
Two Fat Cats Bakery Lancaster Street
HOLIDAY
PRE-ORDER > CHRISTMAS & HANUKKAH
- * 9" Apple Pie$32.50
Made with perfectly spiced, fresh, local Cortland and McIntosh apples.
- * 9" Blueberry Pie$32.50
The ideal Maine pie: famous wild Maine blueberries tossed with a sprinkle of sugar and warm spices.
- * 9" Bumbleberry$32.50
A delicious combination of wild Maine blueberries, apples, raspberries, and rhubarb.
- * 9" Cherry Pie$32.50
Delicious sour cherries with a touch of almond, topped with a beautiful lattice pie crust.
- * 9" Chocolate Cream Pie$26.50
Rich, chocolate pastry cream in a flaky pie crust topped with fresh whipped cream.
- * 9" Bourbon Pecan Pie$32.50
Classic with a twist - roasted buttery pecans combined with a splash of Bourbon.
- * 6" Vanilla Cake$29.00
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting Frosting: Vanilla, Chocolate Fillings: Lemon, Raspberry (+$6)
- * 8" Vanilla Cake$39.00
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting Frosting: Vanilla, Chocolate Fillings: Lemon, Raspberry (+$6)
- * 6" Chocolate Cake$29.00
Our luscious dark chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a fabulous holiday treat. Frosting: Vanilla, Chocolate Fillings: Lemon, Raspberry (+$6)
- * 8" Chocolate Cake$39.00
Our luscious dark chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a fabulous holiday treat. Frosting: Vanilla, Chocolate Fillings: Lemon, Raspberry (+$6)
- * 6'' Red Velvet Cake$36.00
Rich and delicious - this naked-frosted red velvet cake makes a statement with vanilla or cream cheese frosting.
- * 8" Red Velvet Cake$46.00
Rich and delicious - this naked-frosted red velvet cake makes a statement with vanilla or cream cheese frosting.
- * 7" Eggnog Cheesecake$25.00
Rich eggnog-spiced cheesecake in a gingerbread cookie crust, topped with candied ginger.
- * Chocolate Yule Log with Espresso Filling$60.00
Chocolate roll cake with espresso buttercream filling, decorated with meringue “mushrooms,” sugar berries and leaves, it looks as delicious as it tastes. Serves 10-12.
- * Sticky Toffee Pudding$28.00
A classic British dessert, this confection is a "cakey" pudding loaded with medjool dates and baked in a rich toffee sauce. Serves 6-8.
- * Chocolate Whoopie Pies (6)$22.50
6 Chocolate whoopie pies filled with vanilla cream
- * Maple Pecan Coffee Cake$24.95
New England style coffee cake with pecan crumble and maple drizzle. Serves 8-10
- * Chocolate Gingerbread Loaf$13.50
Warm spice gingerbread studded with chocolate chips. The epitome of a holiday treat!
- * Cinnamon Rolls (6 pack)$30.00
6 pack of our classic cinnamon rolls dripping with vanilla glaze. Make breakfast easy & delicious!
- * 9" Tourtiere Pie$32.50
Traditional French-Canadian pork pie made with mashed potatoes, cloves and other spices. Serves 4-6.
- * 9" Chicken Pot Pie$32.50
Delicious and ready to eat - pulled light and dark meat chicken, peas, carrots, pearl onions, and thyme. Serves 4-6.
- * Holiday Cookie Box$32.00
12 delicious seasonal cookies: 3 each Lemon Ginger Spice, Chocolate Crinkle, Cran-Raspberry Sandwich cookies, and Eggnog Snickerdoodle Cookies.
- * Bag of 3 Holiday Shortbread Cookies$7.50
3 colorful, iced shortbread cookies in holiday shapes.
- * Bag of 3 Gingerbread Cookies$12.00
3 pack of decorated gingerbread people cookies.
- * Pack of 6 Lemon Shortbread Cookies$12.60
6 Shortbread cookies with lemon glaze.
- * Peanut Brittle$9.25
6 oz bag of brittle with toasted pecans & housemade caramel
- * 6" Winter Berry & Citrus Cake$36.00
Classic vanilla cake layered with a cranberry-raspberry filling and finished with a lightly spiced orange buttercream.
- * 8" Winter Berry & Citrus Cake$46.00
Classic vanilla cake layered with a cranberry-raspberry filling and finished with a lightly spiced orange buttercream.
