Skip to Main content
  • Tommy I's

Currently not accepting online orders

Tommy I's

215 Huguenot Street, New Paltz, NY

Featured Items

  • Kid Cheeseburger

    $9.00
  • All American Burger

    8 oz burger topped with American cheese, apples, bacon, and a root beer reduction on a toasted potato roll
    $18.00
  • Burger

    8 oz burger with your choice of one topping, lettuce and tomato on a toasted potato roll
    $16.00

Apps

  • ********DONT MAKE*******

  • Chicken Fingers

    Served with BBQ, honey mustard or ranch
    $11.00
  • Crab Cakes

    3 Crab cakes served with citrus herb aioli
    $13.00
  • Fried Pickle Spears

    Served with spicy aioli
    $10.00
  • Hog Wings

    2 tender mini pork shanks tossed in your choice of wing sauce. Served with Bleu cheese
    $12.00
  • Mozz Planks

    2 mozzarella planks served with marinara sauce
    $10.00
  • Pepper Shrimp

    6 shrimp topped with a black pepper and garlic drizzle
    $14.00
  • Wings

    10 wings tossed in your choice of Mild, Hot Honey BBQ, Garlic Parmesan or Lemon Pepper. Served with carrots, celery and Bleu cheese
    $15.00
  • Wings 1/2 and 1/2

    Your choice of any 2: Mild, Hot Honey BBQ, Garlic Parmesan or Lemon Pepper. Served with carrots, celery and Bleu cheese
    $15.00

Salad

  • Buffalo Chicken Salad

    Fresh greens topped with crispy buffalo chicken, tomato, celery, and monterey Jack cheese with a side of Bleu cheese dressing
    $17.00
  • Caesar Salad

    Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with homemade Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese and croutons
    $12.00
  • Greek Salad

    Fresh romaine with grape tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, feta, Kalamata olives and grilled gyro meat. Served with a side of Tzatziki sauce
    $17.00
  • Tossed Salad

    Fresh greens with tomato, cucumber, egg, monterey Jack cheese, carrots and croutons
    $11.00
  • Wedge Salad

    Freshly chopped iceberg with Bleu cheese, tomato, bacon and scallions
    $13.00

Burgers

  • All American Burger

    8 oz burger topped with American cheese, apples, bacon, and a root beer reduction on a toasted potato roll
    $18.00
  • Black Bean Burger

    Topped with provolone cheese, balsamic caramelized onions, lettuce and tomato on a toasted potato roll
    $16.00
  • Breakfast Burger

    8 oz burger topped with American cheese, bacon and a fried egg on a toasted potato roll
    $18.00
  • Burger

    8 oz burger with your choice of one topping, lettuce and tomato on a toasted potato roll
    $16.00
  • Burger Quesadilla

    8 oz burger stuffed in a grilled flour tortilla with monterey Jack cheese, pickles and Russian dressing
    $18.00
  • Patty Melt

    8 oz burger on grilled rye with Swiss and caramelized onions
    $18.00
  • Tommy I Burger

    8 oz burger served on a toasted English muffin with cheddar cheese, pickle sauce, banana peppers and a battered fried onion ring
    $18.00

Sandwiches

  • 1 Hot Dog

    Served a la carte
    $4.00
  • 2 Hot Dogs

    Served a la carte
    $7.00
  • Amber Melt

    Oven roasted turkey breast on grilled sourdough with cheddar, tomato and spicy aioli
    $16.00
  • Chicken Sandwich Crispy

    Crispy chicken cutlet served with one topping, lettuce and tomato on a toasted potato roll
    $16.00
  • Chicken Sandwich Grilled

    Grilled breast on a toasted potato roll with choice of one topping, lettuce and tomato
    $16.00
  • Corned Beef Rueben

    Tender corned beef on grilled rye with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing
    $17.00
  • Crab Cake Sandwich

