapeno & Cheese Brat
Zesty jalapeno and cheese bratwurst for a flavorful kick.$7.99/lbAndouille Sausage Brat
Spicy and smoky Andouille sausage brats with Cajun seasoning.$7.99/lbItalian Brat
Classic Italian sausage brats with a rich, herbaceous flavor.$7.99/lbMac & Cheese Brat
Mac and cheese-stuffed bratwurst for cheesy indulgence.$7.99/lbPizza Brat
Pizza-flavored bratwurst for a fun, cheesy twist.$7.99Teriyaki Pineapple Brat
Sweet and tangy teriyaki pineapple bratwurst for tropical flair.$7.99/lbOriginal Brat Patties
Savory brat patties perfect for grilling or sandwiches.$5.19/lbJalapeno & Cheese Brat Patties
Spicy and cheesy brat patties with jalapenos and cheddar.$6.48
Bacon
Bacon
$6.99 per lb I Final Price upon pickup I Crispy, smoky bacon, a breakfast favorite or recipe essential.$6.99Peppered Bacon
$6.99 per lb I Final Price upon pickup I Pepper-crusted bacon for a robust, smoky flavor.$7.99Cajun Bacon
$6.99 per lb I Final Price upon pickup I A customer favorite! Thick-cut, smoky bacon for an indulgent flavor experience.$7.99Thick Cut Bacon
$6.99 per lb I Final Price upon pickup I Thick, smoky slices of premium bacon, offering a hearty crunch and rich flavor with every bite.$7.99
Sausage Patties
Sausage Patties - Mild
Mild sausage patties for breakfast or sandwiches.$5.59/lbSausage Patties - Hot
Spicy sausage patties with a kick of heat.$5.59Pork Patties Unseasoned
Unseasoned pork patties ready for your custom seasoning.$4.20
Ground Pork
Unseasoned Ground Pork
Price per lb: $3.69 | Packaged in 1 lb bags A versatile kitchen staple, our Unseasoned Ground Pork is perfect for homemade sausage, meatballs, stir-fries, and more. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$3.20Mild Ground Sausage
Price per lb: $4.39 | Packaged in 1 lb bags Our Mild Ground Sausage is perfectly seasoned for a balanced flavor, making it ideal for breakfast, casseroles, and pasta dishes. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$4.59Hot Ground Sausage
Price per lb: $4.39 | Packaged in 1 lb bags Spicy and flavorful, our Hot Ground Sausage adds a kick to any dish—perfect for breakfast, pizzas, or adding heat to your favorite recipes. Product is sold frozen. Final weight and cost will be determined at pickup. All sales are final.$4.59