- Chocolate Dipped Macaroons$3.00
An addictive coconut cookie dipped in chocolate. Sold as singles.
- Apricot & Pecan Rugelach$12.50
6 tender cookies filled with pecans, cinnamon and apricots.
- Hanukkah Decorated Cookies$7.50
The perfect decorated sugar cookie for the holiday! Sold in bags of 3.
BAKERY
Bars
- Lemon Bars$4.75
Our incredible homemade lemon curd is layered on buttery shortbread with a brown sugar, cake crumb & coconut topping
- Date Bar (GF)$4.75
Our new gluten-free date bars are filled with chopped dates, dark chocolate, rolled oats and a touch of almond. They are simply delicious and naturally sweet.
- Brownie$4.25
Pies
- 7" Apple Pie$22.50
Made with fresh, local Cortland and McIntosh apples, this is the all-American autumn treat.
- 7" Black & Blue Pie$22.50
Blackberries and wild Maine blueberries combined with a hint of ginger and cinnamon.
- 7" Blueberry$22.50
The ideal Maine pie: famous wild Maine blueberries tossed with a sprinkle of sugar and warm spices.
- 7" Bumbleberry$22.50
Wild Maine blueberries, raspberries, apple & rhubarb come together in this delicious seasonal favorite.
- 7" Cherry Pie$22.50
Delicious sour cherries with a touch of almond, topped with a beautiful lattice pie crust.
- 7" Chicken Pie$22.50
Delicious and ready to eat - pulled light and dark meat chicken, peas, carrots, pearl onions, and thyme
- 7" Triple Berry Pie$22.50
A delicious combination of wild Maine blueberries, blackberries, and raspberries. Each Triple Berry Pie contributes to our Baking That Matters Program!
- 7" New England Bog$22.50
Wild Maine blueberries and cranberries are combined with a hint of orange and topped with a chocolate oat crumble.
- 7" Pecan Pie$22.50
Classic with a twist - roasted buttery pecans combined with a splash of Bourbon.
- 7" Pumpkin Pie$22.50
- 7" Vegan Blueberry$22.50
Vegan version of our famous wild Maine blueberry pie.
- 7" Vegan Cherry$22.50
Vegan version with sour cherries, a touch of almond, topped with a beautiful lattice pie crust.
- 9" Apple Pie$32.50
Made with fresh, local Cortland and McIntosh apples, this is the all-American autumn treat.
- 9" Black & Blue Pie$32.50
Blackberries and wild Maine blueberries combined with a hint of ginger and cinnamon.
- 9" Blue Pie$32.50
The ideal Maine pie: famous wild Maine blueberries tossed with a sprinkle of sugar and warm spices.
- 9" Bumbleberry$32.50
Wild Maine blueberries, raspberries, apple & rhubarb come together in this delicious seasonal favorite.
- 9" Cherry Pie$32.50
Delicious sour cherries with a touch of almond, topped with a beautiful lattice pie crust.
- 9" Chicken Pie$32.50
Delicious and ready to eat - pulled light and dark meat chicken, peas, carrots, pearl onions, and thyme
- 9" Triple Berry Pie$32.50
A delicious combination of wild Maine blueberries, blackberries, and raspberries. Each Triple Berry Pie contributes to our Baking That Matters Program!
- 9" New England Bog$32.50
Wild Maine blueberries and cranberries are combined with a hint of orange and topped with a chocolate oat crumble.
- 9" Pecan Pie$32.50
Classic with a twist - roasted buttery pecans combined with a splash of Bourbon.
- 9" Pumpkin Pie$32.50
- 9" Vegan Blueberry$32.50
Vegan version of our famous wild Maine blueberry pie.
- 9" Vegan Cherry$32.50
Vegan version with sour cherries, a touch of almond, topped with a beautiful lattice pie crust.
Platters
- Large Breakfast Platter (30)$142.50
Enjoy a mix of fresh baked muffins, cinnamon buns, scones, and blueberry buckle (5 of each).
- Small Breakfast Platter (15)$71.25
Enjoy a mix of fresh baked muffins, cinnamon buns, scones, and blueberry buckle (15 pieces total).
- Large Bar & Cookie Platter (30)$135.00
A variety of our fresh baked chocolate chip, peanut butter, lemon shortbread, ginger molasses, with brownies & whoopie pies (5 of each item).