    $17.00
  • Grilled Cheese

    $8.00
  • Gyro Wrap

    Grilled gyro meat with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, feta, red onion and Tzatziki sauce in a warm flour tortilla
    $17.00
  • Jr. Turkey Club

    Oven roasted turkey, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on 2 slices of sourdough or rye toast
    $16.00
  • Kielbasa Rueben

    Polish kielbasa on grilled rye with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Russian dressing
    $17.00
  • Salmon Sandwich

    Fresh Atlantic salmon on a toasted club roll with lettuce, tomato and a side of tartar sauce
    $18.00
  • Spicy Chicken Wrap

    Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and hot honey aioli in a warm flour tortilla
    $16.00
  • Steak Sandwich

    Grilled marinated flank steak on a toasted club roll with provolone cheese and caramelized onions
    $22.00
  • Turkey Reuben

    $17.00

Dinner

  • Cajun Shrimp Alfredo

    $23.00
  • Chicken Francese

    Egg battered boneless chicken breast sauteed in a lemon butter sauce
    $23.00
  • Chicken Piccata

    $23.00
  • Dinner Flat Iron Steak

    Marinated sliced flank steak grilled to your liking
    $25.00
  • Fish n Chips

    Battered fried haddock served with tartar sauce
    $20.00
  • Gemelli a la Vodka

    Served with garlic bread
    $20.00
  • Salmon Dinner

    Broiled Atlantic salmon with a citrus dill buerre blanc
    $23.00
  • Shrimp Scampi

    Sauteed jumbo shrimp tossed in a garlic butter sauce
    $23.00
  • Tommy I’s Chicken Parm

    Crispy chicken cutlet topped with melted provolone cheese and creamy vodka sauce, served over gemelli
    $24.00
  • Chicken Marsala

    $23.00
  • Steak Marsala

    $25.00

Sides

  • Broccoli

    $6.00
  • Fries

    $6.00
  • Garlic Bread

    $3.00
  • Mac Salad

    $5.00
  • Onion Rings

    $8.00
  • Pasta Marinara

    $6.00
  • Pasta Olio

    $6.00
  • Side Salad

    $5.00
  • Bag of chips

    $2.00
  • Side Caesar

    $5.00
  • Apple Sauce

    $3.00
  • Sweet Potato Fries

    $8.00

Kids

  • Kid Cheeseburger

    $9.00
  • Kids Burger

    $8.00
  • Kids Dog

    $8.00
  • Kids pasta

    $8.00
  • Kids Tenders

    $8.00
  • Kids Grilled Cheese

    $8.00
  • Kid Drink

    $2.00

Dessert

  • Cheesecake

    $8.00
  • Key Lime Pie

    $8.00
  • One Scoop

    $4.00
  • Two Scoops

    $7.00
  • Brownie Sundae

    $8.00

N/A Beverages

  • Soda

    $3.00
  • Ice Tea

    $3.00
  • Celsius

    $7.00
  • Snapple

    $3.00
  • Bottle Water

    $2.00
  • Gatorade

    $3.00
  • Can Soda

    $3.00
  • Kids Drink

    $2.00
  • Coffee

    $3.00
  • Hot Tea

    $3.00
  • Lemonade

    $3.00
  • Juice

    $4.00
  • Ginger Beer

    $3.00
  • Iced Coffee

    $3.00

Snacks

  • Trail Mix

    $2.00
  • Doritos

    $2.00
  • Pretzels

    $2.00
  • Chips

    $2.00
  • Granola Bar

    $2.00
  • Snickers

    $2.50
  • Peanuts

    $2.00
  • peanut m&m's

    $2.00

Mozz Planks

$10.00

2 mozzarella planks served with marinara sauce

Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Tommy I's Location and Ordering Hours

(845) 419-2428
215 Huguenot Street, New Paltz, NY 12561
Closed • Opens Monday at 11AM
Facebook logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement
  • |CA Privacy Statement