Order Online

Pre-Order your Pies or Cakes for Pick-up at Lancaster St. in Portland

Two Fat Cats Bakery Lancaster Street

195 Lancaster, Portland, ME

Pickup Only

‌
‌

THANKSGIVING 2026

HOLIDAY PREORDER PICK-UP SCHEDULE - **LANCASTER:** TUES 11/24: 7:30AM - 4PM ; WED 11/25: 7:30AM - 4PM ; THURS 11/26: 7:30AM - 11AM **WEST END:** TUES 11/24: 7:30AM - 4PM ; WED 11/25: 7:30AM - 4PM ; THURS CLOSED BOTH LOCATIONS CLOSED FRIDAY 11/27 ONLY HOLIDAY ITEMS ARE AVAILABLE ON THESE DATES.

6 flaky, buttery, savory sage & cheddar biscuits.
$23.99
Delicious, moist, perfectly spiced pumpkin quick bread.
$18.00
NY Style Coffee Cake with apples and fall spices folded in, and topped with a crumb topping.
$25.99
3 uniquely decorated, holiday-themed shortbread cookies.
$11.99
6 pack of a fall favorite! Moist and decadent pumpkin chocolate chip cookies.
$21.00
6 pack of raspberry almond thumbprint cookies (Gluten-free).
$21.00
6 Shortbread cookies with lemon glaze.
$16.99
Made with fresh, local Cortland and McIntosh apples, this is the all-American autumn treat
OUT OF STOCK
$35.00
The ideal Maine pie: famous wild Maine blueberries tossed with a sprinkle of sugar and warm spices.
OUT OF STOCK
$36.50
OUT OF STOCK
$36.50
Classic with a twist - roasted buttery pecans combined with a splash of Bourbon
OUT OF STOCK
$38.00
Delicious sour cherries with a touch of almond, topped with a beautiful lattice pie crust.
OUT OF STOCK
$38.00
Rich chocolate pastry cream in a flaky pie crust, topped with fresh whipped cream.
OUT OF STOCK
$35.00
Perfectly spiced, pumpkin pie in our classic buttery crust.
OUT OF STOCK
$36.00
An open face pastry filled with pears, blackberries and ginger.
$25.99
Creamy, pumpkin spiced cheesecake with a graham cracker crust, topped with whipped cream.
$32.00
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting for a real crowd pleaser. Frostings: Vanilla, Chocolate Fillings: Lemon (+6.00), Raspberry (+$8.50)
$33.00
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting for a real crowd pleaser.
$44.00
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
$33.00
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
$44.00
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins layered & topped with cream cheese frosting.
$44.00
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins layered & topped with cream cheese frosting.
$52.00
Pumpkin spice cake layered with coffee buttercream & caramel drizzle
$42.00
Pumpkin spice cake layered with coffee buttercream & caramel drizzle
$52.00
Chocolate cake with an Oreo frosting.
$42.00
Chocolate cake with an Oreo frosting.
$52.00

Two Fat Cats Bakery

Two Fat Cats Bakery Lancaster Street

THANKSGIVING 2026

*Sage & Cheddar Biscuits (6)

*Pumpkin Bread

*Apple Spice Crumb Cake

*Bag of 3 Deco Cookies

*Bag of 6 Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

*Bag of 6 Raspberry Almond Thumbprints (GF)

*Bag of 6 Lemon Shortbread Cookies

*9" Apple Pie

*9" Blueberry Pie

*9" Triple Berry Pie

*9" Bourbon Pecan Pie

*9" Sour Cherry Pie

*9" Chocolate Cream Pie

*9" Pumpkin Pie

*9" Pear Blackberry Galette

*7" Pumpkin Cheesecake

*6" Vanilla Cake

*8" Vanilla Cake

*6" Chocolate Cake

*8" Chocolate Cake

*6" Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

*8" Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

*6" Pumpkin Latte Cake

*8" Pumpkin Latte Cake

*6" Oreo Cake

*8" Oreo Cake

Two Fat Cats Bakery Locations and Ordering Hours

Lancaster Street

West End