- Small Bar & Cookie Platter (15)$67.50
A variety of our fresh baked chocolate chip, ginger molasses, lemon shortbread, peanut butter cookies, with brownies & whoopie pies (15 pieces total).
- Large Cupcake Platter (24)$78.00
Enjoy a variety of chocolate & vanilla cupcakes with chocolate & vanilla buttercream frosting. Sprinkles optional but recommended.
- Small Cupcake Platter (12)$42.00
Enjoy a variety of chocolate & vanilla cupcakes with chocolate & vanilla buttercream frosting. Sprinkles optional but recommended.
- Large Whoopie Platter (24)$90.00
A combination of our classic chocolate whoopie pies & seasonal whoopie pies. Seasonal flavors are not customizable but can be replaced with chocolate whoopies.
- Small Whoopie Platter (12)$45.00
A combination of our classic chocolate whoopie pies & seasonal whoopie pies. Seasonal flavors are not customizable but can be replaced with chocolate whoopies.
Whoopies
BREAKFAST
Breakfast Goods
CAKES
- 6" Carrot Cake$36.00
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
- 6" Chocolate Blackout Cake$38.00
Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs (We cannot write or decorate these cakes as the cookie coating makes it difficult).
- 6" Chocolate Cake$29.00
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
- 6" Coconut Cake$36.00
Our classic vanilla cake with coconut filling, coconut buttercream frosting, covered with toasted coconut—for the coconut lover of course!
- 6" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake$36.00
A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting.
- 6" German Chocolate Cake$36.00
Moist chocolate cake with layers of pecans and coconuts topped with chocolate buttercream and toasted coconut.
- 6" Lemon Cake$36.00
This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.
- 6" Red Velvet Cake$36.00
Rich and delicious - this red velvet cake makes a statement with vanilla or cream cheese frosting - your choice! Cream Cheese option has a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
- 6" Vanilla Cake$29.00
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!
- 6" Spice Cake$36.00
Cake layered with spices and topped with a cream cheese frost.
- 8" Carrot Cake$46.00
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
- 8" Chocolate Blackout Cake$48.00
Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs (We cannot write or decorate these cakes as the cookie coating makes it difficult).
- 8" Chocolate Cake$39.00
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
- 8" Coconut Cake$46.00
Our classic vanilla cake with coconut filling, coconut buttercream frosting, covered with toasted coconut—for the coconut lover of course!
- 8" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake$46.00
A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting.
- 8" German Chocolate Cake$46.00
Moist chocolate cake with layers of pecans and coconuts topped with chocolate buttercream and toasted coconut.
- 8" Lemon Cake$46.00
This citrusy favorite gets a layer of lemon curd on top of vanilla cake and plenty of lemon buttercream frosting.
- 8" Red Velvet Cake$46.00
Rich and delicious - this red velvet cake makes a statement with vanilla or cream cheese frosting - your choice! Cream Cheese option has a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
- 8" Vanilla Cake$39.00
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!
- 8" Spice Cake$46.00
Cake layered with spices and topped with a cream cheese frost.
- 10" Carrot Cake$62.00
A classic made with fresh carrots, chopped pecans, and golden raisins with a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
- 10" Chocolate Cake$54.00
Simple, sweet and moist chocolate cake can be paired with your favorite filling and frosting for a deliciously unique treat.
- 10" Coconut Cake$62.00
Our classic vanilla cake with coconut filling, coconut buttercream frosting, topped with coconut pieces - for the coconut lover of course.
- 10" Fruit & Honey Cream Cake$62.00
A beautiful vanilla cake layered with vanilla pastry cream & strawberry filling with a lightly sweetened honey buttercream frosting.
- 10" Ger Choc Cake$62.00
Moist chocolate cake with layers of pecans and coconut filling. topped with chocolate buttercream and coconut flakes.
- 10" Lemon Cake$62.00
Known as the "Fat Cat Lemon" this sweet favorite has vanilla cake layered with lemon curd, frosted with lemon buttercream frosting and topped with more housemade lemon curd.
- 10" Red Velvet Cake$62.00
Rich and delicious - this red velvet cake makes a statement with vanilla or cream cheese frosting - your choice! Cream Cheese option has a naked frosted style (no frosting on sides, can request to have full coverage)
- 10" Vanilla Cake$54.00
Sophisticated vanilla cake layered with your choice of filling and frosting to create a specialty cake of your very own!